Skip to main content

Table 1 Characteristics of included studies

From: Barriers and facilitators of patient centered care for immigrant and refugee women: a scoping review

StudyObjectiveDesignClinical topicParticipants (n)Migrant typeMigrant originSpecific to women
(% women)
Harding [26]
2019
Australia
BarriersInterviewsGeneralClinicians (14)RefugeesSyria, Iraq, Sudan, BurmaNo
Winn [27]
2018
Canada
Barriers, facilitatorsInterviewsMaternityClinicians (10)RefugeesSyria, Iraq, Eritrea, Congo, AfghanistanYes
Mollah [28]
2018
Australia
Barriers, facilitatorsInterviewsMental healthClinicians (20)Immigrants and refugeesGeneralNo
Murray [29]
2018
Australia
FacilitatorsInterviewsMedicationPatients (17)
Clinicians (13)
RefugeesBhutanNo (17.6)
Hjorleifss [30]
2018
Norway
FacilitatorsFocus groupsGeneralClinicians (28)ImmigrantsAsia, South America, EuropeNo
Jones [31]
2018
United States
Barriers, facilitatorsInterviewsGeneralPatients (20)ImmigrantsMexicoNo (65.0)
Mohammadi [32]
2017
Sweden
BarriersInterviewsMaternityPatients (11)RefugeesAfghanistanYes
Paternotte [33]
2017
Netherlands
FacilitatorsInterviewsGeneralPatients (30)NR (“non-native”)Surinam, Turkey, Morocco, Portugal, Indonesia, Iraq, China, Ireland, United StatesNo (not reported)
Larsson [34]
2016
Sweden
BarriersInterviewsAbortionClinicians (13)ImmigrantsGeneralYes
Paternotte [35]
2016
Netherlands
BarriersInterviewsGeneralClinicians (17)NR (“non-native”)Morocco, Turkey, Hungary, Nicaragua, Australia, Belgium, Pakistan, NigeriaNo
Phillippi [36]
2016
United States
FacilitatorsInterviewsMaternityPatients (50)ImmigrantsCambodia, Somalia, Syria, Iraq, Burma, Mexico, South AmericaYes
Clochesy [37]
2015
United States
BarriersFocus groupsGeneralPatients (60)Immigrants (31.7%)Mexico, South America, RussiaNo (46.7)
De Jesus [38]
2014
United States
FacilitatorsFocus groupsMental healthPatients (48)ImmigrantsBrazil, Cape Verde (Portuguese)No (50.0)
Papic [39]
2012
Canada
Barriers, facilitatorsSurveyGeneralClinicians (598)ImmigrantsGeneralNo
Hasnain [40]
2011
United States
Barriers, facilitatorsSurveyGeneralPatients (27)
Clinicians (80)
ImmigrantsGeneral (Muslim)Yes
Lo [41]
2010
United States
BarriersInterviewsGeneralClinicians (24)ImmigrantsGeneralNo