- Research article
- Open Access
Tuberculosis suspicion and knowledge among private and public general practitioners: Questionnaire Based Study in Oman
BMC Public Health volume 8, Article number: 177 (2008)
Early detection of smear positive TB cases by smear microscopy requires high level of suspicion of TB among primary care physicians. The objective of this study is to measure TB suspicion and knowledge among private and public sector general practitioners using clinical vignette-based survey and structured questionnaire.
Two questionnaires were distributed to both private and public GPs in Muscat Governorate. One questionnaire assessed demographic information of the respondent and had 10 short clinical vignettes of TB and non-TB cases. The second questionnaire had questions on knowledge of TB, its diagnosis, treatment, follow up and contact screening based on Ministry of Health policy. TB suspicion score and TB Knowledge score were computed and analyzed.
A total of 257 GPs participated in the study of which 154 were private GPs. There was a significant difference between private and public GPs in terms of age, sex, duration of practice and nationality. Among all GPs, 37.7% considered TB as one of the three most likely diagnoses in all 5 TB clinical vignettes. Private GPs had statistically significantly lower TB suspicion and TB knowledge scores than public GPs.
In Oman, GPs appear to have low suspicion and poor knowledge of TB, particularly private GPs. To strengthen TB control program, there is a need to train GPs on TB identification and adopt a Private Public Mix (PPM) strategy for TB control.
Detection of smear positive TB cases by direct microscopy is a key element of the DOTS (Direct Observed Treatment – Short course) strategy . The success of this strategy depends on the ability of the health care system to identify and follow up TB suspects . Health system's inability to diagnose and treat TB has been shown by many studies, both in low and high incidence countries [3–7].
Although Oman has been able to significantly reduce the burden of all forms) TB over the last 25 years, from 85 to 12 cases per 100,000 population. However, a slower decline was observed in the latter 10 years . Along with other Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) countries, Oman fixed an 'elimination target' for smear positive cases defined as 3/100,000 population by 2005 and 1/100,000 population by 2010. However, the smear positive notification rate in 2005 was 6/100,000 population, which necessitates additional efforts towards TB control in the country including systematic evaluation of the various components and factors affecting TB control .
In Oman, modern public health care services are free and delivered at three different levels, primary, secondary and tertiary. Secondary and tertiary hospitals have subspecialties and admission facilities. They are mainly located in the major cities. Primary health care is the main mode of public health care delivery, delivered through 140 health centers all over Oman, manned by general practitioners (GPs). In addition, private health care is available in Oman and has increased over the last 10 years. Private health care is delivered mainly through private clinics/hospitals and private pharmacies. In private clinics and/hospitals, GPs are the main providers for both Omani nationals and non-nationals (guest workers) .
Both public and private GPs are at the front line with regard to the diagnosis of TB. Therefore, skillful and adequately trained GPs would facilitate identifying TB cases. However, while both public and private GPs can make a diagnosis of TB, in Oman only public GPs are authorized to follow up and manage TB patients, under the law . Being a rapidly expanding sector, it is important to evaluate the ability of private GPs to suspect TB. The aim of this paper was to study level of suspicion and knowledge of TB among private and public GPs using written vignettes and structured questionnaires.
The survey was carried out in Muscat Governorate which hosts the capital of Oman, Muscat city. Muscat governorate has 6 willayates (towns) with approximately 700,000 inhabitants. Each willayate is serviced by 4 to 6 public primary health care centers (depending on population). Most health centers have 8 to 10 GPs. In addition, Muscat has the largest private sector in Oman with more than two thirds of all private health manpower in the country practicing in Muscat.
All GPs working in both private and public sector in Muscat were targeted in the study. (n = 326; 54.3% private and 45.7% public). Public and private physicians worked in out patient clinics, staffed by an average of 8–10 GPs in the public sector and 2–3 in the private sector. Public GPs were both nationals and non-nationals with a basic medical degree but no specialty training. There were a few family physicians working in health centers and these were excluded from the survey. Private GPs were mostly non-nationals with a basic medical degree.
