Table 1 Characteristics of included studies
From: Barriers and facilitators of patient centered care for immigrant and refugee women: a scoping review
Study | Objective | Design | Clinical topic | Participants (n) | Migrant type | Migrant origin | Specific to women (% women) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Harding [26] 2019 Australia | Barriers | Interviews | General | Clinicians (14) | Refugees | Syria, Iraq, Sudan, Burma | No |
Winn [27] 2018 Canada | Barriers, facilitators | Interviews | Maternity | Clinicians (10) | Refugees | Syria, Iraq, Eritrea, Congo, Afghanistan | Yes |
Mollah [28] 2018 Australia | Barriers, facilitators | Interviews | Mental health | Clinicians (20) | Immigrants and refugees | General | No |
Murray [29] 2018 Australia | Facilitators | Interviews | Medication | Patients (17) Clinicians (13) | Refugees | Bhutan | No (17.6) |
Hjorleifss [30] 2018 Norway | Facilitators | Focus groups | General | Clinicians (28) | Immigrants | Asia, South America, Europe | No |
Jones [31] 2018 United States | Barriers, facilitators | Interviews | General | Patients (20) | Immigrants | Mexico | No (65.0) |
Mohammadi [32] 2017 Sweden | Barriers | Interviews | Maternity | Patients (11) | Refugees | Afghanistan | Yes |
Paternotte [33] 2017 Netherlands | Facilitators | Interviews | General | Patients (30) | NR (“non-native”) | Surinam, Turkey, Morocco, Portugal, Indonesia, Iraq, China, Ireland, United States | No (not reported) |
Larsson [34] 2016 Sweden | Barriers | Interviews | Abortion | Clinicians (13) | Immigrants | General | Yes |
Paternotte [35] 2016 Netherlands | Barriers | Interviews | General | Clinicians (17) | NR (“non-native”) | Morocco, Turkey, Hungary, Nicaragua, Australia, Belgium, Pakistan, Nigeria | No |
Phillippi [36] 2016 United States | Facilitators | Interviews | Maternity | Patients (50) | Immigrants | Cambodia, Somalia, Syria, Iraq, Burma, Mexico, South America | Yes |
Clochesy [37] 2015 United States | Barriers | Focus groups | General | Patients (60) | Immigrants (31.7%) | Mexico, South America, Russia | No (46.7) |
De Jesus [38] 2014 United States | Facilitators | Focus groups | Mental health | Patients (48) | Immigrants | Brazil, Cape Verde (Portuguese) | No (50.0) |
Papic [39] 2012 Canada | Barriers, facilitators | Survey | General | Clinicians (598) | Immigrants | General | No |
Hasnain [40] 2011 United States | Barriers, facilitators | Survey | General | Patients (27) Clinicians (80) | Immigrants | General (Muslim) | Yes |
Lo [41] 2010 United States | Barriers | Interviews | General | Clinicians (24) | Immigrants | General | No |