Association between perinatal depression in mothers and the risk of childhood infections in offspring: a population-based cohort study

Dataset and study population

We used data from The Health Improvement Network (THIN), a large database of anonymised computerised primary health care records of patients throughout the UK. There is a high standard of validated recording of medical diagnoses, medical conditions and symptoms and prescriptions in THIN [14, 15]. The data in this study derive from 255 general practices across England and Wales with longitudinal records of 3.9 million patients. Previous research [15, 16] has shown that the population in THIN is generally representative of the UK population. Ethical approval for this study was granted by the South East Research Ethics Committee.

For each woman who was of childbearing age (15 to 50 years of age) at any time between January 1988 and November 2004, birth-related entries in their general practice records during this period were linked to registered children born in the same household at the time of delivery. Women were included if they had one or more live born children recorded in the database. For this study, we only included the first recorded singleton pregnancy ending in a live born child for each woman. Pregnancies ending in stillbirth, miscarriage, therapeutic abortion and multiple pregnancies (e.g. twins delivered) were excluded. Follow-up data were available for all children for the first four years of their life unless they died or ceased to be registered at the practice. All analyses were restricted to the first four-years of life since in the UK children generally start attending school at between 4 and 5 years of age, leading to a considerable change in their environmental exposure to infection.

We extracted data including records of GI infections, LRTIs and antibiotic prescriptions for children and records of maternal perinatal depression and antidepressant use for mothers. Based on previous research [9, 10, 17, 18], we also extracted data (where available) on maternal age at birth, body mass index [BMI] before pregnancy, smoking status before childbirth, caesarean section delivery, and household socioeconomic status (represented by quintiles of Townsend deprivation indices [19]), and the sex of the child, since these factors may be related to maternal perinatal depression as well.

Measurement of maternal perinatal depression

Mothers were defined as having perinatal depression if, at any time during pregnancy or in the first six months after childbirth, they had a medical record of diagnosed depression (e.g. major depression, mild depression, or chronic depression), or if they received at least one prescription for an antidepressant medication.

Measurement of childhood infections and antibiotic prescriptions

Children were defined as having GI infections if they had at least one clinical diagnosis of GI infection (e.g. infectious colitis, enteritis or gastroenteritis) or infection-related symptoms (e.g. vomiting or diarrhoea) recorded in their general practice records. The date of recovery from illness was defined as the 15^th day after diagnosis. If a subsequent diagnosis was recorded prior to the recovery date, this was considered part of the same episode of illness and the recovery date was extended to the 8^th day after this recording (only if later than the original recovery date, ensuring that an episode lasted at least 14 days). Further recordings prior to the recovery date were treated in the same way. Recordings after the date of recovery were treated as indicating the onset of new episodes of illness. We used the same process to identify and classify episodes of LRTIs, where these were defined as at least one clinical diagnosis of an LRTI (e.g. pneumonia or bronchitis) in the primary care record. To obtain a measure of more severe episodes of illness, we also identified all antibiotic-treated GI and LRTI infectious episodes, which we defined as those where children had one or more records of a prescription for an antibiotic dated on or after the date of onset and prior to the date of recovery.

Statistical analysis

We calculated crude incidence rates as the total number of episodes for each infectious outcome (episodes of GI infections with and without antibiotic treatment and episodes of LRTIs with and without antibiotic treatment) divided by children's total follow-up period during the first four years of life. We calculated the absolute differences in crude incidence rates by subtracting the rates in children of mothers without perinatal depression from those in children of mothers with perinatal depression. To assess whether the incidence rates changed over the first years of the child's life and whether the association of maternal perinatal depression with childhood infections changed with increasing time from birth, we also calculated the incidence rates for each year of the child's life separately.

To estimate the effect of maternal perinatal depression on the risk of childhood infections, we used Poisson regression to obtain incidence rate ratios (IRRs) for each type of infectious outcome among children of mothers with perinatal depression relative to children of mothers without perinatal depression, overall and for each year of age up to 4 years. Findings were considered statistically significant where p was less than 0.05.

We also attempted to assess whether mothers with perinatal depression might be more likely to report childhood illness to their general practitioners (GPs), or to do so sooner than mothers without perinatal depression, by examining whether time to first polio immunisation in children differed between mothers with and without perinatal depression as a potential marker of mothers' healthcare-seeking behaviour. We determined the date of each child's first polio immunisation as recorded in the general practice records for children born between 1^st January 1991 and 31^st December 2003 only, since the UK immunisation schedule and vaccine type did not change during this time period [20, 21]. We calculated a median time to first polio vaccination in children of mothers with and without perinatal depression. All analyses were carried out using Stata SE 10.0 software.

Statistical Power

Based on previous studies [2–4, 22], we estimated that about 10% of mothers in our study population would have perinatal depression. We calculated that our sample size would give us over 99% power to detect a 1.5-fold increased rate in children of mothers with perinatal depression for both GI infections and LRTIs.

