Open Access
Open Peer Review

This article has Open Peer Review reports available.

How does Open Peer Review work?

Incidence of paediatric fatal and non-fatal low speed vehicle run over events in Queensland, Australia: eleven year analysis

  • Bronwyn R Griffin1, 2Email author,
  • Kerrianne Watt3, 4,
  • Belinda A Wallis1, 2,
  • Linda E Shields1, 2, 5 and
  • Roy M Kimble1, 2, 6
BMC Public Health201414:245

https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2458-14-245

Received: 18 June 2013

Accepted: 27 February 2014

Published: 11 March 2014

Abstract

Background

The purpose of this study was to estimate the incidence of fatal and non-fatal Low Speed Vehicle Run Over (LSVRO) events among children aged 0–15 years in Queensland, Australia, at a population level.

Methods

Fatal and non-fatal LSVRO events that occurred in children resident in Queensland over eleven calendar years (1999-2009) were identified using ICD codes, text description, word searches and medical notes clarification, obtained from five health related data bases across the continuum of care (pre-hospital to fatality). Data were manually linked. Population data provided by the Australian Bureau of Statistics were used to calculate crude incidence rates for fatal and non-fatal LSVRO events.

Results

There were 1611 LSVROs between 1999–2009 (IR = 16.87/100,000/annum). Incidence of non-fatal events (IR = 16.60/100,000/annum) was 61.5 times higher than fatal events (IR = 0.27/100,000/annum). LSVRO events were more common in boys (IR = 20.97/100,000/annum) than girls (IR = 12.55/100,000/annum), and among younger children aged 0–4 years (IR = 21.45/100000/annum; 39% or all events) than older children (5–9 years: IR = 16.47/100,000/annum; 10–15 years IR = 13.59/100,000/annum). A total of 896 (56.8%) children were admitted to hospital for 24 hours of more following an LSVRO event (IR = 9.38/100,000/annum). Total LSVROs increased from 1999 (IR = 14.79/100,000) to 2009 (IR = 18.56/100,000), but not significantly. Over the 11 year period, there was a slight (non –significant) increase in fatalities (IR = 0.37-0.42/100,000/annum); a significant decrease in admissions (IR = 12.39–5.36/100,000/annum), and significant increase in non-admissions (IR = 2.02-12.77/100,000/annum). Trends over time differed by age, gender and severity.

Conclusion

This is the most comprehensive, population-based epidemiological study on fatal and non-fatal LSVRO events to date. Results from this study indicate that LSVROs incur a substantial burden. Further research is required on the characteristics and risk factors associated with these events, in order to adequately inform injury prevention. Strategies are urgently required in order to prevent these events, especially among young children aged 0–4 years.

Keywords

Child Adolescent Prevention & control Accident prevention Epidemiology Queensland

Background

Preventable injuries to children are a significant burden on society and a considerable cost to the health care system [1]. “Low speed vehicle run over (LSVRO) incidents” is a term used to describe incidents where a pedestrian – usually a child – is injured or killed by a slow moving vehicle in either a traffic or non-traffic area [2]. LSVROs have been identified as a significant cause of transport pedestrian fatalities in young children. After pool drowning, LSVROs are the second largest cause of death from unintentional injury for children in Australia aged 1-4 yrs [3]. LSVRO incidents have different characteristics to other pedestrian casualties that occur on public roads and at greater speeds. However, comprehensive data on this particular mechanism have not been well documented. As most of these deaths and injuries are preventable and result when a parent or close relative is driving the vehicle, the cost in psychological terms for the family are high, often leading to extensive grief and frequently a breakdown of the family unit [4].

These types of incidents have been variously described in scientific journals since 1964, when a case report was described in Illinois [5, 6]. Then later in 1980 a case series of patients admitted to intensive care at St Louis Children’s Hospital in Washington were reported [7]. International awareness grew during the 1990s with studies describing this tragic injury in the US, [814] Canada, [15] United Kingdom, [16] Brazil, [17] New Zealand [1821] and Australia [2225]. In Australia, child deaths in driveways were first highlighted as a significant health issue in 2000.

The World Health Organization recommends that data quality pertaining to transport injuries needs improvement in order to develop effective prevention strategies. Specifically, more comprehensive data about the numbers and types of injuries, and the circumstances in which those injuries occur, taking into account the complexities of the problem, are required. The information should be of sufficient quality to allow inferences to be made about the magnitude of problem, and where prevention measures are most urgently needed [26].

There is little current research that describes this mechanism of injury in detail, at a population level. No papers define both fatal and non-fatal data in the same data set, in the same area, in the same time period, with an age group up to 15 years [27]. In addition, different data collecting systems collect differing data (i.e., different fields of information), so ascertaining the true incidence of these events is difficult.

Currently, the most frequent method of identifying LSVRO incidents is to identify non-traffic pedestrian transport incidents using ICD codes, then manually interrogate data to determine the location of the incident (if it is recorded). This level of difficulty in classifying LSVRO incidents has compromised ability to complete comprehensive, population-based studies, as the process is complex, time consuming and costly.

These methodological limitations of previously published work on LSVRO events have resulted in a lack of adequate information about the burden (fatal and non-fatal) of this injury, and the circumstances surrounding the incident. This information is crucial in informing effective prevention strategies to reduce the burden of LSVRO events.

The purpose of this study was to provide improved estimates of the incidence of fatal and non-fatal LSVRO events at a population level. Characteristics of LSVRO events are addressed elsewhere [28].

Methods

This study was a population-based, retrospective cohort study. For the purposes of this study, the definition of LSVRO suggested by the Commission for Children Young People and Child Guardian (CCYPCG) and Queensland Injury Surveillance Unit (QISU) has been used. That is, LSVRO incidents are those where a pedestrian, usually a child, is injured or killed by a slow moving vehicle (30 km/hr or 19 mph) in both traffic and non-traffic areas (2). All children aged 0–15 years (inclusive) involved in a fatal or non-fatal LSVRO incident between 1999–2009 were included in this study.

