Meta-analysis of adverse health effects due to air pollution in Chinese populations
BMC Public Health volume 13, Article number: 360 (2013)
Pooled estimates of air pollution health effects are important drivers of environmental risk communications and political willingness. In China, there is a lack of review studies to provide such estimates for health impact assessments.
We systematically searched the MEDLINE database using keywords of 80 major Chinese cities in Mainland China, Hong Kong and Taiwan on 30 June 2012, yielding 350 abstracts with 48 non-duplicated reports either in English or Chinese after screening. We pooled the relative risks (RR) per 10 μg/m3 of particulate matter (PM10), nitrogen dioxide (NO2), sulphur dioxide (SO2) and ozone (O3).
For short-term effects, the pooled RR (p < 0.05) ranges were: 1.0031 (PM10) to 1.0140 (NO2) for all-cause mortality, 1.0034 (cardiopulmonary, PM10) to 1.0235 (influenza and pneumonia, SO2) for 9 specific-causes mortality, 1.0021 (cardiovascular, PM10) to 1.0162 (asthma, O3) for 5 specific-causes hospital admissions. For birth outcomes, the RR (p < 0.05) ranged from 1.0051 (stillbirth, O3) to 1.1189 (preterm-birth, SO2) and for long-term effect on mortality from 1.0150 (respiratory, SO2) to 1.0297 (respiratory, NO2). Publication bias was absent (Egger test: p = 0.326 to 0.624). Annual PM10 and NO2 concentrations were inversely associated with RR of mortality (p = 0.017-0.028).
Evidence on short-term effects of air pollution is consistent and sufficient for health impact assessment but that on long-term effects is still insufficient.
Air pollution has been a worldwide problem in both outdoor and indoor environment. Among all air pollutants, the most commonly monitored are particulate matter (PM), nitrogen dioxide (NO2), sulphur dioxide (SO2) and ozone (O3). The World Health Organization (WHO) had reviewed the health effects of these four pollutants and recommended them in the Air Quality Guidelines early in 1987  and the latest in 2005 .
Epidemiologic evidence which showed the link between the ambient level of air pollution and adverse respiratory and cardiovascular outcomes [3, 4] was mainly based on assessment of excess mortality numbers associated with short-term exposures. Examples include the APHEA and NMMAPS studies in both Europe and the US [5–7]. Meta-analysis and review studies have been conducted to pool the short-term health effects of air pollutants in many countries [8–10] but seldom in China. The concentration-response gradient for air pollutants from other countries may not be applicable to Chinese populations due to the differences in community settings, pollutant compositions, time-microenvironment-activity patterns, culture, lifestyles, genetic susceptibility, and the much higher exposure levels in China where saturation mechanism may reduce the exposure-response gradients . The lack of pooled risk estimates due to air pollution in China would limit health impact assessments that are important drivers of environmental risk communications and political willingness. A successful application of the pooled risk estimates in the present study has been demonstrated in another paper on the health impact assessment of marine emissions in Pearl River Delta , supporting environmental policy decisions in a timely manner.
With the rapid economic growth in China, the level of air pollution from both motor vehicles and industrial emissions has drastically increased. Compared to other countries, such as the United States and the United Kingdom, potential health effects of increasing air pollution in China remain largely unmeasured, with the exception of results from the PAPA study in Asia , Kan’s study from four reports in China , and Zhou’s study in Yangtze River Delta . At present, there were three studies found in PubMed (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed) about meta-analysis of adverse effects of air pollutants in Chinese population [14, 16, 17] with pooled risk estimates for PM10 and SO2 in mainland China and Hong Kong only but not for NO2 and O3.
In this study, a systematic review and a meta-analysis were carried out to pool the risk estimates for mortality and morbidity outcomes due to the four classical air pollutants , PM10, NO2, SO2 and O3, in the Chinese populations including Mainland China, Hong Kong and Taiwan.
We searched the MEDLINE database (last entry on 30th June 2012) using the following terms for titles and abstracts: (“particulate matter” OR “PM10” OR “PM(10)” OR “nitrogen dioxide” OR “NO2” OR “NO(2)” OR “sulfur dioxide” OR “sulphur dioxide” OR “SO2” OR “SO(2)” OR “ozone” OR “O3” OR “O(3)”) AND health AND (“China” OR “Taiwan” OR “river delta” OR “Chinese”). We also added terms for the names of 80 major Chinese locations (with population size ranged from 0.5 to 29 millions. See Additional file 1), yielding 26 locations with relevant literatures including Anshan, Beijing, Chongqing, Foshan, Fuzhou, Guangzhou, Hangzhou, Hong Kong, Kaohsiung, Lanzhou, Nanjing, Quanzhou, Shanghai, Shenyang, Shenzhen, Suzhou, Taichung, Taipei, Taiyuan, Tangshan, Tianjin, Urumqi, Wuhan, Xian, Zhongshan and Zhuhai.
There were 350 abstracts retrieved from PubMed on 30th June 2012 and 48 literatures were selected for this review by a researcher using the following inclusion criteria: (i) All epidemiologic studies on the adverse health effects of PM10, NO2, SO2 or O3 in Chinese population as the main research question; (ii) the health outcomes were related to deaths, births and hospital utilization; (iii) the subjects were not designed to specific high risk groups (e.g. patients or smokers) nor specific age subgroups (e.g. children or elders); (iv) exposures to ambient levels (not indoor, occupational or accidental exposures); (v) the health risk estimates were expressed in terms of unit change in pollutant mass concentration; and (vi) reported in English or Chinese. Duplicate publication of the same results would be included only once (Figure 1). The study was adhered to the PRISMA guidelines .
