- Research article
- Open Access
An integrated individual, community, and structural intervention to reduce HIV/STI risks among female sex workers in China
BMC Public Health volume 13, Article number: 717 (2013)
We assessed the effectiveness of an integrated individual, community, and structural intervention to reduce risks of HIV and sexually transmitted infections (STIs) among female sex workers (FSWs).
The integration individual, community, and structural intervention was implemented from 2004 to 2009 in six counties of Shandong Province. Post-intervention cross-sectional surveys were conducted in six intervention counties and 10 control counties.
Of 3326 female sex workers were recruited and analyzed in the post-intervention survey with 1157 from intervention sites and 2169 from control sites. No HIV positive was found in both intervention and control counties. The rate of syphilis was 0.17% for intervention sites and 1.89% for control sites (OR = 11.1, 95% CI: 2.7, 46.1). After adjusted for age, marital status, education, economic condition, recruitment venues, the rates of condom use in the last sex with clients(AOR = 2.7; 95% CI: 1.9, 3.8), with regular sex partners(AOR = 1.5; 95% CI: 1.1, 1.9) and consistent condom use in the last month with clients (AOR = 3.3; 95% CI: 2.6, 4.1) and regular sex partners (AOR = 1.7; 95% CI: 1.3, 2.3) were significantly higher in intervention sites than that in control sites. The proportion of participants correctly answered at least six out of eight HIV-related questions (83.3%) in intervention sites is significant higher than that (21.9%) in control sites (AOR = 24.7; 95% CI: 2.5, 42.7), the five indicators related to HIV-related intervention services ever received in the last year including HIV testing(AOR = 4.9; 95% CI: 2.8, 6.7), STD examination and/or treatment(AOR = 5.1; 95% CI: 4.2, 6.4), free condom(AOR = 20.3; 95% CI: 14.3, 28.9), peer education(AOR = 4.3; 95% CI: 3.5, 5.4), education materials(AOR = 19.8; 95%CI: 13.1, 29.8) were significantly higher in intervention sites than that in control sites, the participants in the intervention sites are more likely to seek medical treatment when they had any disorders (AOR = 3.2; 95% CI: 2.5, 4.2).
This study found that the integrated individual, community, and structural intervention showed positive impact in reducing HIV and STI risks among FSWs.
Efforts in HIV risk reduction for female sex workers (FSWs) have often relied on not only individual- level interventions, e.g., condom promotion and sexually transmitted infection (STI) management [1–4], but also structural interventions to alter the social and physical environments in which individual behave [5, 6]. Two structural interventions have been applied in the context of sex work – community mobilization initiatives such as the “Sonagachi project” in India [7, 8] and government policy initiatives such as the Thai “100% condom program” [9, 10] – and program assessments of each have documented decreases in unprotected sex and prevalence of STI. Some countries have sought to adopt or adapt either the community mobilization [11, 12] or government policy approach [13, 14] to prevent HIV and STI among FSWs and their partners. The integrated interventions with both community mobilization and government policy demonstrated positive effects on HIV and STI risk reduction among FSWs . Structural factors, including political, legal, social, cultural, economic, and environmental factors, are known to affect individual risk and vulnerability to HIV, and to operate at several different societal levels (individual, interpersonal, community, culture and policy) [16, 17].
Sexually transmitted diseases (STDs) were nearly eliminated in China after the new government was established in 1950’ . Structural interventions played a critical role in the process, e.g., the establishment of infrastructure of health facilities in all workplace, training and dispersion of the “barefoot doctors”, elimination of prostitution, emancipation of women, full employment, education campaign, and expanded public health intervention for screening and treatment of syphilis and other STI [19, 20]. However, following the economic reforms which began in the 1980s, STDs reappeared and today constitute a major public health problem in China. This resurgence parallels the privatization of the economy, the breakdown of the national health insurance system, the return of prostitution, and other factors. The commercial sex was driven and reinforced following the growing economic disparities, population migration, increased disposable income, changing in sexual attitude, reestablishment and growth of sex trade [21–26], that fueled the resurgence of STDs in the nation . As the most populous country in the world, today China confronted with the huge challenges that HIV and STI pose. Injection drug use has been the predominant route of the transmission for HIV in the early stage of the epidemic [27, 28], however, two thirds of national estimated 78,000 HIV/AIDS cases in 2011 were infected through sexual transmission with a half through heterosexual contact . The experience of African countries has already indicated that when the heterosexual transmission became the main mode of HIV transmission, the epidemic grew rapidly. Hence, heterosexual transmission of HIV through unprotected contact with FSWs is of particular concern in China .
China initiated a series of intervention programs among high-risk populations in the 1990's, including providing standardized STI testing and treatment for FSWs during police crackdowns on prostitution . The Global Fund AIDS Program was implemented in certain areas in China in 2004, including six counties in Shandong Province. Along the east coast, Shandong is the second most populous provinces in China. The first HIV case in Shandong was identified in 1992; there were 3740 cumulative reported HIV/AIDS cases through the end of 2012. The proportion of heterosexual contact has been increasing in the newly reported HIV/AIDS cases in Shandong Province, nearly half in 2011 . Both HIV and syphilis prevalence rates in the general population in Shandong province remains at relatively low level. Data from the sentinel surveillance in Shandong showed that the HIV and syphilis prevalence among the general population was 0.03% and 0.20% respectively in 2011, but it increases rapidly among some specific groups in the recent years . With the support from the Global Fund AIDS Program, six intervention counties implemented an integrated individual, community, and structural intervention among FSWs from 2004 to 2009. This study applied post intervention cross-sectional surveys to investigate the impact of the integrated interventions among FSWs.
