Chlamydia trachomatis prevalence in undocumented migrants undergoing voluntary termination of pregnancy: a prospective cohort study

  • Hans Wolff1, 3Email author,

    Affiliated with

    • Ana Lourenço2,

      Affiliated with

      • Patrick Bodenmann3,

        Affiliated with

        • Manuella Epiney2,

          Affiliated with

          • Monique Uny2,

            Affiliated with

            • Nicole Andreoli2,

              Affiliated with

              • Olivier Irion2,

                Affiliated with

                • Jean-Michel Gaspoz1 and

                  Affiliated with

                  • Jean-Bernard Dubuisson2

                    Affiliated with

                    BMC Public Health20088:391

                    DOI: 10.1186/1471-2458-8-391

                    Received: 31 July 2008

                    Accepted: 24 November 2008

                    Published: 24 November 2008

                    Abstract

                    Background

                    Chlamydia trachomatis infection (CTI) is the most frequent sexual transmitted disease (STI) in Switzerland but its prevalence in undocumented migrants is unknown. We aimed to compare CTI prevalence among undocumented migrants undergoing termination of pregnancy (ToP) to the prevalence among women with residency permit.

                    Methods

                    This prospective cohort study included all pregnant, undocumented women presenting from March 2005 to October 2006 to the University hospital for ToP. The control group consisted of a systematic sample of pregnant women with legal residency permit coming to the same hospital during the same time period for ToP

                    Results

                    One hundred seventy five undocumented women and 208 women with residency permit (controls) were included in the study. Mean ages were 28.0 y (SD 5.5) and 28.2 y (SD 7.5), respectively (p = 0.77). Undocumented women came primarily from Latin-America (78%). Frequently, they lacked contraception (23%, controls 15%, OR 1.8, 95% CI 1.04;2.9). Thirteen percent of undocumented migrants were found to have CTI (compared to 4.4% of controls; OR 3.2, 95% CI 1.4;7.3).

                    Conclusion

                    This population of undocumented, pregnant migrants consisted primarily of young, Latino-American women. Compared to control women, undocumented migrants showed higher prevalence rates of genital CTI, which indicates that health professionals should consider systematic screening for STI in this population. There is a need to design programs providing better access to treatment and education and to increase migrants' awareness of the importance of contraception and transmission of STI.

                    Background

                    Geneva (Switzerland), as one of the wealthiest areas of the world, is a common target of illegal migration. Most of these undocumented migrants, also called "illegals" or "clandestines", leave their home country because of difficult economic conditions. An estimated 8,000 to 12,000 undocumented migrants, who lack legal residential permit, live and work in the canton of Geneva [1], representing 1.4 to 3.5% of the 434,500 resident population. Because of their difficult living conditions, separation from their families, permanent threat of being caught by the police, and exclusion from the health care system, it is reasonable to believe that undocumented migrants are in poor health. Since undocumented migrants do not have any social protection, unintended pregnancy may place them at risk when associated with loss of work and income. Previous studies of undocumented migrants delivering in Geneva found a high rate of unintended pregnancies (75 to 83%) and inadequate contraceptive use [2, 3].

                    Chlamydia trachomatis infection (CTI) is the principal cause of sexually transmitted infections (STI) in the developed world [4]. CTI is frequently asymptomatic but may have serious sequelae if untreated, such as chronic pelvic pain, ectopic pregnancy, and pelvic inflammatory disease with subsequent risk of infertility.

                    Surveillance data based on declaration of the Swiss national laboratory reports showed an increase in the number of CTI diagnosed by approximately 50% between 1999 and 2005 [5]. Nevertheless, the precise burden of disease remains unclear. A prevalence study among Swiss gynaecologists including 772 sexually active women found a CTI prevalence of 2.8% [6]. This study revealed an important degree of underreporting by the national laboratory reports, which are the only source of national data on CTI in Switzerland. In Europe, CTI prevalence is estimated at 3.4% in asymptomatic women [7] and 5 to 12% for women undergoing termination of pregnancy (ToP) [79]. Studies in Latin America show CTI prevalence rates of 1.9% to 4.5% in Chile, Peru, Brazil, and Mexico [4, 10, 11] and 12.2% in women attending family planning clinics [4, 12].