The survey instrument comprised two questionnaires (A & B). Questionnaire (A)) See Additional file 1) had two parts. The first part solicited background demographic information of respondents (Table 1). The second part had 10 short written case vignettes (Box 1). Each vignette, described a patient who had key symptoms and signs of a respiratory illness. Some vignettes also included results of diagnostic procedures. Five of the vignettes were TB cases with different presentations. The other five vignettes were typical cases of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD), pneumonia, sarcoidosis, bronchiectasis and pulmonary fibrosis. In each of the 10 vignettes, GPs were asked to provide a maximum of 3 possible diagnoses in order of likelihood (i.e. most likely diagnosis first).
The clinical vignettes were prepared and the diagnoses finalized by a team of chest and infectious disease specialists and medical residents at Sultan Qaboos University Hospital, Muscat.
Questionnaire (B) (See Additional file 2) focused on TB and also had two parts. The first was on experience with TB, i.e. diagnosing and following up TB cases, TB training courses attended, and the second had a case vignette of a classical case of pulmonary TB followed by 20 multiple choice questions (MCQs) pertinent to the diagnosis, treatment, contact screening and follow up of such a TB case. The questions were based on the national TB manual published by Ministry of Health . There was only one correct answer for each question. The questionnaire was also reviewed and finalized by the same group of specialist physicians.
Public sector GPs
Each public health centre has a nurse in-charge. She, along with other nurses moderates patients' movements to consultation rooms of the GPs. We trained all nurses in-charge of all 17 health centers in Muscat governorate. Towards the end of the morning hours, the nurse in charge presented questionnaire (A) first to the available GPs and requested them to seal the questionnaire once they answered it. Then, questionnaire (B) was given to the same GPs and similarly sealed. GPs working in the evening hours were given the questionnaires in a similar manner.
Private sector GPs
For the private sector, we trained health inspectors who were familiar with all the private clinics in Muscat (they routinely visit them every week). Health inspectors were asked to give the questionnaire to all available private GPs. The questionnaires were distributed in a similar way to the public GPs i.e. questionnaire (A) first and then (B). The health inspectors were asked to wait in the clinic until the GPs finished responding to both questionnaires.
A TB suspicion score in the five TB vignettes was computed for each GP. We awarded 3, 2, 1 and 0 points for those who gave TB as a first, second, third and not-considered diagnosis, respectively. We also computed a TB general knowledge score from 20 MCQs (one point for every correct answer and none for an incorrect one). The reliability of the questionnaires was tested using chronbach alpha statistic and it was estimated to be 0.51 for the suspicion questionnaire and 0.64 for the knowledge questionnaire. Standard statistical measures were used to summarize the characteristics of GPs. Statistical test were used to assess the influence of random variation in the comparisons of groups. Comparison between public and private GPs was carried out using Chi square test for categorical variables. Independent sample t-test was used to compare the means of age and experience in years. Mann-Whitney test was applied for comparison of the distributions of the scores. A p-value of 0.05 and less was considered as indicating a statistically significant difference. We used multiple linear regression analysis to study a model with the two kinds of scores as dependent variables and potentially related independent variables. Robust estimation of standard error was used due to possible non-normality and heteroscedastisity of the observed TB suspicion and knowledge scores .
Participants were given choice not to participate in the study. Anonymity was assured by not collecting individual details related to name, health center or clinic. The study was approved by the medical research and ethics committee (MREC), Sultan Qaboos University, College of Medicine and Health Sciences, Muscat, Oman
During the study period, we met 170 (96%) of the private GPs and 117 (78.5%) of the public GPs. Seven of the private GPs were on leave and 32 public GPs were also on leave or away for training courses. Out of the 170 private GPs, 13 (7.6%) refused to participate and 2 returned unanswered questionnaire (1.2%). Among the 117 public GPs, 9 (7.8%) refused to participate and 5 (4.3%) did not return the questionnaire.