The integrated individual, community, structural intervention program among FSWs was implemented from 2004 to 2009 in six intervention counties (Xintai, Caoxian, Chengwu, Mudanqv, Pingdu, and Zhoucheng) supported by the China’s Global Fund AIDS program. The integrated individual level intervention, community mobilization and structural interventions included community solidarity and collective commitment, multisectoral government community partnership coordination, stigma and discrimination reduction at all settings, 100% condom promotion activities, outreach and peer education to promote risk and health-seeking behavior change, expand HIV testing and promote standardization of clinical STI services, monitoring and encouraging adherence, improvement of the access to high quality of HIV/AIDS treatment, care and support and secondary prevention services for people living with HIV [34, 35]. The selection of these six intervention sites were based on the number of HIV/AIDS case reporting among total 140 counties of Shandong. Xintai and Pingdu are developed sites economically and the rest four are less developed sites. Ten control counties were selected including four developed counties (Huaiyin, Longkou, Rushan, Zhiwu) and six less developed counties (Decheng, Dongming, Gaomi, Jvxian, Pingyin, Yanggu). The cut of value between economically developed and less developed counties was $2500 of average per capita income of its residents. The selection of control sites was to ensure that the background characteristics between intervention and control sites are similar in the baseline including the sociodemographics, economical development, and the status of HIV/STI epidemics. The six intervention sites hosted 7.2 million with 103 cases of HIV/AIDS reported through the year of 2004 compared with 10.9 million population and 32 diagnosed and reported cases of HIV/AIDS in the 10 control sites.
During the intervention period from 2004 to 2009, the integrated individual, community, structural intervention supported by the Global Fund AIDS Program was only implemented in the six intervention sites as described in the following “Intervention components”. The ten control sites and all other counties or cities across the province were provided the “standard of care”, the routine testing, prevention, care and treatment services for HIV and STI, but not the integrated individual, community, and structural intervention.
Leadership and governance, community solidarity and collective commitment
To support the effective implementation of the integrated individual, community, structural intervention program, the Global Fund AIDS Program committees were established and chaired by the senior government officials, and comprised the heads of all government development departments, including health, police, legislation, propaganda, education, finance, labor, commerce, civil, construction and engineering, broadcasting and TV, women’s union, family planning, academic institutions, transportation, nationality and religion. The role of the committees is to integrate HIV treatment, care, and prevention activities into all government programs. Each department has taken their share of the responsibilities in carrying out the intervention program. In the five years, the Global Fund AIDS Program at provincial and prefecture levels held project meetings, multisectoral coordination meetings, workshops, seminars 965 times. the target of these activities was primarily high-level decision and key policymakers and implementers including legislators, law enforcement personnel, medical professionals, government senior leaders, private sector and civil society leaders including PLHIV, Non-Government Organization (NGO), and Community-Based Organization (CBO) leaders. A total of 1394 projects formed multisectoral agreements were supported by The Global Fund AIDS Program, among which 682 were the government projects and 712 non-government projects. Multistakeholder policy advocacy and support groups (including people living with HIV (PLHIV), community members, and FSWs) were established to determine current priority issues and advocacy messages, and visit project sites in regular base to advocate for improved service delivery and policy implementation. NGOs including Workers’ Union, Youth Union, Red Cross, Science Association, Student Nutrition and Health Promotion Association, Grass Root Organizations, and Self Support Organizations were also mobilized to deliver the treatment, care, prevention services. The capacity of institutional and civil society in planning, management and prevention and care service delivery were strengthened through training, seminars, technical assistance. The government-community partnership was built through improving information and coordination, e.g., the establishment of community advisory boards, a quarterly coordination meeting, and regular information exchange. Quarterly workshops and monthly follow-up meetings were implemented with sex workers, establishment owners and managers, and other establishment employees. The purpose of these encounters was to encourage and strengthen a sense of solidarity and collective commitment toward HIV and STI prevention, care and antiretroviral treatment, and discussion included the role that each actor could play in supporting sex workers to use condoms with their partners. Educational materials were developed and distributed to reinforce responsibilities and benefits pertinent to each group. An additional focus of the workshops and materials was the role of trust and intimacy associated with condom use among sex workers and regular-paying and nonpaying partners.
Stigma and discrimination reduction at all settings
Activities including seminars, workshops and publications, and consultation, for stigma and discrimination reduction were organized among service providers, all settings including general public, the workplace. CBOs, NGOs and PLHIV helped to lead anti-stigma trainings for teachers, health care workers, security personnel, and a body of ‘open-source’ supporting materials were collected to be used in the scale-up of similar workshops. In addition, NGOs and CBOs from key partner, sex workers, and health professionals worked with relevant local government departments to advocate and provide training on reducing stigma and mainstreaming anti-discrimination policy and practices into relevant settings, including the health, public security and education sectors, and the private sector.