                    The aim of the present study is to compare the prevalence of CTI in women with and without legal residency permit undergoing ToP in Geneva, Switzerland.

                    Methods

                    Voluntary ToP in Switzerland

                    In Switzerland, termination of pregnancy up to 12 weeks after onset of amenorrhea is available at women's request when performed by a trained gynaecologist in an authorised public or private clinic. ToP must be declared anonymously to health authorities and medical expenses are covered by general mandatory health insurance.

                    Health care facility offering free access to health care

                    Since 1996, a health care facility offers medical care for free or at low cost to undocumented migrants in Geneva. It has no formal administrative requirements and has a high visibility among the local migrant population, reaching the majority of pregnant, undocumented, and uninsured women [13]. The health care facility refers all undocumented women to the Woman's University Hospital where they can receive free care.

                    Study plan and population

                    Undocumented migrants

                    Between March 2005 and October 2006, this prospective cohort study included all undocumented pregnant women requesting ToP and presenting to the Woman's University Hospital, which is the only public woman's hospital in Geneva. In 2003, 74% of the 1,413 ToP's in Geneva were performed in this hospital. All women requesting ToP, including those presenting directly to the hospital, met with two coordinating nurses.

                    Control group

                    The control group consisted of a systematic sample of women with legal residency permit and mandatory health insurance undergoing ToP at the Woman's University Hospital. The undocumented migrants and the control group were assigned to the same nurses. Patient sampling occurred during predetermined days, from November 2005 to May 2006. In each pre-selected day, all women were asked to be included in the study.

                    Exclusion criteria

                    We excluded women who could not communicate in French, Spanish, or English. Women attending the free health care facility but not considered to be undocumented migrants (e.g. tourists) were excluded.

                    Questionnaire and blood tests

                    Two specially trained nurses speaking all three study languages administered a socio-demographic questionnaire in a face-to-face interview. The questionnaire included 21 questions about age, health insurance, nationality, education, civil status, duration of stay in Geneva, and contraceptive methods. CTI was assessed by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) performed on cervical swabs.

                    Ethical considerations

                    All undocumented migrants and controls gave written consent. The study was approved by the ethical research committee of the Geneva University Hospitals (no 05058-CD).

                    Main outcomes and potential confounders

                    The main study outcome was CTI. The main potential confounding factors were considered to be age, Latin American origin, civil status, and education.

                    Statistical analysis

                    In order to investigate the relationship between legal status and the main outcome, we first used 2 × 2 tables and performed Chi-square and Fisher's exact tests to compare proportions for categorical variables and unpaired student's t-tests to compare means for continuous variables. We performed the same analyses after stratifying for potential confounding factors. Finally we used multiple logistic regression analysis adjusting systematically for age and those confounding factors that remained statistically significant (p < 0.05) in the models. All analyses were performed using SPSS for Windows (version 15.0).

                    Missing data

                    Missing data are indicated in the tables. Only those study participants who had relevant complete data were included in the statistical analyses.

                    Results

                    During 20 months (from March 2005 to October 2006), 1596 adult women underwent ToP at the Woman's University Hospital, of which 255 were undocumented migrants. One hundred seventy five (67%) accepted participation in the study, and 208 (85%) of 244 controls were selected for the study. As illustrated in Figure 1, 80 undocumented women (33%, mean age 32.3 years, range 17–47) and 36 controls (15%, mean age 29.4 years, range 18–46) refused participation, mainly because of lack of time.
                    http://static-content.springer.com/image/art%3A10.1186%2F1471-2458-8-391/MediaObjects/12889_2008_Article_1361_Fig1_HTML.jpg
                    Figure 1

                    Flow-chart illustrating the selection of undocumented migrants vs. women with legal residency status (control group) who had voluntary termination of pregnancy (ToP) at the Geneva University Hospital, Switzerland between March 2005 and October 2006.

