Policy content and stakeholder network analysis for infant and young child feeding in Nepal
BMC Public Health volume 17, Article number: 421 (2017)
Despite concerted effort from government and partners, Nepal continues to have a high burden of under nutrition among children. Identifying opportunities to strengthen policy support for infant and young child feeding (IYCF) is a key component to improve child survival, growth and development. This study aims to explore policy support for IYCF and to identify the influential stakeholders for IYCF for effective future policy development and programmatic action.
Policies relevant to IYCF were identified through web searches and direct approaches to relevant government ministries. Policy content was analysed based on four key domains focussed on mothers, using a qualitative synthesis approach. Three group interviews were conducted using the participatory tool “Net-Map”, to identify the influential stakeholders in IYCF policy and programming processes.
Twenty-six relevant policy documents were analysed for content relating to IYCF. General support for IYCF was found in most of the development plans and high-level health sector policies. Most implementation level documents included support for provision of correct information to mothers. Capacity building of frontline workers for IYCN and system strengthening were well supported through sectoral plans and policies. However, gaps were identified regarding maternity protection, support for monitoring and evaluation, and translation of high-level policy directives into implementation level guidelines, resulting in a lack of clarity over roles and responsibilities.
Both government and non-governmental stakeholders, particularly donors, emerged as influential drivers of IYCF policy decisions in Nepal, through technical assistance and funding. The Nutrition Technical Committee under the Ministry of Health, UNICEF, Suaahara, USAID and WHO were identified as key actors providing technical assistance. Key funding agencies were identified as UNICEF and USAID.
This study reveals strong policy support for key dimensions of IYCF, supported by a highly networked stakeholder environment. Opportunities to further strengthen IYCF policy in Nepal include: further support for training of frontline workers and complementary feeding interventions; extending maternity leave provisions; and clarifying roles and responsibilities of actors, particularly non-governmental actors. Engaging technical and funding agencies and developing partnerships with other relevant actors will be crucial for ensuring effective policy translates into effective practice.
Nepal has achieved a significant reduction in mortality and morbidity amongst children under-five and women in the last decade . Policy commitment to decentralisation and implementation of priority programs has improved access to maternal and child health services and contributed to achievement of most of the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) . Nepal is signatory to Agenda 2030, also known as the Sustainable Development Goals and has already adopted the 2012 WHA nutrition target in its recently endorsed health sector strategy .
Despite long-standing and influential cultural practices that support feeding babies with their mothers’ milk , poor feeding and care practices continue to be responsible for the high burden of under-nutrition amongst infants and young children in Nepal . Recent survey data indicate low prevalence of early initiation of breastfeeding (44.5%), exclusive breastfeeding (69.6%), and age-appropriate complementary feeding practices . Although the majority (66%) of infants between the ages of 6–8 months are introduced to complementary foods, the rate of minimum acceptable diet is very low. Only a quarter of children are fed the recommended breast milk or milk product, four or more food groups, and a minimum meal frequency according to their age and breastfeeding status . While most of the data related to IYCF practices are far from reaching the 2012 WHA nutrition target, Nepal has already met the target for exclusive breastfeeding of up to or at least 50%. However, the recent decline in breastfeeding rate is a concern .
Globally, almost half of the deaths among under-5 children can be attributed to under-nutrition . Global evidence shows a 45% reduction in risk of neonatal mortality if the baby is breastfed within 24 h of birth followed by exclusive breastfeeding . Consumption of minimum acceptable diet (minimum meal frequency and adequate dietary diversity) is known to reduce the risk of under-nutrition in children . Improving infant and young child feeding practices, therefore, has the potential to reduce mortality and morbidity, especially during the initial 2 years of life . The World Health Organization (WHO) has recognised the protection, promotion and support of breastfeeding and optimal complementary feeding as crucial to improving child survival, growth and development .
The Government of Nepal has policies and programs in place to promote optimal practices for breastfeeding and complementary feeding, with the aim of achieving targets set by the WHO . Nepal has adopted a multi-sector approach to addressing under-nutrition and has made a concerted effort to achieve policy coherence by involving all relevant sectors and concerned stakeholders. Recently, Ministry of Health and Population has also formulated a multisectoral policy advisory committee for nutrition , to provide technical as well as policy guidance for the health sector and beyond.
However, the 2012 World Breastfeeding Trend Initiative Nepal Report  identified gaps in IYCF policy and programs, scoring countries based on international recommendations for IYCF policy support. Nepal scored only 40.5 out of 100, compared to an average performance of 54.3 among the 40 countries assessed . The report also observed that there has been little improvement in the IYCF policy environment since 2005.
Policy analysis enables us to understand and strengthen the policy environment [17, 18]. At this time, when a multi-sectoral approach is being given significant priority to address the multi-factorial dimensions of nutrition [9, 19], the role of stakeholders becomes particularly crucial in terms of understanding how the decision-making process is influenced for policy and programming.
This paper describes our analysis of the content of the policy documents for IYCF support and the stakeholders who influence IYCF policy and programme decisions in Nepal. Our study aimed to identify opportunities to strengthen the IYCF policy environment in Nepal and to identify the stakeholders best placed to achieve this. The results of this study will inform more effective policy development and programmatic action. First, the policy support for protection, promotion and support for breastfeeding and complementary feeding practices is described, followed by a participatory approach to analyse stakeholder’s influence on policy and program decisions.