Ethics approval

This study was approved by the Behavioural and Social Sciences Ethics Review Committee of the University of Queensland; Children’s Health Service District – Health Research Ethics Committee, Office of Health and Medical Research – Queensland Health. Approval to access data was also obtained from all of the relevant data custodians (Queensland Ambulance Service; Queensland Health; Mater Hospital; Commission for Children, Young People and Child Guardian).

In order to calculate incidence of LSVRO events as accurately as possible, retrospective data on all fatal and non-fatal LSVROs among 0–15 year olds in Queensland, Australia from 1999–2009 were obtained from multiple sources across the continuum of care and manually linked by the first author. Any child who received treatment for an LSVRO from one of the following were included in the study:
  1. 1)

    Pre-hospital (Queensland Ambulance Service-QAS) - statewide.

     
  2. 2)

    Emergency Department (Emergency Department Information System - EDIS) – almost statewide, supplemented by Queensland Injury Surveillance Unit - QISU);

     
  3. 3)

    Hospital admissions for 24 hours or more (Queensland Health Admitted Patient Data Collection) - statewide; and

     
  4. 4)

    Fatalities (Commission for Children, Young People and Child Guardian -Child Death Review (CCYPCG-CDR) – statewide. The CCYPCG-CDR did not exist prior to 2004, so for 1999–2001 data were obtained from the Queensland Council on Obstetric and Paediatric Morbidity and Mortality (QCOPMM).

     

QAS, CCYPCG and QHAPDC data are state-wide. Every incident that resulted in death, admission to a hospital in Queensland, or that was attended by Queensland Ambulance Service, is included in this data set. EDIS is not statewide but does capture the majority of ED presentations in QLD, and all of the major Emergency Departments.

Identification of relevant cases was difficult due to the absence of specific codes describing LSVRO incidents. Data extraction occurred separately for each of the databases. Data were first obtained on children admitted to hospital as a consequence of an LSVRO, using ICD codes (external cause, and where possible, location codes – see Table 1). In cases where it was not possible to determine whether the incident was an LSVRO from the available ICD codes, further information was sought from manually searching additional databases (e.g., QISU, EDIS) using text fields to rule out high speed incidents. Data regarding all definite incidents resulting in hospital admission were then obtained from QAS, EDIS and QISU, if the incident was present in that database, using manual linkage. In addition, all cases involving paediatric pedestrian crashes were extracted from the pre-hospital database and manually interrogated using free text fields (case description). Similarly, all paediatric pedestrian events in the EDIS database were extracted using the presenting complaint field, and this field was then further manually interrogated for relevant cases. For QISU data, a similar manual search process occurred for all cases initially extracted using transport codes (0509–0599). For fatality data, the events were already clearly defined in the CDR database, using a combination of coroners’ reports and forensic investigation forms. For all databases, where insufficient information existed to determine whether a case was definitely an LSVRO incident, it was not included. Once all definite LSVRO incidents were identified in each database, data were linked using (in order) name, gender, age/date of birth, date of incident, and hospital. Data were then cleaned to ensure that every incident was represented only once in the database. A more detailed explanation regarding case ascertainment and data linkage is described elsewhere [29].
Table 1

ICD codes used for retrospective data search across all time periods [3033]

Code set of ICD version

External cause code

Place of occurrence code

ICD9-CM (1/1/1999)

E813.6, E814.7, E816.6, E816.7, E817.7, E819.6, E825.7

E849.0, E849.5, E849.8

ICD-10-AM 1st Ed (1/7/99 – 30/6/00)

V03 (all),V04 (all), V09, V13, V14, V19, V84.1, V84.2, V84.3, V84.4, V84.6, V84.7, V84.9

N/A

ICD-10-AM 2nd Edition - 6th Edition (30/6/00 - current)

V03, V04, V09, V13, V14, V19, V84.1, V84.2, V84.3, V84.4, V84.6, V84.7, V84.9

Y92.0, Y92.4, Y92.7, Y92.8

ICD-10-AM 3rd edition - 6th Edition (1/7/02-current)

V03.0, V03.1, V03.9, V04, V09.0, V09.1, V84, V84.1, V84.2, V84.3, V84.4, V84.5 V84.8

Y92.00, Y92.40, Y92.41, Y92.42, Y92.48, Y92.49, Y92.87

Data analysis

Crude incidence rates (IRs) and 95% Confidence Intervals [34] were calculated separately for fatal and non-fatal LSVRO incidents (this was further divided into events resulting in hospital admission, and events not resulting in hospital admission). The Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) provides population data for each age year, from 1901 onwards. Number of LSVRO events for a particular age and calendar year were divided by the corresponding population for that age year, for each year from 1999–2009. This was done separately for fatal and non-fatal events (hospital admissions and non-admissions), all events combined, males and females, and for the total population. Incidence rates were also calculated for age groups (0-4 years; 5-9 years; 10-15 years). Data on all LSVRO events that occurred in Queensland were extracted, however only events that involved residents of Queensland were used to calculate incidence rates, because accurate population data (for the denominator) on non-Queensland residents was not available. Trends over time were analysed by chi-square test for trend using Epi Info (7.0).

Results

Incidence rates for fatal, non-fatal and total LSVRO events by calendar year (1999–2009) are shown in Figure 1. During the 11 year data collection period, there were 1,611 LSVRO incidents among 0–15 year old residents of Queensland, yielding an annual crude incidence rate of 16.87 per 100,000 (male: 20.97/100,000; female: 12.55/100,000). Approximately 39% (n = 621) of the total number of LSVRO events involved 0–4 year olds, yielding an annual incidence rate of 21.45/100000/annum, and incidence was higher among males (IR = 26.75/100,000; females: 15.85/100,000). The annual incidence rate for 5–9 year olds was 16.47/100,000 (males 20.72; females 11.99), and for 10–15 year olds it was 13.59/100,000 (males 16.62; females 10.40).
Figure 1

Crude LSVRO fatal, admission and non-admission incidence rates by year, age-group, 1999–2009, Queensland (per 100,000 per annum).