                    Socio-demographic characteristics

                    The socio-demographic characteristics are summarized in Table 1. Age was similar in both study groups (28 years, p = 0.77). Seventy-eight percent of the undocumented women came from Latin America and had lived in Geneva for approximately 4 years. The control group was primarily composed of Europeans (82%). Years of education were similar in both groups (12.3 vs 12.8 years, p = 0.19).
                    Table 1

                    Sociodemographic characteristics of undocumented migrants vs. women with legal residency status (control group) who had voluntary termination of pregnancy (ToP) at the Geneva University Hospitals, Switzerland between March 2005 and October 2006

                    Characteristic

                    or measurement

                    Undocumented

                    (n = 175)

                    Missing

                    n (%)

                    Control group

                    (n = 208)

                    Missing

                    n (%)

                    p-value

                    Mean age in years (SD)

                    28.0 (5.5)

                    0

                    28.2 (7.5)

                    0

                    0.77

                    Continent of origin (%)

                    Latin America 78.2, Europe 0.6, Asia 8.0, Africa 13.2

                    1 (0.6)

                    Europe 82.0, Lat.-America 7.3, Africa 8.7, Asia 1.5, Australia 0.5

                    2 (1.0)

                    <0.001

                    Nationality (%)

                    Bolivia 43.3, Brazil 13.7, Equator 9.1, Cameroun 6.3, Mongolia 4.0, Philippines 2.3, Colombia 2.9

                    1 (0.6)

                    Switzerland 51.9, Portugal 11.1, France 5.8, Brazil 3.4, Spain 2.9

                    2 (1.0)

                    <0.001

                    Civil status:

                        

                    <0.001

                       Single

                    69.5%

                    1 (0.6)

                    79.9%

                    6 (2.9)

                     

                       Married

                    17.2%

                    1 (0.6)

                    19.8%

                    6 (2.9)

                     

                       Divorced

                    12.6%

                    1 (0.6)

                    0.5%

                    6 (2.9)

                     

                       Widowed

                    0.6%

                    1 (0.6)

                    0%

                    6 (2.9)

                     

                    Education:

                         

                       Education years (SD)

                    12.3 (3.3)

                    12 (6.9)

                    12.8 (3.5)

                    2 (1.0)

                    0.19

                       Highest achieved education:

                        

                    0.006

                    Primary school

                    5.5%

                    12 (6.9)

                    1.5%

                    2 (1.0)

                     

                    Secondary school

                    40.5%

                    12 (6.9)

                    56.3%

                    2 (1.0)

                     

                    High school degree

                    34.4%

                    12 (6.9)

                    24.3%

                    2 (1.0)

                     

                    University

                    19.6%

                    12 (6.9)

                    18.0%

                    2 (1.0)

                     

                    Years living in Geneva (SD)

                    3.8 (7.4)

                    4 (2.3)

                    14.8 (10.6)

                    3 (1.4)

                    <0.001

                    Contraception and ToP

                    As shown in table 2, undocumented migrants had their first contact with a health professional one week later than controls (8.0 vs. 6.9 weeks of pregnancy, p < 0.001). Insecure contraceptive methods (condoms, withdrawal, calendar) were frequent in both study groups, used by 83.6% of the undocumented migrants and 75.7% of the controls. No difference between the study groups could be observed concerning condom use and withdrawal (coitus interruptus). However, undocumented migrants more frequently used the calendar method (29.9% vs 17%, OR 2.2, 95% CI 1.3;3.8). Furthermore, compared to controls, almost twice as many undocumented women did not use any contraceptive method (OR 1.8, CI:1.0;2.9), and only half of them used the contraceptive pill during the month of conception (OR 2.1, 95% CI 1.1;3.8). Stated reasons for absence of contraception in undocumented migrants were: infrequent intercourse, 22%; short term contraception interruption (running out of pills, pill side effects, or lack of money to buy pills), 20%; belief of being infertile, 16%; partner had refused to use condoms, 10%; lacking knowledge on contraceptive methods, 6%; and not knowing where to get contraception, 6%. Other reasons noted to explain the absence of contraception were: "I didn't think about it", "latent wish of pregnancy but planned for later", and "presumed sterility of the partner".
                    Table 2

                    Access to care, contraception, chlamydia trachomatis infection, history and type of voluntary pregnancy interruption (ToP) of undocumented pregnant migrants vs. pregnant women with legal residency status (control group) who had ToP at the Geneva University Hospitals, Switzerland between March 2005 and October 2006

                    Characteristic

                    or measurement

                    Undocumented

                    migrants

                    (n = 175)

