- Research article
- Open Access
Analyzing the spatio-temporal relationship between dengue vector larval density and land-use using factor analysis and spatial ring mapping
BMC Public Health volume 12, Article number: 853 (2012)
Dengue, a mosquito-borne febrile viral disease, is found in tropical and sub-tropical regions and is now extending its range to temperate regions. The spread of the dengue viruses mainly depends on vector population (Aedes aegypti and Aedes albopictus), which is influenced by changing climatic conditions and various land-use/land-cover types. Spatial display of the relationship between dengue vector density and land-cover types is required to describe a near-future viral outbreak scenario. This study is aimed at exploring how land-cover types are linked to the behavior of dengue-transmitting mosquitoes.
Surveys were conducted in 92 villages of Phitsanulok Province Thailand. The sampling was conducted on three separate occasions in the months of March, May and July. Dengue indices, i.e. container index (C.I.), house index (H.I.) and Breteau index (B.I.) were used to map habitats conducible to dengue vector growth. Spatial epidemiological analysis using Bivariate Pearson’s correlation was conducted to evaluate the level of interdependence between larval density and land-use types. Factor analysis using principal component analysis (PCA) with varimax rotation was performed to ascertain the variance among land-use types. Furthermore, spatial ring method was used as to visualize spatially referenced, multivariate and temporal data in single information graphic.
Results of dengue indices showed that the settlements around gasoline stations/workshops, in the vicinity of marsh/swamp and rice paddy appeared to be favorable habitat for dengue vector propagation at highly significant and positive correlation (p = 0.001) in the month of May. Settlements around the institutional areas were highly significant and positively correlated (p = 0.01) with H.I. in the month of March. Moreover, dengue indices in the month of March showed a significant and positive correlation (p <= 0.05) with deciduous forest. The H.I. of people living around horticulture land were significantly and positively correlated (p = 0.05) during the month of May, and perennial vegetation showed a highly significant and positive correlation (p = 0.001) in the month of March with C.I. and significant and positive correlation (p <= 0.05) with B.I., respectively.
The study concluded that gasoline stations/workshops, rice paddy, marsh/swamp and deciduous forests played highly significant role in dengue vector growth. Thus, the spatio-temporal relationships of dengue vector larval density and land-use types may help to predict favorable dengue habitat, and thereby enables public healthcare managers to take precautionary measures to prevent impending dengue outbreak.
Dengue is a vector-borne disease, estimated to affect millions of individuals each year in tropical and subtropical areas, and it is reemerging in areas that have been disease-free for relatively long periods of time. This expansion is creating new opportunities for viruses to propagate in new areas and is acting as a common cause of epidemics in what were Aedes (Ae.) free countries , and is associated with numerous problems at local and global scales. Dengue is endemic in tropical and subtropical regions as the viruses that cause it are transmitted through the bite of an already infected mosquito. Epidemics of this mosquito-borne illness are rising worldwide due to increased international travel and unplanned urbanization combined with lack of effective mosquito control measures in tropical developing countries . In recent years, transmission of these viruses has increased predominantly in urban and semi-urban areas, and is a major international public health concern owing to its hold over approximately half of the world’s population. According to estimates by the World Health Organization (WHO), there could be as many as 50 to 100 million dengue infections worldwide each year . In the absence of an effective drug or vaccine, the only strategic options to control dengue are case management to prevent death and control of vectors to reduce viral transmission . The appearance of numerous infectious diseases is strongly facilitated by environmental factors, such as climate or land-use change . The spatial distribution of vector-borne diseases are typically determined by the geographical extent of the vector or reservoir hosts and their habitat priorities . During immature stages, vector species differ in their priorities for habitat. Therefore, change in land-use permits the colonization of new habitats as well as the expansion or reduction of the range of the vector. This may also modify the composition of the mosquito vector community . Agriculture is the largest driver for land-use change across the earth. Croplands and pastures together have become one of the largest terrestrial biomes on the planet, rivaling forest, and cover in extent of 40% of the land surface area [8, 9]. Land-use/land-cover patterns and socio-cultural practices have a strong relation with dengue incidence . Vegetation and land-cover characteristics can influence the risk of contracting dengue as they modify mosquito population. Land-use change is a major constituent of global environmental change that can potentially affect human health in relation to mosquito-borne diseases by influencing the mosquito’s habitat. The distribution and abundance of vectors concomitantly mediates human-mosquito interactions including biting rate .
Vector population estimates have been carried out by many researchers using dengue indices, i.e. house index (H.I.), container index (C.I.) and Breteau index (B.I.), as indicators that can be adopted to compare their individual relationships with each of the habitat parameters [4, 12]. The relationship between number of dengue virus infections (cases) and climatic factors has been reported by many researchers using several indices, and it has been concluded that climatic conditions have a strong influence on dengue infection [13–15]. However, drawbacks associated with the use of dengue case data include the occurrence of asymptomatic infections which cannot be used to support a real-time indication of a forthcoming disease scenario, as can be predicted using larval density data . The dengue vector species mainly contributing to dengue outbreak include Ae. aegypti (L) and Ae. albopictus (L) . Of both species, female mosquito mostly likes to feed on human blood, whereas male mosquito prefers nectar feeding . The former does not fly far and the majority of the population remains within a 200 meter distance from the site of their emergence . However, this type of mosquito uses a wide range of confined larval habitats, both natural and man-made. On the other hand, larvae of the later species have been found not only in natural containers, i.e. tree holes, plant axils, cut bamboo stumps and opened coconuts, but also in outdoor artificial containers, i.e. rubber tyres, water storage barrels, glass and plastic bottles, and jars located up to one-kilometer diameter [15, 18].
Spatial epidemiology is the study of spatial variation in disease risk or incidence. Several ecological processes can result in strong spatial patterns of such risk or incidence, e.g. pathogen dispersal might be highly localized, vectors or reservoirs for pathogens might be spatially restricted, or susceptible hosts might be clumped . In addition to the reported relationship between climatic conditions and dengue infection [13, 15], understanding the contribution of land-use type to dengue vector breeding ability is directly required to unveil the underlying scenario comprehensively. A few previous studies have emphasized the analysis of land-use and land-cover types due to their relevance with mosquito breeding habitat and people’s living style. It was pointed out by many researchers that the land-cover can be an important risk determinant for dengue infection [20, 21], therefore it demands a comprehensive analysis of surrounding landscape and its possible relationship with the dynamics of mosquito population for subsequent dengue incidence.
