Skip to main content

Table 1 Characteristics of the included articles

From: Utilization of public health care by people with private health insurance: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Author, year of publication

Full Report or Abstract

Country

Study Design

Study Population

Target Exposure Group

Target Control Group (s)

Target Outcome(s)

Abougergi et al. [14] 2019

Full report

The United States

Retrospective cohort study

Patients with nonvariceal upper gastrointestinal hemorrhage

Private insurance

Nondisabled public insurance

Inpatient service (LOS)

Abraham et al. [15] 2014

Full report

The United States

Retrospective cohort study

The Affordable Care Act (ACA) target population

Private insurance

Public insurance and no insurance

Outpatient service (ED visit and outpatient visit) and inpatient service (rate of hospitalization)

Abraham et al. [16] 2017

Abstract

India

Retrospective cohort study

Patients with breast, oral and ovarian cancer

Private insurance

No insurance and two kinds of public insurance

Outpatient service (outpatient visits)

Abraham et al. [17] 2017

Abstract

India

Retrospective cohort study

Patients with breast cancer

Private insurance

No insurance and public insurance

Inpatient service (LOS)

Araujo et al. [18] 2017

Full report

Brazil

Retrospective case control study

Adults ā‰„18ā€‰years of age.

Private health insurance

No private insurance

Outpatient service (outpatient visits) and inpatient services (rate of hospitalization)

Bhandari et al. [19] 2018

Abstract

The United States

Retrospective cohort study

Adults aged 18ā€“64ā€‰years

Commercial insurance (qualified health plans, QHPs)

Public insurance (Medicaid)

Outpatient service (ED visit and outpatient visit) and inpatient service (rate of hospitalization)

Cunningham et al. [20] 2018

Full text

The United States

Retrospective cohort study

Population of California counties

Private insurance

No insurance and public insurance

Outpatient service (outpatient visits) and inpatient services (rate of hospitalization)

Dabbous et al. [21] 2014

Abstract

The United States

Retrospective cohort study

Adult diabetic patients

Private insurance

No insurance and public insurance

Outpatient service (outpatient visits)

Fontenelle et al. [22] 2018

Full report

Brazil

Retrospective cohort study

Household survey population

Private health insurance

No insurance coverage

Outpatient service (outpatient visits)

Gandhi et al. [23] 2014

Full report

The United States

Retrospective case control study

Patients with non-emergency visits

Private health insurance

No insurance and public insurance (Medicare and Medicaid)

Outpatient service (outpatient visits)

Ginde et al. [24] 2012

Full report

The United States

Cross-sectional household interview survey

noninstitutionalized US civilian population

Private insurance

Public insurance (Medicare and Medicaid)

Outpatient service (ED visit)

Halpern et al. [25] 2011

Full report

The United States

Retrospective cohort study

Individuals with epilepsy

Private insurance

No insurance and public insurance (Medicare and Medicaid)

Outpatient service (ED visit and outpatient visit) and inpatient service (inpatient LOS and rate of hospitalization)

Hasegawa et al. [26] 2014

Full report

The United States

Retrospective case control study

Patients ages 18 to 54ā€‰years with acute asthma

Private health insurance

No health insurance and public health insurance

Outpatient service (ED visit)

Henke et al. [27] 2013

Full report

The United States

Retrospective cohort study

Inpatient patients

Private health insurance

Public insurance (Medicare)

Inpatient service (LOS)

Hullegie et al. [28] 2010

Full report

Germany

Retrospective cohort study

West German individuals

Private insurance

Public insurance

Outpatient service (outpatient visit) and inpatient service (inpatient LOS)

Jeon et al. [29] 2013

Full report

South Korea

Retrospective cohort study

Adults participating in Korea Health Panel Survey (KHPS)

Private insurance

No private insurance

Outpatient service (outpatient visit) and inpatient service (inpatient LOS and rate of hospitalization)

Leach et al. [30] 2012

Full report

Australia

Retrospective cohort study

Participants aged 15ā€“93ā€‰years old

Private health insurance

No insurance

Outpatient service (outpatient visit)

Mandsager et al. [31] 2015

Full report

The United States

Retrospective cohort study

Health center patients

Private insurance

Public insurance

Outpatient service (outpatient visit)

Pomerantz et al. [32] 2013

Abstract

Brazil

Retrospective cohort study

Survey adults in Brazil

Private insurance

Public insurance

Outpatient service (ED visits) and inpatient service (inpatient LOS and rate of hospitalization)

Rice et al. [33] 2014

Full report

The United States

Retrospective cohort study

Diabetic Patients

private/employer-sponsored insurance (ESI)

Public insurance (Medicaid)

Outpatient service (ED visits) and inpatient service (inpatient LOS)

Sarkar et al. [34] 2017

Full report

The United States

Retrospective cohort study

Population of children with special health care needs (CSHCN) in Ohio

Private insurance

Public insurance (Medicaid)

Outpatient service (ED visits) and inpatient service (rate of hospitalization)

Shmueli et al. [35] 2014

Full report

Australia

Retrospective cohort study

Inpatients of the public New South Wales hospitals

Private insurance

Public insurance

Inpatient service (inpatient LOS)

Terveen et al. [36] 2015

Abstract

The United States

Retrospective cohort study

Pediatric ophthalmic inpatients

Private insurance

Public insurance (Medicaid)

Inpatient service (inpatient LOS)

Yoshioka et al. [37] 2010

Full report

Japan

Retrospective cohort study

Community-dwelling frail elderly people

Private insurance provided by private care management agencies

Public insurance provided by social welfare corporations or public agencies)

Outpatient service (outpatient visit)

You et al. [38] 2018

Full report

South Korea

Retrospective cohort study

Diabetes outpatients

Supplementary private health insurance (SPHI)

Without SPHI

Outpatient service (outpatient visits) and inpatient services (rate of hospitalization)

Young et al. [39] 2009

Full report

The United States

Retrospective cohort study

Children with autism

Private insurance

Public insurance (Medicaid)

Outpatient service (outpatient visits)

  1. Abbreviations: LOS length of stay, ED emergency department