Meta-analysis [19, 20] for each adverse health outcome reported by two or more studies was conducted to estimate the pooled estimates effects of PM10, NO2, SO2 and O3 on mortality (all-natural and cause-specific mortality), hospital admissions and emergency room visits. Quantities of risk estimates from the selected studies were summarized using the overall average of these quantities weighted by the inverse variance. All risk estimates were expressed as or converted to percentage change in the number of adverse health events associated with every 10 μgm-3 change in pollutant concentration. Only the single-pollutant model results were included. When there were more than one publications on the same population, the one from the latest study was selected in order to avoid over-representation (Figure 1). For short-term risk estimates, lags ranged within day 0 and 1 were used since they were mostly reported [13, 21]. We first included risk estimates with the single lag day (either 0 or 1) that is more significantly larger than unity with a smaller p-value, then included estimates of an average lag day (0–1) only if estimates of single lag were not reported. When there was no report for lag 0, 1 or 0–1, we included lag day 2 and an average lag day 0–2. In sensitivity analysis, we included risk estimates that were only reported with lags more than two days. When pooling the estimates, we used random effects if I 2 statistics for heterogeneity was >25% or otherwise the fixed effect .
Heterogeneity and publication bias
The overall relative risk (RR) for mortality due to cardiovascular diseases (CD) and respiratory diseases (RD) were pooled; and diagnosis for overall heterogeneity due to each study was assessed by influence plots . Funnel plots with Egger test on asymmetry at alpha level 0.1 was used for assessment of publication bias . The overall heterogeneity was assumed significant under normal distribution when the square root of q 2 statistic laid outside 95% of all statistic values to be between −1.96 and 1.96 .
The rubrics were identified according to the diseases ICD code instead of the description of the authors. Sensitivity analysis was done to assess the differences in the usage of ICD codes for the same rubric between studies. We calculated by the percentage difference between the code ranges that were most commonly used and the code ranges that were less common (See Additional file 1). The median percentage difference among all rubrics was 40%. The risk estimates in each rubrics were pooled again using studies with percentage difference ≤40%. For studies without ICD codes reported, the authors of these papers were contacted in both Chinese and English to provide code information.
Air pollutant concentrations
Studies from the Mainland China, Taiwan and Hong Kong reported from 1989 to 2010. The annual mean concentrations ranged 44–156 μg/m3 for PM10, 23–70 μg/m3 for NO2, 14–213 μg/m3 for SO2 and 34–86 μg/m3 for O3 (Figure 2). All relative risks (RR) [95% confidence intervals] in the following contexts were based on 10 μg/m3 increase in one pollutant concentration.
Estimates of the effect of exposure to daily concentration of air pollutants on daily mortality numbers were reported by 26 studies in 24 Chinese jurisdictions including Anshan, Beijing, Chongqing, Foshan, Fuzhou, Guangzhou, Hangzhou, Lanzhou, Shanghai, Shenyang, Suzhou, Taiyuan, Tangshan, Tianjin, Urumqi, Wuhan, Xian, Zhongshan, Zhuhai; Kaohsiung, Taichung, Taipei, and Hong Kong (Tables 1 and 2).
The pooled RR of all-cause mortality were 1.0031 [1.0022-1.0041] for PM10, 1.0140 [1.0106-1.0174] for NO2, 1.0071 [1.0045-1.0097] for SO2 and 1.0042 [1.0031-1.0053] for O3. All the cities reported statistically significant associations between daily mortality and all the four pollutants except PM10 in Lanzhou, Tangshan, Urumqi and Zhongshan, NO2 in Beijing, Taichung and Urumqi, SO2 in Chongqing and O3 in Fushan and Wuhan. The associations were not significant (95% CI including unity) for all pollutants in Anshan, Kaohsiung, Taipei and Zhuhai.
For cause-specific mortality, the pooled RR of CD mortality were 1.0049 [1.0034-1.0063] for PM10, 1.0162 [1.0118-1.0205] for NO2, 1.0072 [1.0039-1.0105] for SO2 and 1.0051 [1.0025-1.0077] for O3. The pooled RR of RD mortality were 1.0057 [1.0040-1.0075] for PM10, 1.0220 [1.0156-1.0284] for NO2, 1.0129 [1.0058-1.0199] for SO2 and 1.0048 [1.0019-1.0076] for O3. The pooled RR of cardiopulmonary mortality were 1.0034 [1.0023-1.0046] for PM10, 1.0155 [1.0049-1.0261] for NO2 and 1.0123 [1.0093-1.0153] for SO2. For other specific causes, all the four pollutants were associated with cerebrovascular mortality, whereas NO2 and SO2 were associated with mortality for COPD. PM10, NO2 and SO2 were associated with mortality for influenza and pneumonia, as well as cardiac diseases.
The pooled RR estimate of all the statistically significant results (p < 0.05) for all cause mortality ranged from 1.0031 (PM10) to 1.0140 (NO2), for CD from 1.0049 (PM10) to 1.0162 (NO2), and for RD from 1.0048 (O3) to 1.0220 (NO2).
Estimates of the effect of exposure to annual average concentration of air pollutants on mortality were reported by 3 cohort studies which covered 32 cities in mainland China. Data of RR were not yet sufficient for meta-analysis at present (Table not shown).
