Skip to main content

Advertisement

Table 1 Summary of all 'included' studies (Alphabetical order by first named author)

From: The effectiveness of health appraisal processes currently in addressing health and wellbeing during spatial plan appraisal: a systematic review

Study identification Author, year of publication Country Internal validity score ++/+/- External validity score ++/+/- Appraisal type Subject of Appraisal
Corburn, J. & Bhatia, R. (2007)[5] USA + ++ HIA/IA Urban housing redevelopment
Dannenberg, A., et al. (2008)[6] USA + + HIA 1. Rincon Hill Area Plan 2004 - Area plan for new downtown residential neighbourhood
      2. Eastern Community Neighbourhoods Community 2006
      3. City of Decatur community transportation plan 2007
      4. National petroleum reserve - Alaska - oil development plan, Alaska 2007
      5. Derby redevelopment 2007 Masterplan, zoning ordinance, design guidelines and budget request for community development project
Douglas, M., et al. (2001)[7] UK + + HIA Draft Local Transport Strategy
Douglas, M., et al. (2007)[8] UK + + HIA 1. West Yorkshire Local Transport Plan (2000)
      2. City of Edinburgh Council's Urban Transport Strategy (2000)
      3. London Mayoral Strategy on Transport (2000)
      4. Thurrock Local Tranport Plan (2001)
      5. The 2003 West Midlands Local Transport Plan (2003)
Farhang, L, et al. (2008) [9] USA + ++ HIA Rezoning plan for the Eastern Neighborhoods of San Francisco
Fischer, T., et al. (2009) [10] UK/Germany + ++ SA/SEA 1. Scoping Report and Core Strategy Preferred Options Report
      2. Local Transport Plan 2
     SA/SEA SA 3. Scoping Report and the Key Issues and Strategy Options for a Local Development Plan
      4. Regional plan of Western Saxony 2008
      5. Draft local statutory land use plan of Leipzig 2005
      6. Structure vision for Emmen
France, C. (2004)[11] UK + + HIA Review of adopted Structure Plan policies and revision of emerging Structure Plan.
Glasgow Centre for Population Health (2007) [12] UK + - HIA Draft Local Development Strategy
Gow, A., & Dubois, L. (2007) [13] Australia + + HIA Two potential residential developments
Greig, S., et al. (2004) [14] UK + + HIA Planning study of motorway corridor to inform a regeneration investment strategy
Kørnøv, L. (2009) [15] Denmark + ++ SEA Review of 100 Danish SEAs
Ng, K., & Obbard, J. (2005) [16] Hong Kong + + SEA Strategic planning case studies:
      1. territorial development strategy review
      2. third comprehensive transport study
Mathias, K., & Harris-Roxas, B. (2009) [17] NZ + + HIA Greater Christchurch Urban development strategy
Mindell, J., et al. (2004) [18] UK + + HIA Draft Transport Strategy
Neville, L., et al. (2005) [19] Australia + + HIA Shellharbour Foreshore Management Plan, environment management plan with some land use issues
Planning Advisory Service (2008) [20] UK + + EqIA Final draft masterplan to inform the Sustainability Appraisal of plan
Plant, P., et al. (2007) [21] UK + - IIA Further Alterations to The London Plan
Stevenson, A., et al. (2007) [22] NZ + + HIA Greater Christchurch Urban Development Strategy 2005
Tennant, K and Newman, C. (2007) [23] Australia + + HIA Greater Granville Regeneration Strategy
Wismar, M., et al. (2007) [24] UK, Finland, NL + ++ HIA/SIA 1. Draft Air Quality Action Plan
      2. Detailed local plan for Korteniitty - complement an existing residential area with low and dense construction
      3. Plan for restructuring an industrial area into a residential area