100% condom promotion activities
Multisectoral collaborative condom management, promotion and distribution were implemented systematically. To create an enabling environment for condom and other intervention activities in FSWs, coordination meetings were organized among local health departments, outreach NGOs, police, public security personnel, neighborhood authorities and owners/managers of establishments where FSWs work or gather; experience sharing for establishment owners/managers arranged with other counties where interventions have been successfully been implemented; advocacy for 100% condom use. Free condoms and water-based lubricants were provided to FSWs (particularly street-based FSWs) and other risk groups. Training workshops were held for FSWs on condom use and negotiation. Social marketing of condoms through shops and vending machines was also implemented. Condoms were made easily available through drugstores, small shops, supermarkets, vending machines and at places identified as hotspots for people at high risk, and at drop-in centers, VCT sites, STI clinics and other health facilities. Over three hundred thousand condoms were distributed in six intervention sites.
Outreach and peer education to promote risk and health-seeking behavior change
Activities for outreach and peer education included workshops, design/adaptation and pre-testing of materials, materials production and distribution, and evaluation of final products by members of target populations and through field testing. Training and supporting outreach workers and peer educators included: (1) training on outreach and outreach management; (2) training on peer education, (3) conducting outreach work and peer education, (4) local coordination meetings and exchange of experience; (5) revision and updating of the training manual and a variety of guidelines and documentation for used by outreach workers and peer educators, including topics, condom promotion and distribution, promotion of STI services, HIV testing and counseling, local service providers and referral information; 6) collection and reporting of program data. Outreach workers and peer educators included full-time and part-time personnel from NGOs/CBOs (including people from key FSWs), local Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), health centers and other relevant organizations. A comprehensive range of interventions, using traditional and innovative strategies for different settings, were implemented.
Expand HIV testing and promote standardization of clinical STI services
A total of 66 voluntary counseling and testing (VCT) sites were established in six intervention sites. Training for staff providing VCT was emphasized how to assess and refer people diagnosed with HIV to other services including antiretroviral treatment, and other care and prevention services. Over thirty thousand participants visited the VCT sites in the program counties. The program provided both HIV testing in VCT sites and designated health facilities under the adapted national technical guidelines, and referring HIV positive clients to local CDCs for follow-up. At the time the intervention began, FSWs were required to attend STI checks at government clinics, and health professionals were mandated to monitor their attendance. Our intervention activities provided clinicians and inspectors with training in the areas of basic HIV/AIDS information, communication skills, reproductive health education, health counseling, data collection and monitoring, and ethical procedures.
Monitoring and encouraging adherence
In the six intervention counties, establishment owners were notified of their status in terms of adherence to 5 study elements on a monthly basis: presence of posters, visible condoms, stocks of at least 100 condoms, attendance of sex workers, and lack of positive STI diagnoses among the establishment’s sex workers. These elements were evaluated each month by the inspectors. At the end of each month, establishments that were not adherent these elements were the focus of intensified educational efforts.
Increase access to high quality of HIV/AIDS treatment, care and support and secondary prevention services for PLHIV
Activities included (1) adapt and widely disseminate national technical guidelines and protocols on the provision of HIV/AIDS treatment, care and support to PLHIV at the local level; (2) provide training of health care providers, especially grassroots health workers, and including laboratory staff; (3) increase access to and improve quality of ART to PLWHIV in adherence to the adapted national guidelines; (4) provide regular monitoring to ART patients, including clinical and adherence monitoring; (5) train and support peer counselors to provide peer education and support for improving ART adherence; (6) identify, train and support local NGOs, CBOs and relevant government agencies to provide care and support to people living with and affected by HIV/AIDS in collaboration with local CDC and health facilities; (7) provide a continuum of care and support to people living with and affected by HIV/AIDS, including psychosocial support, positive prevention, nutritional support, poverty alleviation; and (8) provide regular clinical monitoring to people living with HIV who are not currently on treatment. There were 328 AIDS patients received ART treatment, 108 children influenced by HIV/AIDS got care and supported. There were a total of 1050 supported activities developed in the six intervention sites.
Recruitment and participants
Sociodemographic mapping was conducted with venue-based recruitment, community outreach and peer referral techniques to recruit the study participants. A detailed geographical map with roads, key streets, markets, shops, hotels, and bus depots was developed in each county. The numbers of FSWs in each establishment and street were numerated and/or estimated. All establishments and streets were listed and stratified within the sampling frame. Participants were recruited using a convenience sample strategy from randomly selected establishments or streets. A maximum of 25 participants were recruited from the large selected establishments; for smaller selected establishment with ≤15 FSWs. All potential participants in the selected sites were approached and invited for eligibility assessment. Recruitment criteria required that participants be female, willing to participate and complete the survey, and self-reported having had commercial sex in the past month. Verbal informed consent was obtained from all participants. Structured questionnaire-based interviews were conducted by trained experienced health professionals with assistance from trained FSW peers. Voluntary participation, anonymity and confidentiality were ensured for all participants. This study was approved by the Institutional Review Board of Shandong CDC.