Policy content analysis
The research team, through a series of consultative meetings of the South Asia Infant Feeding Research Network (SAIFRN), developed a standard matrix with the key IYCF domains that could be supported by policy, based on best-practice recommendations for promoting protecting and supporting IYCF. These included: a) general support for infant and young child nutrition, b) provision of correct information to mothers, c) training of health workers to counsel mothers, and d) enabling mother to engage with health care workers for informed decision making.
We used the definition by Buse et al. of “health policy” as embracing ‘courses of action (and inaction) that affect the set of institutions, organizations, services and funding arrangements of the health system but focussed on public (government) policy . The SAIFRN research team used mind-mapping to identify four types of policy documents (and examples) with potential relevance to IYCF: those focussed on guiding overall government strategy; sector-specific documents; implementation-level documents; and other relevant policy documents.
We identified policy documents by searching relevant websites (National Planning Commission, Law Commission, Ministry of Health and Population, Department of Health Services, Ministry of Agricultural Development, UNICEF Nepal, World Bank-Nepal, USAID-Nepal). We used keywords such as “infant and young child feeding”, “nutrition”, “breastfeeding”, “complementary feeding”, “IYCF” “counselling” in various combinations. Reference lists found in the above documents were reviewed to identify potentially relevant reports and documents. We also contacted experts from government, external development partners, national and international non-governmental organisations, and academic institutions working in the field of health and nutrition to identify other relevant documents. Archives of organisations and newspapers were examined to identify information related to policy support for nutrition and IYCF.
The content of each policy was reviewed manually, using the matrix to identify provisions that support IYCF across each of the four domains described above. Relevant policy text and references were extracted and entered into the matrix template in an excel spread-sheet. The Extracts were grouped under the emerging themes. We used narrative as well as thematic synthesis to analyse the policy content in relation to IYCF support. We used a qualitative narrative synthesis approach to describe the ways in which the current policy landscape provided support for IYCF.
Policy-relevant stakeholder analysis
In order to understand the role of actors, a participatory method known as Net-Map  was used. This interview technique investigates social networks, power relations and perspectives of relevant stakeholders. The tool can be used to visualise interactions between actors and how the network of these interactions influences decision-making.
The research team initially prepared an exhaustive list of stakeholders with knowledge and experience of IYCF policy processes in Nepal. Development of this list was informed by our knowledge of the field and discussions with expert informants including, nutrition programme managers at the Ministry of Health and Population, academic researchers, and colleagues working with the non-government organisations in the field of nutrition. The initial list comprised of people who had worked in this field previously, along with the current stakeholders. The list was subsequently revised and finalised by asking participants to identify further relevant participants. Those stakeholders not involved in recent policy development processes were left out.
We conducted 3 semi-structured group interviews between March and June 2015 involving a total of 25 participants (9 government, 5 academia/research, 5 UN agencies and 2 international non-government organisations, and 4 civil society organisations) to capture diverse views, opinions and perspectives (Table 1). The interviews focussed on the following questions: a) Who plays a role in shaping policy and program decisions on IYCF at the national level in the country?; b) Who provides funding and technical assistance to whom as a means of engaging in or influencing policy and programme decisions on IYCF?; and c) How strongly does each actor influence the shaping of policy and program decisions on IYCF? A trained facilitator led the interviews. Interviews were recorded and notes were taken by two to document inaudible features of the discussion. During these interviews, physical maps were created to represent participants’ descriptions of the stakeholders and their interactions, and qualitative data were recorded from the discussions.
Ethics approval was obtained from Nepal Health Research Council for this study. Verbal consent was sought from participants during Net-Map interview after explaining the objective of the study and the exercise.
The quantitative Net-Map data from all three exercises were entered into MS Excel datasheet individually and later combined for analysis using social network analysis software ORA (Organizational Risk Analyzer, copyright Carley, Carnegie Mellon University) . ORA was used to create a map visualising the key stakeholders and their networks for technical as well as the financial exchange for IYCF policy and programme decisions in Nepal. The qualitative data regarding opinions and perceptions of wide-ranging actors involved in IYCF were used to understand how these actors play a role influencing the decision for policy and programming for IYCF in Nepal.
In a Network Map, each stakeholder is represented by a node. Relationships between nodes is represented by a line, called a directed edge. Edges are described as directed because they indicate which node initiated the relationship (it’s direction). Directed edges also indicate the flow of support (in this case, funding and technical support). In our findings, we use four network centrality measures to describe the roles of actors in the network. In-degree indicates the number of directed edges incident on an actor, reflecting inward-directed support. Out-degree is the number of directed edges that originate at a node. Betweenness measures interconnectedness, and represents the capacity of an actor to control the flow of information between any pair of all other member actors in a network. Closeness measures the ease of reaching other nodes. An actor having high closeness centrality is well connected with the remaining network actors and vice versa.
Results and discussion
Policy content analysis
We identified a total of 26 relevant public policy documents. Most of these documents were from the health and agriculture sectors, while few policies belonged to the country’s strategic development plan. We also identified two acts of parliament. Content analysis indicated that policy support exists in Nepal for all four aspects of IYCF intervention examined (Table 2).