                    Missing

                    n(%)

                    Control group

                    (n = 208)

                    Missing

                    n(%)

                    Mean difference (CI95%)° or OR (CI95%)°°

                    Gravidity (SD)

                    2.8 (1.6)

                    1 (0.6)

                    2.4 (1.4)

                    6 (2.9)

                    0.4 (0.1;0.7)°

                    Parity (SD)

                    1.2 (1.2)

                    0

                    0.8 (0.9)

                    0

                    0.4 (0.2;0.6)°

                    Weeks of pregnancy at first contact with a health professional (SD)

                    8.0 (2.6)

                    0

                    6.9 (2.1)

                    0

                    1.2 (0.7;1.6)°

                    Delayed first contact with a health professional

                         

                       (>10 weeks of amenorrhea)

                    14.9%

                    0

                    5.8%

                    0

                    2.9 (1.4;5.8)°°

                       (>12 weeks of amenorrhea)

                    4.0%

                    0

                    1.4%

                    0

                    2.9 (0.7;11.7)°°

                    Chlamydia trachomatis infection: (CTI)

                    12.8%

                    3 (1.7)

                    4.4%

                    2 (1.0)

                    3.2 (1.4;7.3)°°

                       CTI by type of contraception:

                         

                    Condom use

                    7.0%

                    3 (1.7)

                    3.8%

                    2 (1.0)

                    1.9 (0.4;9.0)°°

                    Other means of contraception

                    15.7%

                    3 (1.7)

                    4.8%

                    2 (1.0)

                    3.7 (1.4;9.7)°°

                    Contraception the month of conception:

                         

                       No contraception

                    23.4%

                    0

                    14.9

                    0

                    1.8 (1.04;2.9)°°

                       Insecure contraception (of those with contraception)

                    83.6%

                    0

                    75.7%

                    0

                    1.6 (0.9;2.9)°°

                    Condom

                    42.5%

                    0

                    46.3%

                    0

                    1.4 (0.9;2.1)°°

                    Calendar (Ogino)

                    29.9%

                    0

                    17.0%

                    0

                    2.2 (1.3;3.8)°°

                    Withdrawal

                    11.2%

                    0

                    12.4%

                    0

                    1.1 (0.6;2.3)°°

                       Secure contraception (of those with contraception):

                         

                    Pill

                    12.7%

                    0

                    21.5%

                    0

                    2.1 (1.1;3.8)°°

                    Others

                    3.7%

                    0

                    2.8%

                    0

                    1.6 (0.4;5.8)°°

                    °Mean difference for continuous data (if value 0 included in CI95% then p > 0.05),

                    °°Age-adjusted OR for categorical data (if value 1 included in CI95% then p > 0.05)

                    Chlamydia trachomatis infection (CTI)

                    CTI was three times more frequent in undocumented migrants (12.8%) than in controls (4.4%, crude OR 3.2 (95% CI 1.4;7.2)). The OR adjusted for age was 3.2 (95% CI 1.4;7.3).

                    Stratification by origin (Latin American vs. not of Latin American origin) showed a similar increase of CTI prevalence among undocumented migrants: 5.8% (95% CI -9.9;21.5) vs.6.7% (95% CI -2.7;16.2).

                    Discussion

                    The prevalence of genital CTI in women requesting ToP was threefold higher in undocumented migrants than in women with legal residency permit (OR 3.2 (95% CI 1.4;7.3)). Insecure contraceptive methods (condoms, withdrawal, calendar) were frequent in both study groups. Compared to the control group, undocumented migrants used less hormonal contraception and were twice as likely to not use any contraception. The lesser use of contraception and the fact that over one third of women reported to have occasional partners may partially explain the high prevalence of CTI (12.8%) in this group.