Questionnaire-based interviews provided demographic information, sexual and drug use behavioral information, ever had HIV testing, HIV knowledge and received HIV-related services in the past year. HIV knowledge was assessed by 8 questions based on correctly identifying modes of HIV transmission and prevention as well as misperception. All questions were equally weighted. Responses to these questions were combined into an overall score for each correct and incorrect answer. These scores were then stratified into 2 groups, according to whether 6 or more appropriate responses were given to the 8 questions. The use of HIV-related prevention service was assessed by 5 indicators related to relevant prevention services received in the last 12 months (ever had a test for HIV, STD examination and/or treatment; or received free condoms, peer education, and HIV-related education materials). The survey instruments were used from the China National Comprehensive Surveillance Survey Guideline, recommended by a panel of national surveillance experts . Serospecimens were collected from all participants. Two screening tests using an enzyme-linked immunoassay (Beijing Jinhao Biologic Production Co. and Beijing Wantai Biological Medicine Company, Beijing, China) were performed to determine HIV serostatus. Syphilis was determined using rapid plasma reagin (RPR™) and a Passive Particle Agglutination Test for Detection of Antibodies to Treponema pallidum (TPPA™, Rong Sheng Biostix Inc, Shanghai, China). These methods were described elsewhere .
Questionnaire-based data were recorded and double-examined with EpiData software (EpiData 3.0 for Windows™, The EpiData Association Odense, Denmark). SPSS® software (Version 15.0; SPSS Inc., Chicago, Illinois, US) was utilized for all analyses. We used data validation tools available in SPSS to check for duplicate data entry. Chi-square test was applied for univariate analysis of variables of sociodemographic and behavioral characteristics, use of HIV-related intervention services, and HIV knowledge score. Multivariable logistic regression models were constructed using a stepwise backward sequence. Both adjusted odds ratios (AOR) and 95% confidence intervals (CI) were obtained for each explanatory variable in the final models. Variables with p < 0.05 in multivariable analysis were considered statistically significant.
Characteristics of participants
A total of 3326 FSWs were interviewed in the cross-sectional survey. Of the 3326 participants, 1157 came from the intervention sites and 2169 from control sites. The compositions of samples in intervention sites and control sites were not different by education, over 85% received middle school or higher education and only 12.3% received primary school or lower education in intervention and control sites. The compositions of samples were different by age, marital status, economic conditions and recruitment venues in intervention and control sites. The proportion of subjects aged above 25 years was 31.5% in intervention sites compared 34.2% in control sites; being single accounted for 69.3% in intervention sites compared 66.3% in control sites; 60.9% came from developed area in intervention sites and 54.0% in control sites, 36.5% recruited from clubs/KTV and 14.3% from non-venue based in intervention sites while the proportion were 55.0% and 7.0% in control sites, respectively.
HIV/syphilis prevalence and sexual/drug use behaviors
No participant was found HIV positive both sites of this study. Syphilis prevalence was 0.17% among the participants in intervention sites versus 1.89% in control sites. In intervention sites, 92.7% of the participants reported condom use in the last sex episode with clients versus 74.7% in control sites. The proportion of consistent condom use with clients in the last month among the participants is significantly higher in intervention sites (77.7%) and control sites (51.7%) (P < 0.001). The proportions of participants reported ever having regular sex partners among the participants were similar in intervention sites (41.8%) versus control sites (39.3%) (P > 0.05), but the condom use rate in the last sex (67.9%) and consistent use rate in the last month (37.6%) were significantly higher among the participants in the intervention sites than that (54.0%, last sex; 28.9%, consistent use) in the control sites (P < 0.001). There was 0.1% participants reported having ever used illicit drugs in intervention versus 0.8% in control sites (Table 1). Multiple logistic regression models suggested that the rates of condom use in the last episode with clients (AOR = 2.7; 95% CI: 1.9, 3.8), with regular sex partners (AOR = 1.5; 95% CI: 1.1, 1.9) and consistent condom use in the last month with clients (AOR = 3.3; 95% CI: 2.6, 4.1) and regular sex partners (1.7; 95% CI: 1.3, 2.3) were significantly higher in intervention sites than that in control sites (Table 2).
HIV-related knowledge and HIV-related service utilization
After adjusted for age, marital status, education, economic condition, recruitment venues, the proportion of participants correctly answered at least six out of eight HIV-related questions (83.3%) in intervention sites is significant higher than that (21.9%) in control sites (AOR = 24.7; 95% CI: 2.5, 42.7) (Tables 1 and 2), the five indicators related to HIV-related services ever received in the last year including HIV testing (AOR = 4.9; 95%CI: 2.8, 6.7), STD examination and/or treatment(AOR = 5.1; 95% CI: 4.2, 6.4), free condom (AOR = 20.3; 95% CI: 14.3, 28.9), peer education(AOR = 4.3; 95% CI: 3.5, 5.4), HIV-related education material (AOR = 19.8; 95%CI: 13.1, 29.8) were significantly higher in intervention sites than that in control sites (Table 2), the participants in the intervention sites are more likely to seek medical treatment when they had any disorders (AOR = 3.2; 95% CI: 2.5, 4.2).
HIV interventions focused on high risk groups, e.g., FSWs, have often targeted individual behavior, with impediments to success frequently including structural factors beyond the scope of the programs [17, 37, 38]. In this study, we have examined the integrated individual, community, structural intervention to HIV/STI prevention, which sought to change those context-specific political, social, legal, and environmental factors that known to affect HIV/STI risk and vulnerability [16, 17], as part of a large-scale Comprehensive AIDS Response, community-based HIV treatment, care, prevention program, in Shandong Province.