The present study was conducted to predict the suitable potential habitat for dengue-transmitting mosquitoes, integrating dengue indices and land-use types using spatial epidemiology and statistical approaches. Moreover, the extent to which land-use types influence dengue-transmitting mosquito growth was also investigated.
Phitsanulok is a province of Thailand, located in its lower northern region (16.78 N, 100.20 E), 377 km from Bangkok (Figure 1). The province has a population density of 77.99 (people km-2) and has nine amphoes (districts), ninety-three tambons (sub-districts) and more than one thousand muban (villages) . Villages are considered the smallest unit under Thailand’s public health system. The study area has diverse land-use and land-cover types, e.g. urban, field crops, orchards, mountains, river, waterfalls, swamps, forests, grasslands, caves, reservoirs and an extensive network of canals. The major land-use classes in the study area are urban and crop land, as most people have adopted farming as an occupation. A major outbreak of dengue was witnessed during 2008 when 1385 patients were admitted to hospitals (Figure 2). It was declared the worst outbreak in the history of Phitsanulok Province. The outburst prompted Phitsanulok’s government agencies to study the behavior and pattern of the disease, and also to ascertain possible causes contributing to favorable habitats for its spread. This was done in order to cope with and prevent future outbreaks of such magnitude at the national level, considering Phitsanulok Province on a priority basis.
The climate of the province is hot tropical with an annual rainfall of approximately 1800 mm. However, at higher altitudes the weather is cool with a maximum temperature of around 25.0°C and at lower altitudes it is around 33.0°C. During the study period (2009), the mean temperature, humidity and rainfall recorded were 28.0°C, 75.0% and 112.0 mm, respectively (Figure 3).
The province has good numbers of registered medical treatment units, i.e. 145 health centers and 270 clinics, for its residents . Still there are constant health issues faced by the citizens in the province, with a dramatic increase in the rate of annual in-patients suffering from various kinds of diseases. Dengue fever (D.F.) and dengue hemorrhagic fever (D.H.F.) are among the top five leading diseases in the province.
Data of dengue-transmitting mosquitoes, i.e. house index (H.I.), container index (C.I.) and Breteau index (B.I.), were collected according to WHO standards by the Ministry of Public Health (MOPH), Division-9th, Phitsanulok, Thailand for the year 2009.
Dengue indices were calculated using the following formulas:
Information about land-use and land-cover was obtained from the Land Development Office, Phitsanulok. Data for the administrative boundaries was acquired from the Royal Thai Survey Department of Thailand.
Data sampling and conversion to GIS
Dengue indices were observed by trained staff of the Ministry of Public Health (MOPH) in Phitsanulok during the study period. They were well-trained in mosquito species identification and sampling methods. Samples were collected from 92 villages, where dengue cases were reported, and in 2009 sampling were done on three separate occasions in the months of March, May and July. On average 78 houses per village were randomly sampled. Covered indoor and outdoor areas of the selected premises, containing water, also sampled. The different lifestyles of the people and diversity of the surrounding environment were also considered. Out of 92 sampled villages, in 11 villages a total of 29 houses were found locked during revisits; where houses were locked adjacent house was sampled instead, as the neighboring house had almost similar structure and surrounding environment, i.e. land-cover types. Large stagnant ponds, running water and open areas, such as parks and playgrounds were ignored because Aedes mosquitoes do not prefer open areas [20, 23]. Generally, the peak season for dengue breeding in the study area ranges from April to June and the level of rainfall in the months of April, May and June has a positive effect on dengue larvae; whereas, after July, heavy rains usually start and flush away eggs, larvae and pupae of the dengue vector . May was explored as it was considered to be the peak of the dengue breeding season. Sampled villages were marked with GPS and all the point data was converted into shape files and shifted to GIS layers for spatial epidemiological analysis. Inverse Distance Weighted (IDW) interpolation was performed to indicate the overall situation of C.I. (Figure 4), H.I. (Figure 5) and B.I. (Figure 6) in the study area. ArcGIS 10 ArcMap software was used for GIS analysis, which provides powerful functionality for GIS data and is usually used and recommended by public health professionals .
Spatial and statistical analysis
Locations sampled were overlaid on a detailed land-cover map to examine the geographically related environmental conditions around villages having different ranges of B.I. Land-cover for 1860 classes was merged into 171 classes following Land Development Department Thailand rules of classification codes, based on similar class structures. The resultant classes were further contracted to 27 classes representing all types of major and mixed classes, as reported in the literature about the relationship of dengue with land-use type [7, 11, 15] (Figure 7). Successive contractions of land-cover classes were carried out to reduce the redundancy of similar patterns to clearly determine the comprehensive phenomena of vector-borne disease (dengue). Considering the maximum mosquito flight range during its life span around the village, a buffering operation of one-kilometer was performed using GIS software for the 92 villages . This helped to indicate the environmental conditions around the observed locations, i.e. type of trees, crops, fruits and built-up areas, together with all the other factors that play a role in increasing or decreasing dengue indices values. Bivariate Pearson’s correlation analysis was conducted to find out the relationship between mosquito density-related indices and land-use/land-cover classes, which were investigated to explore factors potentially contributing to favorable habitats that facilitate the life-cycle development of dengue-transmitting mosquitoes.
Factor analysis, using principal component analysis (PCA) with the varimax rotation method, was performed to explain variance among the land-cover classes to understand the habitat ecology. The factors were analyzed to determine the unique dimensions existing in the data. Prior to conducting the factor analysis procedure, cleaning of data was done, i.e. removal of outlier, verification of data with raw data. Rotation in factor analysis produced results in a more interpretable form and helped to scrutinize the land-cover classes based on their contribution to dengue indices, i.e. B.I., C.I., and H.I. values, either individually or when associated with one or more land-cover classes. Factor analysis is often used to generate hypotheses regarding causal mechanisms and to screen variables for subsequent analysis [25, 26].