Over the 11 years of data collection, the annual incidence rate for non-fatal LSVRO events (16.60/100,000) was 61.5 times higher than for fatal events (0.27/100,000). Of all non-fatal events, 56.8% (n = 896) involved admission to hospital for 24 hours or longer (IR = 9.38 per 100,000 per annum). As can be seen in Table 2, incidence rates were higher among boys than girls for all age groups, for both fatal and non-fatal events. Table 2 also shows that the incidence rate was higher in 0–4 year olds than other age groups, for both fatal and non-fatal LSVRO events. Between 1999–2009, 85% of fatal and 38% of non-fatal events involved children aged 0–4 years. Similar patterns were observed in admissions and non-admissions (this includes treatment involving pre-hospital or Emergency Department only).
Table 2

Crude incidence rates of fatal and non-fatal LSVRO events by age-group and gender (1999–2009) (per 100,000, per annum)

Age groups

Fatal

Non-fatal*

Male IR

Female IR

Total IR

Male IR

Female IR

Total IR

 

(95% CI)

(95% CI)

(95% CI)

(95% CI)

(95% CI)

(95% CI)

0-4 yrs

0.94

0.49

0.72

26.55

15.84

20.969

(0.940-0.941)

(0.496-0.498)

(0.725-0.726)

(26.509-26.593)

(15.824-15.875)

(20.946-20.993)

5-9 yrs

0.19

-

0.10

20.98

12.05

16.63

(2.034-2.048)

(20.951-21.016)

(12.039-12.076)

(16.619-16.656)

10-15 yrs

0.05

-

-

16.66

10.45

13.59

(0.052-0.053)

(16.646-16.692)

(10.444-10.473)

(13.577-13.603)

0-15 yrs

0.43

0.15

0.293

21.01

12.59

16.77

(0.428-0.429)

(0.1506-0.151)

(0.292-0.294)

(20.997-21.033)

(12.579-12.601)

(16.769-16.789)

*Non-fatal IR includes admission to hospital for 24 hours or longer, as well as treatment at Ambulance and/or, Emergency Department only).

Trends over time

Between 1999–2009, the incidence of LSVRO events (fatal and non-fatal combined) among 0–15 year olds increased from 14.79 (1999) to 18.56 (2009) per 100,000, with two distinct peaks (Figure 1). The first peak occurred in 2000 (22.48 per 100,000) and the second in 2008 (22.65 per 100,000). The lowest observed IR of LSVRO events occurred in 2003 (12.36 per 100,000) and 2006 (12.54 per 100,000). The increase in LSVRO incidence over time was not significant (X2 = 0.05; p > .05). Of concern is that in the four years since 2006, the incidence of LSVRO events increased by a factor of almost 1.5, to 18.56 per 100,000. Trends over time differed by severity of injury: incidence of hospitalisation resulting from LSVRO events decreased over the 11 year period (X2 = 96.80; p < .001); but incidence of non-admissions increased (X2 = 172.97; p < .001). Incidence of fatalities did not change significantly (X2 = 0.15; p > .05).

In 0–15 year old males, the incidence of fatal and non-fatal LSVRO events (combined) increased from 18.39 to 23.82 per 100,000 between 1999–2009 (an increase by a factor of 1.5, although this increase was not significant (X2 = 0.93; p > .05). For females, the incidence increased from 10.98 to 13.00 per 100,000 (X2 = 0.91; p > .05). For most years between 1999–2009, the incidence of LSVRO events among 0–15 year old females in Queensland remained between 9 and 14 per 100,000 per annum. For both males (X2 = 96.73; p < .001) and females (X2 = 41.81; p < .001), incidence of hospital admission due to LSVRO incidents decreased during the 11 year period, but incidence of non-admissions increased (males: X2 = 60.97; p < .001; females: X2 = 64.27; p < .001). Mortality did not change significantly during this time.

As indicated in Figure 1, over the 11 year period, annual incidence of LSVRO events among 0–4 year olds decreased significantly from 30.3 to 12.51 per 100,000 (incidence among males decreased from 35.09 – 14.68/100,000/annum, and among females incidence decreased from 25.24 – 10.2/100,000/annum). Conversely, annual incidence of LSVROs among children aged 5–9 years increased from 13.62 in 1999 to 17.8 in 2009 (females: IR increased from 7.99 to 13/ 100,000/annum; males: IR increased from 18.39 to 22.45/100,000/annum), however these increases were not significant. A more substantial increase was observed among older children aged 10-15 yrs (X2 = 77.58; p < .001). In 1999 the annual incidence rate was 3.29 per 100,000 (males: 4.49 per 100,000; females: 2.03 per 100,000), and in 2009 it was 25.13 per 100,000 (males: 32.7; females: 16.07). Among this age group, most of this increase appears to have occurred since 2005.

Trends over time differed by severity, gender and age group. As can be seen in Figure 1, incidence of admissions due to LSVRO events among 0–4 year old boys (X2 = 75.45; p < .001) and girls (X2 = 57.81; p < .001) decreased significantly between 1999–2009, as well as for 5–9 year old boys and girls (X2 = 26.92, p < .001; X2 = 4.90; p < .01, respectively). Incidence of admissions resulting from LSVRO events increased significantly among 10–15 year old boys (X2 = 3.94; p < .05), and although an increase was also observed among girls, this trend was not significant (X2 = 0.29; p > .05) in each age group (p < .001) (Table 3). The incidence of fatal events among female children aged 0-4 years increased from 0.84 to 1.36 per 100,000, per annum, but decreased among boys of this age group (1.59 to 0.68 per 100,000 per annum); neither trend was significant. It is important to keep this in context. There were seven deaths from LSVRO events among 0–15 year old females in Queensland between 1999–2009, and all of these deaths occurred in the 0–4 year age group. The remaining 19 deaths from LSVRO events occurred among male children, and 14 of these were in boys aged 0-4 years.
Table 3

Crude incidence rates and 95% CI by age groups, gender and calendar year

0-4 years

Incidence of FATAL LSVRO events

 

Male

Female

Total

 

