Table 4 Effectiveness of bundled interventions
Bundle | Studies that Map to Bundlea | HIV Incidence | HIV Testing | STI Incidence/Testing | Sexual Risk Behaviours | Sexual Debut | SRH | HIV prevention knowledge | Gender Attitudes | Psycho social well-being | Education | GBV | Economic |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cash + health information (23) | Study #: 1, 2, 3, 4, 9, 22, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39 40, 41, 42, 43 | 0 of 1 full (0%) 0 of 1 mixed (0%) Total: 0% | 0 of 3 full (0%) 1 of 3 mixed (0%) Total: 0% | 1 of 2 full (50%) 1 of 2 mixed (50%) Total: 100% | 5 of 11 full (45%) 1 of 11 mixed (1%) Total: 46% | 0 of 4 full (0%) 1 of 4 mixed (25%) Total: 25% | 6 of 9 full (66%) 2 of 9 mixed (22%) Total: 88% | 5 of 6 full (83%) 0 of 6 mixed (0%) Total: 83% | 1 of 4 full (25%) 1 of 4 mixed (25%) Total: 50% | 5 of 11 full (45%) 3 of 11 mixed (27%) Total: 72% | 4 of 8 full (50%) 0 of 8 mixed (0%) Total: 50% | 3 of 6 full (50%) 1 of 6 mixed (17%) Total: 67% | 9 of 10 full (90%) 0 of 10 mixed (0%) Total: 90% |
Cash + life skills (22) | Study #: 1, 2, 3, 4, 9, 22, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40 41 | 0 of 1 full (0%) 0 of 1 mixed (0%) Total: 0% | 0 of 3 full (0%) 1 of 3 mixed (33%) Total: 33% | 1 of 2 full (50%) 1 of 2 mixed (50%) Total: 100% | 4 of 9 full (44%) 1 of 9 mixed (11%) Total: 55% | 0 of 4 full (0%) 1 of 4 mixed (25%) Total: 25% | 6 of 8 full (75%) 2 of 8 mixed (25%) Total: 100% | 4 of 5 full (80%) 0 of 5 mixed (0%) Total: 80% | 1 of 4 full (25%) 1 of 4 protective (25%) Total: 50% | 4 of 10 full (40%) 3 of 10 mixed (30%) Total: 70% | 5 of 9 full (55%) 0 of 9 mixed (0%) Total: 55% | 3 of 6 full (50%) 1 of 6 mixed (17%) Total: 67% | 9 of 10 full (90%) 0 of 10 mixed (0%) Total: 90% |
Cash + mentoring (20) | Study #: 1, 2, 3, 4, 22, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 43 | N/A | 0 of 1 full (0%) 1 of 1 mixed (100%) Total: 100% | 0 of 1 full (0%) 1 of 1 mixed (100%) Total: 100% | 3 of 8 full (37%) 1 of 8 mixed (12%) Total: 49% | 0 of 4 full (0%) 1 of 4 mixed (25%) Total: 25% | 5 of 7 full (71%) 2 of 7 mixed (28%) Total: 99% | 5 of 6 full (83%) 0 of 6 mixed (0%) Total: 83% | 1 of 4 full (25%) 1 of 4 mixed (25%) Total: 50% | 5 of 10 full (50%) 2 of 10 mixed (20%) Total: 70% | 5 of 9 full (55%) 0 of 9 mixed (0%) Total: 55% | 2 of 5 full (40%) 1 of 5 mixed (20%) Total: 60% | 8 of 9 full (88%) 0 of 9 mixed (0%) Total: 88% |
Vocational training + health information (18) | Study #: 9, 18, 20, 21, 23, 24, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 34, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40 | 0 of 2 full (0%) 0 of 2 mixed (0%) Total: 0% | 0 of 2 full (0%) 1 of 2 mixed (50%) Total: 50% | 0 of 1 full (0%) 0 of 1 mixed (0%) Total: 0% | 3 of 10 full (30%) 1 of 10 mixed (0%) Total: 30% | 0 of 3 full (0%) 0 of 3 mixed (0%) Total: 0% | 1 of 3 full (33%) 0 of 3 mixed (0%) Total: 33% | 4 of 4 full (100%) 0 of 4 mixed (0%) Total: 100% | 0 of 2 full (0%) 1 of 2 mixed (50%) Total: 50% | 4 of 7 full (57%) 2 of 7 mixed (28%) Total: 85% | 1 of 4 full (25%) 0 of 4 mixed (0%) Total: 25% | 1 of 4 full (25%) 1 of 4 mixed (25%) Total: 50% | 9 of 9 full (100%) 0 of 9 mixed (0%) Total: 100% |
