Are the health messages in schoolbooks based on scientific evidence? A descriptive study
© Barrio-Cantalejo et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2011
Received: 14 June 2010
Accepted: 26 January 2011
Published: 26 January 2011
Most textbooks contains messages relating to health. This profuse information requires analysis with regards to the quality of such information. The objective was to identify the scientific evidence on which the health messages in textbooks are based.
The degree of evidence on which such messages are based was identified and the messages were subsequently classified into three categories: Messages with high, medium or low levels of evidence; Messages with an unknown level of evidence; and Messages with no known evidence.
844 messages were studied. Of this total, 61% were classified as messages with an unknown level of evidence. Less than 15% fell into the category where the level of evidence was known and less than 6% were classified as possessing high levels of evidence. More than 70% of the messages relating to "Balanced Diets and Malnutrition", "Food Hygiene", "Tobacco", "Sexual behaviour and AIDS" and "Rest and ergonomics" are based on an unknown level of evidence. "Oral health" registered the highest percentage of messages based on a high level of evidence (37.5%), followed by "Pregnancy and newly born infants" (35%). Of the total, 24.6% are not based on any known evidence. Two of the messages appeared to contravene known evidence.
Many of the messages included in school textbooks are not based on scientific evidence. Standards must be established to facilitate the production of texts that include messages that are based on the best available evidence and which can improve children's health more effectively.
Quality of health education in the School
Health education forms a part of the compulsory education curriculum in Spain, either as explicit content within a given area of knowledge or as supplementary content in any area or didactic act . In order to encourage development in this area, with regards to both explicit and supplementary health education, various didactic methodologies have been promoted, which are more unidirectional in the first instance, and more participative and interactive in the second instance . This two-fold approach to health education, particularly in the case of supplementary education, has given rise to a situation wherein practically all textbooks contain messages relating to health, irrespective of their subject matter. The profuse levels of information relating to health in school books require rigorous analysis with regards to the quality and suitability of such information . Moreover, such analysis is indispensable as many of the health messages are formulated as advice or recommendations addressing the children directly. Certain studies have evaluated the quality of this information, measuring the effectiveness of messages aimed at illness prevention within the school  or the fostering of healthy habits . Extracurricular programs that have been set in motion in schools by third parties have also been evaluated . On other occasions, studies have focused on identifying the health areas addressed in the books or the didactic methodology employed to expound such content. However, we have found a single study that examined the contents about sexuality of the textbooks used in Spanish secondary education analysing the scientific evidence that support them . Furthermore, in view of the section of the population that is targeted by these messages and their importance in improving health awareness and healthy behaviour amongst children, we must ensure that these messages are based on the best available evidence derived from reliable scientific studies.
Scientific evidence in the health messages in textbooks
Evidence-based Medicine (EBM) is a process for the critical evaluation and incorporation of scientific discoveries into the decision-making process within the healthcare sector. This process can be applied to any type of health-related action: diagnosis, therapy or preventative measures . From this perspective, health-related messages in schools should also be filtered via EBM. Determining the level of evidence of messages included in textbooks is of vital importance. The appropriateness of including messages that will be learned by children in textbooks should be determined by the level of evidence on which such messages are based.
The research questions for this study is if the health-related messages in textbooks are based on scientific evidence. The objective was to identify the scientific evidence used as a fundament for health-related messages in textbooks employed within compulsory education in Spain, namely, Primary and Secondary Education. The use of EBM methodology may prove extremely useful when selecting content to be included in school books. Textbooks should only contain the most reliable affirmations in relation to health, that is, statements that are solidly based on scientific evidence. The results of this study may aid the authors and publishers of school books to improve content. In addition, our results may also help teachers to place greater importance on the assimilation of messages that are more firmly based on scientific evidence. Finally, this study may facilitate the adoption of behaviours amongst children and the acquisition of knowledge by children that have more consistently demonstrated a capacity to improve health and prevent illness.
This is an observational, descriptive and analytical study that was carried out in the city of Granada.
Between the 1st of March 2006 and the 1st of June 2007, textbooks used in primary and secondary schools in a district of the province of Granada were identified. Books written in languages other than Spanish, "Teacher Guides" and books containing no health related messages were excluded. A representative sample of books was selected: a proportion with a precision of 5% was estimated along with a bilateral confidence interval of 95%.