IR

95% CI

IR

95% CI

IR

95% CI

1999

1.60

1.590-1.600

0.84

0.839-0.843

1.23

1.226-1.230

2000

0.80

0.793-0.798

0

0

0.41

0.406-0.410

2001

0

0

0

0

0

0

2002

0

0

0.82

0.821-0.825

0.40

0.398-0.402

2003

0

0

0

0

0

0

2004

2.28

2.274-2.292

1.60

1.597-1.608

1.95

1.946-1.957

2005

2.23

2.222-2.240

0

0

1.15

1.144-1.147

2006

1.45

1.446-1.454

0.77

0.763-0.768

1.12

1.116-1.119

2007

0

0

0

0

0

0

2008

1.34

1.340-1.347

0

0

0.69

0.689-0.693

2009

0.64

0.636-0.641

1.36

1.355-1.363

0.99

0.987-0.988

Incidence of nonfatal LSVRO events resulting in hospital admission

1999

32.71

32.527-32.884

23.55

23.423-23.685

28.25

28.142-28.362

2000

39.00

38.792-39.217

23.50

23.367-23.628

30.23

30.112-30.348

2001

38.53

38.319-38.737

17.43

17.338-17.529

27.06

26.951-27.160

2002

22.59

22.473-22.714

16.47

16.382-16.562

19.62

19.543-19.693

2003

17.72

17.628-17.816

9.78

9.726-9.830

13.47

13.414--13.515

2004

23.60

23.472-23.722

14.43

14.351-14.505

19.13

19.059-19.203

2005

14.13

14.058-14.204

11.77

11.710-11.834

12.60

12.555-12.648

2006

10.88

10.822-10.932

3.83

3.812-3.848

7.45

7.424-7.477

2007

9.14

9.091-9.180

2.24

2.227-2.245

5.06

5.047-5.081

2008

12.10

12.039-12.157

9.26

9.214-9.306

10.37

10.338-10.410

2009

7.02

6.991-7.056

0.68

0.677-0.682

3.95

3.938-3.963

Incidence of nonfatal LSVRO events not resulting in hospital admission

1999

1.60

1.590-1.600

3.36

3.348-3.381

2.46

2.449-2.464

2000

7.96

7.919-8.00

3.36

3.340-3.372

5.72

5.698-5.739

2001

3.15

3.130-3.159

1.66

1.654-1.666

2.42

2.415-2.430

2002

10.13

10.075-10.181

2.47

2.460-2.481

6.41

6.382-6.429

2003

5.39

5.367-5.420

2.44

2.434-2.455

3.96

3.947-3.973

2004

3.81

3.788-3.823

6.41

6.379-6.445

5.08

5.058-5.093

2005

5.95

5.921-5.979

3.14

3.125-3.153

4.58

4.566-4.597

2006

5.80

5.773-5.829

2.30

2.288-2.307

4.10

4.084-4.111

2007

8.43

8.391-8.474

2.98

2.968-2.994

5.79

5.768-5.807

2008

11.43

11.371-11.482

8.55

8.506-8.590

10.03

9.994-10.063

2009

7.02

6.991-7.056

8.16

8.117-8.195

7.57

7.547-7.597

5-9 years

Incidence of FATAL LSVRO events

 

Male

Female

Total

 

IR

95% CI

IR

95% CI

IR

95% CI

1999

0

0

0

0

0

0

2000

0.74

0.743-0.748

0

0

0.38

0.381-0.385

2001

0

0

0

0

0

0

2002

0

0

0

0

0

0

2003

0

0

0

0

0

0

2004

0.72

0.721-0.726

0

0

0.37

0.368-0.372

2005

0

0

0

0

0

0

2006

0

0

0

0

0

0

2007

0.70

0.694-0.699

0

0

0.36

0.355-0.359

2008

0

0

0

0

0

0

2009

2.04

2.033-2.048

0

0

1.05

1.046-1.048

Incidence of nonfatal LSVRO events resulting in hospital admission

1999

15.16

15.080-15.238

6.39

6.361-6.426

10.89

10.852-10.932

2000

28.35

28.198-28.496

7.10

7.061-7.134

18.02

17.950-18.085

2001

20.68

20.571-20.786

9.38

9.328-9.425

15.19

15.131-15.243

2002

12.44

12.379-12.506

7.75

7.712-7.791

10.16

10.127-10.201

2003

10.92

10.860-10.970

6.13

6.103-6.164

8.59

8.556-8.617

2004

12.31

12.248-12.372

3.80

3.782-3.817

8.16

8.129-8.186

2005

10.76

10.708-10.815

6.04

6.005-6.064

8.46

8.427-8.487

2006

12.02

11.963-12.083

2.23

2.219-2.236

7.25

7.220-7.270

2007

7.67

7.632-7.706

4.40

4.3824.423

6.08

6.057-6.098

2008

8.96

8.918-9.005

5.82

5.791-5.847

7.43

7.407-7.458

2009

5.44

5.418-5.468

4.30

4.281-4.321

4.89

4.871-4.903

Incidence of nonfatal LSVRO events resulting in hospital admission

1999

4.55

4.526-4.569

1.60

1.593-1.603

3.11

3.102-3.122

2000

3.73

3.712-3.747

2.37

2.356-2.375

3.06

3.057-3.076

2001

5.17

5.144-5.194

5.47

5.442-5.497

5.31

5.297-5.333

2002

3.66

3.643-3.676

6.98

6.941-7.011

5.27

5.252-5.288

2003

5.09

5.069-5.117

6.90

6.865-6.934

5.97

5.952-5.994

2004

6.52

6.485-6.548

6.84

6.805-6.874

6.67

6.651-6.697

2005

7.89

7.853-7.930

4.53

4.504-4.547

6.25

6.229-6.272

2006

6.37

6.334-6.395

7.43

7.389-7.463

6.88

6.859-6.906

2007

13.25

13.182-13.313

9.54

9.492-9.588

11.44

11.401-11.482

2008

13.10

13.033-13.162

9.46

9.410-9.540

11.32

11.286-11.366

2009

17.01

16.926-17.094

7.89

7.846-7.924

12.56

12.522-12.611

10-15 years

Incidence of FATAL LSVRO events

 

