Skip to main content

Table 1 Baseline characteristics of study participants by allocation group collected from July 19, 2017 until October 10, 2017, across all 4 study sites in Landhi Town, Karachi

From: Effect of vaccine reminder and tracker bracelets on routine childhood immunization coverage and timeliness in urban Pakistan (2017-18): a randomized controlled trial

 

Intervention A: Adapted Alma Sana Bracelet

(n = 482)

Intervention B: Star Bracelet

(n = 482)

Control

(n = 481)

Total

(n = 1445)

Age at BCG (in weeks), m (SD)

2.6 ± (2.4)

2.6 ± (2.6)

2.4 ± (2.2)

2.5 ± (2.4)

Enrolment Vaccine, n(%)

 BCG

217 (45.0)

200 (41.5)

216 (44.9)

633 (43.8)

 Penta-1

265 (55.0)

282 (58.5)

265 (55.1)

812 (56.2)

Female Child, n(%)

257 (53.3)

237 (49.2)

243 (50.5)

737 (51.0)

Age of Mother (in years), m (SD)

26.7 ± (4.7)

26.5 ± (4.6)

26.5 ± (4.7)

26.6 ± (4.6)

Age of Father (in years), m (SD)

31.8 ± (5.6)

31.6 ± (5.6)

31.9 ± (5.8)

31.8 ± (5.7)

Education of Father (in years), n(%)

 0 years

65 (13.5)

57 (11.8)****

87 (18.1)

209 (14.5)

 1 - 5 years

28 (5.8)

37 (7.7)

35 (7.3)

100 (6.9)

 6 - 10 years

255 (52.9)***

251 (52.1)*

218 (45.3)

724 (50.1)

 11 – 12 years

96 (19.9)

77 (16.0)

83 (17.3)

256 (17.7)

 ≥ 13 years

38 (7.9)**

60 (12.4)

58 (12.0)

156 (10.8)

Mean years, m (SD)

8.8 ± (4.2)

8.9 ± (4.2)

8.4 ± (4.7)

8.7 + (4.4)

Education of Mother (in years), n(%)

 0 years

86 (17.8)

76 (15.8)

84 (17.5)

246 (17.0)

 1 - 5 years

56 (11.6)

49 (10.2)

56 (11.6)

161 (11.1)

 6 - 10 years

221 (45.9)

233 (48.3)

219 (45.5)

673 (46.6)

 11 - 12 years

79 (16.4)

83 (17.2)

73 (15.2)

235 (16.3)

 ≥ 13 years

40 (8.3)

41 (8.5)

49 (10.2)

130 (9.0)

Mean years, m (SD)

7.9 ± (4.5)

8.3 ± (4.4)

8.1 ± (4.5)

8.1 ± (4.5)

Father’s Occupation, n(%)

 Unskilled

74 (15.4)

81 (16.8)

90 (18.7)

245 (17.0)

 Skilled Labor

124 (25.7)

144 (29.8)

135 (28.1)

403 (27.9)

 Retail/Sales job

84 (17.4)

88 (18.3)

71 (14.8)

243 (16.8)

 Private job

104 (21.9)

88 (18.3)

97 (20.2)

289 (20.0)

 Other

96 (19.9)

81 (16.8)

88 (18.3)

265 (18.3)

Mother’s occupation, n(%)

 Housewife

477 (99.0)

481 (99.8)

476 (99.0)

1434 (99.2)

 Other

5 (1.0)

1 (0.2)

5 (1.0)

11 (0.8)

Ethnicity, n(%)

 Urdu

289 (60.0)

276 (57.3)

293 (60.9)

858 (59.4)

 Pashto

80 (16.6)

76 (15.8)

86 (17.9)

242 (16.8)

 Hindko

51 (10.6)

57 (11.8)

46 (9.6)

154 (10.7)

 Punjabi

20 (4.2)

28 (5.8)

30 (6.2)

78 (5.4)

 Sindhi

10 (2.1)

10 (2.1)

8 (1.7)

28 (1.9)

 Other

32 (6.6)*

35 (7.3)***

18 (3.7)

85 (5.9)

Household Income per month (USD), m (SD)

176.8 ± (106)

175.3 ± (78)

173.0 ± (102)

175.0 ± (96.0)

Number of family members, m (SD)

8.0 ± (4.4)

8.2 ± (5.0)

8.3 ± (4.9)

8.2 ± (4.8)

Number of live births by child’s mother, m (SD)

2.5 ± (1.6)

2.5 ± (1.4)

2.6 ± (1.5)

2.6 ± (1.5)

Number of ANC visits by mother during last pregnancy, m (SD)

7.2 ± (3.2)

7.6 ± (3.2)***

7.1 ± (3.0)

7.3 ± (3.1)

Place of delivery of child, n(%)

 Health Facility

440 (91.3)

431 (89.4)

444 (92.3)

1315 (91.0)

 Home

42 (8.7)

51 (10.6)

37 (7.7)

130 (9.0)

Who delivered child, n(%)

 Doctor

430 (89.2)

420 (87.1)

433 (90.0)

1283 (88.8)

 Midwife

34 (7.1)

47 (9.8)

33 (6.9)

114 (7.9)

 Nurse

16 (3.3)

14 (2.9)

12 (2.5)

42 (2.9)

 Other

2 (0.4)

1 (0.2)

3 (0.6)

6 (0.4)

Child has been breastfed (Yes), n(%)

457 (94.8)

453 (94.0)

455 (94.6)

1365 (94.5)

  1. *p < 0.05; **p < 0.04; ***p < 0.02; **** p < 0.01
  2. BCG Bacille Calmette Guérin, SD Standard Deviation, m mean, ANC Antenatal Care, USD US Dollar