Skip to main content

Table 2 Efficacy of digital health intervention modalities by outcome across all reviews

From: Do digital health interventions hold promise for stroke prevention and care in Black and Latinx populations in the United States? A scoping review

 

Web-based

Messaging

Phone-Based (Calls/Audio-only)

Mobile Applications

Health Devices

Computer-delivered

Telestroke

Virtual Reality

Clinical Outcome

 HbA1c

[54, 58,59,60]

[47, 48, 54]

 

[47, 53, 56, 63,64,65]

[66]

[46]

[45]

   

 Fasting Blood Sugar

[60]

[47] 

 

[65]

    

 Blood Pressure

[47, 58]

[59]

[55]

[47]

[55]

[67]

[53, 66] [55]

[71]

   

 Anthropometry

[49, 51, 58, 60]

 

[51]

[50, 63, 67]

[64]

[53]

    

 Cholesterol

[58]

[53]

[59]

  

[53]

    

 Identifying Atrial Fibrillation

    

[69]

   

Post-Stroke Outcomes

 Balance (e.g., Functional Reach, Berg Balance Scale)

       

[44, 77,78,79,80]

[81]

 Mobility/Activity (e.g., Timed Up & Go, Carrying, Walking)

    

[70]

[53]

 

[44, 78,79,80,81]

[82]

 Function (Joint, Muscle)

    

[70]

[53]

[42]

[76]

[82]

 Mortality

      

[42, 73]

 

 Symptomatic Intracranial Hemorrhage

      

[42, 73]

 

 Onset to Door/Onset to Treatment

      

[73]

 

 Length of Hospital Stay

      

[73]

[42]

 

 Memory

     

[53]

[75]

  

 Speech

     

[53]

  

Behavioral Outcomes

 Medication Adherence

[55]

[53]

[43, 48, 53, 68]

[57]

[55, 68]

[63, 67]

[68]

    

 Diet

[53, 60]

  

[53]

    

 Physical Activity

[53, 54, 58]

[54]

 

[54]

[53]

[50]

    

 Smoking Cessation

[61, 62]

  

[53]

    
  1. A solid circle indicates (1) a meta-analysis finds a significant effect in the experimental group or (2) the majority of individual studies find a significant benefit (> 50%) when a meta-analysis is not conducted. This indicates a strong case for potential benefits between the modality and the health outcome. A semi-solid circle indicates < 50% of the studies within a review find a significant effect. These findings would be inconclusive. A hollow circle indicates no studies found a significant effect or a meta-analysis was performed, and no effect was found. This would suggest no benefit by the modality upon the outcome
  2. If the meta-analysis aggregated by function (e.g., monitoring) or outcome (e.g., blood pressure) and not modality, then we did not report meta-analytic findings in this table
  3. Measures of anthropometry include BMI [49,50,51, 53, 63], body weight [49, 50, 58, 60, 64], and waist circumference [49, 64]