Male

Female

Total

 

IR

95% CI

IR

IR

IR

95% CI

1999

0

0

0

0

0

0

2000

0.63

0.629-0.633

0

0

0.32

0.322-0.326

2001

0

0

0

0

0

0

2002

0

0

0

0

0

0

2003

0

0

0

0

0

0

2004

0

0

0

0

0

0

2005

0

0

0

0

0

0

2006

0

0

0

0

0

0

2007

0

0

0

0

0

0

2008

0

0

0

0

0

0

2009

0

0

0

0

0

0

Incidence of nonfatal LSVRO events resulting in hospital admission

1999

2.56

2.555-2.574

0.68

0.675-0.680

1.65

1.643-1.651

2000

15.79

15.712-15.863

4.67

4.648-4.691

10.38

10.346-10.416

2001

10.54

10.487-10.586

4.59

4.567-4.608

7.65

7.620-7.670

2002

8.52

8.481-8.559

5.11

5.088-5.134

6.55

6.524-6.566

2003

5.34

5.314-5.360

1.25

1.245-1.251

3.34

3.334-3.354

2004

3.47

3.457-3.485

3.05

3.036-3.061

3.27

3.256-3.275

2005

2.26

2.253-2.269

2.98

2.970-2.994

2.61

2.605-2.619

2006

4.47

4.452-4.489

1.77

1.760-1.771

3.15

3.144-3.162

2007

3.32

3.309-3.335

2.91

2.901-2.923

3.12

3.113-3.131

2008

6.58

6.550-6.606

2.89

2.875-2.898

4.78

4.766-4.795

2009

8.18

8.141-8.211

5.73

5.701-5.750

6.70

6.681-6.722

Incidence of nonfatal LSVRO events resulting in hospital admission

1999

1.92

1.917-1.930

1.35

1.351-1.358

1.65

1.643-1.651

2000

1.89

1.888-1.901

1.33

1.330-1.338

1.62

1.618-1.626

2001

4.96

4.936-4.980

2.62

2.611-2.632

3.82

3.811-3.834

2002

9.13

9.087-9.171

4.47

4.452-4.492

6.86

6.835-6.879

2003

4.74

4.723-4.764

3.74

3.727-3.759

4.26

4.243-4.269

2004

7.52

7.488-7.554

5.49

5.463-5.512

6.53

6.510-6.552

2005

5.65

5.630-5.678

4.18

4.158-4.193

4.93

4.919-4.949

2006

7.27

7.234-7.297

9.42

9.375-9.460

8.31

8.287-8.339

2007

13.84

13.779-13.903

14.56

14.494-14.627

14.19

14.146-14.237

2008

27.41

27.287-27.535

18.48

18.391-18.560

23.06

22.985-23.133

2009

25.07

24.961-25.187

10.88

10.829-10.927

18.15

18.092-18.208

0-15 yrs

Incidence of FATAL LSVRO events

 

Male

Female

Total

 

IR

95% CI

IR

IR

IR

95% CI

1999

0.48

0.482-0486

0.26

0.253-0.257

0.37

0.371-0.374

2000

0.72

0.716-0.719

0

0

0.37

0.367-0.370

2001

0

0

0

0

0

0

2002

0

0

0.25

0.244-0.247

0.12

0.118-0.120

2003

0

0

0

0

0

0

2004

0.90

0.903-0.905

0.48

0.474-0.477

0.70

0.6945-0.697

2005

0.67

0.664-0.667

0

0

0.34

0.340-0.343

2006

0.44

0.435-0.438

0.23

0.228-0.231

0.34

0.334-0.337

2007

0.21

0.213-0.216

0

0

0.11

0.109-0.111

2008

0.42

0.418-0.421

0

0

0.22

0.214-0.217

2009

0.41

0.409-0.412

0.43

0.432-0.435

0.42

0.420-0.423

Incidence of nonfatal LSVRO events resulting in hospital admission

1999

15.73

15.682-15.776

9.45

9.420-9.476

12.67

12.646-12.700

2000

26.79

26.712-26.872

11.11

11.081-11.148

18.80

18.758-18.838

2001

22.17

22.108-22.239

9.97

9.945-10.004

15.88

15.847-15.913

2002

13.98

13.936-14.017

9.34

9.310-9.365

11.60

11.575-11.624

2003

10.78

10.753-10.814

5.32

5.306-5.336

8.01

7.991-8.023

2004

12.21

12.174-12.243

6.66

6.642-6.680

9.51

9.486-9.525

2005

8.43

8.408-8.455

6.55

6.529-6.566

7.40

7.386-7.415

2006

8.73

8.705-8.753

2.53

2.522-2.534

5.71

5.698-5.720

2007

6.43

6.416-6.450

3.17

3.158-3.174

4.62

4.614-4.632

2008

9.03

9.004-9.053

5.76

5.749-5.780

7.33

7.319-7.347

2009

6.98

6.962-6.999

3.69

3.676-3.695

5.27

5.263-5.282

Incidence of nonfatal LSVRO events resulting in hospital admission

1999

2.66

2.655-2.668

2.04

2.038-2.047

2.36

2.356-2.365

2000

4.31

4.294-4.317

2.27

2.268-2.279

3.32

3.311-3.323

2001

4.48

4.470-4.494

3.24

3.233-3.2502

3.88

3.871-3.886

2002

7.69

7.665-7.709

4.67

4.656-4.682

6.22

6.206-6.231

2003

5.05

5.034-5.061

4.35

4.342-4.365

4.71

4.701-4.719

2004

6.10

6.087-6.121

6.19

6.168-6.203

6.14

6.132-6.156

2005

6.43

6.417-6.452

3.98

3.965-3.986

5.24

5.227-5.247

2006

6.55

6.5296.565

6.67

6.647-6.684

6.60

6.592-6.617

2007

12.01

11.975-12.042

9.50

9.473-9.527

10.79

10.766-10.809

2008

18.06

18.008-18.108

12.64

12.602-12.673

15.42

15.390-15.452

2009

16.84

16.790-16.883

9.11

9.080-9.130

13.08

13.050-13.101

Discussion

The results of this study indicate that the incidence of LSVRO events is higher among younger children aged 0–4 years, and among males. Of the three children injured in an LSVRO every week in Queensland, two are male. The majority of the total burden from LSVRO events related to non-fatalities, yet this is the area least previously researched.