Broad guidance or support for IYCF
There is a strong commitment and priority given to nutrition, including infant and young child feeding, by the Government of Nepal. The 9th and 10th Five Year Plans, and the 1st Three-Year Interim Plan [23,24,25] specifically identify the importance of promoting breastfeeding, and the 2nd Three-Year Interim Plan  goes even further, including a recommendation to implement a programme on IYCF with a major focus on counselling.
This strategic support is reflected in the recent Multi-Sector Nutrition Plan , which brings together all relevant sectors. These include health, education, local development, agriculture, water, sanitation and hygiene and women and child welfare. Another key multi-sectoral policy, providing general support for good IYCF practices, is the Substitute for Breast Milk (Sale, Distribution and Control) Act of Nepal . Its provisions include the formation of a high level Breast Feeding Protection and Promotion Committee under the chairmanship of the Secretary for Health. The committee includes representatives from health, agriculture, commerce and supply, industry, and education, demonstrating commitment to cross-sectoral policy coherence to protect, promote and support breastfeeding practices in Nepal. This committee is tasked not only to supervise compliance with the act but also more broadly to protect and promote breastfeeding.
Provision of correct information to the mothers
Of the reviewed policy documents, 12 health sector specific policy and programmatic documents [13, 29,30,31,32,33,34,35,36,37] mandate the provision of correct IYCF information to mothers. These policies focus on ensuring the provision of information to mothers through counselling given by frontline health workers and health volunteers, and through dissemination of information, education and communication material, including via mass media.
The National Health Sector Program (NHSP I & II) includes specific strategies for promotion of counselling at the health facilities as well as through community level frontline workers, to increase awareness of recommended breastfeeding and young child feeding behaviours. The provision of counselling on breastfeeding, delivery care, nutrition and hygiene during antenatal clinics has been included in the Nepal Safe Motherhood Policy 1998 . Likewise, the National Policy on Skilled Birth Attendants 2006  also prioritises educating women and their families in the practice and support of successful breastfeeding practices. This includes encouraging family members to assist mothers to initiate and establish breastfeeding immediately after birth and practice exclusive breastfeeding; and supporting mothers and families to achieve this through inter-personal counselling provided by the birth attendants.
Provision of correct information to mothers through preparation and dissemination of information, education and communication materials and reaching mothers through different channels of communication is recommended in the Multi-Sector Nutrition Plan 2012 . Similarly, the NHSP-II  identifies improved infant feeding and health practices through community networks and media based campaigns as priorities. Likewise, the Substitute for Breast Milk (Sale, Distribution and Control) Act of Nepal  protects breastfeeding by restricting the promotion of breast-milk substitutes. However, neither of these documents addresses the promotion of age-appropriate complementary feeding. Moreover, the National Health Communication Policy 2012  does not include any policy direction or strategies for IYCF communication. The national IYCF Strategy  prescribes a standard set of messages for dissemination through all possible channels across all sectors to ensure uniformity and consistency of the information provided to the target groups.
Training and capacity building of workers on IYCF
Four policies [13, 27, 35, 41] provide for the capacity development of workers for nutrition, including IYCF. At a strategic level – and recognising the importance of a multi-sector approach – the recently endorsed national Multi-Sector Nutrition Plan (MSNP)  has outlined a comprehensive and systematic approach to building the capacity of human resources of all relevant sectors. These sectors include health, education, local development, agriculture, water, sanitation and hygiene, and women and child welfare in nutrition. Specifically, this plan focusses on providing counselling in support of adequate maternal, infant and young child nutrition. The strategy also includes capacity assessment  on nutrition for frontline workers, district level managers and central staff from all relevant sectors; developing a capacity building plan and carrying out training for nutritional and non-nutritional professionals from all the sectors focusing on local level cadres. However, the roles of each sector in conducting training needs assessment for nutrition are not specified in the document. It also specifies the different layers of training to the service providers. However, the training focuses on management skills rather than developing a skilled counselling workforce. Training to build capacity of health workers, community level service providers and medical professionals for counselling at the health facilities is mandated within the National Nutrition Policy and Strategy in 2004 . The Ministry of Health delivers this training with support from professional bodies and academic institutions.
The strategic guidance of MSNP  on scaling up of community IYCF interventions is operationalized in the recently drafted IYCF Strategy , which includes development of training guidelines and modules for health facility as well as community level frontline health workers. The modules on breastfeeding are aligned with the global training manuals developed by WHO and UNICEF [43, 44]. The IYCF Strategy  calls for the development of standard training manuals with sessions that focus on the promotion of optimal breastfeeding practices (early initiation of breastfeeding, exclusive breastfeeding and extended breastfeeding), timely initiation of complementary feeding and, age-appropriate complementary feeding practices to support adequate quantity and quality of complementary feeding.
The national IYCF Strategy  also explicitly identifies the need to provide practical skills and knowledge to frontline health workers to enable them to identify and manage breastfeeding problems and empower mothers to overcome barriers to adopting optimal feeding and care practices. In Nepal, frontline health workers include those working in the health facilities at the community level as well as female community health volunteers. The strategy emphasises the importance of skill-based training to enhance counselling skills of community level service providers from all relevant sectors in line with the MSNP . The document fails to identify the community level cadres from non-health sectors to be trained to provide counselling on nutrition. Using these non-health cadres as peer counsellors, social mobilisers and agriculture extension workers would also strengthen the capacity of sectors other than health to strengthen nutrition and institutionalise nutrition in non-health systems. The strategy includes a recommendation for the review of existing training materials in order to harmonise and integrate into a single comprehensive set of IYCF and Baby Friendly Hospital Initiative (BFHI) training materials for pre-service as well as in-service training for health and non-health service providers. To implement the maternal as well as IYCF Strategy, a joint plan of action for maternal, infant and young child nutrition  has recently been drafted.
