Skip to main content

Table 2 Detected themes and related studies

From: Toward a theory-led meta-framework for implementing health system resilience analysis studies: a systematic review and critical interpretive synthesis

  Quality appraisal Phases Attributes
Anticipation Preparation Response Recovery Growth Awareness Surge capacity Flexibility Resistance
(Meyer et al., 2020) [20] 100        *   
(de Carvalho et al., 2012) [21] NA**          
(Thomas et al., 2013) [22] 25          
(Falegnami et al., 2018) [14] 100 *   *       
(Shirali et al., 2016) [23] 75   *     *   * *
(Haghighi and Torabi, 2018) [24] NA   *     * * *  
(Patriarca et al., 2018) [25] 100 *   *       
(Ho et al., 2016) [26] NA   *      *   
(Therrien et al., 2017) [27] NA    *    * * *  
(Barker et al., 2020) [28] 100       * * *  
(Anderson et al., 2020) [29] 25 *   *       
(Najarian and Lim, 2019) [30] 75 *   * *    * * *
(Omidvar et al., 2017) [31] 50   *     *   *  
(Barasa et al., 2017) [32] NA    *    *    
(Blanchet et al., 2017) [10] NA *      * *   
(Biddle et al., 2020) [12] 100 *      * *   
(Cristian, 2018) [33] NA   * * *   * *   
(Ybarra, 2019) [34] NA    *      *  
(Fridell et al., 2020) [7] 75   * *     * *  
(Gilson et al., 2017) [35] 75    *    *    
(Frisbie and Converso, 2016) [36] 100       * *   
(Moran, 2016) [37] 100    *    * *   
(Witmer and Mellinger, 2016) [38] 100       *    
(Rangachari and L Woods, 2020) [39] NA    * *   *    
(Kong and Simonovic, 2019) [40] 75   *   *      *
(Khan et al., 2018) [41] 100         *  
(Argyroudis et al., 2020) [42] 75     *     * *
(Clay-Williams and Braithwaite, 2019) [43] NA *   *       
(Kagwanja et al., 2020) [44] 100    *    *    
(Pęciłło, 2016) [45] NA *   * *      *
(Vos et al., 2020) [46] 100 *   *      *  
(Rios et al., 2020) [47] 75       * * *  
(Dos Santos et al., 2020) [48] 100 * * * *      *
(Fallah-Aliabadi et al., 2020) [49] 100   * * *      *
(Woods et al., 2014) [50] NA *   *       
(Specking et al., 2019) [51] 25     *     * *
(Tumusiime et al., 2020) [52] 50   * * * * *    
(Wiig et al., 2020) [53] NA      *   * *  
(Nuzzo et al., 2019) [54] 100   *   *    * *  
(Thomas et al., 2020) [5] NA   * *    * * *  
(Turenne et al., 2019) [2] 100    * *     * *
(Iflaifel et al., 2020) [55] 100 *   *    *   * *
OECD, 2014 [56] NA * * * * *    *  
  Quality appraisal Attributes Tools Main strategies
Access to resources Collaboration and Coordination Risk analysis Planning Monitoring ICS* Learning Absorptive Adaptive Transformative
(Meyer et al., 2020) [20] 100   *     *     
(de Carvalho et al., 2012) [21] NA**   *   * *   *    
(Thomas et al., 2013) [22] 25         * * *
(Falegnami et al., 2018) [14] 100      *   *    
(Shirali et al., 2016) [23] 75      *   *    
(Haghighi and Torabi, 2018) [24] NA   *      * *   
(Patriarca et al., 2018) [25] 100      *   *    
(Ho et al., 2016) [26] NA   *    *   *    
(Therrien et al., 2017) [27] NA * *      *    
(Barker et al., 2020) [28] 100   *     *    *  
(Anderson et al., 2020) [29] 25      * * *   *  
(Najarian and Lim, 2019) [30] 75         * *  
(Omidvar et al., 2017) [31] 50        *    
(Barasa et al., 2017) [32] NA *        * * *
(Blanchet et al., 2017) [10] NA   *     *   * * *
(Biddle et al., 2020) [12] 100   *       * * *
(Cristian, 2018) [33] NA   *     * *    
(Ybarra, 2019) [34] NA        *   *  
(Fridell et al., 2020) [7] 75 * *    * *     
(Gilson et al., 2017) [35] 75 *        * * *
(Frisbie and Converso, 2016) [36] 100 * *      *    
(Moran, 2016) [37] 100 * *         
(Witmer and Mellinger, 2016) [38] 100   *       *   *
(Rangachari and L Woods, 2020) [39] NA           
(Kong and Simonovic, 2019) [40] 75           
(Khan et al., 2018) [41] 100 * * * * * * *    
(Argyroudis et al., 2020) [42] 75 *          
(Clay-Williams and Braithwaite, 2019) [43] NA      *   *    
(Kagwanja et al., 2020) [44] 100 *        * * *
(Pęciłło, 2016) [45] NA        * *   
(Vos et al., 2020) [46] 100        *    
(Rios et al., 2020) [47] 75   *        *  
(Dos Santos et al., 2020) [48] 100 *    *      *  
(Fallah-Aliabadi et al., 2020) [49] 100 * *   *   * *    
(Woods et al., 2014) [50] NA      *   *    
(Specking et al., 2019) [51] 25 *    *     * *  
(Tumusiime et al., 2020) [52] 50   *      *    *
(Wiig et al., 2020) [53] NA   *      *    
(Nuzzo et al., 2019) [54] 100 * *   *   *     
(Thomas et al., 2020) [5] NA * *    * * * * * *
(Turenne et al., 2019) [2] 100           
(Iflaifel et al., 2020) [55] 100 *      * *   *  
OECD, 2014 [56] NA   *      * * * *
  1. *Information and Communication Systems
  2. **Not Applicable