                    There are no population studies on CTI prevalence in Switzerland. However, data from sentinel populations and laboratory findings have shown an overall prevalence of CTI of 2.8 to 4% [6, 14], which corresponds to the findings in our control group (4.4%) and is three times lower than the prevalence found here in undocumented migrants (12.8%). In a recent study conducted in women screened for ToP in Liverpool, the prevalence of CTI was 7.3%, mostly affecting women from 20 to 24 years of age [15]. Studies in Latin America show CTI prevalence rates of 1.9% to 4.5% in Chile, Peru, Brazil, and Mexico [4, 10, 11] and a rate of 12.2% in women attending family planning clinics [4, 12]. A study in Italy offered free screening for STI to female migrant sex workers and found a CTI prevalence of 14% [16]. The highest prevalence rates were observed in sex workers from Eastern Europe and, although not directly comparable, it suggests that undocumented migrant women in our study may actually be engaging in high risk sexual behaviours, whether on a voluntary basis or not. In any case, the encountered high prevalence rates of CTI and the availability of single-dose antibiotic treatment urges health professionals to consider systematic STI screening.

                    To the best of our knowledge, this is the first time in a Europe, that ToP characteristics were studied in undocumented migrants and compared to a local control group. Another strength of the study is the prospective and systematic inclusion of a relatively large number of this hard-to-reach population.

                    Limitations of the current study concern the representativeness of our sample from this hard-to-reach population and from the general population of pregnant women. Nevertheless, several aspects lead us to believe that this study reached a substantial proportion of pregnant, undocumented women requesting ToP in Geneva and is therefore representative of them: 1) The free medical care unit is well known by this hard-to-reach population; 2) The proportion of Latin Americans (78%) is similar to that found by other sources: by investigation of the origin of undocumented workers, the Geneva trade union recently found 76% were Latin Americans [17]; 3) In order to achieve optimal participation, undocumented women were enrolled in collaboration with the Woman's University Hospital, which is the only public Women's hospital in the Canton of Geneva. Finally, it is possible that the study sample still differs from the whole undocumented population of Geneva, which is, by definition, unknown. Although our control group was not a random sample from the general population, it was obtained by systematically sampling all the women with valid residence permits who were seen on selected days at the same hospital by the same nurse during the same time period that the sample of undocumented migrants was obtained.

                    Conclusion

                    This population of undocumented, pregnant migrants consisted primarily of young, Latino-American women. Compared to control women, undocumented migrants showed higher prevalence rates of genital CTI, which indicates that health professionals should consider systematic STI screening. There is a need for programs providing better access to treatment and education and to increase the migrants' awareness of the importance of contraception and transmission of STIs.

                    Abbreviations

                    CTI: 

                    chlamydia trachomatis infection

                    STI: 

                    sexually transmitted infection

                    CI: 

                    confidence interval

                    OR: 

                    odds ratio

                    SD: 

                    standard deviation

                    ToP: 

                    voluntary termination of pregnancy.

                    Declarations

                    Acknowledgements

                    This study received funding from the project "Migrant Friendly Hospitals" supported by H+The Association of Swiss Hospitals and the Swiss National Public Health Agency.

                    The authors would like to thank Hans Stalder, Françoise Andreetta, Poo-Gien Werner, Christine Fischer, Dominique Durafour, Simone Curtet, Laura Cardia-Voneche, and Peter Saladin for their excellent collaboration and support throughout the project.

                    Authors’ Affiliations

                    (1)
                    Department of Community Medicine and Primary Care, University Hospitals of Geneva, University of Geneva
                    (2)
                    Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, University Hospitals of Geneva, University of Geneva
                    (3)
                    Department of Ambulatory Care and Community Medicine, University of Lausanne