The factor score is a linear combination of observed variables weighted by eigenvectors. Generation of factor scores is a transformation of observed variables (c1 = β 11x1 + β 12x2 +....... + β 1p x p ). Where c1 is the score of the first component, β 1p is coefficient of regression for observed variable, i.e. its weight and x p is observed variable p. The higher weight of the score attached with observed variable (land-use type) represents the higher correlation with independent variable (dengue index). For example, in case of deciduous forest positive loads are given below in equation extracted using rotated component matrix.
Where, x1, x2, x3 and x4 are land types, and from all these land type x2 has high loading and x4 has less loading. Land-use type x2 determines more of variance compared to other land-use types.
The factor model is given as:
Where, Y is a matrix of observed variables, X is matrix of scores for factors and B is matrix of eigenvectors (weights).
Twelve factors were identified using PCA having an eigen value equal to or above 1.0 (Additional file 1). These factors were further grouped from rotated matrix having maximum amount of variance (Table 1, Additional file 2). Furthermore, Bivariate Pearson’s analysis was conducted on score matrix calculating variables having unique dimensions (land-use classes) with respect to dengue indices. Strength of correlation is indicated in Table 2. Statistical analyses were conducted in SPSS (version 16.0).
Spatial analysis using ring maps
Ring map visualization has been explored as a mean of depicting spatially-referenced, multivariate data in single information graphic. A ring map shows multiple attribute datasets as separate rings of information surrounding a base map of a particular geographic region of interest. Huang et al.  used these techniques to map many variables for location specific data and presented a very good picture of temporal data in one graph instead of displaying them on multiple maps. In this study, ring maps were used to visualize spatio-temporal variations of B.I., and to indicate its relationship with respect to C.I. and H.I. Ring mapping provided a direct mean to explore multivariate and temporal data in a single map to evaluate spatio-temporal patterns. Ring maps were generated in Adobe Illustrator with MAPublisher and all attributes information was imported and reclassified according to indices values. In Figure 8, the base map and inner ring represents the average B.I. calculated. Spokes around the base maps indicate village locations surveyed, while the inner ring values show average B.I. of the sampled villages. Extending to the outside from the inner ring, the outer layers represent the index variations during March, May and July, respectively. Every village sampled shows the spatio-temporal changes with respect to B.I. While Figure 9 shows the spatial variation among dengue indices (C.I., H.I. and B.I.) of each surveyed village.
The overall flow-chart of methodology is shown in Figure 10.
Results and discussion
Paddy fields covered the largest area (44%) and gasoline station/workshop occupied the least area (0.01%) in the sampling buffer during the year 2009. Relative land area for deciduous forest, horticulture, institutions, marsh/swamp/rice paddy, and perennial vegetation cover types in the sampling area (buffer) was 4.90, 0.05, 0.79, 1.10, and 2.34%, respectively (Table 3).
Previous research has shown that Ae. albopictus can have a strong presence in rural areas and forest reserves, inhabiting both macro- and micro-habitats [28, 29]. In the current study, population densities of Ae. aegypti and Ae. albopictus increased as the land under deciduous forest cover increased for the month of March, as there was a significant positive correlation (p ≤ 0.05) observed between house, container and Breteau indices and area under deciduous forest during this month (Table 4). Breeding patterns of Ae. aegypti differ according to locality  and usually this species prefers to stay within urban environments, but Ae. albopictus is a forest mosquito and prefers to breed in tree holes and cavities . Mosquitoes have been observed to be actively present over a wide range within the forest column that could be associated with feeding or ovipositor habits . Some mosquito species are active in the entire vertical forest strata from the ground to the top of the canopy, while others prefer to be either high in the canopy or close to the ground for host-seeking [32, 33]. In deciduous forest cover the dominant species of trees and other woody vegetation shed their leaves in cold months and produce new leaves the following spring. The tree species in deciduous forests vary by region, but mostly include oak, beech, elm, walnut, sweet gum, linden, maple, chestnut and hickory, in areas with sufficient rainfall to support tree growth. In forests containing numerous old trees with big trunks, holes and cavities are naturally present and provide resting and nesting sites to various species of birds and other animals [34, 35]. In such cavities or holes, the accumulations and retention of rainfall water, together with suitable temperature and humidity ranges, could facilitate the development of a microclimate suitable for the breeding of Ae. albopictus. The constant availability of a suitable environment and a variety of hosts in the forest habitat could be another reason for the increased population of Ae. albopictus found in containers located within the flight range of this species. These results are in agreement with the observations of Anosike et al. and Derraik et al. [29, 36], where forest environments naturally supported the population of the mosquito (vector), but is in disagreement with the findings of Nakhapakorn and Tripathi , who observed forests to have a negative effect on dengue incidence. Some researchers have reported the quantitative analysis of mosquito populations in forest habitats [29, 36]. The current study was conducted in and around houses, but forest areas lie within the flight range (i.e. within one-kilometer of houses inspected) of the vectors. It was also observed that some hamlets/dwellings were almost surrounded by forest.