This program focused on addressing structural factors using multisectoral collaborative strategies, following individual level intervention and community mobilization of FSWs, worked in collaborative partnership with policy makers, multisectorial stakeholders and civil society (including CBOs/NGOs and FSWs themselves) to address structural barriers, stigma and discrimination facing the FSW community.
The findings of this study revealed the significant lower rate of syphilis, higher score of HIV knowledge, and the higher rates of condom use, HIV testing and the utilization of HIV prevention services in the intervention sites, compared to that in the control sites, which suggested the successes of the integrated individual, community and structural intervention. These findings are consistent with our previous findings  and which also support the finding of other studies in other Asian country that have showed significant increases in condom use, reductions in HIV and STI rates among FSWs [40–42].
The higher score of HIV knowledge among FSWs demonstrated in intervention sites is consistent with our previous study . Our previous study targeted FSWs in the same 6 sites from 2004 to 2008 showed the rate of correct answer of three HIV/AIDS transmission routes increased from 59.36% at baseline in 2004 to 97.21% in 2008, and increased from 32.76% in 2004 to 82.76% in 2008 for correct answer of non-transmission routes. The higher rate of condom use found in the intervention sites is also consistent with our previous report that the proportion of consistent condom use with clients in the last three months significantly increased from 38.75% at baseline in 2004 to 71.67% in 2009 . In addition, the overall low HIV prevalence indicated from surveillance system and lower syphilis prevalence in intervention sites compared to the control sites indicated the integrated individual level intervention, community mobilization and structural intervention prevention program with multi-sectoral cooperation and strong societal participation made the difference.
Although the progress was evidenced by the increase in condom use in intervention sites compared with control sites, the rates of condom use among FSWs are still low. Condom use has been proven to effectively prevention the transmission and control the epidemic among FSWs, but the coverage of condom is the key [27, 43–47]. The Asian Epidemic Model predicts that a high rate of condom use (>85%) among FSWs is required to control the HIV epidemic [27, 43, 46]. Data also showed high levels of condom use among FSWs and their clients in countries such as Benin, Thailand and Cambodia are likely to have slowed the epidemic [10, 48]. Shandong with 140 counties is the second most populous province in China. The study indicated that the progress on HIV/STD intervention has been made uneven among counties across the province and within counties. This study also showed two-thirds of them had not previously tested for HIV. The relative low condom use and utilization of HIV-related prevention services in both intervention and control sites highlighted the needs of continued effort in scaling up the care, treatment and prevention activities.
Commercial sex in China is illegal. FSWs are often blamed for the breakdown of the traditional family, epidemics of STIs and HIV/AIDS, and escalating crime [22, 24]. Therefore, stigma and discrimination and other potential barriers might have prevented FSWs seeking VCT or other HIV prevention and care services for fear of discrimination, fear of disclosure of commercial sex activities, low of confidentiality [24, 49], and fear of the punishment of the illegal commercial sex. Study also showed stigma and discrimination, site atmosphere, links with other services, quality of the staff, and convenience were important factors for FSWs actively receiving HIV testing and HIV-related services [50, 51]. Hence, the stigma and discrimination reduction effort with multi-sectoral cooperation and strong societal participation, years of efforts of intervention service promotion, well trained health professionals, peer education, condom distribution and promotion, should be a critical part of the large scale Comprehensive AIDS Response program to contain STIs and HIV/AIDS epidemic among FSWs.
Trainings on discrimination and stigma have been a part of China’s response to HIV for many years, but there remains a high degree of ignorance, misinformation and stigma surrounding the virus . This is slowly changing, and a growing number of PLHIV are now willing, given the proper support, to reveal their status. It is therefore now possible to adjust the strategy and adopt a new method: engaging HIV infected individuals and encouraging them to participate in all aspects of anti-stigma campaigns. The fundamental logic behind this activity is that PLHIV involvement in anti-stigma activities can greatly improve their effectiveness . The stigmatization of HIV-infected people and many of the sub-populations who are most vulnerable to infection, and the discrimination that results from it, act as constraints on the delivery of prevention and health care services and damage the lives of those infected with or affected by HIV/AIDS. A high degree of stigma also helps to keep people ignorant about the disease, which increases their own risk of becoming infected. Tackling discrimination and stigma was therefore an integral part of this integrated intervention. Efforts were informed by international best practices related to reducing stigma and discrimination and advocacy for the rights of PLHIV and other key affected populations. By reducing stigma and discrimination in all settings and particularly in health care settings, it is expected that more of the people who are infected or are most at risk of infection will be encouraged to access prevention services, treatment, care and support. Although no data were collected in evaluating the changes of stigma and discriminatory practices and attitudes, the efforts in reducing stigma and discrimination likely affected the behavior change towards eliminating attitudes and practices that act as barriers to ensuring the rights of PLHIV and key affected populations and their access to services and entitlements. The higher rates of HIV testing and the utilization of HIV prevention services in intervention sites, compared to the control sites, which may reflect certain success of stigma and discrimination reduction effort.