                    References

                    1. Longchamp C, Aebersold M, Rousselot B, Ratelband-Pally S: Sans-papiers en Suisse: c'est le marché de l'emploi qui est déterminant, non pas la politique d'asile. Rapport final sur mandat de l'office fédéral des migrations. GFS Bern 6–4-2005
                    2. Wolff H, Stalder H, Epiney M, Walder A, Irion O, Morabia A: Health care and illegality: a survey of undocumented pregnant immigrants in Geneva. Soc Sci Med 2005, 60: 2149–2154.View ArticlePubMed
                    3. Wolff H, Epiney M, Lourenco AP, Costanza MC, Delieutraz-Marchand J, Andreoli N, et al.: Undocumented migrants lack access to pregnancy care and prevention. BMC Public Health 2008, 8: 93.View ArticlePubMed
                    4. WHO: Global prevalence and incidence of selected curable sexually transmitted diseases. [http://​who.​int/​hiv/​pub/​sti/​who_​hiv_​aids_​2001.​02.​pdf] 10–14.
                    5. Federal Office of Public Health: Sexuell übertragbare Infektionen (STI) in der Schweiz 1988 bis 2006: Aktueller Stand und Ausblick. [http://​www.​bag.​admin.​ch/​dokumentation/​publikationen/​01435/​04412/​index.​html?​lang=​de&​sort=​ta&​superflex=​0_​0&​filter_​dms_​thema=​11&​temp_​dms_​fix=​BAG%20​Bulletin%20​2008&​filter_​dms_​jahre=​]
                    6. Paget WJ, Zbinden R, Ritzler E, Zwahlen M, Lengeler C, Sturchler D, et al.: National laboratory reports of Chlamydia trachomatis seriously underestimate the frequency of genital chlamydial infections among women in Switzerland. Sex Transm Dis 2002, 29: 715–720.View ArticlePubMed
                    7. ANAES: Place des techniques de biologie moléculaire dans l'identification des infections urogénitales basses à C. trachomatis. [http://​www.​has-sante.​fr/​portail/​upload/​docs/​application/​pdf/​Chlamydia_​tome1_​rap.​pdf] 21–24.
                    8. Latino MA, Caneparo A, Rosso C, De Maria D, De Intinis G, Intorcia P, et al.: Prevalence and risk factors for Chlamydia trachomatis infection in young women in north-west of Italy. Minerva Ginecol 2008, 60: 29–37.PubMed
                    9. Renton A, Thomas BM, Gill S, Lowndes C, Taylor-Robinson D, Patterson K: Chlamydia trachomatis in cervical and vaginal swabs and urine specimens from women undergoing termination of pregnancy. Int J STD AIDS 2006, 17: 443–447.View ArticlePubMed
                    10. Gunn RA, Hillis SD, Shirey P, Waterman SH, Greenspan JR: Chlamydia trachomatis infection among Hispanic women in the California-Mexico border area, 1993: establishing screening criteria in a primary care setting. Sex Transm Dis 1995, 22: 329–334.View ArticlePubMed
                    11. Oliveira FA, Pfleger V, Lang K, Heukelbach J, Miralles I, Fraga F, et al.: Sexually transmitted infections, bacterial vaginosis, and candidiasis in women of reproductive age in rural Northeast Brazil: a population-based study. Mem Inst Oswaldo Cruz 2007, 102: 751–756.PubMed
                    12. Behets FM, Ward E, Fox L, Reed R, Spruyt A, Bennett L, et al.: Sexually transmitted diseases are common in women attending Jamaican family planning clinics and appropriate detection tools are lacking. Sex Transm Infect 1998, 74 (Suppl 1) : S123-S127.PubMed
                    13. Wolff H, Besson M, Holst M, Induni E, Stalder H: [Social inequalities and health: experiences of a mobile health care unit in Geneva]. Rev Med Suisse 2005, 1: 2218–2222.PubMed
                    14. Abraham S, Toutous-Trellu L, Pechere M, Hugonnet S, Liassine N, Yerly S, et al.: Increased incidence of sexually transmitted infections in Geneva, Switzerland. Dermatology 2006, 212: 41–46.View ArticlePubMed
                    15. Mallinson H, Hopwood J, Skidmore S, Fenton K, Phillips C, Jones I: Provision of chlamydia testing in a nationwide service offering termination of pregnancy: with data capture to monitor prevalence of infection. Sex Transm Infect 2002, 78: 416–421.View ArticlePubMed
                    16. Matteelli A, Beltrame A, Carvalho AC, Casalini C, Forleo MA, Gulletta M, et al.: Chlamydia trachomatis genital infection in migrant female sex workers in Italy. Int J STD AIDS 2003, 14: 591–595.View ArticlePubMed
                    17. SIT: Pour mettre au jour l'économie de l'ombre. Syndicat interprofessionnel de travailleuses et travailleurs, Genève 2003.
                    18. Pre-publication history

                      1. The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:http://​www.​biomedcentral.​com/​1471-2458/​8/​391/​prepub

                    Copyright

                    © Wolff et al. 2008

                    This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://​creativecommons.​org/​licenses/​by/​2.​0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.