While both the MSNP  and the national IYCF Strategy  have recommended a comprehensive and standardised IYCF training package, our review did not identify a clear statement on the roles and responsibilities of relevant agencies or the implementation modalities for the training of service providers. Detailed training schedules, content, resources and personnel, well defined roles and responsibilities and the criteria for selection of participants could be integrated into the national IYCF strategy  and the National Plan of Action for MIYCN , which are yet to be endorsed by the Ministry of Health and Population.
Enabling mothers to engage with care
Eight of the health sector policy documents and the recent Multi-Sector Nutrition Plan [13, 27, 28, 31, 32, 35,36,37,38] target mothers and care takers for IYCF support. Mothers (and caregivers) are specifically enabled to engage with care related to IYCF through improving access to health services for marginalised populations, engaging women in local governance, enabling employed women access to maternity leave and flexible working arrangements, and establishing community based support services to augment formal health service provision.
Empowering and enabling mothers and care takers by involving them in training and group meetings for counselling, through social mobilisation for behaviour change, and improving access to IYCF services is the major approach outlined in the MSNP . Given increasing disparity in IYCF practices, the plan mandates socially inclusive, gender and child friendly approaches in the design and implementation of its programmes; it focuses on reaching the most marginalized, disadvantaged and poorest segments of the population. For women not working in formal sectors, the IYCF strategy provides community-based support through the establishment of mother-to-mother support groups, involving male partners, peer educators or other family and community members. The program is currently being scaled up in 41 out of 75 districts.
The National Nutrition Policy and Strategy in 2004  has identified as one of its strategies, the provision to promote mother and child friendly working environments, by establishing crèches, promotion of breastfeeding breaks for working mothers and to advocate for extended maternity as well as paternity leave with policy makers and central level managers. The recently drafted IYCF Strategy and its Plan of Action [13, 41] have identified the importance of the provision of breastfeeding break and workplace day care centre. These policies align with recommendations by the WHO/UNICEF [43, 45]. However, the detailed activities for its implementation have not been specified.
The current provision for maternity leave, in the Labour Act , which is important for establishing and continuing breastfeeding, differs for women working in different sectors. The duration of leave entitlement varies from 98 days of paid maternity leave for a woman judge at the District Court or Appellate Court, to only 45 days for a woman working at a tea plantation. The Government of Nepal has also decided to grant paternity leave . Under this provision, the male employees could be given 11 days paid leave for the birth of each of their first two children. The recent IYCF strategy  document has explicitly mentioned the need for a review and amendment of the national legislation on maternity protection. It has also suggested implementing a model intervention to demonstrate effective implementation of the revised law in selected private and public sectors and thereby scaling it up nationwide by 2020 based on the effectiveness. However, it is important to note that these provisions apply only to women working in the formal sector, and that the current provision of maternity leave for 12 to 14 weeks is not applied uniformly in the private sectors . More importantly, the majority of women work in the informal sector and are excluded from the maternity leave benefits.
IYCF support across other sectors
We also identified support for IYCF at the policy level in Nepal in the form of strong multisectoral collaboration, and support for agriculture and food security. The Multi-Sector Nutrition Plan , Food and Nutrition Security Plan of Action , National IYCF Strategy  and Health Sector Strategy for Addressing Maternal Under-nutrition , seek to integrate IYCF related services with the programme of other sectors. For example, the Multi-Sector Nutrition Plan  emphasised the integration or linking of IYCF with other sectoral programmes such as the Child Cash Grant (administered by Ministry of Local Development), and water, sanitation and hygiene programmes (administered by Ministry of Urban Development), as well as ensuring that support for good IYCF is explicit in other health sector programmes such as antenatal care, birth preparedness package and growth monitoring.
While there has been limited focus on complementary feeding in the health sector policies, dietary diversity is supported by the Food and Nutrition Security Plan of Action  under the Agriculture Development Strategy . This strategy provides specific programmes to increase access to safe, nutritious and diversified food, and to address food and nutrition security in the existing agriculture education system for production diversification and nutrition diversity. The National Nutrition Policy, MSNP and National IYCF Strategy [13, 27, 35] have provided a detailed framework for monitoring and evaluation of programmes, including  direction to include it in regular surveillance of health and nutrition in the country.
Stakeholders and social network analysis
Overview of findings
A total of 43 actors were identified through three Net-Map group interviews. Six categories of stakeholders were identified, including: Government; Research, Academic and Professional Bodies; UN, Donor, INGO; NGOs and Civil Society Organisations; and Others. These stakeholders were connected through flows of funding and technical advice, represented by lines (Figs. 1 and 2). The varied size of the nodes represents the relative level of influence of the actors in terms of policy and programmatic decision for IYCF at the country level ranging from a smallest node as least influential to the largest node as the most influential.