Within the framework of the study, health-related messages refer to any statement within a school book that addresses any health-related subject in the form of a recommendation or advice. Messages relating to four areas were excluded: a) Aspects of Anatomy or Physiology that are beyond all scientific doubt were ignored (the heart has four chambers). b) Respect for the environment (preventing damage to the ozone, water saving, recycling, etc) as it is currently difficult to evaluate the scientific evidence and effects on health of recommendations in this area; c) Psychological and Social well-being relating to living in a community and mutual respect, as such considerations are not easily transformed into research questions and we were unable to find studies relating to evidence in this regard (in order to live together without conflict, we must respect one another); d) Messages relating to personal hygiene and food hygiene that emphasised norms of urbanity or courtesy (don't let your hair fall into your food, don't clean your mouth with the sleeve of your shirt, etc).
The texts selected were reviewed in order to identify any health-related messages. We drew up a table to classify messages, recording information relating to the school year and subject matter of the textbook containing each message. In addition, the focus of the message was defined in accordance with the classification of health priorities for children and adolescents drawn up by the health authorities .
Each health-related message in the school books was transformed into a research question. In order to transform the messages into interrogations, where possible, the Patient-Intervention-Comparison-Outcomes (PICO) scheme, drawn up by Richardson et al was employed. However, as these authors drew up their scheme for question construction in a clinical setting, which clearly does not apply to schools, the scheme was slightly modified for the present study. In the present study, the following aspects were considered in each question: (P) the individual or group targeted by the health-related message (boys, girls, adolescents, etc); (I) the area of health that the message focuses on, normally in the form of advice or recommendations (the consumption of fruit and vegetables, physical exercise, road safety, etc); (C) comparison with behaviour that is detrimental to health or with the failure to abide by the advice (the absence of fruit and vegetables in the diet, a sedentary lifestyle, failure to wear a helmet, etc); and (O) associated beneficial effects where the advice is followed. An example of transformation of the messages into interrogations is: Tobacco smoke produces severe diseases of the respiratory system (message) in: Does tobacco smoke produce severe diseases of the respiratory system? (question)
Finding the best available evidence in relation to the questions
To this end we employed the Trip Database (TD), one of the most important Internet resources for searches relating to evidence-based medicine. In accordance with TD recommendations, searches were carried out using search terms relating to question content in conjunction with Boolean searching, parenthesis and stemming.
From the results obtained via the TD, we only considered those documents containing information that was classified in terms of evidence, such as clinical practice guides and systematic reviews. The full texts of the documents were located and thoroughly reviewed, searching for a response to each research question. In each case, we identified the institution that published the document and the uniform resource locator (url) providing a link to the full text.
Results relating to the level of evidence were classified into three categories: a) Messages with a level of evidence: messages wherein the research question is answered in at least one of the consulted documents that also report on the level of evidence. b) Messages based evidence without assigned level: messages wherein the research question is answered in at least one of the consulted documents, which nevertheless fail to report on the level of evidence. c) Messages with no known evidence: messages wherein the research question is not addressed in any of the consulted documents.
Scale employed in the study to measure the level of evidence
Canadian Task Force on Preventive Health Care
C, D, E, I
U.S. Preventive Services Task Force
C, D, I
Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine Oxford
Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network (SIGN)
U.K. National Institute of Clinical Excellence (NICE)
D, BPP, IP
U.S. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ)
The statistically analysis used was only descriptive. Frequencies, percentages and mean were calculated.
Textbooks and messages studied
237 textbooks used in primary and secondary schools were identified. 129 of them met the inclusion criteria. A representative sample of 80 books was randomised via simple aleatory selection. All the books were manually revised and 1135 health-related messages were identified. Subsequent to the elimination of messages that did not meet the criteria for inclusion, 844 were studied.
Subject and School year of the health-messages
Selection and randomisation of messages classified by subject.
