Theme Sub-theme | Summary definition | Study reference by infection context and study population | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
SARS | Non-pandemic | H1N1 2009 pandemic | |||||||
S1 | S2 | N1 | N2 | P1 | P2 | P3 | |||
1 | Perceived benefits of non-pharmaceutical interventions | ||||||||
a | Hand and respiratory hygiene is common sense/familiar | Hygiene behaviours are seen as familiar and acceptable in varying contexts and populations | [50] | [43] | |||||
b | Mask wearing demonstrates responsibility and reduces stigma | Mask wearing is seen as a way of visibly demonstrating one’s desire to protect self and others from infection, which can in turn reduce social stigma experienced. | [45] | ||||||
c | Social isolation and distancing are socially responsible actions | Isolation and distancing are believed to be socially responsible actions and seen as necessary for the protection of society as a whole | [36] | ||||||
2 | Perceived disadvantages of non-pharmaceutical interventions | ||||||||
a | Hand washing for respiratory infection control is irrelevant | Additional hand washing behaviours are seen as irrelevant by those who class themselves as regular hand washers | [41] | ||||||
b | Hand washing and mask wearing can attract social stigma | Hand washing and mask wearing are perceived as socially unacceptable due to the potential to attract discrimination and embarrassment | [40] | [41] | [47] | ||||
c | Non-pharmaceutical behaviours have negative personal and socioeconomic impacts | Perceived physical, practical, emotional and socioeconomic costs of isolation social distancing, mask wearing and hygiene behaviours | [47] | [50] | |||||
3 | Personal/cultural beliefs about infection transmission | ||||||||
Common beliefs about respiratory infections are caught and spread e.g. via air, from symptomatic others and in cold temperatures | [36] | [40] | [43] | ||||||
4 | Diagnostic uncertainty in emerging respiratory infections | ||||||||
Identifying symptoms of and having to diagnose infection in an emerging respiratory infection is seen as confusing and concerning and can lead to uncertainty about when to adopt infection control | [43] | ||||||||
5 | Perceived vulnerability to respiratory infections | ||||||||
a | Perceived health status | Evaluating one’s vulnerability to respiratory infection in terms of own perceived health status and the health of others | |||||||
b | Proximity to the origin of outbreak | Evaluating susceptibility to a new respiratory infection in terms of geographical proximity to the origin of the outbreak and type of living environment | [40] | ||||||
6 | Anxiety about emerging respiratory infections | ||||||||
a | Decreasing anxiety over the course of an outbreak | Initial anxiety in an outbreak decreases over the course of the outbreak as public reassess the risk/impact of a new respiratory infection according to personal experience vs. information presented in the media | [40] | [43] | |||||
b | High anxiety if perceived to be more vulnerable | Greater anxiety experienced during H1N1 by those who perceived themselves to be more vulnerable to infection. | [43] | ||||||
c | Low anxiety | Low levels of worry experienced during an emerging respiratory infection outbreak | [43] | ||||||
7 | Communications about emerging respiratory infections | ||||||||
a | Media reporting of information on new respiratory infection outbreaks is seen overhyped | People appraise the credibility of information/communications about a new respiratory outbreak in terms of consistency of information and perceived exaggeration compared to actual/previous experience | [40] | [43] | |||||
b | Official communication about new respiratory infection outbreaks is not reliable (threat is downplayed) | Some people’s evaluation of information influenced by scepticism about level of detail presented (i.e. not being given all the facts) | [50] | [43] |