This is the first study to date in which population-based data across the continuum of care (pre-hospital to fatality) have been linked to obtain an accurate estimation of the magnitude of fatal and non-fatal paediatric LSVRO events. While several studies exist in which LSVRO events are described, [18, 20, 21, 24, 35] none have been as extensive as this population-based, eleven year retrospective review.

Incidence rates for LSVRO events have been reported in five previous studies; three of these studies were conducted in Auckland, New Zealand, [19, 21, 35] and the other two in the USA (Washington State [15]; and Utah [36]). Three studies (all from New Zealand) reported non-fatal incidence rates among 0–15 year olds, [19, 21, 35] in all three studies incidence rates were between 7–9 per 100,000 per annum. The non-fatal incidence rates estimated in the present study are higher than that previously described in the literature [15, 19, 21, 35]. One other study, conducted in Utah, estimated that the non-fatal LSVRO incidence rate in children aged less than 10 years was 7.09 per 100,000 per annum. However after the authors conducted analyses to counteract the acknowledged methodological limitations, the re-calculated incidence rate was closer to that estimated in the present study. It is likely that the higher observed incidence in the present study is due to more accurate identification of total number of LSVRO events than has occurred in previous studies, and inclusion of non-fatal LSVRO events from pre-hospital and emergency department data. We considered it important to include such events because injuries sustained from LSVRO events that do not result in hospitalisation may still be serious, and are often treated on an out-patient basis.

Four of the five previously published studies reported fatal incidence rates [15, 19, 21, 35]. Three of these studies (all from Auckland, New Zealand) involved children aged 0-15 years. In each of these studies, mortality rates were higher than the annual incidence rate of 0.27 per 100 000 estimated in the current study (IR:0.63 per 100 000, [21] IR:0.64 per 100,000, [35] IR: 0.77 per 100,000 [19]). In the fourth study, incidence of fatal LSVRO events among 1–4 year olds in Washington State from 1979–1983 was estimated at 3.2 per 100 000. It is unlikely that fatal LSVRO cases were missed in the present study. Fatality data were obtained from the Child Death Review database maintained by the Commission for Children, Young People and the Child Guardian, which records extensive details of all deaths among children in Queensland, from coroners’ reports, police reports, and other sources. One explanation could be that over time the management of the trauma patient has improved globally.

The study conducted in Washington State was the only study in which gender-specific fatality incidence rates were reported (male 1–4 year olds: 3.2 per 100,000; female 1–4 year olds: 2.5 per 100 000), and again these incidence rates were higher than that observed in the present study. No other study has reported gender and age specific incidence rates for LSVRO events. However, males have consistently been described in descriptive studies as being more frequently involved in LSVRO events in which gender has been analysed [18, 21, 24, 37]. This is consistent with our findings. No other studies in the literature have reported age-specific non-fatal LSVRO incidence rates. However, in descriptive studies that have involved comparable age groups to the present study, higher frequencies of non-fatal LSVRO events have been reported among children aged 0–4 years [18, 24]. The results of the present study confirm this.

In the present study, incidence of total LSVRO events among children aged 0–15 years increased over the 11 year period between 1999–2009. It is not possible to compare this with previous research as no other study to date has presented data on trends over time. Between 1999–2009, two “dips” are apparent, the first of these occurred in 2003. It is possible that this reduction in LSVRO events could be in relation to a driveway safety campaign that was released at that time in the state of New South Wales [38]. The second dip in 2005–2006 may be the result of a non-fatal (but serious/critical) incident that occurred in Australia in October 2005 involving the child of a national sporting celebrity. This event, and the long recovery period, was highly covered by the media at the time [39].

The present data also indicate that while incidence of LSVRO events decreased over time for children aged 0–4 years, an increase was observed among older children aged 10–15 years. The reasons behind this require further investigation.

This study has inherent strengths in comparison to other previously published studies on incidence of LSVRO events. Firstly, this study was a population-based study. Three of the five previously published studies occurred in Auckland, New Zealand, which is predominantly an urban population. The present study included all possible cases across the state of Queensland (population = 4,560,100 (19.7% 0–15 year olds), 1.73 million km2). It is also possible that car movement behaviour in urban areas may be different to that in a rural setting [40]. Secondly, this study captured all possible incidents across the continuum of care, from pre-hospital to fatalities. Thirdly, the case definition for LSVRO events in the present study is broader than that used in previous studies. LSVRO events do not have an assigned ICD code. These events are not restricted to a certain location. Hence authors are forced to search for their own definitions. To date, the two most popular codes used to search for LSVRO events employed in previous studies are: 1. place of occurrence codes (e.g. driveway), or 2. external cause codes (e.g. non-traffic pedestrian). In studies where driveway location is used to identify LSVRO events, [36, 41] case counts exclude events that occur in any location other than the driveway (e.g., in traffic areas where a vehicle may be travelling slowly, such as a school drop off zone, or other non-traffic areas where a vehicle may travel slowly such as beaches, parks, car parks, recreation areas, etc.). Hence, incidence rates from these studies are not directly comparable to our study. Studies in which LSVRO events have been identified through non-traffic pedestrian codes are limited because speed is not defined within ICD codes and LSVRO incidents can occur in traffic areas. Ours is the first study to not limit location (driveway) or external cause (non-traffic pedestrian).

Finally, time is a possible explanation for the observed differences in previously published work on incidence of LSVROs, and our study. Two of the five other studies were conducted in the 1980s, and are therefore not directly comparable to the results of the current study.