In one cohort studies in Shenyang, the RR of all causes of mortality were 1.0153 [1.0150-1.0156] for PM10 and 1.0245 [1.0234-1.0258] for NO2; the corresponding RR of CD mortality were 1.0155 [1.0151-1.0160] and 1.0246 [1.0231-1.0263], of cerebrovascular mortality 1.0149 [1.0145-1.0153] and 1.0244 [1.0227-1.0262] , and of RD mortality 1.0167 [1.0160-1.0174] and 1.0297 [1.0269-1.0327] , respectively. In another cohort study examining the effects of SO2 in 31 cities in mainland China reported that RR of all-cause, CD and RD mortality were 1.018 [1.013-1.023], 1.032 [1.023-1.040] and 1.015 [1.003-1.028] respectively .
Exposure to daily air pollutant concentrations were associated with daily total numbers of hospital admissions, emergency room visits and emergency admissions, mainly for CD and RD, which included sub-categories cardiac diseases, ischemia heart diseases (IHD), cerebrovascular diseases, heart failure, hypertension, asthma, COPD, and influenza and pneumonia (Table 2). Associations with pre- and postnatal outcomes included stillbirths, post-neonatal deaths, preterm births and low birth weight reported by 22 studies in Beijing, Hong Kong, Shanghai, Taipei and the whole Taiwan (Table 2).
For hospital admissions, the pooled RR of CD among 2 cities were 1.0021 [1.0002-1.0040] for PM10 and 1.0095 [1.0054-1.0137] for NO2; that of RD were 1.0060 [1.0012-1.0107] for NO2. The pooled RR of IHD were 1.0065 [1.0027-1.0104] for PM10 and 1.0102 [1.0031-1.0172] for SO2; that of asthma were 1.0077 [1.0029-1.0125] for PM10, 1.0094 [1.0032-1.0155] for NO2 and 1.0162 [1.0103-1.0221] for O3. All the four pollutants were associated with COPD hospital admissions in Hong Kong. Acute respiratory diseases, influenza and pneumonia, and cardiac diseases were reported in Hong Kong only.
For emergency admissions, the associations of CD, RD, cardiac diseases, heart failure, asthma, and COPD reported in Hong Kong only. For emergency room visits, the RR of daily visits were associations in Shanghai only. For specific causes, the association of CD, hypertension, cardiac arrhythmias, acute upper respiratory infections and acute pharyngitis were reported in Beijing only (Figure 2).
For adverse birth outcomes, in Taiwan, the RR of stillbirth was 1.02 [1.00-1.05] in the first and 1.02 [1.00-1.04] in the second month of gestation for PM10 and 1.0076 [1.000-1.0153] in the first-trimester for SO2. In Shanghai, sub-chronic exposure (8-week average) to the PM10, NO2, SO2 and O3 corresponded to RR of preterm births of 1.0442 [1.0160-1.0725], 1.0543 [1.0178-1.0908], 1.1189 [1.0669-1.1709] and 1.0463 [1.0035-1.0891], respectively . For exposure to SO2 in Beijing, the RR of low birth weight was 1.011 [1.006-1.016] . In Taipei, the RR of low birth weight was 1.0087 [1.0013-1.0177] for SO2 maternal exposure during pregnancy .
Heterogeneity and publication bias
The large amount of overall heterogeneity was due to studies in Beijing (±q = 4.01 and 4.74), Guangzhou (±q = 2.63 and 3.00), Hong Kong (±q = −2.11), Taiyuan (±q = −2.42) and Tianjin (±q = 2.14) for PM10; Beijing (±q = −3.12 and −4.47), Guangzhou (±q = 3.11), Hangzhou (±q = −2.82), Shanghai (±q = −2.29), Taiyuan (±q = 2.57 and 3.11), Tianjin (±q = 2.27), Wuhan (±q = 4.05 and 4.09) and Zhongshan (±q = 1.98) for NO2; Tianjin (±q = −2.16) for SO2; and Guangzhou (±q = 2.42) and Wuhan (±q = −2.53) for O3 (Figure 3A).
The number of studies in individual rubric was not sufficient for detection of publication bias. The heterogeneity in the meta-analysis was large in magnitude (I 2 = 61% for PM10, 72% for NO2, 33% for SO2 and 23% for O3). Publication bias for all the pooled estimates was not significant for PM10 (Egger test: p = 0.624), NO2 (p = 0.592), SO2 (p = 0.624) and O3 (p = 0.326) (Figure 3B).
Meta-regression of annual concentrations and the reported RR above the unity (>1) indicated inverse linear associations for PM10 (n = 21, β = −3.659 × 10-5, p = 0.017) and NO2 (n = 23, β = −3.79 × 10-4, p = 0.028) but no associations for SO2 (p = 0.359) and O3 (p = 0.620) (Figure 4).
To summarize, the reported RR that were statistically significant (p < 0.05) for mortality ranged from 1.0031 (all-cause associated with PM10) to 1.0140 (RD associated with NO2); for hospital admissions ranged from 1.0021 (CD associated with PM10) to 1.0162 (asthma associated with O3), and for birth outcomes from 1.0051 (stillbirth associated with O3) to 1.1189 (preterm-birth associated with SO2).
Most of the studies in Chinese populations under review revealed that the pollutants levels were higher than the WHO annual Air Quality Guidelines (AQG)  or the derived annual mean according to WHO short-term AQG . Pooled RR from these studies are useful for health impact assessment because they were based on clinical records of physician-diagnosed diseases, birth outcomes and deaths, which were usually more reliable indicators of population health than measurements of physiological changes and other subtle health effects .