Table 1 shows general characteristics of GPs in the study. The average age of the GPs was 41.3 years with an average experience of 15.2 years. Private GPs were 10 years older than the public GPs (45.2 versus 35.2; p < 0.001) and had longer experience (18.9% versus 9.3%; p < 0.001). There were more non-nationals among private than public GPs (98.0% versus 51.5%; p < 0.001). A private GP was less likely to have diagnosed or followed up a TB case in the last year compared to a public GP (10.4% versus 64.1%; p < 0.001). Less than 15% of GPs had attended TB training courses during the last 5 years (19.2% public versus 11.0% private; p = 0.07).
Table 2 shows number and percentage of GPs who considered TB as one of the three possible diagnoses in any of the clinical vignettes. Except for TB-HIV vignette and TB vignette with heamoptysis, the percentage of private GPs who considered TB as one of three likely diagnoses in TB vignettes were significantly lower than public GPs. In non-TB vignettes, there was no significant difference in considering TB except for pneumonia vignette where 21.2 % of public GPs considered TB as compared to 5.5% of private GPs (p < 0.001). Among all GPs, 37.7% considered TB as one of the three most likely diagnoses in all 5 TB clinical vignettes with private having significantly lower percentage compared to public (27.3% versus 53.4%, p value 0.001)
Furthermore, for cases of sarcoidosis, fibrosis, bronchiectasis and COPD, more than 50% of all GPs were not able to mention the correct diagnosis with no significant difference between the public and private GPs. Pneumonia was correctly diagnosed by more than 80% of both public and private GPs (no statistically significant difference was observed).
Table 3 shows the median and inter-quartile range of TB suspicion and TB knowledge scores. The median scores of all GPs were 11 and 8 for suspicion and knowledge, respectively. For both scores private GPs scored significantly lower than public GPs (p < 0.001). Significant difference in knowledge related to diagnosis (p = 0.037), treatment (p < 0.001) and contact screening (p = 0.041) was observed.
Tables 4 and 5 present the results of simple and multiple robust linear regressions, respectively, with TB suspicion and TB knowledge scores as dependent variables and general characteristics of GPs as independent. "sector of work" (public/private) and "finding or following a TB case last year" were related to TB suspicion score using simple robust regression analysis. However, in the multiple analysis, sector of work was the only variable associated with TB suspicion score with private GPs scoring 1.6 points less than public GPs (95%CI; -2.9, -0.31). In simple analysis, sector of work, nationality, attending TB training course and "finding or following a TB case last year" were independently related to TB knowledge score. In the multiple analysis, private GPs scored 1.5 points less than public GPs (95%CI; -2.74, -0.28). GPs having attended TB training course in the last 5 years scored 2 points more than those who did not 95%CI; (0.71, 3.24).
Vignettes or written case simulations have been used widely to assess clinical knowledge and competence, though their use is controversial when assessing practice is concerned . However they were suitable in our study, as our intention was to assess knowledge and competence, and not clinical performance or action. These former two aspects form the base of an elegant conceptual model of clinical competence, Miller's pyramid  and lend themselves to evaluation using vignettes. Vignettes have the advantage of being easily administered, less costly and usable across different types of clinical practices. Vignettes are uniquely suited for comparative analyses among different providers/groups because they control for case mix. A study that assessed vignettes in comparison to the gold standard of standardized patients in an out patient setting similar to ours, showed that measuring quality with vignettes consistently produced scores that were close to the standardized patient method . It concluded that vignettes appeared to be most useful when the focus of research was on measuring competence among a group of providers.
Our results indicate that both private and public GPs in Oman are unlikely to suspect TB when TB is one of three likely diagnoses. The reasons of this low suspicion and poor knowledge are not clear. However, a possible explanation of the above results could be that as Oman is already a low incidence country (with less than 6/100,000 smear positive cases reported annually), there is little encounter with TB in clinical experience  (which would make GPs consider other, more common, respiratory conditions). Pneumonia and chronic bronchitis were the most common alternative diagnosis to TB (data not shown). There is a lack of TB training courses, less than 15% of all GPs attended TB courses during the last 5 years. A recent randomized controlled trial showed that educational interventions aimed to promote TB screening are effective in increasing TB detection .