There were some limitations associated with this study. Analyses were limited by availability of data – this is especially the case for non-fatal LSVRO incidents. While data on fatalities, hospital admissions and pre-hospital treatment that resulted as a consequence of LSVROs were complete, data on children who sought treatment at an emergency department is less complete. EDIS and QISU do not encompass all emergency departments in Queensland. Hence, our estimation of non-fatal LSVRO events may be an under-estimate. Secondly, apart from QISU (an injury surveillance database), the databases accessed for this study are administrative databases. Therefore important data regarding circumstances leading to the event are not routinely or consistently recorded.

Conclusions

This is the most comprehensive, population-based epidemiological study on fatal and non-fatal LSVRO events to date. This study employed sophisticated methodology to ensure the most accurate ascertainment of LSVRO events possible, and resulted in estimation of age- and gender-specific incidence rates over an 11 year period. Results from this study indicate that LSVROs incur a substantial burden. The initial call for change is to unify consistent definitions between at least local databases, and to implement an ICD code that refers uniquely to this event. Further research is required to fully comprehend the risk factors associated with LSVRO incidents, and to inform appropriate intervention strategies. Specifically, information on culture, geographical location of incident, dwelling design, vehicle design, supervision prior to the event, family composition, etc., is required. This could be captured through mandatory reporting of these event types, however, this would need to be accompanied by some mechanism to ensure that sufficient data were collected consistently across the continuum of care. Optimally, a purpose-built, prospective data collection system would facilitate capture of this information. Utilizing additional injury and trauma databases to supplement data on admitted patients and children fatally injured would also further assist with the ascertainment of LSVRO incidents. Strategies are urgently required in order to prevent these events, especially among young children aged 0–4 years.

Authors’ information

Bronwyn Griffin: BNursing (PGDip ACNE), and PhD student with University of Queensland.

Kerrianne Watt: A/Professor Epidemiology and Public Health, James Cook University; PhD BSc (Hons).

Belinda A Wallis: BBuilt Env; Injury Prevention Research Officer with Centre for Children’s Burns and Trauma Research, Brisbane, Queensland, Australia.

Linda E Shields: MD, PhD, FACN, Professor of Nursing – Tropical Health, James Cook University, Townsville, Australia.

Roy M Kimble: MD, MBChB, FRCS, FRACS, Director of Paediatric Burns and Trauma Surgery, Royal Children’s and Mater Children’s Hospitals, Brisbane, Australia.

Abbreviations

ABS: 

Australian Bureau of Statistics

CCYPCG: 

Commission for Children, Young People, & Child Guardian

CDR: 

Child Death Review

ED: 

Emergency Department

EDIS: 

Emergency Department Information System

ICD: 

International Classification of Diseases

IR: 

Incidence Rate

LSVRO: 

Low Speed Vehicle Run Over

QAS: 

Queensland Ambulance Service

QCOPMM: 

Queensland Council on Obstetric and Paediatric Morbidity and Mortality

QHAPDC: 

Queensland Health Admitted Patients Data Collection

QISU: 

Queensland Injury Surveillance Unit.

Declarations

Acknowledgements

We thank Queensland Children’s Medical Research Institute for providing a motivating research environment, and our data custodians, QHAPDC, QAS, EDIS, QISU and CCYPCG, for their data extraction assistance.

Source of support

This study was funded by the Queensland Injury Prevention Council.

Financial disclosure

The authors have no financial disclosure relevant to this article to disclose.

Authors’ Affiliations

(1)
School of Medicine, The University of Queensland
(2)
Queensland Children’s Medical Research Institute, Level 4, Royal Children’s Hospital
(3)
School of Public Health, Tropical Medicine and Rehabilitation Sciences, James Cook University
(4)
School of Population Health, University of Queensland
(5)
Tropical Health Research Unit, James Cook University & Townsville Health Services District
(6)
Queensland University of Technology