In the present review, our pooled RR were somehow consistent with the literature. The pooled RR of all causes mortality in all age groups for PM10, NO2, SO2 and O3 were differed from −5% to +68% of those recently reported in a meta-analysis on Asian countries by the Health Effects Institute (HEI). The pooled RR of CD and RD mortality were differed from −10% to +42% and −13% to +59% respectively [13, 26, 27, 69]. The main difference from the HEI meta-analysis is that we included literatures that published in Chinese language and confined only to Chinese populations.
In total, we reviewed 23 different rubrics of adverse health outcomes based on population studies. The patterns of pooled RR of mortality and hospital admission for various rubrics were quite consistent with the order that NO2 > SO2 > PM10 > O3 per unit increase in concentration of each pollutant. Such order was found in the HEI report [13, 67]. However, for all-cause mortality, CD and COPD, the RR of O3 was slightly higher than that of PM10; the RR of hospital asthma admissions was the highest for O3. For emergency room visits and admissions, the number of studies was insufficient to observe the pattern. The values of RR of mortality were also consistent for all pollutants in the order for RD > CD > all-causes, except for O3, and this pattern was also found elsewhere [13, 67], supporting that health effects of air pollution in China are comparable to those shown in other parts of the world .
The range of RR (p < 0.05) of each rubric for the four pollutants (PM10, NO2, SO2 and O3) can be classified into three levels: (i) RR ranged from less than 1 to 2% including all causes, CD, RD (for hospital admissions and emergency room visits), cardiopulmonary diseases, cardiac diseases, cerebrovascular diseases, IHD (for hospitalization), heart failure (for emergency room visits), cardiac arrhythmias, COPD, asthma, acute RD, non-cardiopulmonary-non-accidental, diabetes, pneumonia, cancer, stillbirth and low birth weight. (ii) Rubrics with RR ranging from 1 to 4% included RD (for mortality and emergency admissions), IHD (for mortality), acute upper respiratory infections, acute pharyngitis, and influenza and pneumonia. (iii) Rubrics with RR ranging from 4 to 12% included heart failure (emergency admissions), hypertension and preterm birth. These ranges may provide a useful summary in specifying the health impacts due to every 10 μg/m3 increase in air pollution in Chinese populations.
Seasonality modified the effects of the pollutants, in that largest RR occurred during the winter season . These findings in Chinese cities are similar to some other countries [69, 70]. But different results may also be found in other countries such as the US and Netherlands [71, 72], suggesting that an inadequate adjustment for confounding due to seasonality which varied from studies to studies may lead to variance in the effect estimates.
In meta-regression analysis we found some evidence of an inverse linear relationship between RR of mortality and the annual PM10 and NO2 concentration. This pattern indicates that the concentration-response relationship as a downward leveling off pattern rather than linear . Similar pattern of inverse association has been observed in a cross-sectional study of lung function and exposure to indoor PM2.5 concentration . This inverse relationship could be related to a saturation mechanism occurring at lower exposure levels  where both irreversible and reversible processes may simultaneously exist. This has been hypothesized that, as indicated by structural changes in airways [75, 76], air pollutant that penetrate to the deepest part of the lung and cause alveolar epithelial injury are associated with both acute reversible inflammatory responses and cumulative irreversible pulmonary damage . Explanation by the saturation hypothesis for cardiovascular diseases is also warranted . Our findings suggest there are needs for further study to assess the inverse relationships using literatures in the world. We did not find any patterns yet for SO2 and O3 probably due to insufficient data for meta-regressions.
In the present review, there were sufficient Chinese studies on all-cause and cause-specific mortality for all pollutants to perform the meta-analysis; but studies on hospitalizations and emergency room visits as well as adverse birth outcomes and long-term effects were insufficient. The changes in levels of exposure and city background characteristics such as urbanization level, medical and hygiene standards have now been underway during the rapid economic development in the past decade. This may be a confounding factor that explains why at present the magnitude of the reported RR of long-term effects in China [63–65] is incomparable to those in the western countries. The evidence of long-term effects is therefore immature for drawing a definite conclusion. However, the aforementioned confounding factor is not applicable to the assessment of short-term effects, and so the reported RR of common disease rubrics in China, Taiwan and Hong Kong were largely similar and comparable to international findings [13, 67].
The limitations of the present study may include search bias because we based our literature search on PubMed only, despite the fact that PubMed is a well known biomedical literature database and missing of important epidemiologic studies are less likely happened. Publication bias is also a common limitation for meta-analysis, in which “positive” results are more likely to be published than those the “negative” results, leads to the censoring of studies with non-significant results . However, in our study publication bias was not observed. We detected some heterogeneity due to several studies for each pollutant. The potential reasons may include the difference in age structure in different populations, study designs and statistical methods for analysis. For differences in ICD codes, we identified that some studies used quite different codes or reported no codes [28, 29, 43, 49, 78, 79] in defining the health outcome, making them almost incomparable with the majority of other studies. When excluded studies using different codes, the pooled RR have changed only about 1-7%. Hence, we based our interpretations on the pooled RR using the all the ICD codes.
Ambient air pollution in Chinese populations is poor when compared with well developed countries in Europe, North America, and Asia-Pacific region. For short-term exposure, the pooled relative risks estimates of the major health effects including all causes, cardiovascular and respiratory diseases were comparable with findings from studies worldwide. Inverse linear associations between short-term relative risks of mortality and annual mean PM10 and NO2 concentrations suggests that the concentration response relationship may be non-linear and characterized by a concave downward curve leveling off at high concentration. These are useful for developing health evidence-based risk communications and health impact assessments. However, evidence on long-term effects and adverse birth outcomes are still insufficient for meta-analysis and decision-making in environmental policy and management.