Study population

We identified a cohort of 107,587 mothers and their first live born children. Of the mothers, 9,722 (9.1%) had perinatal depression. The mean age of the mothers was 29 years (Standard Deviation 5.7). Complete follow-up data to age 4 years was available for 80.5% of all children, and 96.0% of children were followed up to at least 2 years of age.

Maternal depression and childhood infections

Proportionately more children born to mothers with perinatal depression had at least one GI infection (60.6%) than children born to mothers without perinatal depression (49.2%). Similarly, children born to mothers with perinatal depression were more likely to have one or more LRTIs than children born to mothers without perinatal depression (20.9% vs. 17.0%). When only episodes of childhood infections with at least one antibiotic prescription were considered, the prevalence decreased to 5.2% and 3.6% for GI infections and 10.2% and 8.7% for LRTIs, respectively.

In addition, the rates of childhood infections in children of mothers with perinatal depression were consistently higher than those of mothers without perinatal depression through the first four years of life, generally decreasing gradually in both cohorts for both GI infections and LRTIs as the children got older (Table 2).

Maternal perinatal depression and the time to first polio vaccination in children

We identified 92,218 children born between 1^st January 1991 and 31^st December 2003 who accounted for 85.7% of the whole cohort and who were representative of the whole cohort as they had almost identical distributions of maternal characteristics (data not shown). Overall, 98% of children born to women with perinatal depression had their first polio vaccination, as did the same proportion of children born to women without perinatal depression. The median time of receipt of the first polio vaccination was 61 days after birth for children of mothers with perinatal depression (interquartile range [IQR] 58-68) and this was almost identical for children of mothers without perinatal depression (median = 61 days; IQR 57-67).

Principal findings

Our results show that children born to women with perinatal depression had a 40% increased rate of GI infections and a 27% increased rate of LRTIs compared with children born to women without perinatal depression. For more severe, antibiotic-treated infections, the observed effects increased slightly for GI infections to 47% but decreased slightly for LRTIs to 19%. Our observed absolute differences in rates suggest that over a one year period there were about 97 more GI infections and 19 more LRTIs among every 1000 children born to women with perinatal depression than among 1000 children born to women without perinatal depression. Moreover, the near identical timing of the first polio vaccination among both groups provides no evidence to support the possibility that higher rates of GI infections and LRTIs in children of mothers with perinatal depression may be explained by differential levels of diagnosis due to increased healthcare-seeking behavior among this group.

Strengths and limitations

We have conducted a large population-based cohort study of the association between maternal perinatal depression and childhood infections using primary care data in the UK. Our considerable sample size means that our findings are unlikely to be due to chance. The data we used were obtained from a national database and prospectively recorded by GPs, thus excluding the possibility of recording or recall bias in both our exposure and outcome.

Full 4-year follow-up data were not available for 19.5% of children. Such drop-outs occur due to death or patients deregistering from GP practices. There was no evidence of an increased risk of death in either cohort. In the UK registration with a general practitioner is continuous unless a patient actively requests removal from the practice list, or makes an application to join another practice (typically due to a change of address, or the opening of a new practice). Drop-out rates were similar in both cohorts and we feel they are unlikely to have had a substantial impact on our results.

Although the inclusion of postpartum depression in the exposure definition meant that there could be potential for reverse causation due to some overlap between postpartum depression and childhood infections in the first six months of a child's life, such overlap could not affect the observations at age 1, 2, and 3 years. As we found that the increased risk of childhood infections in mothers with perinatal depression was consistent throughout the first four years of the child's life, we believe it is unlikely that our results were due to reverse causality.

There was a legitimate weakness in our exposure measurement as a certain proportion of mothers with perinatal depression are neither diagnosed nor treated in primary care. The prevalence of diagnosed maternal perinatal depression found in our study (about 9.1%) was in general 4-6% lower than some previous studies conducted in high-income countries [2–4, 23]. However, these studies were based in research settings where selected populations were screened for depression mostly using self-administered questionnaires and their samples were much smaller than ours. On restricting to diagnosed depression using a standardized interviewing schedule, two previous studies (including a meta-analysis) [4, 22] found fairly similar prevalence figures to ours. Although we acknowledge that existing depression does remain undiagnosed in the population, during pregnancy and in the first few months after delivery, women typically have more frequent contact with health professionals than they would usually do because of antenatal/postnatal check-ups. This would tend to reduce under-diagnosis of depression this period. Nevertheless, the presence of under-diagnosis in this population would only result in an underestimation of the risk of childhood GI infections and LRTIs in children associated with perinatal depression, since such misclassification would produce a bias towards the null-hypothesis (of no association between perinatal depression in mothers and childhood infections in offspring).