Tracing the central stakeholders
Several actors were found to be highly influential through the provision of technical assistance (Fig. 1; Table 2). The Nutrition Technical Committee (NuTEC) at the Nutrition Section, Child Health Division (CHD) was the primary influencer in the network. This is a committee under the MoHP to provide policy advisory and technical as well as programmatic guidance to health sector for nutrition. The quantitative analysis indicates that NuTEC received substantial technical support (in-degree), provided technical support (out-degree), was accessible to a wide range of other actors in the network (closeness), and exerted a high degree of control over the flow of information between actors by its position in the network (betweenness) (Table 3). This was supported by the (qualitative) discussion regarding NuTECs central position as an actor. The NuTEC plays a key role in providing technical input as well as receives the input for IYCF policy and programmatic decision. Suhaara, an NGO, was the only other actor to rank in the top 10 for all of the four network measures, also indicating its role as an influencer in the network.
International agencies – UNICEF, Save the Children, World Bank and USAID – were also key sources of technical support (out-degree), and were strategically positioned within the network (betweenness and closeness) (Fig. 1; Tables 2 and 3). In addition to these organisations, one individual (an academic) emerged as an important source of technical assistance for IYCF.
The most influential actors with respect to provision of funding were NGOs, mainly INGOs (Out-degree; Table 3), and the network map showed a funding flow from INGOs towards government departments (Fig. 2). The primary influencer with respect to funding was UNICEF, which found to provide funding (out-degree), coordinate funding from other donors (in-degree), was accessible to a wide range of other actors in the network (closeness) and exerted a high degree of control over the flow of funds between actors by its position in the network (betweenness) (Table 3). WHO, the World Bank, Suaahara, Save the Children, USAID and WFP emerged as secondary influences, providing funding (out-degree) and having high connectivity within the network (closeness and betweenness).
NuTEC, Suaahara and UNICEF were notable actors in that they were influential in both the funding and technical support networks – each of these actors appeared in the top ten for seven of the eight network measures (Table 3). The discussion indicated that this reflects their roles as coordinators of IYCF policy and program action. The main differences apparent between these three was that UNICEF was not one of the top ten receivers of technical support, whereas Suaahara was not one of the top ten receivers of funding, and NuTEC was not one of the top ten providers of funding.
In terms of relative influence for IYCF policy and programme decisions, the (qualitative) discussion indicated that government agencies namely NuTEC/CHD, NHTC, NHEICC, NPC, DFTQC, FHD were perceived as the most influential by the interview participants because they had the authority and the decision-making power. UNICEF, WHO, USAID, Save the Children and Suaahara were also influential in terms of providing technical support and funding. Individuals like Prof PSS, RKA and AU were perceived to be influential through their provision of technical support and high level of connectedness.
Communities of actors
Further analysis of the social network revealed that there were distinct communities within the broader network for technical support as well as financing. Actors within each of these of IYCF policy and program communities were all more engaged among themselves compared to other actors.
There were four distinct major communities under the technical assistance network (Fig. 3). The composition of these technical communities was diverse; all included a mix of actors from government, INGOs, donor agencies and academic institutions (Fig. 1; Fig. 3). Government agencies dominated the largest community, which had NuTEC in the centre, and NuTEC was found to be connected with all other communities. Another major technical assistance community had mostly INGOs and donor agencies with Suaahara, UNICEF and Prof RKA as the key actors, and Suaahara and UNICEF were also found to have connection across to other communities. The WFP was at the centre of a third major community, and WHO and DFTQC were central players in a fourth, smaller, community. There were a few small communities with two or one actors that were not linked with all the communities in the network. This analysis of communities indicates that NuTEC plays an essential role as a hub for technical assistance from different communities. This understanding of working patterns and grouping of actors can also help to inform advocacy efforts.
Five communities emerged within the funding network (Fig. 4). Each community was clustered around one or two major donors (USAID and Pool Partners; UNICEF; World Bank; WFP; and WHO). NuTEC received funding support from all donor agencies from these different communities, and were part of a community containing several other donors. In other communities, local NGOs, INGOs and research institutions were the major recipients of funding support. The World Bank and WHO provided funding support to government institutions only.
The analysis indicates that the effort for strengthening the policy landscape for promotion, protection and support for optimal IYCF practices in last few years have led to a strong and supportive policy environment for IYCF in Nepal. Current initiatives by government to harmonise the interventions across sectors is a particularly positive step. This policy focus has been reflected in stakeholder influence. Multisectoral nutrition committees play a central role in drafting the IYCF strategy and National Plan of Action [13, 41] and review the evidence to inform reformulation of programming.
Specific strengths in the policy landscape that were identified in our analysis. These include support for counselling to mothers and care takers, creating enabling environment for breastfeeding, ensuring correct and consistent information for mothers through all possible contact points and health system support for IYCF, building the capacity of frontline workers for IYCF counselling and creating supportive environment for mothers to seek care and support for improving IYCF.
However, we observed a gap in the policy and programming environment around complementary feeding. Given the current low level of complementary feeding practices in Nepal , addressing this gap should be prioritised.