The horticulture land-use class includes the cultivation of bamboo, truck crops, floriculture, vine, pepper, strawberry, passion fruit, raspberry, herbs, grasses, etc, and is characterized by the presence of regularly applied irrigation to maintain landscape vigor and associated production of fruits and flowers. Male mosquitoes feed usually on floral nectar, sucking sugar-containing syrup as their staple food [37–39]. Since males don’t bear the burden of producing young-ones, they avoid human biting and mostly feed on floral nectars . This nutritious syrup is found in floral nectars, at the base of leaves and soft stems, and even less frequently, on fruit [40, 41]. This is also observed as exuding from damaged plants as honeydews [42–44]. Mosquitoes also feed directly from plants by piercing undamaged tissue [45, 46]. Mostly the female Aedes mosquito feeds on human blood. This is because these need the protein found in blood to produce eggs . Bamboo, as a horticultural plant could provide a suitable breeding habitat for mosquitoes, especially Ae. albopictus [47, 48]. Hence, horticultural land serves as one of the major breeding places for mosquitoes. In the present study, the number of houses infected with dengue significantly increased with increasing horticultural land (p = 0.05) and a positive relationship was observed between H.I. and the area under horticultural land-use for the month of May (Table 4). Availability of moisture due to irrigation, or abrupt increases in rainfall, in the month of May might have supported the development of a suitable breeding environment for Ae. albopictus in horticultural zones and possible propagation of adult mosquitoes to containers in houses within their flight range. Increased mosquito populations in or around horticultural land during the months of May and June due to increased rain showers was also observed . Furthermore, the results are in agreement with the findings of Vanwambeke et al. , who observed a positive relationship between the population of Ae. albopictus and area of horticultural land-cover.
Integrated effect of land-use type
The relationship of groups of land-use types with house, container and Breteau indices with their mean values is presented in Table 1. As a result of factor analysis, land-cover types including factor 1 (orchard, perennial and rangeland) have a significant correlation (p = 0.05) with the number of houses containing infected containers (H.I.) during the month of March. The obvious reason for this significant correlation was high vector population during this period. Mosquitoes feed on floral nectar, fruit juices and liquids exuded from plants, and nectar sugar is burned as fuel for flight and is replenished on a daily basis, whereas blood protein is needed for egg production, so is imbibed less frequently . Plant axils, as in bananas, are favorable for dengue vector, but these feed mainly on nectar from wildflowers. Also, the peak mosquito spawning season coincides with the peak blossoming of fruit trees . Rangeland and perennials consist of grass, shrub, bamboo, etc; where the bamboo can contribute to the availability of favorable habitats for dengue vectors . Factor 3 (deciduous forest and mines) had a combined significant correlation (p ≤ 0.05) with house, container and Breteau indices for the month of March. As already explained, forest environment provides feeding and breeding habitat to Ae. albopictus dengue mosquito. Similarly, Factor 8 (gasoline station/workshop, marsh, swamp and paddy fields) was significantly correlated (p = 0.001) with the H.I. for the months of May and July with an average value (p = 0.05) for this study period, and with B.I. (p = 0.001) for the month of May. The commonality among such land-use types could be the presence of water either in fields, such as rice paddies and swamps, or in containers, like tyres from nearby gasoline stations . Studies by various investigators [57, 59, 64] have shown the presence of dengue vectors at gasoline station/workshops, marsh and paddy fields; however, none of the studies reported indices.
Type of land-use in most cases remained the same within the period from March to July; however, it was noted that the habitat characteristics determined by the stage of vegetation (vegetative, flowering), management practices (irrigation, sowing, harvesting) and rainfall pattern varied across the said duration. Some flowering plants had already reached post flowering stages in March and thereby the same vegetation, only newly seeded, was at its full blooming stage during the month of May and became an attraction for and served as a supporting habitat to many insects including mosquitoes for nectar feeding during this month. Depending on the differences in number of houses inspected (H.I.) and number of containers infested (C.I.), behavior indices varied from each other. This happened when the number of inspected houses increased or decreased with only a slight change in the number of infested containers. In May, the number of houses infested increased but the number of infested containers within a house remained the same, and so, in some cases this would not result in a respective change in C.I. and B.I.
With local increases in human population, new schools and other institutional facilities are continuing to be developed. Institutional land-cover includes facilities for education, religion, healthcare, military, etc. All buildings, including grounds, parking lots and other auxiliary land-uses, are included within this land-use type. In the present study, greater institutional land area resulted in enhanced dengue mosquito density in houses within one-kilometer radius and a strong correlation (p = 0.01) existed between the area under institutions and the number of houses with infected containers (Table 4). Ae. aegypti is well-adapted to populated environments and typically breeds in clean, stagnant water (rain water) in proximity to human dwellings [23, 50, 51]. Water containers, such as roof gutters, catch basins, rain barrels, swimming pools, wading pools, cesspools, septic tanks, tyres, paint buckets, tin cans, yard debris, coconut shells, bottles and rubbish collecting units are usually present in or around institutional buildings in urban areas and could serve as breeding sites for dengue vectors . In people attending institutions, dengue infections have been widely reported. Most of the virus transmission occurred in people within these institutions, and such places are likely being the most appropriate habitat for mosquito breeding and dengue epidemic as well [53, 54]. Previous reports also indicate that most of the surveyed institutions were found positive for Ae. Aegypti, and therefore special attention is required to such high potential breeding sites [55, 56].
Marsh/swamp is an open place which holds standing water. Paddy fields are uncultivated areas having standing water, which have been prepared for rice crop to be sown in near future. Rice paddy fields have almost identical characteristics, but possess growing rice crop. All three were considered to be a single land-cover type. Marshes feature an abundance of reeds, rushes and cattails, and are generally treeless and open spaces, whereas swamps are either completely or partially covered with trees and shrubs. A wide variety of birds, such as ducks, swans, terns, geese, herons and songbirds live in marshes and swamps. Rice paddy fields contain rice crops for about four months, two times a year in Thailand (total of 8 months per year). Marsh, swamp and rice paddy are all characterized by standing water from 2.5 cm to 30 cm in depth, and also serve as catchments for the rain water. Mosquitoes commonly breed in areas with standing water or temporary pools like salt marshes, swamps and areas flooded by snow melts and spring rains [57, 58]. In the study area, the areas located in proximity to land containing marshes, swamps and paddy fields possess increased dengue vector population. This increase was highly significant, as indicated by correlations between land covered with marsh, swamp and rice paddy and B.I. (p = 0.001) for the month of May and also with the average H.I. (p = 0.05) for all three months (Table 4). Although major vector species of the genus Aedes (Ae. aegypti and Ae. albopictus) are known as container-breeding species and prefer small volumes of water in artificial environments (urban), these species can also be expected in natural situations. They breed in water collected in dead leaves, tree holes and rock pools observed in marshes, swamps and rice paddies, and can also feed on birds living in marshes and swamps . They might also have access to containers from houses in the vicinity. Marshes, swamps and rice paddies have been reported as a source of vectors for many other diseases, but recently it has been observed that the still water at such places is a suitable habitat for dengue vectors. It has been recommended, as a precautionary measure, to stay away from such habitats [60, 61]. Also, many farmers build temporary houses in rice paddy fields and live there throughout the growing period until harvest. They store water in earthenware containers which serve as potential habitats for dengue vectors.