References

  1. Roberts I, DiGuiseppi C, Ward H: Childhood injuries: extent of the problem, epidemiological trends, and costs. Inj Prev. 1998, 4 (Suppl 1): 10-16.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
  2. CCYPCG: Annual Report Deaths of Children and Young People. 2005, Brisbane, Australia: Commission for children and Young People and Child GuardianGoogle Scholar
  3. Ivers R, Clapham K, Senserrick T, Harrison J: Collecting measures of Indigenous status in driver licencing data. Aust Epidemiol. 2012, 19 (2): 9-10.Google Scholar
  4. Webster G, Daisley A, King N: Relationship and family breakdown following acquired brain injury: the role of the rehabilitation team. Brain Inj. 1999, 13 (8): 593-603. 10.1080/026990599121331.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  5. Kravitz H, Korach A: Deaths due to car driveway accidents. IMJ Ill Med J. 1964, 126: 688-PubMedGoogle Scholar
  6. Geographic Information Systems: ARIA and Accessibility. [cited 2013 29th May 2013]; Available from: http://www.adelaide.edu.au/apmrc/research/projects/category/aria.html
  7. Bell M, Ternberg J, Bower R: Low velocity vehicular injuries in children-“run-over” accidents. Pediatrics. 1980, 66 (4): 628-631.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  8. Tanz R, Christoffel K: Pedestrian injury. The next motor vehicle injury challenge. Am J Dis Child. 1985, 139 (12): 1187-1190. 10.1001/archpedi.1985.02140140021016.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  9. Williams A: Children killed in falls from motor vehicles. Pediatrics. 1981, 68 (4): 576-578.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  10. Winn D, Agran P, Castillo D: Pedestrian injuries to children younger than 5 years of age. Pediatrics. 1991, 88 (4): 776-782.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  11. Wright MS: Nonambulatory “pedestrians”: infants injured by motor vehicles in driveways. Clin Pediatr (Phila). 1998, 37 (8): 515-517. 10.1177/000992289803700810.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
  12. Agran P, Winn D, Anderson C: Differences in child pedestrian injury events by location. Pediatrics. 1994, 93 (2): 284-288.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  13. Agran P, Winn D, Anderson C, Tran C, Del Valle C: The role of the physical and traffic environment in child pedestrian injuries. Pediatrics. 1996, 98 (6 Pt 1): 1096-1103.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  14. Partrick D, Bensard D, Moore E, Partington M, Karrer F: Driveway crush injuries in young children: a highly lethal, devastating, and potentially preventable event. J Pediatr Surg. 1998, 33 (11): 1712-1715. 10.1016/S0022-3468(98)90616-9.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  15. Brison R, Wicklund K, Mueller B: Fatal pedestrian injuries to young children: a different pattern of injury. Am J Public Health. 1988, 78 (7): 793-795. 10.2105/AJPH.78.7.793.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
  16. Campbell-Hewson G, Egleston C, Cope A: Traumatic asphyxia in children. J Accid Emerg Med. 1997, 14 (1): 47-49. 10.1136/emj.14.1.47.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
  17. Cavalcanti A, Barros de Alencar C: Injuries to the head and face in 0–4 year old child victims of fatal external causes in Campina Grande, PB, Brazil. Turk J Pediatr. 2010, 52 (6): 612-617.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  18. Roberts I, Norton R, Jackson R: Driveway-related child pedestrian injuries: a case–control study. Pediatrics. 1995, 95 (3): 405-408.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  19. Roberts I, Kolbe A, White J: Non-traffic child pedestrian injuries. J Paediatr Child Health. 1993, 29 (3): 233-234. 10.1111/j.1440-1754.1993.tb00494.x.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  20. Shepherd M, Austin P, Chambers J: Driveway runover, the influence of the built environment: a case control study. J Paediatr Child Health. 2010, 10 (1111): 440-1754.Google Scholar
  21. Hsun-Hsiao K, Newbury C, Bartlett N, Dansey R, Morreau P, Hamill J: Paediatric driveway run-over injuries: time to redesign?. J N Z Med Assoc. 2009, 122 (1298): 17-24.Google Scholar
  22. Stevenson M: Childhood pedestrian injuries: what can changes to the road environment achieve?. Aust N Z J Public Health. 1997, 21 (1): 33-37. 10.1111/j.1467-842X.1997.tb01650.x.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  23. Robinson P, Nolan T: Paediatric slow-speed non-traffic fatalities: Victoria, Australia, 1985–1995. Accid Anal Prev. 1997, 29 (6): 731-737. 10.1016/S0001-4575(97)00042-0.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  24. Holland A, Liang R, Singh S, Schell D, Ross F, Cass D: Driveway motor vehicle injuries in children. Med J Aust. 2000, 173 (4): 192-195.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  25. Griffin B, Watt K, Wallis B, Shields L, Kimble R: Paediatric low speed vehicle run-over fatalities in Queensland. Inj Prev. 2011, 17 (Suppl I): i10-i13. 10.1136/ip.2010.030304.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  26. World Health Organization: Road Traffic Injuries. 2012, Media Centre, Fact sheet N°358: [Available from: http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs358/en/ Google Scholar
  27. Griffin B, Watt K, Wallis B, Shields L, Kimble R: Systematic literature review of incidence rates of low speed vehicle run over incidents in children. Worldviews Evid Based Nurs. 2013, in pressGoogle Scholar
  28. Griffin B, Wallis B, Shields L, Kimble R, Watt K: Characteristics of low speed vehicle run over events in children: an eleven year review. Inj Prev J. 2013, In PressGoogle Scholar
  29. Griffin B, Watt K, Shields L, Wallis B, Kimble R: Methodology of an 11 year retrospective cohort study on low speed vehicle run over incidents in Queensland. Aust Epidemiol Assoc J. 2013, 20 (1): 29-33.Google Scholar
  30. World Health Organisation: International classification of diseases, 9th revision. Clinical Modification: ICD-9-CM 1999. 1999, Sydney, Australia: WHO PressGoogle Scholar
  31. World Health Organisation: International Classification of Diseases, ICD-10-AM. 1998, Geneva: WHO-Press, 1Google Scholar
  32. World Health Organisation: International Classification of Diseases, ICD-10-AM. 2000, Geneva: WHO-Press, 2Google Scholar
  33. World Health Organisation: International Classification of Diseases, ICD-10-AM. 2002, Geneva: WHO-Press, 3 -6Google Scholar
  34. Bland J: An Introduction to Medical Statistics. 2000, Oxford University Press, ThirdGoogle Scholar
  35. Murphy F, White S, Morreau P: Driveway-related motor vehicle injuries in the paediatric population: a preventable tragedy. N Z Med J. 2002, 115 (1160): U148-PubMedGoogle Scholar
  36. Pinkney KA, Smith A, Mann NC, Mower GD, Davis A, Dean JM: Risk of pediatric back-over injuries in residential driveways by vehicle type. Pediatr Emerg Care. 2006, 22 (6): 402-407. 10.1097/01.pec.0000221337.29551.00.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  37. Shepherd M, Austin P, Chambers J: Driveway runover, the influence of the built environment: a case control study. J Paediatr Child Health. 2010, 46 (12): 760-767. 10.1111/j.1440-1754.2010.01835.x.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  38. Holland AJ, Ross FI, Manglick P, Fahy FE, Cass DT: Driveway motor vehicle injuries in children: a prospective review of injury circumstances. Med J Aust. 2006, 184 (6): 311-PubMedGoogle Scholar
  39. Kimber B, Dick T: Accident sparks call for 4WD cameras. The Sydney Morning Herald. 2005, New South WalesGoogle Scholar
  40. Tziotis M, Roper P, Edmonston C, Sheehan M: Road safety in rural and remote areas of Australia. 2006, Melbourne: Australian Road Research Board, EditorGoogle Scholar
  41. Silen M, Kokoska E, Fendya D, Kurkchubasche A, Weber T, Tracy T: Rollover injuries in residential driveways: age-related patterns of injury. Pediatrics. 1999, 104 (1): e7-10.1542/peds.104.1.e7.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  42. Pre-publication history

    1. The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/14/245/prepub

Copyright

© Griffin et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2014

This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly credited.