Vocational training + life skills (20) | Study #: 9, 18, 20, 21, 23, 24, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40 | 0 of 2 full (0%) 0 of 2 mixed (0%) Total: 0% | 0 of 2 full (0%) 1 of 2 mixed (50%) Total: 50% | 0 of 1 full (0%) 0 of 1 mixed (0%) Total: 0% | 3 of 10 full (30%) 1 of 10 mixed (1%) Total: 40% | 0 of 3 full (0%) 0 of 3 mixed (0%) Total: 0% | 1 of 3 full (33%) 0 of 3 mixed (0%) Total: 33% | 4 of 4 full (100%) 0 of 4 mixed (0%) Total: 100% | 0 of 2 full (0%) 1 of 2 mixed (50%) Total: 50% | 4 of 9 full (44%) 3 of 9 mixed (33%) Total: 77% | 1 of 4 full (25%) 0 of 4 mixed (0%) Total: 25% | 1 of 4 full (25%) 1 of 4 mixed (25%) Total: 50% | 9 of 9 full (100%) 0 of 9 mixed (0%) Total: 100% |
Savings account + cash + fiscal literacy + health information (14) | Study #: 1, 6, 22, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 41, 43 | N/A | N/A | N/A | 2 of 5 full (40%) 1 of 5 mixed (20%) Total: 60% | 0 of 1 full (0%) 0 of 1 mixed (0%) Total: 0% | 3 of 3 full (100%) 0 of 3 mixed (0%) Total: 100% | 4 of 5 full (80%) 0 of 5 mixed (0%) Total: 80% | 1 of 2 full (50%) 0 of 2 mixed (0%) Total: 50% | 4 of 9 full (44%) 2 of 9 mixed (22%) Total: 63% | 2 of 4 full (50%) 0 of 4 mixed (0%) Total: 50% | 0 of 2 full (0%) 0 of 2 mixed (0%) Total: 0% | 4 of 4 full (100%) 0 of 4 mixed (0%) Total: 100% |
Vocational training + microcredit + health + life skills (4) | Study #: 18, 20, 23, 24 | 0 of 1 full (0%) 0 of 1 mixed (0%) Total: 0% | N/A | 0 of 1 full (0%) 0 of 1 mixed (0%) Total: 0% | 2 of 4 full (50%) 0 of 4 mixed (50%) Total: 50% | 0 of 1 full (0%) 0 of 1 mixed (0%) Total: 0% | 0 of 1 full (0%) 0 of 1 mixed (0%) Total: 0% | 2 of 2 full (100%) 0 of 2 mixed (0%) Total: 100% | N/A | 1 of 1 full (100%) 0 of 1 mixed (0%) Total: 100% | N/A | 1 of 2 full (50%) 0 of 2 mixed (0%) Total: 50% | 4 of 4 full (100%) 0 of 4 mixed (0%) Total: 100% |
Vocational training + mentoring (6) | Study #: 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 43 | N/A | 0 of 1 full (0%) 1 of 1 mixed (100%) Total: 100% | N/A | 0 of 3 full (0%) 0 of 3 mixed (0%) Total: 0% | 0 of 2 full (0%) 0 of 2 mixed (0%) Total: 0% | 1 of 1 full (100%) 0 of 1 mixed (0%) Total: 100% | 2 of 2 full (100%) 0 of 2 mixed (0%) 100% | 0 of 1 full (0%) 1 of 1 mixed (100%) Total: 100% | 2 of 3 full (66%) 1 of 3 mixed (33%) Total: 99% | 0 of 2 full (0%) 0 of 2 mixed (0%) Total: 0% | 0 of 1 full (0%) 1 of 1 mixed (100%) Total: 100% | 2 of 2 full (100%) 0 of 2 mixed (0%) Total: 100% |
Voucher + savings account + fiscal literacy + life skills (1) | Study #: 1 | N/A | N/A | N/A | 1 of 1 full (100%) 0 of 1 mixed (0%) Total: 100% | 0 of 1 full (0%) 0 of 1 mixed (0%) Total: 0% | 1 of 1 full (100%) 0 of 1 mixed (0%) Total: 100% | 0 of 1 full (0%) 0 of 1 mixed (0%) Total: 0% | 0 of 1 full (0%) 0 of 1 mixed (0%) Total: 0% | N/A | 0 of 1 full (0%) 0 of 1 mixed (0%) Total: 0% | N/A | 1 of 1 full (100%) 0 of 1 mixed (0%) Total: 100% |
Fiscal literacy + health information + life skills (1) | Study #: 5 | N/A | 1 of 1 full (100%) 0 of 1 mixed (0%) Total: 100% | N/A | N/A | N/A | 1 of 1 full (100%) 0 of 1 mixed (0%) Total: 100% | 1 of 1 full (100%) 0 of 1 mixed (0%) Total: 100% | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A |
DREAMS: unspecified (11) | Study #: 7, 8, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 19 | 1 of 5 full (20%) 1 of 5 mixed (20%) Total: 40% | 2 of 4 full (50%) 2 of 4 mixed (50%) Total: 100% | 0 of 4 full (0%) 1 of 4 mixed (25%) Total: 25% | 1 of 4 full (25%) 1 of 4 mixed (25%) Total: 50% | N/A | 1 of 1 full (100%) 0 of 1 mixed (0%) Total: 100% | 1 of 1 full (100%) 0 of 1 mixed (0%) Total: 100% | N/A | 0 of 1 full (0%) 1 of 1 mixed (100%) Total: 100% | 0 of 1 full (0%) 0 of 1 mixed (0%) Total: 0% | 0 of 4 full (0%) 1 of 4 mixed (25%) Total: 25% | 1 of 1 full (100%) 0 of 1 mixed (0%) Total: 100% |