Perennial vegetation in this study includes para rubber, coconut, oil palm, teak, magosa, mangrove, coffee and tea plantations, all of which can serve as breeding sites for Ae. Albopictus. These can all serve as substitutes for the regular components of the tree hole fauna [28, 29] and natural containers used for development of its larvae and pupae, as these have been found in tree holes and coconut shells . In present study, a greater area of perennial vegetation is found to have a positive correlation with the density of Ae. aegypti and Ae. albopictus in containers placed in houses within the flight range of adult mosquitoes. Particularly, a significant and positive correlation (p ≤ 0.05) was observed between the number of containers infected with dengue and B.I. for the month of March (Table 4). A possible reason could be the presence of constant favorable habitat due to moderate microclimate and breeding sites (tree trunks, leaves and tree holes) that facilitated the growth of Ae albopictus. This is in agreement with Anosike et al.  and Mangudo et al.  who reported the favorability of woody tree vegetation environments for the growth of Ae. albopictus.
Spatial temporal analysis of dengue indices
Spatial and temporal analyses were performed at provincial and district levels. Provincial level results were extracted and are shown in Figures 4, 5 and 6, while the district level temporal and spatial changes can be seen in Figures 9 and 10 in ring maps.
Out of the B.I. sampled villages in districts 6501 to 6509, 0, 0, 13, 25, 0, 8, 0, 0, and 0% had optimal B.I.; and 15, 0, 12, 25, 0, 8, 17, 0, and 0% had emergency B.I., respectively (Figure 9, Table 5). Out of the total sampled villages in districts 6501 to 6509, 5, 11, 0, 0, 0, 8, 0, 0, and 0% had optimal H.I., and 70, 67, 87, 67, 87, 67, 86, 69, 83, 91 and 50% had emergency, H.I., respectively (Figure 9, Table 6). According to the risk levels set by the National Institute of Health (NIH), Thailand, optimal control is a H.I. < 1% and emergency levels of infestation are indicated by a H.I. of 10% or greater. Similarly, a B.I. < 5% is consider to be an optimal index and > 50% is consider as high risk . C.I. only provides information on the proportion of water-holding containers that are positive. The B.I. and H.I. are commonly used for the determination of priority (risk) areas for control measures. Figure 8 shows the detailed results generated using ring maps for each district of Phitsanulok Province in terms of B.I. Figure 9 shows the relationship between average B.I., C.I. and H.I. Common breeding habitats found in study area are shown in Additional file 3.
Heavy rains and floods may increase the risk of infectious diseases, such as typhoid fever, cholera, leptospirosis and hepatitis A, and vector-borne diseases like dengue, malaria, yellow fever, and West Nile fever . Often flood generate favourable breeding habitats for Aedes and thus may result in increase of vector population in flooded area. This may lead to potential risk of dengue outbreak following a flood. But there are no immediate effects as floods interrupts vector-borne disease cycle as it alters vector breeding habitats and in result may cause reduction in dengue for the time . Flood may change land-use and so can directly affect the habitat of dengue due to water availability, such as increase in marsh/swamp areas, increase in water fill in used tyres around workshops, etc. can result in more breeding places. Hence, vector growth can re-emerge within 3 to 4 weeks following the flood. But good control programs like cleaning operations, disposing of unused water containers including old tyres, tin-cans, broken jars and plastic bottles, etc. can lead to better control on vector population. As per report of MOPH Thailand, the number of dengue fever cases fell by 36% in Thailand after 2011 flood that was the worst flood during five decades. MOPH, Thailand vector-borne diseases took serious efforts to reduce breeding habitats and so it may be the reason of less infection in next year.
Accuracy assessment of statistical methods
Figure 11 is the graphical representation of verification between spatial and statistical results. A similar pattern was observed for the areas of high and low B.I. However, out of a total of twelve factors seven showed no significant difference for B.I., indicating the complexity of dengue habitats with land-cover types. Thus, high B.I. was found to be associated with a variety of land-cover types including perennial, orchard, rangeland, deciduous forest and mixed marsh/swamp/rice paddy land-cover with nearby gasoline stations/workshops. Factors associated with low B.I. mainly include the land-cover types, such as aquaculture and non residential urban (city). Factors having land-use types, such as mixed marsh/swamp and rice paddy fields, have been found to disagree with the statistical results. This could be due to there being very few places that have workshops nearby, so making them unsuitable as habitats for dengue vectors.
Limitations and future recommendations
In order to explore the natural/pragmatic phenomena for expected dengue risk, randomly selected houses having water containers of different sizes, shapes and numbers were observed. One of the limitations of this study is that the containers vary from house to house with respect to their size, shape and more importantly their number. To combat this complexity related to number of containers a ratio between infested and inspected containers was adopted. It might be the reason for variation of B.I., H.I. and C.I. For example, the relationship between dengue indices, as shown through ring mapping (Figure 9), indicates that many villages contain higher H.I. as compared to C.I. and B.I. This indicates that increases or decreases in the number of inspected houses does not always bring a change in the number of infested containers and consequently in the B.I. at the same rate. Hence, behavior of H.I., C.I. and B.I. can be different depending on the existing scenario. Owing to lack of resources data of 2009 survey was investigated in the present study. Furthermore, a weak correlation with a single factor, i.e. land-cover/land-use can be expected owing to the multi-factorial complex phenomena involved in determining the scenario. Availability of larval data might be beneficial in predicting more precisely the suitable artificial and natural containers in study area.