This research has identified specific opportunities to improve IYCF policy in Nepal, as well as identifying key stakeholders to inform advocacy, using policy mapping and stakeholder analysis methods. Consideration of two key aspects of policy (content and actors) through in-depth content analysis and stakeholder analysis is a strength of this study. The study has considered crucial domains of IYCF in the analysis, which will guide to address the gaps identified in terms of effective IYCF policy and interventions. However, the limitations of this research include the decision not to measure changes in the policy environment and stakeholder environment over time (due to funding constraints), and the focus on only two avenues of influence in the stakeholder mapping. In addition, the detailed study to understand the power dynamics and factors responsible for an actor to be influential in the network would provide a better understanding about the IYCF policy landscape in the country.
The recently drafted strategy on IYCF  makes provision for effective counselling at the health facility and community level, for which, it has emphasised the importance of capacity building of health workers and the role of health system support in institutionalising IYCF programmes. This IYCF programme has been rolled out in most of the districts . However, there are significant opportunities to enhance the realisation of these policy goals through the inclusion of more specific attention to implementation. The National Plan of Action on MIYCN  seeks to prioritise IYCF counselling and supporting interventions through the health system, but lacks clarity around roles and responsibilities of partners, effective mechanisms for monitoring and evaluation at national level, and allocation of sufficient resources. Opportunities to strengthen IYCF policy include the development and consistent implementation of standard training packages for frontline workers, and improving monitoring and evaluation of IYCF policies and programs.
Given increasing urbanisation and more women coming into the formal workforce, another opportunity to strengthen policy is to enhance support for working mothers, particularly in urban areas. This analysis indicates that specific opportunities exist to extend maternity leave for 6 months for women in formal employment, and to strengthen the community-based efforts to provide access to health services for women in informal employment. Our stakeholder analysis suggests that effective advocacy will require collaboration between government and non-government stakeholders to develop and propose evidence based policy options. It would be important for the major actors, such as UNICEF and NuTEC, to strengthen links with the actors responsible for the different aspects of maternity protection, such as the Ministry of Labour and private sector actors, who are not well connected in the network so that their perspectives could also be considered during policy decisions and programming.
A major challenge identified for implementation of nutrition interventions, including IYCF, are the shortage of human resources and their capacity in delivering nutrition services at the community level . The quality of counselling on IYCF largely depends on the knowledge and skills of frontline health workers. The Government of Nepal is responding to this challenge, with MoHP initiating the development of an integrated training package on MIYCN . However, our content analysis identified a need for this initiative to be supported by clear timelines and delineation of roles and responsibilities. The stakeholder analysis component of this study further supports this, indicating that implementation of nutrition interventions, including IYCF, is heavily dependent on non-government sectors, yet their roles and responsibilities are not clearly defined in the policy documents. The MSNP  also does not highlight training the frontline workers from other sectors on IYCF.
One option may be to explore alternate community-level cadres (like peer counsellor, social mobilisers, agriculture extension workers) to deliver the IYCF counselling other than health frontline workers. Given there is increasing commitment to multi-sector approaches to nutrition in Nepal, building capacity of such cadres could improve delivery of nutrition services. This approach has been included in the policy  under the agriculture sector. This approach would build on the increasing role of NGOs in IYCF policy delivery.
Infant and Young Child Feeding
Infant and Young Child Nutrition
United States Agency for International Development
World Health Organisation
United Nations Children Fund
Child Health Division
Millennium Development Goal
South Asia Infant Feeding Research Network
Maternal Infant and Young Child Nutrition
Maternal, Newborn and Child Health
Nepal Health Sector Programme
Ante Natal Care
Multi-Sector Nutrition Plan
International Non-Governmental Organisation
Nutrition Technical Committee
World Food Programme
Helen Keller International
National Health Training Centre
National Planning Commission
National Health Education, Information and Communication Centre
Department of Food Technology and Quality Control
Family Health Division
Prakash Sunder Shrestha
Ramesh Kant Adhikari
Ministry of Education
Ministry of Agricultural Development
BASICS II, The MOST Project, and USAID. Nepal Child Survival Case Study: Technical Report. Basic Support for Institutionalizing Child Survival Project (BASICS II) for the United States Agency for International Development. Arlington, Virginia; 2004.
NPC and UNCT, Nepal Millennium Development Goals Progress Report. Government of Nepal, National Planning Commission and United Nations Country Team; Kathmandu, Nepal; 2013.
Government of Nepal, MoHP. Nepal Health Sector Strategy 2015–2020. Ministry of Health and Population; Kathmandu, Nepal; 2015.
Paneru S. Breast Feeding in Nepal: Religious and Culture Beliefs. Contrib Nepal Stud. 1981;8:43–54.
Senarath U, et al. Comparisons of complementary feeding indicators and associated factors in children aged 6–23 months across five South Asian countries. Matern Child Nutr. 2012;8(Suppl 1):89–106.
Ministry of Health and Population (MoHP) [Nepal], New ERA, and ICF International Inc. Nepal Demographic and Health Survey 2011. Kathmandu, Nepal: Ministry of Health and Population, New ERA, and ICF International, Calverton, Maryland; 2012.
IFPRI, Global Nutrition Report 2016. From Promise to Impact: Ending Malnutrition by 2030. International Food Policy and Research Institute. Washington, D.C. 2016.
Black RE, et al. Maternal and child undernutrition and overweight in low-income and middle-income countries. Lancet. 2013;382(9890):427–51.