The effective method of promoting multisectoral participation in HIV/AIDS prevention, care and treatment is to ensure that each sector has its own responsibilities, in line with its respective strengths and comparative advantages, under an agreed HIV/AIDS action framework. The involvement of community such as CBOs, grassroots NGOs and organizations representing PLHIV and FSWs, is encouraged by the Global Fund AIDS Program, has played a consistently important role in increasing capacity building and technical support to civil society. Effective multisectorial cooperation and improved community participation in the six intervention sites ensured the successful implementation of the community-based HIV treatment, care and prevention program.
Strengths of this study include its estimation of the size of the targeted population and mapping strategy. Efforts on investigating the venue and preliminary estimates in each establishment strengthen the mapping strategy and targeted population size estimation to reduce selection bias. Our study subjects may represent a wider spectrum of FSWs in Shandong. The socio-demographic and behavioral factors identified in our study are informative, giving us a stronger grasp of Shandong’s current HIV epidemic and risk behavior and the use of prevention services among FSWs. We also recognized the limitations of this study. Selection bias existed in this study. Non-response information was not collected. The questionnaire data relying on retrospective self-reports was subject to recall bias. Sensitivity of sexually-related questions could lead to reporting bias. The cross-sectional research design precludes identification of causal relationships. No baseline survey conducted among control sites could be another limitation of the study. This study also served as a behavior surveillance survey, which was conducted with careful planning, implementation, and quality control. In spite of these limitations, we believe that this study provide invaluable information to guide the ongoing comprehensive community-based treatment, care, prevention intervention program among this group.
In summary, the results of the study indicated that significant progress has been made in the intervention sites compared with control sites among FSWs. This study demonstrated that the integrated individual, community, and structural intervention have positive impact in reducing HIV and STI risks among FSWs. The findings highlighted the needs of effective multisectoral cooperation with broad community participation in implementing the comprehensive community based HIV treatment, care and prevention program. Structural factors including stigma and discrimination are critical concerns among this FSW population and needed to be addressed to enable vulnerable women to adopt the safer sexual behaviors that are required to respond the HIV/STI epidemic.
Female commercial sex workers
Human immunodeficiency virus
Sexual transmitted infection
Sexual transmitted disease
People living with HIV
Community based organization
Voluntary counseling and testing
Center for disease control and prevention
Acquired immunodeficiency syndrome
Adjusted odds ratio.
Laga M, Alary M, Nzila N, Manoka AT, Tuliza M, Behets F, et al: Condom promotion, sexually transmitted diseases treatment, and declining incidence of HIV-1 infection in female Zairian sex workers. Lancet. 1994, 344 (8917): 246-248. 10.1016/S0140-6736(94)93005-8.
Bhave G, Lindan CP, Hudes ES, Desai S, Wagle U, Tripathi SP, et al: Impact of an intervention on HIV, sexually transmitted diseases, and condom use among sex workers in Bombay, India. AIDS (London, England). 1995, 9 (Suppl 1): S21-S30.
Ngugi EN, Wilson D, Sebstad J, Plummer FA, Moses S: Focused peer-mediated educational programs among female sex workers to reduce sexually transmitted disease and human immunodeficiency virus transmission in Kenya and Zimbabwe. J Infect Dis. 1996, 174 (Suppl 2): S240-S247.
Ford K, Wirawan DN, Fajans P, Meliawan P, MacDonald K, Thorpe L: Behavioral interventions for reduction of sexually transmitted disease/HIV transmission among female commercial sex workers and clients in Bali, Indonesia. AIDS (London, England). 1996, 10 (2): 213-222. 10.1097/00002030-199602000-00013.
Sweat MD, Denison JA: Reducing HIV incidence in developing countries with structural and environmental interventions. AIDS (London, England). 1995, 9 (Suppl A): S251-S257.
Sumartojo E: Structural factors in HIV prevention: concepts, examples, and implications for research. AIDS (London, England). 2000, 14 (Suppl 1): S3-S10.
Jana S, Bandyopadhyay N, Mukherjee S, Dutta N, Basu I, Saha A: STD/HIV intervention with sex workers in West Bengal, India. AIDS (London, England). 1998, 12 (Suppl B): S101-S108.
Jana S, Singh S: Beyond medical model of STD intervention--lessons from Sonagachi. Indian J Public Health. 1995, 39 (3): 125-131.
Hanenberg RS, Rojanapithayakorn W, Kunasol P, Sokal DC: Impact of Thailand’s HIV-control programme as indicated by the decline of sexually transmitted diseases. Lancet. 1994, 344 (8917): 243-245. 10.1016/S0140-6736(94)93004-X.
Rojanapithayakorn W, Hanenberg R: The 100% condom program in Thailand. AIDS (London, England). 1996, 10 (1): 1-7. 10.1097/00002030-199601000-00001.
Williams E, Lamson N, Efem S, Weir S, Lamptey P: Implementation of an AIDS prevention program among prostitutes in the Cross River State of Nigeria. AIDS (London, England). 1992, 6 (2): 229-230. 10.1097/00002030-199202000-00016.
Williams EE: Women of courage: commercial sex workers mobilize for HIV/AIDS prevention in Nigeria. Aidscaptions. 1994, 1 (2): 19-22.
Morisky DE, Pena M, Tiglao TV, Liu KY: The impact of the work environment on condom use among female bar workers in the Philippines. Health Educ Behav. 2002, 29 (4): 461-472. 10.1177/109019810202900406.