Further, we have found that private GPs have significantly lower levels of suspicion and lower knowledge of TB compared to public GPs. This is consistent with findings in other studies in high incidence setting, e.g Pakistan and India, and also in low incidence setting, e.g US [14–17]. The fact that public GPs were more involved in finding and following TB cases than private is a possible explanation of the observed difference. Cases identified in the private sector are to be notified and referred immediately to the public health system. A possible implication of this policy is that private GPs lose interest in diagnosing and managing TB. Another possible explanation for the above difference is that public GPs reported attending TB training courses more frequently than private GPs which had an impact on their overall TB knowledge. In addition, public GPs as group of physicians (8 to 10 GPs in each health centre) share together knowledge and experiences to a greater extent than private GPs, where a maximum of 2 at each private clinic practice together.
General practitioners knowledge may have an impact on their patients' health. An important implication of our results is that there can be delays in diagnosis of TB cases, especially among those attending private clinics or hospitals . Therefore, there is a need to evaluate if there is a delay in diagnosis among TB patients as this may hinder the efforts to control TB. A well designed health care seeking behavior study for TB patients and TB suspects would help to identify factors related to both patients and health system delay.
Our results has also shown that the diagnostic accuracy of the non-TB vignettes were also not optimum. This highlights the need for strategy that also incorporates other disease like PAL strategy (Practical Approach to Lung Health). The aim of this strategy is to increase the quality of the respiratory care in primary health care settings. Therefore, such strategy would improve the diagnosis and the management not only of TB patients but other conditions as well .
Private Public Mix (PPM) as a strategy has been recommended by the WHO. PPM has been shown to improve case detection rate and is a necessity for National TB Programs (NTP) to control TB . In Oman, NTP should develop a contextualized strategy to engage with private GPs. Both private and public GPs should be actively engaged in TB control activities in a strategy of "Private Public Mix (PPM) for TB control in Oman". Such a strategy should explicitly highlight the rules for private sector in TB control, through implementing some of the practical tools recommended by the WHO, e.g. referral and notification as these are believed to increase case detection .
Although the study included only GPs working in Muscat governorate, the extrapolation of the results to Oman in general is valid as GPs in both the public and private sectors are not likely to be different from one region to another in Oman. One limitation of our study is that it did not assess the actual practice of the GPs, as vignettes are not appropriate to assess practice, they assess knowledge and competence. However, reported practice tends to be better than the actual practice. Therefore, the suspicion scores could be even lower than the reported.
In Oman, general practitioners appear to have a low level of suspicion and knowledge of TB and private GPs have lower suspicion and knowledge compared to public. It is recommended to actively engage both private and public health sectors in the National TB Control Program training and the necessary educational activities.
Organization; WH: What is DOTS? A guide to understanding the WHO-recommanded TB control strategey known as DOTS. 1999
Thorson A: Equity and equality: Case Detection of Tuberculosis among women and men in Vietnam. Department of Public Health Sciences Divison of International Health(IHCAR). 2003, Stockholm , Karolinnska Instiute, PhD: 8-
Pehme L, Rahu K, Rahu M, Altraja A: Factors related to health system delays in the diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis in Estonia. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis. 2007, 11 (3): 275-281.
Mirsaeidi SM, Tabarsi P, Mohajer K, Falah-Tafti S, Jammati HR, PhD PF, Mansouri SD, Masjedi MR, Velayati AA: A Long Delay from the First Symptom to Definite Diagnosis of Pulmonary Tuberculosis. Archives of Iranian Medicine. 2007, 10 (2): 190-193.
Rajeswari R, Chandrasekaran V, Suhadev M, Sivasubramaniam S, Sudha G, Renu G: Factors associated with patient and health system delays in the diagnosis of tuberculosis in South India. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis. 2002, 6 (9): 789-795.