WHO: Air quality guidelines for Europe. 1987, Copenhagen: World Health Organization Regional Office for Europe
WHO: Air Quality Guidelines Global Update 2005: particulate matter, ozone, nitrogen dioxide and sulfur dioxide. 2006, Copenhagen: WHO Regional Office for Europe
Spickett JT, Brown HL, Rumchev K: Climate change and air quality: the potential impact on health. Asia Pac J Public Health. 2011, 23: 37S-45S. 10.1177/1010539511398114.
EPA: US: Integrated Science Assessment for Particulate Matter (Final Report). 2009, Washington: US Environmental Protection Agency
Katsouyanni K, Touloumi G, Samoli E, Gryparis A, Le Tertre A, Monopolis Y, Rossi G, Zmirou D, Ballester F, Boumghar A, et al: Confounding and effect modification in the short-term effects of ambient particles on total mortality: results from 29 European cities within the APHEA2 project. Epidemiology. 2001, 12: 521-531. 10.1097/00001648-200109000-00011.
Sunyer J, Ballester F, Tertre AL, Atkinson R, Ayres JG, Forastiere F, Forsberg B, Vonk JM, Bisanti L, Tenias JM, et al: The association of daily sulfur dioxide air pollution levels with hospital admissions for cardiovascular diseases in Europe (The Aphea-II study). Eur Heart J. 2003, 24: 752-760. 10.1016/S0195-668X(02)00808-4.
Samet JM, Zeger SL, Dominici F, Curriero F, Coursac I, Dockery DW, Schwartz J, Zanobetti A: The national morbidity, mortality, and air pollution study. Part II: morbidity and mortality from air pollution in the united states. Res Rep Health Eff Inst. 2000, 94: 5-70. discussion 71–79
Chen H, Goldberg MS, Villeneuve PJ: A systematic review of the relation between long-term exposure to ambient air pollution and chronic diseases. Rev Environ Health. 2008, 23: 243-297.
Baldacci S, Viegi G: Respiratory effects of environmental pollution: epidemiological data. Monaldi Arch Chest Dis. 2002, 57: 156-160.
WHO: Health aspects of air pollution: results from the WHO project “Systematic review of health aspects of air pollution in Europe”. 2004, Copenhagen: WHO Regional Office for Europe
Lai HK, Hedley AJ, Repace J, So C, Lu QY, McGhee SM, Fielding R, Wong CM: Lung function and exposure to workplace second-hand smoke during exemptions from smoking ban legislation: an exposure-response relationship based on indoor PM2.5 and urinary cotinine levels. Thorax. 2011, 66: 615-623. 10.1136/thx.2011.160291.
Lai HK, Tsang H, Chau J, Lee CH, McGhee SM, Hedley AJ, Wong CM: Health impact assessment of marine emissions in pearl river delta region. Mar Pollut Bull. 2013, 66: 158-163. 10.1016/j.marpolbul.2012.09.029.
Wong CM, Vichit-Vadakan N, Kan H, Qian Z: Public health and Air pollution in asia (PAPA): a multicity study of short-term effects of air pollution on mortality. Environ Health Perspect. 2008, 116: 1195-1202. 10.1289/ehp.11257.
Kan HD, Chen BH, Chen CH, Wang BY, Fu QY: Establishment of exposure-response functions of air particulate matter and adverse health outcomes in China and worldwide. Biomed Environ Sci. 2005, 18: 159-163.
Zhou Y, Fu JS, Zhuang G, Levy JI: Risk-based prioritization among air pollution control strategies in the Yangtze River Delta, China. Environ Health Perspect. 2010, 118: 1204-1210. 10.1289/ehp.1001991.
Aunan K, Pan XC: Exposure-response functions for health effects of ambient air pollution applicable for China – a meta-analysis. Sci Total Environ. 2004, 329: 3-16. 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2004.03.008.
Huang W, Wang HY, Wang Q: Association between inhalable particulate matter and mortality in China: a meta-analysis. Zhonghua Yu Fang Yi Xue Za Zhi. 2011, 45: 1031-1035.
Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, Altman DG, Group P: Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. BMJ. 2009, 339: b2535-10.1136/bmj.b2535.
Woodward M: Meta-analysis (Chapter 12). Epidemiology: study design and data analysis. 2nd edition. 2005, Chapman & Hall/CRC: Boca Raton, Fla
Anderson HR, Atkinson RW, Peacock JL, Marston L, Konstantinou K: Meta-analysis of time-series studies and panel studies of particulate matter (PM) and ozone (O3): report of a WHO task group. 2004, Copenhagen: World Health Organization
Katsouyanni K, Samet JM, Anderson HR, Atkinson R, Le Tertre A, Medina S, Samoli E, Touloumi G, Burnett RT, Krewski D, et al: Air pollution and health: a European and North American approach (APHENA). Res Rep Health Eff Inst. 2009, 5-90. HEI Report number: 142 [http://pubs.healtheffects.org/view.php?id=327]
Egger M, Davey Smith G, Schneider M, Minder C: Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. BMJ. 1997, 315: 629-634. 10.1136/bmj.315.7109.629.