Bhutta ZA, et al. Evidence-based interventions for improvement of maternal and child nutrition: what can be done and at what cost? Lancet. 2013;382(9890):452–77.
Marriott BP, et al. World Health Organization (WHO) infant and young child feeding indicators: associations with growth measures in 14 low-income countries. Matern Child Nutr. 2012;8(3):354–370.
Bhutta ZA, et al. What works? Interventions for maternal and child undernutrition and survival. Lancet. 2008;371(9610):417–40.
WHO, The World Health Report 2002: Reducing Risks, Promoting Healthy Life. World Health Organization. Geneva; 2002.
Government of Nepal, MoHP, Department of Health Services, Child Health Division, Strategy for Infant and Young Child Feeding: Nepal 2014 (Draft). Child Health Division; Kathmandu, Nepal; 2014.
Government of Nepal, Ministry of Health, Department of Health Services, CHD, Terms of Reference- Nutrition Technical Committee (NuTEC), Nutrition Section, Child Health Division. Kathmandu, Nepal; 2012.
Shrestha PS, Pant KT. The World Breastfeeding Trends Initiative - Nepal Report 2012. Nepal Breastfeeding Promotion Forum. Kathmandu, Nepal; 2012.
Gupta A, et al. The status of policy and programmes on infant and young child feeding in 40 countries. Health Policy Plan. 2012;28(3):279–98.
Walt G, Gilson L. Reforming the health sector in developing countries: the central role of policy analysis. Health Policy Plan. 1994;9(4):353–70.
Walt G, et al. ‘Doing’ health policy analysis: methodological and conceptual reflections and challenges. Health Policy Plan. 2008;23(5):308–17.
International Bank for Reconstruction and Development, International Development Association or The World Bank. Improving nutrition through multisectoral approaches. The World Bank: Washington DC; 2013.
Buse K, Mays N, Walt G. Making health policy. UK: McGraw-Hill Education; 2012.
Schiffer, E. and D. Waale, Tracing power and influence in networks: Net-map as a tool for research and strategic network planning. International Food Policy Research Institute. Washington, D.C; 2008.
Effken JA, et al. Using* ORA, a network analysis tool, to assess the relationship of handoffs to quality and safety outcomes. Comp Inf Nurs. 2013;31(1):36.
His Majesty's Government of Nepal, NPC, Nepal - Ninth Plan (1997–2002). National Planning Commission; Kathmandu, Nepal; 1997.
His Majesty's Government of Nepal, NPC, Nepal - Tenth Plan (2002–2007). National Planning Commission; Kathmandu, Nepal; 2002.
Government of Nepal, NPC, Nepal - Three Year Interim Plan (2007/08–2009/10). National Planning Commission; Kathmandu, Nepal; 2007.
Government of Nepal, NPC, Nepal - Three Year Interim Plan (2010/11–2012/13). National Planning Commission; Kathmandu, Nepal; 2010.
Government of Nepal, NPC, Multi-sector Nutrition Plan: For Accelerating the Reduction of Maternal and Child Under-nutrition in Nepal, 2013–2017. Kathmandu, Nepal; 2012.
His Majesty's Government, NLC. Mother’s Milk Substitutes (Control of Sale and Distribution) Act, 2049 (1992). National Law Commission. Kathmandu, Nepal; 1992.
Government of Nepal, MoHP, National Communication Strategy for Maternal, Newborn and Child Health (2012–16). National Health Education Information and Communication Centre. Kathmandu. Nepal; 2012.
Government of Nepal, MoHP. National Health Policy 1991. Ministry of Health and Population; Kathmandu, Nepal; 1991.
Government of Nepal, MoHP. Second Long Term Health Plan 1997–2017: Perspective Plan for Health Sector Development. Health Sector Reform Unit; Kathmandu, Nepal; 1997.
Government of Nepal, MoHP, Nepal Health Sector Programme-2 Implementation Plan, (2010–2015). Ministry of Health and Population; Kathmandu. Nepal; 2010.
Government of Nepal, MoHP. National Health Communication Policy 2012. National Health Education Communication and Information Centre; Kathmandu, Nepal; 2012.
Government of Nepal, MoHP. National Health Policy 2071. Ministry of Health and Population; Kathmandu, Nepal; 2014.
Government of Nepal, MoHP. National Nutrition Policy and Strategy 2004. Department of Health Services, Child Health Division; Kathmandu, Nepal; 2008.
Government of Nepal, MoHP, DoHS and CHD, National MIYCN Communication Plan (Draft). Ministry of Health & Population, Department of Health Services, Child Health Division; Kathmandu, Nepal; 2014.
His Majesty’s Government, MoH, Nepal Health Sector Programme - Implementation Plan (NHSP-IP), (2004–2009). Ministry of Health. Kathmandu, Nepal; 2004.
His Majesty’s Government of Nepal, MoH, Safe Motherhood Policy 1998. Department of Health Services, Family Health Division; Kathmandu, Nepal; 1998.
Government of Nepal, MoHP, National Policy on Skilled Birth Attendants: Supplementary to Safe Motherhood Policy 1998. Department of Health Services, Family Health Division; Kathmandu, Nepal; 2006.
Government of Nepal, MoHP, Nepal Health Sector Programme-II 2010–2015. Ministry of Health and Population; Kathmandu. Nepal; 2010.