Morisky DE, Tiglao TV, Sneed CD, Tempongko SB, Baltazar JC, Detels R, et al: The effects of establishment practices, knowledge and attitudes on condom use among Filipina sex workers. AIDS care. 1998, 10 (2): 213-220. 10.1080/09540129850124460.
Kerrigan D, Moreno L, Rosario S, Gomez B, Jerez H, Barrington C, et al: Environmental-structural interventions to reduce HIV/STI risk among female sex workers in the Dominican Republic. Am J Public Health. 2006, 96 (1): 120-125. 10.2105/AJPH.2004.042200.
Gupta GR, Parkhurst JO, Ogden JA, Aggleton P, Mahal A: Structural approaches to HIV prevention. Lancet. 2008, 372 (9640): 764-775. 10.1016/S0140-6736(08)60887-9.
Gurnani V, Beattie TS, Bhattacharjee P, Mohan HL, Maddur S, Washington R, et al: An integrated structural intervention to reduce vulnerability to HIV and sexually transmitted infections among female sex workers in Karnataka state, South India. BMC Public Health. 2011, 11: 755-10.1186/1471-2458-11-755.
Cohen MS, Henderson GE, Aiello P, Zheng H: Successful eradication of sexually transmitted diseases in the People’s Republic of China: implications for the 21st century. J Infect Dis. 1996, 174 (Suppl 2): S223-S229.
Chen XS, Gong XD, Liang GJ, Zhang GC: Epidemiologic trends of sexually transmitted diseases in China. Sex Transm Dis. 2000, 27 (3): 138-142. 10.1097/00007435-200003000-00003.
Abrams HK: The resurgence of sexually transmitted disease in China. J Public Health Policy. 2001, 22 (4): 429-440. 10.2307/3343160.
Kang D, Liao M, Jiang Z, Zhang X, Mao W, Zhang N, et al: Commercial sex venues, syphilis and methamphetamine use among female sex workers. AIDS Care. 2011, 23 (Suppl 1): 26-36.
Chen ZQ, Zhang GC, Gong XD, Lin C, Gao X, Liang GJ, et al: Syphilis in China: results of a national surveillance programme. Lancet. 2007, 369 (9556): 132-138. 10.1016/S0140-6736(07)60074-9.
Chen XS, Yin YP, Liang GJ, Gong XD, Li HS, Poumerol G, et al: Sexually transmitted infections among female sex workers in Yunnan, China. AIDS Patient Care STDS. 2005, 19 (12): 853-860. 10.1089/apc.2005.19.853.
Liao M, Jiang Z, Zhang X, Kang D, Bi Z, Liu X, et al: Syphilis and methamphetamine use among female sex workers in Shandong Province, China. Sex Transm Dis. 2011, 38 (1): 57-62. 10.1097/OLQ.0b013e3181ebb475.
Lu F, Jia Y, Sun X, Wang L, Liu W, Xiao Y, et al: Prevalence of HIV infection and predictors for syphilis infection among female sex workers in Southern China. Southeast Asian J Trop Med Public Health. 2009, 40 (2): 263-272.
Lu F, Jia Y, Bin S, Li C, Limei S, Kristensen S, et al: Predictors for casual sex and/or infection among sexually transmitted disease clinic attendees in China. Int J STD AIDS. 2009, 20 (4): 241-248. 10.1258/ijsa.2008.008290.
Liu L, Luan R, Yang W, Zhang L, Zhang J, Nan L, et al: Projecting dynamic trends for HIV/AIDS in a highly endemic area of China: estimation models for Liangshan Prefecture, Sichuan Province. Curr HIV Res. 2009, 7 (4): 390-397. 10.2174/157016209788680642.
Jia Y, Sun J, Fan L, Song D, Tian S, Yang Y, et al: Estimates of HIV prevalence in a highly endemic area of China: Dehong Prefecture, Yunnan Province. Int J Epidemiol. 2008, 37 (6): 1287-1296. 10.1093/ije/dyn196.
Ministry of Health and Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS: 2011 Estimates for the HIV/AIDS Epidemic in China. 2012
Scorgie F, Chersich MF, Ntaganira I, Gerbase A, Lule F, Lo YR: Socio-demographic characteristics and behavioral risk factors of female sex workers in sub-saharan Africa: a systematic review. AIDS Behav. 2012, 16 (4): 920-933. 10.1007/s10461-011-9985-z.
The State Council AIDS Working Committee Office and the UN Theme Group on HIV/AIDS in China: A joint assessment of HIV/AIDS prevention, treatment and care in China. 2007
Shandong Provincial CDC: Comprehensive report on HIV/AIDS in Shandong Province 2011. 2012, Jinan: Shandong Provincial CDC
Shandong CDC: Shandong provincial behavioral and biological surveillance report 2011. 2012, Beijing: Shandong Center for AIDS/STD Control and Prevention, Shandong CDC
China CDC: Shandong Provincial Global Fund program plan 2004. 2004, Jinan: Shandong Center for Disease Control and Prevention
China CDC: National Global Fund Program Plan 2004. 2004, Beijing: National Center for AIDS/STD Control and Prevention, China CDC
China CDC: National guidelines for comprehensive surveillance of HIV/AIDS. National Center for AIDS/STD Control and Prevention. Edited by: China CDC. 2008
Shahmanesh M, Patel V, Mabey D, Cowan F: Effectiveness of interventions for the prevention of HIV and other sexually transmitted infections in female sex workers in resource poor setting: a systematic review. Trop Med Int Health. 2008, 13 (5): 659-679. 10.1111/j.1365-3156.2008.02040.x.