WHO: Health effects of air pollution: an overview. Air Quality Guidelines Global Update 2005: particulate matter, ozone, nitrogen dioxide and sulfur dioxide. 2006, : WHO Regional Office for Europe, [http://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0005/78638/E90038.pdf]
Lai HK, Wong CM, McGhee SM, Hedley AJ: Assessment of the health impacts and economic burden arising from proposed New Air quality objectives in a high pollution environment. Open Epidemiol J. 2011, 4: 106-122. 10.2174/1874297101104010106.
Chen R, Pan G, Kan H, Tan J, Song W, Wu Z, Xu X, Xu Q, Jiang C, Chen B: Ambient air pollution and daily mortality in Anshan, China: a time-stratified case-crossover analysis. Sci Total Environ. 2010, 408: 6086-6091. 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2010.09.018.
Chen R, Kan H, Chen B, Huang W, Bai Z, Song G, Pan G, Group oBotCC: Association of particulate air pollution with daily mortality: the china air pollution and health effects study. Am J Epidemiol. 2012, 175: 1173-1181. 10.1093/aje/kwr425.
Chen R, Samoli E, Wong CM, Huang W, Wang Z, Chen B, Kan H, CCG: Associations between short-term exposure to nitrogen dioxide and mortality in 17 chinese cities: the china Air pollution and health effects study (CAPES). Environ Int. 2012, 45C: 32-38.
Xu X, Gao J, Dockery DW, Chen Y: Air pollution and daily mortality in residential areas of Beijing, China. Arch Environ Health. 1994, 49: 216-222. 10.1080/00039896.1994.9937470.
Venners SA, Wang B, Xu Z, Schlatter Y, Wang L, Xu X: Particulate matter, sulfur dioxide, and daily mortality in Chongqing, China. Environ Health Perspect. 2003, 111: 562-567.
Tao Y, Huang W, Huang X, Zhong L, Lu SE, Li Y, Dai L, Zhang Y, Zhu T: Estimated acute effects of ambient ozone and nitrogen dioxide on mortality in the Pearl River Delta of southern China. Environ Health Perspect. 2012, 120: 393-398.
Wong CM, Thach TQ, Chau PY, Chan EK, Chung RY, Ou CQ, Yang L, Peiris JS, Thomas GN, Lam TH, et al: Part 4. Interaction between air pollution and respiratory viruses: time-series study of daily mortality and hospital admissions in Hong Kong. Res Rep Health Eff Inst. 2010, 283-362. HEI Report number: 154 [http://pubs.healtheffects.org/view.php?id=348]
Tsai SS, Huang CH, Goggins WB, Wu TN, Yang CY: Relationship between air pollution and daily mortality in a tropical city: Kaohsiung, Taiwan. J Toxicol Environ Health A. 2003, 66: 1341-1349. 10.1080/15287390306389.
Kan H, London SJ, Chen G, Zhang Y, Song G, Zhao N, Jiang L, Chen B: Differentiating the effects of fine and coarse particles on daily mortality in Shanghai, China. Environ Int. 2007, 33: 376-384. 10.1016/j.envint.2006.12.001.
Kan H, Chen B, Zhao N, London SJ, Song G, Chen G, Zhang Y, Jiang L, Committee HEIHR: Part 1. A time-series study of ambient air pollution and daily mortality in Shanghai, China. Res Rep Health Eff Inst. 2010, 17-78. HEI Report number: 154 (http://pubs.healtheffects.org/view.php?id=348)
Yang C, Yang H, Guo S, Wang Z, Xu X, Duan X, Kan H: Alternative ozone metrics and daily mortality in Suzhou: the China Air Pollution and Health Effects Study (CAPES). Sci Total Environ. 2012, 426: 83-89.
Tsai DH, Wang JL, Chuang KJ, Chan CC: Traffic-related air pollution and cardiovascular mortality in central Taiwan. Sci Total Environ. 2010, 408: 1818-1823. 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2010.01.044.
Yang CY, Chang CC, Chuang HY, Tsai SS, Wu TN, Ho CK: Relationship between air pollution and daily mortality in a subtropical city: Taipei, Taiwan. Environ Int. 2004, 30: 519-523. 10.1016/j.envint.2003.10.006.
Zhang YS, Zhou MG, Jia YP, Hu YS, Zhang JL, Jiang GH, Pan XC: Time-series analysis on the association between gaseous air pollutants and daily mortality in urban residents in Tianjin. Zhonghua Liu Xing Bing Xue Za Zhi. 2010, 31: 1158-1162.
Qian Z, He Q, Lin HM, Kong L, Zhou D, Liang S, Zhu Z, Liao D, Liu W, Bentley CM, et al: Part 2. Association of daily mortality with ambient air pollution, and effect modification by extremely high temperature in Wuhan, China. Res Rep Health Eff Inst. 2010, 91-217. HEI Report number: 154 [http://pubs.healtheffects.org/view.php?id=348]
Dai H, Song W, Gao X, Chen L: Study on relationship between ambient PM10, PM2.5 pollution and daily mortality in a district in Shanghai. Wei Sheng Yan Jiu. 2004, 33: 293-297.
Guo Y, Barnett AG, Zhang Y, Tong S, Yu W, Pan X: The short-term effect of air pollution on cardiovascular mortality in Tianjin, China: comparison of time series and case-crossover analyses. Sci Total Environ. 2010, 409: 300-306. 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2010.10.013.
