Skip to main content

Table 3 Comparison of Mental Health Practice concerning patients seen during one week for General Practitioners, Private and Public Psychiatrists.

From: Differing mental health practice among general practitioners, private psychiatrists and public psychiatrists

 

Patients of General Practitioners

Patients of private psychiatrists

Patients of public psychiatrists

Chi2 test or ANOVA

New patients (N = 603) (Percentage of MHP patients)

N = 439 (28.9%)

N = 73 (6.1%)

N = 91 (15.1%)

 

Patient recruitment (%)

   

<0.0001

Patient

88.4

61.6

42.8

 

Family

14.1

23.3

17.6

 

GPs

0.0

26.0

24.2

 

Psychiatrist

0.0

6.8

19.8

 

Percentage of patients who consulted too late according to the professional (%)

25.2

60.7

52.6

<0.0001

Care project = management by the professional (%)

70.2

89.1

88.6

<0.0001

Wish for collaboration with another physician (%)

42.3

9.6

61.1

<0.0001

Patients already known (N= 2724) (Percentage of MHP patients)

N = 1079 (71.1%)

N = 1130 (93.9%)

N = 515 (84.9%)

 

Mean days from last consultation (sd)

36.4 (34.9)

17.6 (16.4)

25.7 (18.5)

<0.0001

Collaboration with other professionals (%)

26.3

29.6

53.4

<0.0001

Type of care (%)

    

Pharmacological treatment

-

18.9

51.5

 

Psychotherapy

-

52.9

16.8

 

Both

-

28.2

31.8

Â