Skip to main content

Table 1 Relative risks of all-cause mortality in all age groups due to air pollution in different reviewed studies

From: Meta-analysis of adverse health effects due to air pollution in Chinese populations

Ref#

City

Period

PM10

 

NO2

 

SO2

 

O3

 
   

RR

SE

RR

SE

RR

SE

RR

SE

[25]

Anshan

2004–2006

1.0024

14

1.0130

70

1.0027

17

  

[26, 27]

Beijing

2007–2008

1.0017*

5

1.0040

24

    

[28]

 

1989

    

1.0107*

25

  

[29]

Chongqing

1995

    

1.0030

26

  

[30]

Foshan

2006–2008

1.0050*

10

1.0187*

24

  

1.0036

21

[26, 27]

Fuzhou

2004–2006

1.0063*

23

1.0271*

106

    

[30]

Guangzhou

2006–2008

1.0074*

11

1.0166*

20

  

1.0064*

11

[26, 27]

Hangzhou

2002–2004

1.0032*

14

1.0095*

46

    

[26, 27, 31]

Hong Kong

1996–2002

1.0064*

12

1.0122*

13

1.0091*

26

1.0034*

16

[32]

Kaohsiung

1994–2000

1.0000

43

1.0003

87

1.0040

111

0.9984

56

[26, 27]

Lanzhou

2004–2008

1.0001

5

1.0054*

22

    

[26, 27]

Nanjing

2007–2010

  

1.0107*

28

    

[33]

Shanghai

2004–2005

1.0016*

7

      

[26, 27, 34]

 

2001–2004

  

1.0127*

13

1.0095*

17

1.0031*

14

[26, 27]

Shenyang

2005–2008

1.0018*

8

1.0150*

30

    

[26, 27]

Suzhou

2005–2008

1.0037*

11

1.0173*

27

    

[35]

 

2006–2008

      

1.0036*

15

[36]

Taichung

1993–2006

1.0039*

10

1.0016

16

    

[37]

Taipei

1994–1998

0.9984

41

1.0015

63

0.9982

135

0.9995

75

[26, 27]

Taiyuan

2004–2008

1.0021*

9

1.0422*

70

    

[26, 27]

Tangshan

2006–2008

1.0011

19

1.0141*

58

    

[26, 27]

Tianjin

2005–2008

1.0075*

16

1.0246*

58

    

[38]

 

2005–2007

    

1.0056*

17

  

[26, 27]

Urumqi

2006–2007

1.0010

10

1.0085

60

    

[26, 27]

Wuhan

2003–2005

1.0042*

8

1.0290*

25

    

[39]

 

2000–2004

    

1.0120*

28

1.0029

17

[26, 27]

Xian

2004–2008

1.0019*

8

1.0225*

36

    

[30]

Zhongshan

2006–2008

1.0044

24

1.0122*

40

  

1.0061*

20

[30]

Zhuhai

2006–2008

1.0037

69

1.0139

77

  

1.0022

30

  

Pooled RR a

1.0031 R*

5

1.0140 R*

11

1.0071 R*

13

1.0042 F*

6

  1. Note. RR, Relative risk per 10 μg/m3 increase in pollutant concentration; SE, Standard error in 10-4. R represented random effects. F represented fixed effects. * indicated statistically significant at alpha = 0.05. 95% Cl = 1.96*SE ± RR.