The unpredictability and complexity of infectious disease is still a challenge for health managers and decision makers, because several factors contribute the outbreak. Climatic, economic, biological, ecological and socio-economic factors are certainly among the other factors which compile suitable/unsuitable environments for dengue vector propagation, and by integrating these, a useful model can be developed. The resultant multi-factorial relationship with dengue indices and land-cover types may help elucidate the complex phenomenon of dengue outbreak more precisely. This type of geo-spatial approach can help public health department to take timely dengue control measures to thwart disease outbreak.
In the present study, settlements with a greater number of gasoline stations/workshops and institutional areas had higher B.I. values, suggesting that these factors significantly contribute to the favorable dengue vector habitats. Dwellings surrounded by marsh/swamp located near paddy fields proved suitable for the growth of dengue vector populations, especially during the rainy season. The strong relationship between deciduous forest, horticulture and perennial areas, and dengue indices indicates that such vegetation is potential habitat for Aedes. These findings show that the presented micro-level datasets created from analysis using statistical methods and spatial tools are beneficial in predicting dengue habitat to facilitate early public health responses. These findings along with reported climatic and demographic factors have special significance in minimizing or curbing the potential risk of dengue outbreak morbidity and mortality. However, these indices weakly predict dengue cases, but can present a fairly close scenario of suitability of dengue habitat. A clear understanding of the procedures for spatial factor assessment and temporal analysis facilitates identification and display of potential predictors for the incidence of dengue in the near future and the risk associated with this disease, and will provide a novel way to start investigations. In conclusion, the use of integrative technologies can enable the healthcare mangers to take early decisions to prevent the spread of dengue outbreak.
MSS, TT and PK participated in data collection with the collaboration of Ministry of Public Health, Thailand team. MSS carried out the analysis and drafted the initial manuscript while Dr. NKT, Dr. TT and Dr. MS designed the conceptual approach and also assisted in the analysis of data. All authors jointly contributed to the revision and approved the final manuscript.
Rezza G: Aedes albopictus and the reemergence of Dengue. BMC Public Health. 2012, 12: 72-10.1186/1471-2458-12-72.
Chang A, Parrales M, Jimenez J, Sobieszczyk M, Hammer S, Copenhaver D, Kulkarni R: Combining Google Earth and GIS mapping technologies in a dengue surveillance system for developing countries. Int J Health Geographics. 2009, 8: 49-10.1186/1476-072X-8-49.
World Health Organization Regional Office for South-East Asia: Comprehensive Guidelines for Prevention and Control of Dengue and Dengue Haemorrhagic Fever. 2011, New Delhi, India, http://www.searo.who.int/LinkFiles/Dengue_DHF_prevention&control_guidelines_rev.pdf,
Lin C, Wen T: Using Geographically Weighted Regression (GWR) to explore spatial varying relationships of immature mosquitoes and human densities with the incidence of dengue. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2011, 8 (7): 2798-2815.
Patz J, Olson S, Uejio C, Gibbs H: Disease emergence from global climate and land use change. Med Clinics of North Am. 2008, 92 (6): 1473-1491. 10.1016/j.mcna.2008.07.007.
Kitron U: Landscape ecology and epidemiology of vector-borne diseases: tools for spatial analysis. J Med Entomology. 1998, 35 (4): 435-445.
Patz J, Norris D: Land use change and human health. DeFries, Asner, and Houghton, Note. 2004, 6: 159-67.
Asner G, Elmore A, Olander L, Martin R, Harris A: Grazing systems, ecosystem responses, and global change. Annu Rev Environ Resour. 2004, 29: 261-299. 10.1146/annurev.energy.29.062403.102142.
Ramankutty N, Foley J: Estimating historical changes in global land cover: croplands from 1700 to 1992. Global Biogeochemical Cycles. 1999, 13 (4): 997-1027. 10.1029/1999GB900046.
Application of GIS modeling for dengue fever prone area based on socio-cultural and environmental factors–a case study of delhi city zone Citeseer. http://www.isprs.org/proceedings/XXXVII/congress/8_pdf/2_WG-VIII-2/03.pdf,
Vanwambeke S, Lambin E, Eichhorn M, Flasse S, Harbach R, Oskam L, Somboon P, van Beers, van Benthem, Walton C: Impact of land-use change on dengue and malaria in northern Thailand. EcoHealth. 2007, 4: 37-51. 10.1007/s10393-007-0085-5.
Sanchez L, Cortinas J, Pelaez O, Gutierrez H, Concepcion D, Van DerStuyft: Breteau Index threshold levels indicating risk for dengue transmission in areas with low Aedes infestation. Trop Med & Int Health. 2010, 15 (2): 173-175. 10.1111/j.1365-3156.2009.02437.x.
Jeefoo P, Tripathi N, Souris M: Spatio-temporal diffusion pattern and hotspot detection of dengue in Chachoengsao Province, Thailand. Int J Env Res Public Health. 2010, 8: 51-74. 10.3390/ijerph8010051.
Martínez-Vega R, Danis-Lozano R, Velasco-Hernández J, Díaz-Quijano F, González-Fernández M, Santos R, Román S, Argaez-Sosa J, Nakamura M, Ramos-Castañeda J: A prospective cohort study to evaluate peridomestic infection as a determinant of dengue transmission: Protocol. BMC Public Health. 2012, 12: 262-10.1186/1471-2458-12-262.
Nakhapakorn K, Tripathi N: An information value based analysis of physical and climatic factors affecting dengue fever and dengue haemorrhagic fever incidence. Int J Health Geographics. 2005, 4: 13-10.1186/1476-072X-4-13.
George R, Lum L, Gubler D, Kuno G: Clinical spectrum of dengue infection. Dengue and Dengue Hemorrhagic Fever. Edited by: Gubler DJ, Wallingford KunoG. 1997, UK: CAB International, 89-113.
Campaign Against Dengue, National Environment Agency Singapore. http://www.dengue.gov.sg/images/Guidelines,
Halstead SB: Dengue. 2009, London: Imperial College Pr, http://books.google.co.th/books?id=6zLd9mFwxwsC&printsec=frontcover&source=gbs_ge_summary_r&cad=0#v= onepage&q&f=false
Ostfeld R, Glass G, Keesing F: Spatial epidemiology: an emerging (or re-emerging) discipline. Trends in Ecol & Evol. 2005, 20 (6): 328-336. 10.1016/j.tree.2005.03.009.