Zhang YS, Zhou MG, Jia YP, Hu YS, Zhang JL, Jiang GH, Pan XC: Time-series analysis of association between inhalable particulate matter and daily mortality among urban residents in Tianjin. Zhonghua Liu Xing Bing Xue Za Zhi. 2010, 31: 544-548.
Zhang YP, Zhang ZQ, Liu XH, Zhang XP, Feng BQ, Li HP: Concentration-response relationship between particulate air pollution and daily mortality in Taiyuan. Beijing Da Xue Xue Bao. 2007, 39: 153-157.
Wong TW, Tam WS, Yu TS, Wong AH: Associations between daily mortalities from respiratory and cardiovascular diseases and air pollution in Hong Kong, China. Occup Environ Med. 2002, 59: 30-35. 10.1136/oem.59.1.30.
Kan H, Wong CM, Vichit-Vadakan N, Qian Z, Teams PP: Short-term association between sulfur dioxide and daily mortality: the public health and Air pollution in asia (PAPA) study. Environ Res. 2010, 110: 258-264. 10.1016/j.envres.2010.01.006.
Kan H, Jia J, Chen B: The association of daily diabetes mortality and outdoor air pollution in Shanghai, China. J Environ Health. 2004, 67: 21-26.
Chen R, Chu C, Tan J, Cao J, Song W, Xu X, Jiang C, Ma W, Yang C, Chen B, et al: Ambient air pollution and hospital admission in Shanghai, China. J Hazard Mater. 2010, 181: 234-240. 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2010.05.002.
Bell ML, Levy JK, Lin Z: The effect of sandstorms and air pollution on cause-specific hospital admissions in Taipei, Taiwan. Occup Environ Med. 2008, 65: 104-111. 10.1136/oem.2006.031500.
Wong TW, Lau TS, Yu TS, Neller A, Wong SL, Tam W, Pang SW: Air pollution and hospital admissions for respiratory and cardiovascular diseases in Hong Kong. Occup Environ Med. 1999, 56: 679-683. 10.1136/oem.56.10.679.
Wong CM, Atkinson RW, Anderson HR, Hedley AJ, Ma S, Chau PY, Lam TH: A tale of two cities: effects of air pollution on hospital admissions in Hong Kong and London compared. Environ Health Perspect. 2002, 110: 67-77.
Ko FW, Tam W, Wong TW, Lai CK, Wong GW, Leung TF, Ng SS, Hui DS: Effects of air pollution on asthma hospitalization rates in different age groups in Hong Kong. Clin Exp Allergy. 2007, 37: 1312-1319. 10.1111/j.1365-2222.2007.02791.x.
Cao J, Li W, Tan J, Song W, Xu X, Jiang C, Chen G, Chen R, Ma W, Chen B, Kan H: Association of ambient air pollution with hospital outpatient and emergency room visits in Shanghai, China. Sci Total Environ. 2009, 407: 5531-5536. 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2009.07.021.
Guo YM, Liu LQ, Chen JM, Yang MJ, Wich M, Pan XC: Association between the concentration of particulate matters and the hospital emergency room visits for circulatory diseases: a case-crossover study. Zhonghua Liu Xing Bing Xue Za Zhi. 2008, 29: 1064-1068.
Guo Y, Jia Y, Pan X, Liu L, Wichmann HE: The association between fine particulate air pollution and hospital emergency room visits for cardiovascular diseases in Beijing, China. Sci Total Environ. 2009, 407: 4826-4830. 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2009.05.022.
Su C, Guo YM, Franck U, Pan XC: Association between ambient air pollution and hospital emergency room visits for respiratory diseases: a case-crossover study. Zhonghua Liu Xing Bing Xue Za Zhi. 2010, 31: 845-849.
Leitte AM, Schlink U, Herbarth O, Wiedensohler A, Pan XC, Hu M, Richter M, Wehner B, Tuch T, Wu Z, et al: Size-segregated particle number concentrations and respiratory emergency room visits in Beijing, China. Environ Health Perspect. 2011, 119: 508-513. 10.1289/ehp.1104385R.
Guo Y, Tong S, Li S, Barnett AG, Yu W, Zhang Y, Pan X: Gaseous air pollution and emergency hospital visits for hypertension in Beijing, China: a time-stratified case-crossover study. Environ Health. 2010, 9: 57-10.1186/1476-069X-9-57.
Guo Y, Tong S, Zhang Y, Barnett AG, Jia Y, Pan X: The relationship between particulate air pollution and emergency hospital visits for hypertension in Beijing, China. Sci Total Environ. 2010, 408: 4446-4450. 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2010.06.042.
Hwang BF, Lee YL, Jaakkola JJ: Air pollution and stillbirth: a population-based case–control study in Taiwan. Environ Health Perspect. 2011, 119: 1345-1349. 10.1289/ehp.1003056.
Jiang LL, Zhang YH, Song GX, Chen GH, Chen BH, Zhao NQ, Kan HD: A time series analysis of outdoor air pollution and preterm birth in Shanghai, China. Biomed Environ Sci. 2007, 20: 426-431.
Wang XB, Ding H, Ryan L, Xu XP: Association between air pollution and low birth weight: a community-based study. Environ Health Persp. 1997, 105: 514-520. 10.1289/ehp.97105514.
Lin CM, Li CY, Yang GY, Mao IF: Association between maternal exposure to elevated ambient sulfur dioxide during pregnancy and term low birth weight. Environ Res. 2004, 96: 41-50. 10.1016/j.envres.2004.03.005.