Government of Nepal, MoHP, National MIYCN Plan of Action (Draft) 2014. Ministry of Health and Population, Department of Health Services, Child Health Division; Kathmandu, Nepal; 2014.
Shrimpton R, Atwood S. Nepal National and District Nutrition Capacity Assessment. Kathmandu: National Planning Commission; 2013.
UNICEF, Programming Guide: Infant and Young Child Feeding. United Nations Children's Fund. New York; 2011.
WHO, UNICEF. Infant and young child feeding counselling: an integrated course. World Health Organization. Geneva; 2006.
WHO, UNICEF, Global Strategy for Infant and Young Child Feeding. World Health Organization. Geneva; 2003.
His Majesty’s Government, NLC, Labour Act, 2048 (1992). National Law Commission; Kathmandu, Nepal; 1992.
BBC News. Nepal introduces paternity leave. 2004. [Accessed 10 Mar 2016]. Available from: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/3686148.stm.
Government of Nepal, MoAD, Food and Nutrition Security Plan of Action (FNSPA) of Nepal. Ministry of Agricultural Development; 2016.
Government of Nepal, MoHP, DoHS, Health Sector Strategy for Addressing Maternal Undernutrition 2013–2017. Department of Health Services; Kathmandu, Nepal; 2014.
Government of Nepal, MoAD, Agriculture Development Strategy 2015-2035. Ministry of Agricultural Development; Kathmandu, Nepal; 2016.
Department of Health Services. Annual Report. Management Division; Kathmandu, Nepal; 2015.
His Majesty's Government of Nepal, NPC, Nepal - The Fifth Plan (1975–80) In Brief. National Planning Commission; Kathmandu, Nepal; 1975.
His Majesty's Government of Nepal, NPC, Nepal - Sixth Plan (1980–1985). National Planning Commission; Kathmandu, Nepal; 1980.
His Majesty's Government of Nepal, NPC, The Seventh Plan (1985–1990). National Planning Commission; Kathmandu, Nepal; 1985.
His Majesty's Government of Nepal, NPC, The Eighth Plan (1992–1997). National Planning Commission; Kathmandu, Nepal; 1992.
Government of Nepal, NPC. An Approach Paper to the Thirteenth Plan (FY 2013/14–2015/16): National Planning Commission; Kathmandu, Nepal; 2013.
This research was funded by the Australian Government, Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, (Public Sector Linkage Program, AusAID agreement number- 60729) through the University of Sydney. We would like to acknowledge Prof. Michael J Dibley, Sydney School of Public Health, University of Sydney, who steered us towards this policy and stakeholder analysis as an activity of the South Asian Infant Feeding Research Network. We are grateful to Dr. Kalpana Tiwari who contributed in the conception and design of this study. We would like to thank Ms. Isha Karmacharya and Ms. Smriti Maskey for their help in conducting Net-Map, transcribing qualitative data and extracting the relevant content from the policy documents. We thank Mr. Rajkumar Pokharel for coordination in carrying out all three NetMap exercises. The authors acknowledge and appreciate the constructive input from the reviewers. We would also like to acknowledge the contribution of Ms. Elizabeth Kirkwood, Sydney School of Public Health, University of Sydney, for coordinating preparation of the supplement.
Availability of data and material
All the participants in the study were assured confidentiality. The policy content review sheet is kept with the research team. The team will be unable to provide access to the NetMap Exercise dataset due to the chances of disclosure of individual participants’ identity in small geographic location.
This research work is funded by the Australian Government Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, (grant number- Gr 01030) through the University of Sydney. The fund was channelized through locally registered agency as part of the South Asian Infant Feeding Research Network. The authors take all the responsibility for the content. The views and interpretations of this paper does not necessarily represent the view of DFAT or University of Sydney. The cost of publication was funded by the Australian Government, Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, (Public Sector Linkage Program, AusAID agreement number- 60729) through the University of Sydney.
All authors contributed equally in conceptualizing and structuring of the paper. SAK did the first draft of the paper in consultation and significant input from the MDD and AMT. SAK coordinated for writing the paper, did content as well as social network analysis, incorporated comments made by reviewers and led the revision of drafts until publication. MDD contributed to do the content analysis and sections under the policy content analysis and did overall review of the paper. SU contributed in analysing the Net-Map data, assisted in writing the sections related to social network and stakeholder analysis. AMT contributed in conceptualising the paper, assisted in writing methodology section, doing content analysis, assisted in writing the discussion and conclusion and did review of the paper. All authors contributed to the final paper.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
The ethical approval for this study was obtained from Ethical Review Board of the Nepal Health Research Council. A verbal informed consent was obtained from the participants in the NetMap Exercise before conducting the exercise.
Consent for publication
About this supplement
This article has been published as part of BMC Public Health Volume 17 Supplement 2, 2017: The policy landscape for Infant and Young Child Feeding (IYCF) in South Asia. The full contents of the supplement are available online at https://bmcpublichealth.biomedcentral.com/articles/supplements/volume-17-supplement-2.
About this article
Cite this article
Karn, S., Devkota, M.D., Uddin, S. et al. Policy content and stakeholder network analysis for infant and young child feeding in Nepal. BMC Public Health 17 (Suppl 2), 421 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-017-4340-6