From: How should we evaluate sweetened beverage tax policies? A review of worldwide experience
Tax design | Example where implemented | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Location | Exempted products/ | Stated purpose | Framing | |||||
Ad valorem | Excise on distributors, importers & manufacturers [general budget] | Barbados [27] [national] | Announced: June 2015 Implemented: 1 September 2015 | Carbonated soft drinks, juice drinks, sports drinks, fruit juices that contain added high calorie sweeteners based on Harmonized System (HS) tariff codes | • 100% juices • Powders and concentrates • Sugar sweetened dairy/milks | 10% of value/price that manufacturer/distributors charge retailers. | Address the high burden of non-communicable diseases in Barbados [27] | Revenue generation Reduce consumption of taxed beverages [27] |
Ad valorem | Goods and Services Tax (GST) collected at point of purchase [general budget] | India [28] [national] | Implemented: 1 July 2017 | Aerated drinks and lemonades based on HS tariff code | • 100% juices • Powders and concentrates • Sugar sweetened dairy/milks • Other non-aerated drinks with added sugar | Aerated drinks and lemonades (40%: from 12% GST on all processed packaged foods/beverages + 28% GST on sin goods) | Simplify tax structure of prior Central VAT + State VAT, and eliminate cascading taxes [28] | Improve tax collection and revenue generation [28] |
Specific – Volume | Excise on distributors, importers & manufacturers [general budget] | Mexico [29] [national] | Implemented: 1 Jan 2014 | All non-alcoholic beverages with added sugar including reconstituted powdered sugar-sweetened drinks and flavoured/sweetened dairy products that are not milks | • Milk products (milk is the primary/first ingredient) • 100% fruit and/or vegetable juice | 1 Mexican Peso per ready-to-drink litre Indexed to inflation once cumulative inflation hits 10% | Address high prevalence of diabetes and cardiovascular diseases in Mexico [29] | Reduce consumption of taxed beverages [29] |
Specific – Volume | Excise on distributors, importers & manufacturers [Office of education and general budget] | Philadelphia County/City in Pennsylvania, United States [30] [City Council vote] | Enacted: 16 June 2016 Implemented: 1 Jan 2017 | • Bottled beverages • Syrups/concentrates for commercial sale • Fruit/vegetable drinks with added sugar • Mixers • Coffee syrups distributed to coffee shops • Beverages containing sweeteners that are only non-caloric (“diet drinks”) | • Milk products (milk is the primary/first ingredient) • 100% fruit and/or vegetable juice • Syrups, concentrates, and powders sold to consumers • Natural or common sweeteners that are not already in beverages | US $0.015 per ounce on retail sale on ready-to-drink volumes of taxable beverages Not indexed to inflation | None Earmark not in ordinance but in mayor’s budget [26]. | Revenue generation to support new or expanded programs including Pre-K access and Rebuild (for park, community centre, and library repairs) [26]. |
Specific – Volume tax based on sugar concentr-ation threshold | Excise on distributors, importers & manufacturers (exempt producers with < 1 million litres/year) [general budget] | United Kingdom [31] [national] | Announced: March 2016 Public Consultation: Aug 2016 Implemented: 6 April 2018 | All packaged beverages that contain sugar added during production of at least 5 g of sugar per 100 ml in ready to drink form | • Drinks with ≥75% milk • Milk replacement drinks (e.g. plant based ‘milks’) • Alcohol replacement drinks (with alcohol by volume < 0.5%) • 100% fruit/veg juices • Liquid drink flavouring added to food/drinks • Powders mixed into liquids and served in open container | £0.18 per litre for drinks containing at least 5 g of sugar per 100 ml £0.24 per litre for drinks with more than 8 g per 100 ml. | Reduce childhood obesity by removing added sugar from soft drinks [31]. Encourage soft drink producers and importers to [31]: • reformulate to cut sugar content • reduce portion sizes of added sugar drinks • import reformulated drinks with less sugar | Reformulations Reduce sugar consumption from beverages Fund children’s health initiatives (e.g., school sports and healthy school breakfast clubs) [31] |
Specific – Sugar content based | Excise on distributors, importers & manufacturers (exempt producers with < 50 K liters/yr) [general budget] | South Africa [32] [national] | Policy paper for public consultation: July 2016 Draft legislation: Feb 2017 Enacted: Dec 2017 Implemented: 1 April 2018 | Based on Harmonised System (HS) tariff codes • Syrups and concentrates • Cocoa powder and milk extracts • Non-alcoholic waters, mineral, aerated or juices, with sugar or flavouring • Non-alcoholic beer | • Milk products (milk is the primary/first ingredient) • 100% fruit and/or vegetable juice | 2.1 SA cents per gram of sugar in excess of 4 g/100 ml based on ready-to-drink (reconstituted) form Products in taxable HS category with no sugar information will be taxed based on default of 20 g of sugar/100 ml in reconstituted form Indexed to inflation | Address high prevalence of diabetes, obesity and cardiovascular diseases [32, 33] | Reduce sugar consumption from beverages [32] |
Specific – Sugar type based | Excise on distributors, importers & manufacturers [general budget] | Philippines [34] [national] | Enacted: 19 Dec 2017 Implemented: 1 Jan 2018 | Sweetened pre-packaged: • Sweetened juice drinks • Sweetened tea • All carbonated beverages • Flavoured water • Energy and sports drinks • Powdered drinks not classified as milk, juice, tea or coffee • Cereal /grain beverages • Other non-alcoholic beverages with added sugar | • All milk products, whether powdered or in liquid form, sweetened or not • 3-in-1 coffee packs • 100% fruit and vegetable juices • beverages sweetened with stevia or coconut sugar. | Drinks with caloric and non-caloric sweeteners will be taxed 6 Ph Peso per litre. Drinks with high-fructose corn syrup taxed at 12 Ph Peso per litre. Not indexed to inflation | Generate revenue and fight obesity and diabetes and poor dental health Part of larger Tax Reform for Acceleration and Inclusion (TRAIN) Law [34] | Health measure to addressed poor oral health which results in poor school attendance and poor nutrition Improve tax collection and revenue generation [34] |