Rao VK, Iademarco EP, Fraser VJ, Kollef MH: Delays in the Suspicion and Treatment of Tuberculosis among Hospitalized Patients. Annals of Internal Medicine. 1999, 130 (5): 404-411.
Golub JE, Bur S, Cronin WA, Gange S, Baruch N, Comstock GW, Chaisson RE: Patient and health care system delays in pulmonary tuberculosis diagnosis in a low-incidence state. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis. 2005, 9 (9): 992-998.
Al-Maniri A, Al-Rawas O, Al-Tuhami H, Eriksson B, Diwan VK: Towards the elimination of tuberculosis in a developing country: 25 years of tuberculosis control in Oman. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis. 2007, 11 (2): 175-180.
Ministry of Health: Annual Statistics Report. 2005, Oman , Ministry of health
Health M: Tuberculosis control program.TB Manual. 1998, Oman , Tuberculosis control program
Pires AM RIM: Multiple linear regression with some correlated errors: classical and robust methods. Stat Med. 2007, 26 (15): 2901-2918. 10.1002/sim.2774.
Peabody JW, Luck J, Glassman P, Dresselhaus TR, Lee M: Comparison of Vignettes, Standardized Patients, and Chart Abstraction A Prospective Validation Study of 3 Methods for Measuring Quality. JAMA. 2000, Am Med Assoc, 283 (13): 1715-1722. 10.1001/jama.283.13.1715.
GE M: The assessment of clinical skills/competence/performance. Acad Med. 1990, 65 (Suppl 9): S63- S67.
Singla N, Sharma PP, Singla R, Jain RC: Survey of knowledge, attitudes and practices for tuberculosis among general practitioners in Delhi, India. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis. 1998, 2 (5): 384-389.
Shah SK, Sadiq H, Khalil M, Noor A, Rasheed G, Shah SM, Ahmad N: Do private doctors follow national guidelines for managing pulmonary tuberculosis in Pakistan?. Eastern Mediterranean Health Journal. 2003, 9 (4): 776-788.
Khan J, Malik A, Hussain H, Ali NK, Akbani F, Hussain SJ, Kazi GN, Hussain SF: Tuberculosis diagnosis and treatment practices of private physicians in Karachi, Pakistan. Eastern Mediterranean Health Journal. 2003, 9 (4): 769-775.
LoBue PA . : Management of tuberculosis in San Diego County: a survey of physicians' knowledge, attitudes and practices. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis. 2001, 5 (10): 933-938.
World Health Organization: PAL: A primary health care strategy for the integrated management of respiratory conditions of people of five years of age and over. 2005, (WHO/HTM/TB/2005.351; WHO/NMH/CHP/CPM/CRA/05.3)
World Health Organization: Public-Private Mix for DOTS - Practical tools to help implementation. 2003, WHO/CDS/TB/2003325
The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/8/177/prepub
This study was financially supported from Sultan Qaboos University as part of an overall funding for a PhD scholarship for the first author. Authors would like to acknowledge all nurses and health inspectors who helped in data collection. Also Authors would like to acknowledge Directorate General of Muscat health Services, Directorate of Private Health Establishments, Directorate General of Health Services and National TB Control program for their support.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
AAA–M was involved in study design, data collection, data analysis and Manuscript writing. OAA–R was involved in Study design, data analysis and manuscript writing. FA–A was involved in Study design, data collection and manuscript writing. ADC was involved in study design and manuscript writing. BE was involved in data analysis and manuscript writing. VKD was involved in Study design and Manuscript writing. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Electronic supplementary material
About this article
Cite this article
Al-Maniri, A.A., Al-Rawas, O.A., Al-Ajmi, F. et al. Tuberculosis suspicion and knowledge among private and public general practitioners: Questionnaire Based Study in Oman. BMC Public Health 8, 177 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2458-8-177
- Gulf Cooperation Council
- Health System Delay
- Contact Screening
- Multiple Robust Linear Regression