Total Messages 1135
n (%) 1
Not eligible Messages
79 (27.1 )
Social and Psychological Well-being
Respect for the environment
Norms of Urbanity or Courtesy
Accidents in the Home
Protection against environmental agents
Smoking 27 (3.2)
Books, messages and messages per book according to school year and subject.
n (%) 1
Year of School
Spanish Language and Literature
Social Sciences Geography and History
Biology and Geology
Table 3 also provides information on the number of books and classified messages according to academic year and subject matter. 59 books (73.7%) and 548 messages (64.9%) were of Primary School and 21 (26.3%) and 296 (35.1%) respectively of Secondary School. The mean of messages for book in Primary School was 9.3 and in Secondary School 15.
Scientific evidence of the health-messages
Messages according to subject and level of evidence.
Messages with a level of
n (%) 1
Balanced Diet Malnutrition
Vaccines Medical Treatment
Accidents in the Home
Protection against environmental agents
Sexual Behaviour AIDS
46 (5.5) 2
12 (1.4) 2
65 (7.7) 2
513 (60.8) 2
208 (24.6) 2
"Balanced diets and malnutrition" is the subject matter that is most often addressed in messages and also gives rise to the highest frequency of messages based on a given source of evidence, although the level of evidence is not known. This subject, along with messages concerning "Food and Hygiene", "Tobacco", "Sexual behaviour and AIDS" and "Rest and ergonomics", is based on a source of evidence in more than 70% of cases, although, once again, the level of evidence is not specified.
"Oral health" registered the highest percentage of messages based on a high level of evidence (37.5%), followed by "Pregnancy and newly born infants" (35%).
Almost a quarter of the messages (24.6%) are not based on any known evidence. In the case of "Respiratory illnesses" and "Protection against environmental agents" more than half the messages are not based on any known evidence (57.9% and 53.1% respectively) and in the case of "Oral Health", the number of messages not based on any known evidence accounts for 40% of the total. In two instances, according to the documents consulted, the messages appeared to contravene known evidence.
Consulted Guides and Systematic Reviews with url to facilitate their location.
Safety education of pedestrians for injury prevention
Phytomedicines (medicines derived from plants) for sickle cell disease
A systematic review of the interventions to promote the wearing of hearing protection
Water for preventing urinary calculi
School-based programmes for preventing smoking
School-based prevention for illicit drugs' use
Feverfew for preventing migraine
Herbal therapy for treating osteoarthritis
European guidelines for the management of chronic non-specific low back pain
Clinical Practice Guides
Antenatal care routine care for the healthy pregnant woman
Guidelines preventive activities general practice
Dyspepsia: pregnanacy associated
Care of umbilical cord
Interventions to promote breast-feeding: applying the evidence in clinical practice
Canadian Immunization Guide 7th Edition
Immunizations-Childhood Vaccination Programme
Children's services: acute health care provision
Preventive services for children and adolescents
The Teen Driver
Bicycle helmets: it's time to use them
NHS - SIGN
Prevention and management of dental decay in the pre-school child
NHS - SIGN
Preventing Dental Caries in Children at High Caries Risk
Oral Health Risk Assessment Timing and Establishment of the Dental Home
Guideline on Periodicity of Examination. Preventive Dental Services
Clinical guideline on infant oral health care
Clinical guideline on adolescent oral health care.