We defined childhood infections as children having been diagnosed with GI infections or LRTIs in primary care, which primarily relied on mothers bringing their children to see their GPs, so they most likely represented the more severe end of the spectrum of these infections. We supposed that, if women with perinatal depression felt more anxious or less capable to take care of their children, they may take children to see their GPs more often than women without perinatal depression and the increased risk of childhood infections in mothers with perinatal depression therefore could be an overestimate due to biased ascertainment. The first childhood polio vaccination is a routine appointment common to both cohorts of children and mothers and one might expect the timing to be earliest and uptake the greatest amongst children of mothers with high levels of healthcare-seeking behaviour. Although timing and uptake of polio vaccination were all but identical in both cohorts we accept that this is only an indirect, measure of mothers' health seeking behaviour and we cannot conclusively exclude the possibility of biased ascertainment.

Although we considered other factors related to maternal perinatal depression in our analysis, the records of a substantial number of individuals did not provide information about factors such as household socioeconomic status (44% missing), maternal smoking (26.4%) and maternal BMI (40% missing). We were also unable to adjust for some other factors, such as the period of breastfeeding and the child's birth weight which have previously been linked to childhood infections [13, 24, 25] in low-income countries, because birth weight and breastfeeding status are seldom recorded in THIN. It could be argued, however, that these factors may form part of a causal pathway linking maternal perinatal depression to childhood infections. After adjusting for these factors, one previous study [10] (carried out in Pakistan) still found a statistically significant association between maternal postpartum depression and childhood GI infections, suggesting that incomplete adjustment for confounding is unlikely to completely explain the observations of our study.

Interpretation in context of previous studies

Although to our knowledge there are only three previous studies [9–11] examining the potential association between maternal perinatal depression and childhood infections, all have found an increased risk of childhood infections in children born to women with perinatal depression. For example, in a recent American cross-sectional study of 194 mothers and their children at 4-6 weeks postpartum, Groer and Morgan found that children of mothers with postpartum depression experienced more physical illness (including diarrhoeal illness) since birth compared with children of mothers without postpartum depression (p = 0.03) [9]. This study, however, did not provide any measure of effect and did not adjust for potential confounding factors.

In our study, we combined the period of antenatal and postnatal depression together and therefore we did not examine whether the increased risk of childhood infections was independently associated with antenatal depression or early postnatal depression. Rahman et al carried out a similar cohort study [11] of 265 mothers (130 mothers with perinatal depression) in Pakistan and found an increased risk of diarrhoea and a slightly increased, but not statistically significant, risk of ARIs in children of mothers with antenatal or postnatal depression compared with children of mothers without depression (OR = 2.4; 95% CI 1.7-3.3 and OR = 1.1; 95% CI 0.9-1.4, respectively), although they did not adjust for any confounding factors. A subsequent study by the same authors [10] which focused only on the relationship between postnatal depression and childhood diarrhoeal illness showed a similar result to the first, although the risk of diarrhoea in children of mothers with postnatal depression compared with children of mothers without postnatal depression was much stronger once adjusted for important maternal and child factors (unadjusted OR = 2.3; 95% CI 1.6-3.1 and adjusted OR = 3.1; 95% CI 1.8-5.6). The latter study used data from the same cohort of women and only about 5% of women with antenatal depression did not also have postnatal depression [10].

Compared with our study, Rahman et al found a larger effect on GI infections but a slightly smaller one on respiratory infections. Their study population was from a rural area of Pakistan where childhood infections were much more common than in our study population. Furthermore, they used only binary outcomes of more or fewer than five childhood diarrhoeal episodes and more or fewer than six ARI episodes per year, while our outcomes were incidence rates of individual episodes of GI infections and LRTIs. Consequently, our results are not directly comparable. In spite of different study populations and different measures of outcome, we both found an increased risk of GI infections (and also a similar magnitude of respiratory infection risk) in children born to women with perinatal depression compared with those born to women without perinatal depression.

There could be several potential explanations for the association between perinatal depression in mothers and childhood infections in offspring. First of all, previous research [6, 9] has found that mothers with depression during the perinatal period have a dysregulated hypothalamic pituitary adrenocotical axis resulting in decreased levels of salivary cortisol and potentially depressed cellular immunity. This may have a direct impact on the child's immune and neuroendocrine development. Secondly, perinatal depression can have a considerable impact on mothers' childcare abilities. Previous studies [9, 26] reported that mothers with postpartum depression were less likely to breastfeed their children and more likely to give up exclusive breastfeeding than mothers without depression. Breastfeeding can strengthen the immune system of the child and it has been shown that children who are not breastfed have more acute respiratory infections than those who are not [13]. Likewise, children of mothers with perinatal depression have been found to be less well nourished than those of mothers without depression [27, 28], which will increase susceptibility to infection.

In addition, postpartum depression in mothers can lead to child neglect and poorer childcare practices, especially in high-income countries [5, 29, 30]. Children may thus be more exposed to unsanitary and dangerous environments, increasing the potential for exposure to sources of infection.