Table 1 Description of selected articles
From: Transferability of interventions in health education: a review
Authors | Year | Using transferability term | Types of articles | Theme | Detail |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Zubrick[15] | 2005 | yes | intervention | mental health | provides adaptation modalities |
Belansky[16] | 2006 | yes | intervention | nutrition and physical activity | provides adaptation modalities |
Frijiling[48] | 2003 | no | intervention | cardiovascular diseases | efficacy studies |
Tsey[18] | 2005 | yes | intervention | global health | provides adaptation modalities |
Glasgow[26] | 2004 | no | theoretical and/or methodological | all themes | about REAIM model/tool |
Roush[17] | 2009 | yes | theoretical and/or methodological | all themes | about RCT models and transferability factors |
Rychetnik[19] | 2002 | yes | theoretical and/or methodological | all themes | about transferability factors and quality of evidence |
Wang[3] | 2006 | yes | theoretical and/or methodological | all themes | about limits of RCT model and transferability factors |
Heller[56] | 2008 | yes | theoretical and/or methodological | all themes | about external validity |
Zeicmeister[41] | 2008 | no | theoretical and/or methodological | mental health | about limits of RCT model and need for qualitative evaluation |
Blackstock[49] | 2007 | no | intervention | BPCO | efficacy studies |
Gray[50] | 2000 | no | intervention | alcohol | efficacy studies |
Malterud 2001[20] | 2001 | yes | theoretical and/or methodological | all themes | about qualitative studies |
Elford[21] | 2003 | yes | theoretical and/or methodological | HIV | external validity, limits of RCT models, and transferability factors |
Nielsen[51] | 2008 | no | intervention | nutrition | efficacy studies |
Glasgow[33] | 2003 | no | intervention | diabetes | about process evaluation and use of RE-AIM model |
Hautmann[52] | 2008 | no | intervention | mental health | provides adaptation modalities |
Flowers[22] | 2002 | yes | intervention | HIV | efficacy studies |
Cattan[23] | 2005 | yes | review | loneliness | assesses the transferability of several studies |
Victora[25] | 2004 | no | theoretical and/or methodological | all themes | type of studies, limits of RCT models, dose-intervention and dose response |
Estabrooks[28] | 2003 | no | theoretical and/or methodological | physical activity | focuses on a tool to assess external validity : RE-AIM model/tool |
Baranowski[31] | 2000 | no | review | nutrition | analysis of intervention process, about qualitative evaluation |
Buijs[32] | 2003 | no | intervention | global health and seniors | analysis of intervention process, about qualitative evaluation |
Glasgow[27] | 2003 | no | theoretical and/or methodological | all themes | about RE-AIM model and contextual factors |
Glasgow[55] | 2006 | yes | theoretical and/or methodological | all themes | about RE-AIM model and contextual factors |
Spoth[34] | 2008 | no | theoretical and/or methodological | global health, teenagers | evidence-based public health and translational research |
Klesges[35] | 2008 | no | review | obesity | efficacy studies |
Reinschmidt[40] | 2010 | no | review | diabetes | accounting for adaptations of an experimental study |
Lorig[53] | 2004 | no | intervention | patient education | provides adaptation modalities |
Perrin[45] | 2006 | no | intervention | patient education | providing adaptation modalities |
Kwak[36] | 2005 | no | theoretical and/or methodological | global health | transferability factors, notably focused on participation rate |
Cohen[29] | 2008 | no | theoretical and/or methodological | global health | focuses on the RE-AIM model, types of adaptation, the need to drive evaluation in real settings |
Card[46] | 2009 | no | theoretical and/or methodological | HIV | describes adaptation process in seven steps |
Feldstein[37] | 2008 | no | theoretical and/or methodological | all themes | describes PRISM model to assess external validity |
Bull[38] | 2003 | no | review | all themes | uses RE-AIM model |
Chen[30] | 2009 | no | theoretical and/or methodological | all themes | limits of Campbellian model and RCT model |
Stevens[24] | 2001 | yes | review | mental health | provides adaptation modalities |
Cuijpers[47] | 2005 | no | theoretical and/or methodological | all themes | transferability factors |
Mukoma[44] | 2009 | no | intervention | HIV | process intervention |
Eakin[39] | 2002 | no | review | obesity | uses RE-AIM model |
Rimer[42] | 2001 | no | theoretical and/or methodological | all themes | evidence-based public health, limits of RCT models |
Dzewaltowski[54] | 2004 | no | theoretical and/or methodological | physical activity | describes interest of using REAIM model |
Dzewaltowski[43] | 2004 | no | theoretical and/or methodological | all themes | describes interest of using RE-AIM model |