Skip to main content

Table 4 Meta-analysis characteristics: comparison to original review

From: A review of the quantitative effectiveness evidence synthesis methods used in public health intervention guidelines

 

Original Review (39 guidelines)

Updated Review (24 Reviews)

RCTs only

4 (40%)

12 (50%)

Final outcomes

6 (60%)

20 (83%)

Lumping of interventions

7 (70%)

12 (50%)

Random effects meta-analysis

8 (80%)

19 (79%)

Fixed effects meta-analysis

1 (10%)

2 (8%)

Forest plots for presentation

9 (90%)

21 (88%)

Assessed publication bias

1 (10%)

3 (13%)