Foss AM, Hossain M, Vickerman PT, Watts CH: A systematic review of published evidence on intervention impact on condom use in sub-Saharan Africa and Asia. Sex Transm Infect. 2007, 83 (7): 510-516. 10.1136/sti.2007.027144.
Li JZ, Kang DM, Tao XY, Zheng W, Zhang N, Zhu XY, et al: Evaluation on effectiveness of behavior intervention among female sexual workers in some part of Shandong Province from 2004 to 2008. Prev Med Trib. 2010, 16: 193-195.
Ramesh BM, Beattie TS, Shajy I, Washington R, Jagannathan L, Reza-Paul S, et al: Changes in risk behaviours and prevalence of sexually transmitted infections following HIV preventive interventions among female sex workers in five districts in Karnataka state, south India. Sex Transm Infect. 2010, 86 (Suppl 1): i17-i24. 10.1136/sti.2009.038513.
Reza-Paul S, Beattie T, Syed HU, Venukumar KT, Venugopal MS, Fathima MP, et al: Declines in risk behaviour and sexually transmitted infection prevalence following a community-led HIV preventive intervention among female sex workers in Mysore, India. AIDS. 2008, 22 (Suppl 5): S91-S100. 10.1097/01.aids.0000343767.08197.18.
Moses S, Ramesh B, Isac S, Reza-Paul S, Alary M, Bradley J, et al: Increased condom use and decreased HIV and STI prevalence among female sex workers following a targeted HIV prevention program in Karnataka, South India. In 19th Biennial Conference Of The International Society For Sexually Transmitted Diseases Research. Volume 87. 2011, Sexually Transmitted Infections.: Quebec City
Cohen J: The Asian epidemic model’s provocative curves. Science. 2004, 304 (5679): 1934-10.1126/science.304.5679.1934.
Fang C, Chang Y, Wang J: Higher-than-85% condom use rate in persons with multiple sexual partners is required to control HIV. Sex Transm Infect [serial on the Internet]. 2005, Available from: http://sti.bmj.com/content/80/suppl_1/i19/reply
Fang CT, Hsu HM, Twu SJ, Chen MY, Chang YY, Hwang JS, et al: Decreased HIV transmission after a policy of providing free access to highly active antiretroviral therapy in Taiwan. J Infect Dis. 2004, 190 (5): 879-885. 10.1086/422601.
Brown T, Peerapatanapokin W: The Asian epidemic model: a process model for exploring HIV policy and programme alternatives in Asia. Sex Transm Infect. 2004, 80 (Suppl 1): i19-i24.
Rou K, Wu Z, Sullivan SG, Li F, Guan J, Xu C, et al: A five-city trial of a behavioural intervention to reduce sexually transmitted disease/HIV risk among sex workers in China. AIDS (London, England). 2007, 21 (Suppl 8): S95-S101. 10.1097/01.aids.0000304703.77755.c7.
Morison L, Weiss HA, Buve A, Carael M, Abega SC, Kaona F, et al: Commercial sex and the spread of HIV in four cities in sub-Saharan Africa. AIDS (London, England). 2001, 15 (Suppl 4): S61-S69.
Chapman J, Estcourt CS, Hua Z: Saving ‘face’ and ‘othering’: getting to the root of barriers to condom use among Chinese female sex workers. Sex Health. 2008, 5 (3): 291-298. 10.1071/SH07057.
Wu Z, Sun X, Sullivan SG, Detels R: Public health. HIV testing in China. Science. 2006, 312 (5779): 1475-1476. 10.1126/science.1120682.
Merson MH, Dayton JM, O’Reilly K: Effectiveness of HIV prevention interventions in developing countries. AIDS (London, England). 2000, 14 (Suppl 2): S68-S84.
China CDC: China CARES (China Comprehensive Aids RESponse) – A Community-Based HIV Treatment, Care and Prevention Program in Central China. 2005
The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/13/717/prepub
This research was funded by China’s Global Fund AIDS program (NO: GF-CHN-SHANDONG-AIDS-R3-05). The authors would like to thank team members from Xintai, Caoxian, Chengwu, Mudanqv, Pingdu, Chuocheng, Huaiyin, Longkou, Rushan, Zhiwu, Decheng, Dongming, Gaomi, Jvxian, Pingyin, Yanggu county CDC for their contributions to design, implementation of the surveys. Special thanks to all subjects for their voluntary participation, and the owners of venues, mommies for their support in the preparation and implementation of the surveys.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
DK, XT, ML, and YJ contributed to the study design and literature searches and drafted the manuscript. ML, JL, XZ and NZ performed all the statistical analyses. SS, BL, and XS supervised laboratory test. DK and XT helped to draft the manuscript and critically reviewed the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final version of the manuscript.
About this article
Cite this article
Kang, D., Tao, X., Liao, M. et al. An integrated individual, community, and structural intervention to reduce HIV/STI risks among female sex workers in China. BMC Public Health 13, 717 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2458-13-717
- Female sex workers
- Condom use
- Intervention counties