Barbazan P, Tuntaprasart W, Souris M, Demoraes F, Nitatpattana N, Boonyuan W, Gonzalez J: Assessment of a new strategy, based on Aedes aegypti (L.) pupal productivity, for the surveillance and control of dengue transmission in Thailand. Ann Trop Med Parasitology. 2008, 102 (2): 161-171. 10.1179/136485908X252296.
Vanwambeke S, Van Benthem, Khantikul N, Burghoorn-Maas C, Panart K, Oskam L, Lambin E, Somboon P: Multi-level analyses of spatial and temporal determinants for dengue infection. Int J Health Geographics. 2006, 5: 5-10.1186/1476-072X-5-5.
Phitsanulok Provincial Statistical Office MinistyofInformationandCommunicationTechnology: Provincial Statistical Report: 2011. Phitsanulok, Thailand;. 2011, http://web.nso.go.th/,
Bohra A, Andrianasolo H: Application of GIS in modeling of dengue risk based on sociocultural data: case of Jalore, Rajasthan, India. Dengue Bull. 2001, 25: 92-102.
National Institute of Health (NIH) of Thailand Department of Medical Sciences: Biology, Ecology and Mosquito Control in Thailand (Thai-version). 2010, Bangkok, Thailand, http://webdb.dmsc.moph.go.th/ifc_nih/a_nih_1_001c.asp?info_id=1366,
PROC Factor: how to interpret the output of a real-world exampls. http://www2.sas.com/proceedings/sugi22/STATS/PAPER268.PDF,
Suhr D: Principal component analysis vs. exploratory factor analysis. SUGI 30 Proceedings. 2005, 203-230. http://www2.sas.com/proceedings/sugi30/203-30.pdf,
Huang G, Govoni S, Choi J, Hartley M, Wilson M: Geovisualizing Data with Ring Maps. ArcUser, Winter. 2008, 54-55. http://www.esri.com/news/arcuser/0408/files/ringmaps.pdf,
Lourenço-de Oliveira R, Castro M, Braks M, Lounibos L: The invasion of urban forest by dengue vectors in Rio de Janeiro. J Vector Ecol. 2004, 29: 94-100.
Anosike J, Nwoke B, Okere A, Oku E, Asor J, Emmy-Egbe I, Adimike D: Epidemiology of tree-hole breeding mosquitoes in the tropical rainforest of Imo State, south-east Nigeria. Ann Agric Environ Med: AAEM. 2007, 14: 31-
Service MW: The ecology of the mosquitos of the Northern Guinea Savannah of Nigeria. Bull Entomological Res. 1963, 54: 601-632. 10.1017/S000748530004904X.
Haddow A, Gillett J, Highton R: The mosquitoes of Bwamba County, Uganda; the vertical distribution and biting-cycle of mosquitoes in rain-forest, with further observations on microclimate. Bull Ent Res. 1947, 37: 301-10.1017/S000748530003042X.
Snow KR: Insects and disease. 1974, London, UK: Routledge & Kegan Paul Ltd, http://books.google.co.th/books/about/Insects_and_Disease.html?id=6t89AAAAIAAJ&redir_esc=y,
Braack L, Coetzee M, Hunt R, Biggs H, Cornel A, Gericke A: Biting pattern and host-seeking behavior of Anopheles arabiensis (Diptera: Culicidae) in northeastern South Africa. J Med Entomol. 1994, 31 (3): 333-339.
Pattanavibool A, Edge WD: Single-tree selection silviculture affects cavity resources in mixed deciduous forests in Thailand. J Wildlife Manage. 1996, 60 (1): 67-73. 10.2307/3802041. http://www.jstor.org/discover/10.2307/3802041?uid=3739136&uid=2129&uid=2&uid=70&uid=4&sid=21101121194533 sid=21101121194533
Carlson A, Sandström U, Olsson K: Availability and use of natural tree holes by cavity nesting birds in a Swedish deciduous forest. Ardea. 1998, 86: 109-119.
Derraik J, Snell A, Slaney D: Vertical distribution of adult mosquitoes in native forest in Auckland, New Zealand. J Vector Ecol. 2005, 30 (2): 334-
Downes J: The feeding habits of biting flies and their significance in classification. Ann Rev Entomol. 1958, 3: 249-266. 10.1146/annurev.en.03.010158.001341.
Slansky Jr F, Rodriguez JG, et. al: Nutritional Ecology of Insects, Mites, Spiders, and Related Invertebrates. 1987, John Wiley, New York: John Wiley, http: //books.google.co.th/books/about/Nutritional_ecology_of_insects_mites_spi.html?id=LZjwAAAAMAAJ&redir_esc=y
Yuval B: The other habit: sugar feeding by mosquitoes. Bull Soc Vector Ecologists. 1992, 17 (2): 150-156.
Haeger J: The non-blood feeding habits of Aedes taeniorhynchus (Diptera, Culicidae) on Sanibel Island, Florida. Mosq News. 1955, 15: 21-26.
Nielsen ET, Greve H: Studies on the swarming Habits of Mosquitos and other Nematocera. Bull Ent Res. 1950, 41: 227-258. 10.1017/S0007485300027607.
Nasci R: Toxorhynchites rutilus septentrionalis feeding on tree sap. J Am Mosquito Control Assoc. 1986, 2 (4): 559-
PATTERSON BJDRT R S: SMITTLE: Feeding Habits of Male Southern House Mosquitoes1 on 32P-labeled and Unlabeled Plants2. J Economic Entomol. 1969, 62 (6): 1455-1455.
Joseph S, et. al: Fruit feeding of mosquitoes in nature. Proc New Jersey Mosquito Extermination Assoc. 1970, 57: 125-131.
Abdel-Malek A, Baldwin W: Specificity of plant feeding in mosquitoes as determined by radioactive phosphorus. Nature. 1961, 192: 178-179. 10.1038/192178a0.
