Skip to main content

Table 5 Process evaluation assessment plan and timeline

From: Evaluation of a civic engagement approach to catalyze built environment change and promote healthy eating and physical activity among rural residents: a cluster (community) randomized controlled trial

INSTRUMENT

DATA COLLECTED

PARTICIPANT CATEGORY

TIMEPOINT(S)

COMPENSATION

NOTES

Post-Meeting Surveys

-Implementation outcomes, nutrition and PA content (dose received: attendance, perceived participant satisfaction, engagement, appropriateness/fit, relevance/usefulness; fidelity: components covered, to what degree, enhancements/modifications, meeting start & end times; feasibility: prep time, cost)

Facilitators/

Educators

After each meeting

N/A

CC cost questions asked on final Post-Meeting Survey

Post-Theme Surveys

-Implementation outcomes, nutrition & PA content (dose received)

-Implementation outcomes, CC action plan (group functioning)

-Mechanisms of outcomes (perceptions about personal behavior change)

CCMa

After each curriculum themeb

$20c

Participant cost questions asked on first Post-Theme Survey only

Post-Curriculum Interview Guide

-Barriers and facilitators to implementation of nutrition and PA content (CFIR constructs)

Educators

At conclusion of all curriculum modules

N/A

 

Post-Curriculum Interview Guide

-Implementation outcomes, nutrition & PA content (dose received)

-Implementation outcomes, CC action plan (group functioning)

-Mechanisms of outcomes (perceptions about personal behavior change; perceptions about how CC action plan will impact community)

CCMd

At conclusion of all curriculum modules

$40

 

Check-In Survey

-Implementation outcomes of the CC action plan (fidelity to action plan, group functioning)

-CC action plan outcomes (goal achievement, impact)

Educators

Monthly for 12 months, starting one month after conclusion of all curriculum modules

N/A

CC cost questions asked on final Check-In Survey

One Year Post Interview Guide

-Barriers and facilitators to implementation of the CC action plans (CFIR constructs)

-CC action plan implementation outcomes (fidelity, group functioning)

-CC action plan outcomes (goal achievement, impact)

-Mechanisms of outcomes (CCM only: perceptions about personal behavior change)

Educators, CCM

12 months after the conclusion of all curriculum modules

$40 (CCM only)

 

Mini-Interview Guide

-CC action plan outcomes (perceptions of impact on community)

-Mechanisms of community resident outcomes (perceptions of impact on self)

Community Residentse

12 months after the conclusion of all curriculum modules

$20

 

Online Survey: Process Evaluation Questions

-CC action plan outcomes (current activities, goal achievement, new initiatives)

CCM

12-, 24-, and 36-month timepoints

Part of overall study compensation

Process evaluation questions will be  included in the annual online survey

Online Survey: Process Evaluation Questions

-Mechanisms of friends and family members, community resident outcomes (awareness of CC projecta; involvement in CC projecta; involvement in any other community change initiatives; awareness of changes in behavior or weight loss of community members)

Friends and Family Members, Community Residents

12-, 24-, and 36-month timepoints

Part of overall study compensation

Process evaluation questions will be included in the annual online survey

Two Year Post Interview Guide

-CC action plan outcomes (goal achievement, new initiatives)

-Implementation outcomes (sustainability)

Educators

24 months after the conclusion of all curriculum modules

N/A

Will include CC cost questions

  1. a Only those in intervention community
  2. b Or at other appropriate intervals, depending on meeting structure
  3. c Must complete all surveys to receive compensation
  4. d Random sub-sample from each CC
  5. e Approximately 15 per intervention community
  6. CC Change Club, CCM Change Club Members, CFIR Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research, PA Physical Activity