Zhang P, Dong G, Sun B, Zhang L, Chen X, Ma N, Yu F, Guo H, Huang H, Lee YL, et al: Long-term exposure to ambient air pollution and mortality due to cardiovascular disease and cerebrovascular disease in Shenyang. China. PLoS One. 2011, 6: e20827-10.1371/journal.pone.0020827.
Dong GH, Zhang P, Sun B, Zhang L, Chen X, Ma N, Yu F, Guo H, Huang H, Lee YL, et al: Long-term exposure to ambient Air pollution and respiratory disease mortality in shenyang, china: a 12-year population-based retrospective cohort study. Respiration. 2011, 85: 360-368.
Cao J, Yang C, Li J, Chen R, Chen B, Gu D, Kan H: Association between long-term exposure to outdoor air pollution and mortality in China: a cohort study. J Hazard Mater. 2011, 186: 1594-1600. 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2010.12.036.
WHO: Health effects of transport-related air pollution. Edited by: Krzyzanowski M, Kuna-Dibbert B, Schneider J. 2005, Copenhagen: WHO Regional Office for Europe, [http://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0006/74715/E86650.pdf]
HEI: Outdoor Air Pollution and Health in the Developing Countries of Asia: A Comprehensive Review. Special Report 18. 2010, Boston, MA: International Scientific Oversight Committee Health Effects Institute
Rainham DG, Smoyer-Tomic KE, Sheridan SC, Burnett RT: Synoptic weather patterns and modification of the association between air pollution and human mortality. Int J Environ Health Res. 2005, 15: 347-360. 10.1080/09603120500289119.
Qian Z, Lin HM, Stewart WF, Kong L, Xu F, Zhou D, Zhu Z, Liang S, Chen W, Shah N, et al: Seasonal pattern of the acute mortality effects of air pollution. J Air Waste Manag Assoc. 2010, 60: 481-488. 10.3155/1047-32188.8.131.521.
Kan H, London SJ, Chen G, Zhang Y, Song G, Zhao N, Jiang L, Chen B: Season, sex, age, and education as modifiers of the effects of outdoor air pollution on daily mortality in Shanghai, China: the public health and air pollution in asia (PAPA) study. Environ Health Perspect. 2008, 116: 1183-1188. 10.1289/ehp.10851.
Peng RD, Dominici F, Pastor-Barriuso R, Zeger SL, Samet JM: Seasonal analyses of air pollution and mortality in 100 US cities. Am J Epidemiol. 2005, 161: 585-594. 10.1093/aje/kwi075.
Hoek G, Brunekreef B, Verhoeff A, van Wijnen J, Fischer P: Daily mortality and air pollution in The Netherlands. J Air Waste Manag Assoc. 2000, 50: 1380-1389. 10.1080/10473289.2000.10464182.
Smith KR, Peel JL: Mind the Gap. Environ Health Persp. 2010, 118: 1643-1645. 10.1289/ehp.1002517.
Liistro G, Vanwelde C, Vincken W, Vandevoorde J, Verleden G, Buffels J: Technical and functional assessment of 10 office spirometers - a multicenter comparative study. Chest. 2006, 130: 657-665. 10.1378/chest.130.3.657.
Dockery DW, Speizer FE, Ferris BG, Ware JH, Louis TA, Spiro A: Cumulative and reversible effects of lifetime smoking on simple tests of lung-function in adults. Am Rev Respir Dis. 1988, 137: 286-292. 10.1164/ajrccm/137.2.286.
Flouris AD, Metsios GS, Carrillo AE, Jamurtas AZ, Gourgoulianis K, Kiropoulos T, Tzatzarakis MN, Tsatsakis AM, Koutedakis Y: Acute and short-term effects of secondhand smoke on lung function and cytokine production. Am J Resp Crit Care. 2009, 179: 1029-1033. 10.1164/rccm.200812-1920OC.
Walker E, Hernandez AV, Kattan MW: Meta-analysis: its strengths and limitations. Cleve Clin J Med. 2008, 75: 431-439. 10.3949/ccjm.75.6.431.
Xu Z, Yu D, Jing L, Xu X: Air pollution and daily mortality in Shenyang, China. Arch Environ Health. 2000, 55: 115-120. 10.1080/00039890009603397.
Ko FW, Tam W, Wong TW, Chan DP, Tung AH, Lai CK, Hui DS: Temporal relationship between air pollutants and hospital admissions for chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in Hong Kong. Thorax. 2007, 62: 780-785. 10.1136/thx.2006.076166.
The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/13/360/prepub
We would like to thank Haidong Kan (Fudan University), Kun Chen (Zhejiang University), and Zhiqin Zhang (Taiyuan Center for Disease Control and Prevention) for providing advice and detailed information of their studies.
The author(s) declare that they have no competing interests.
HKL initiated the study and designed the analytical methodology. HT collected the data and conducted the data analysis with HKL. HT and HKL drafted the manuscript. CMW provided critical comments and edited on the draft. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Electronic supplementary material
Additional file 1: (1) Forest plot for the all-causes mortality in different studies; (2) Analysis of differences in ICD used in the literatures; (3) 60 locations without relevant literatures; (4) Older literatures excluded from the pooled relative risks of meta-analysis in Table 1. (DOCX 270 KB)
About this article
Cite this article
Lai, HK., Tsang, H. & Wong, CM. Meta-analysis of adverse health effects due to air pollution in Chinese populations. BMC Public Health 13, 360 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2458-13-360
- Air pollution
- Health and mortality
- Systematic review
- Relative risk
- Random effects
- Fixed effect