Müller G, Schlein Y: Plant tissues: the frugal diet of mosquitoes in adverse conditions. Med Veterinary Entomol. 2005, 19 (4): 413-422. 10.1111/j.1365-2915.2005.00590.x.
Knudsen A, et. al: Global distribution and continuing spread of Aedes albopictus. Parassitologia. 1995, 37 (2-3): 91-
Scholte E, Jacobs F, Linton Y, Dijkstra E, Fransen J, Takken W: First record of Aedes (Stegomyia) albopictus in the Netherlands. Eur Mosquito Bull. 2007, 22: 5-9.
Yard and Garden: 2011. http: //ianrhome.unl.edu/c/document_library/get_file?p_l_id=4472532&folderId=341641&name=DLFE-45847.pdf
Plummer R, Kulkarni R, Sethi A: Dengue fever: the fundamentals. J Pakistan Assoc Dermatologists. 2009, 19: 127-130.
Wen T, Lin M, Fang C: Population Movement and Vector-Borne Disease Transmission: differentiating spatial–temporal diffusion patterns of commuting and noncommuting dengue cases. Ann Assoc Am Geographers. 2012, 102 (5): 1026-1037. 10.1080/00045608.2012.671130.
Arunachalam N, Tana S, Espino F, Kittayapong P, Abeyewickrem W, Wai K, Tyagi B, Kroeger A, Sommerfeld J, Petzold M: Eco-bio-social determinants of dengue vector breeding: a multicountry study in urban and periurban Asia. Bull World Health Organization. 2010, 88 (3): 173-184. 10.2471/BLT.09.067892.
Kantachuvessirim A: Dengue hemorrhagic fever in Thai society. Southeast Asian J Trop Med Public Health. 2002, 33 (1): 56-62. http://www.searo.who.int/LinkFiles/Dengue_Bulletin_Volume_25_shortnotes.pdf,
Endy T, Nisalak A, Chunsuttiwat S, Libraty D, Green S, Rothman A, Vaughn D, Ennis F: Spatial and temporal circulation of dengue virus serotypes: a prospective study of primary school children in Kamphaeng Phet, Thailand. Am J Epidemiol. 2002, 156: 52-59. 10.1093/aje/kwf006.
Sharma R, Panigrahi N, Kaul S: Aedes aegypti prevalence in hospitals and schools, the Priority Sites for DHF Transmission in Delhi, India. Dengue Bull. 2001, 25: 107-
Ricardo C, Maria D, Valmir A, Ana M, Celso S: Spatial distribution of the risk of dengue fever in southeast Brazil, 2006-2007. BMC Public Health. 2011, 11 (1): 355-10.1186/1471-2458-11-355. http://www.biomedcentral.com/content/pdf/1471-2458-11-355.pdf,
FAQ’s on Mosquitos: Center for Vector Biology. http://www.uri.edu/ce/factsheets/sheets/mosquito.html,
Towards Sustainable Vector Control: Larvicides. http://www.vectorcontrol.bayer.com/bayer/cropscience/bes_vectorcontrol.nsf/id/EN_Larvicides,
Richards S, Ponnusamy L, Unnasch T, Hassan H, Apperson C: Host-feeding patterns of Aedes albopictus (Diptera: Culicidae) in relation to availability of human and domestic animals in suburban landscapes of central North Carolina. J Med Entomol. 2006, 43 (3): 543-10.1603/0022-2585(2006)43[543:HPOAAD]2.0.CO;2.
Infection illnesses in Southeast Asia. http://expat.interglobal.com/2012/05/08/contagious-illnesses-in-southeast-asia,
How is dengue fever transmitted?. http://www.ehow.com/how-does_4599985_how-dengue-fever-transmitted.html,
Mangudo C, Aparicio J, Gleiser R: Tree holes as larval habitats for Aedes aegypti in public areas in Aguaray, Salta province, Argentina. J Vector Ecol. 2011, 36: 227-230. 10.1111/j.1948-7134.2011.00162.x.
Alcohol ingestion stimulates mosquito attraction. http://www.secretlake.net/mosquitos.html,
Lagrotta M, Silva W, Souza-Santos R: Identification of key areas for Aedes aegypti control through geoprocessing in Nova Iguaçu, Rio de Janeiro State, Brazil. Cadernos de Saúde Pública. 2008, 24: 70-80.
Ivers L, Ryan E: Infectious diseases of severe weather-related and flood-related natural disasters. Curr Opin Infectious Diseases. 2006, 19 (5): 408-10.1097/01.qco.0000244044.85393.9e.
Oliva O, Pan American Health Organization. http://www.paho.org/English/dd/ped/te_vect.htm,
The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/12/853/prepub
Authors would like to acknowledge the Office of Disease Prevention and Control’s team (Dr. Sakchai Chaiyamahapurk, Dr. Niramon Pimnumyen, Ms. Sarinthorn Sontisirikit, Mr. Jirapat Ketkaew, Miss Saowanee Deemoon, and Mr. Worawit Tidtean), Municipality Office’s team (Miss Chun Siriwan, Miss Patcharee Panudom and Miss Supaluk Klinyam) and Land Development Office of Phitsanulok for collaboration during survey and distribution of data. Authors’ are also thankful for financial support provided by Higher Education Commission (HEC) of Pakistan, Bureau of Vector Borne Diseases, Phitsanulok, and Asian Institute of Technology (AIT) Thailand to complete this research. Authors would like to thanks Dr. Muhammad Arshad, Assistant Professor, Faculty of Life Sciences, Karakoram International University (KIU), Pakistan for technical assistance throughout the study.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Authors’ original submitted files for images
Below are the links to the authors’ original submitted files for images.
About this article
Cite this article
Sarfraz, M.S., Tripathi, N.K., Tipdecho, T. et al. Analyzing the spatio-temporal relationship between dengue vector larval density and land-use using factor analysis and spatial ring mapping. BMC Public Health 12, 853 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2458-12-853
- Rice Paddy
- Dengue Hemorrhagic Fever
- Dengue Infection
- Tree Hole
- Dengue Case