Acne Management. Third Edition
Management and control of eye conditions at primary level
Guidance on Infection Control In Schools and other hile Care Settings
Urinary tract Infection
Abrasion and laceration wound care: pre-school through grade twelve
Environmental management of pediatric asthma
Feverish illness in children
Office-Based conseling for injury prevention
Sprains and strains
Counseling to prevent skin cancer: recommendations and rationale
Guidelines for School Programs To Prevent Skin Cancer
Pediatric eye and vision examination
Impact of media use on children and youth
Prevention of healthcare-associated infections primary and community care
Screening for Visual Impairment in Children Younger than Age 5 Years
Hearing assessment in infants and children
Physical activity in the prevention. treatment and rehabilitation of diseases
Health professional's guide rehabilitation of the patient with osteoporosis
Sexually Transmitted Infections in Primary Care
Tabacco use prevention and cessation for adults and mature adolescents
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
Diet and Lifestyle Recommendations. Revision 2006
Tobacco. Alcohol. and Other Drugs: The Role of the Pediatrician
Prevention of Ventricular Remodeling. Cardiac Dysfunction. and Heart Failure
NHS - SIGN
The management of harmeful drinking and alcohol dependence in primary care
Food and Nutrition Guidelines for Healthy Adolescents
Guidance for working with cocaine and crack
Dietary recommendations for children and adolescents
Insect bites and stings
Anemia - Iron deficency
Food and nutrition guidelines for healthy adolescent
Diet and Lifestyle Recommendations Revision 2006
NHS - SIGN
Management of obesity in children and young people
Prevention and screening of colorectal cancer
HIV Transmisión: Guidelines for assessing risk. 5th Edition
Overweight children and adolescents
The provision of vascular service 2004
Identifying and preventing overweight in childhood. Clinical practice guideline
Secondary prevention in primary-secondary care patients myocardial infarction
Nutrition and physical activity for Australian children
Optimizing Bone Health and Calcium Intakes of Infants. Children. and Adolescents
Salt and health
Nutrition and Athletic Performance
B12 Deficiency - Investigation & Management of Vitamin B12and Folate Deficiency
Mediterranean diet evidence
Prevention of Rickets and Vitamin D Deficiency
Coronary Heart disease
Guidelines for the management and health Surveillance of food handlers
Malnutrition: What nurses working with children and young people
Practice guideline for the treatment of patients with eating disorders
Prevention and management of obesity (mature adolescents and adults)
Increasing physical activity in schools: kindergarten through eighth grade
Guidelines for School and Community Programs to Promote Lifelong Physical Activity Among Young People
Activity Healthy living: prevention of childhood obesity through increased physical activity
Guidelines for action in the event of a deliberate release
Staying Healthy in Child Care
Bugs in our meal: Food for thought
Dietary guidelines for Americans. 2005
Infection at work: Controlling the risks
Examples of messages with different levels of evidence
LEVEL OF EVIDENCE
• Children should use toothpaste with fluoride
• The Mediterranean diet helps to prevent excess cholesterol
• Adopting habits such as not smoking prevents certain types of cancer
• Sugar-free chewing gum helps to prevent tooth decay
• After cleaning, cover a wound with a plaster or bandage
• Pregnant women should visit the doctor once a month
• Moderate exercise strengthens the heart muscles and prevents illnesses affecting the circulatory system
• Alcohol consumption leads to malnutrition and complaints affecting the alimentary canal
• In Summer, apply sun cream to babies several times a day and after bathing
• Drinking two litres of water per day helps us to remain healthy
• Children should always be assisted by an adult when cooking in order to avoid accidents in the home
• Fruit should be thoroughly washed or pealed prior to consumption
NO EVIDENCE FOUND
• Do not swim after a meal. The digestive process may be affected, giving rise to a stomach cramp.
• Breathing through the nose rather than the mouth prevents colds
• An adequate intake of vitamin B lowers the probabilities of illness
• Wounds should be disinfected with peroxide
• A period of inactivity should always be observed in the event of muscular injury
Attention should be drawn to the considerable number of health-related messages found in school books. This can be interpreted as a symptom of the high levels of observance of the official recommendation to include health education in all areas of the curriculum. However, a shadow is cast on this optimistic view when we consider the number of messages that are not based on scientific evidence. This raises questions in relation to the criteria that are employed to select messages for inclusion in school books. The fact that almost a quarter of the messages that were studied are not based on any documentary evidence (Guides and Systematic Reviews), suggests a certain degree of arbitrariness and a lack of clearly defined criteria to evaluate the importance of a health-related message. If we assume that the inclusion of a health-related message in the sources of evidence is indicative of their importance and suitability, our results show that far too many health-related messages aimed at school children are not firmly based on scientific evidence.
Nevertheless, the presence of health-related messages in guides and systematic reviews can not be used as the only means of justification for their inclusion in school books. This is due to the fact that clinical practice guides and systematic reviews entail a long preparation period that may significantly delay the publication and circulation of health information based on evidence. Moreover, the psychology of learning suggests that directing a health-related message towards children, even where the message is not based on sufficient scientific evidence, may aid the consolidation of healthy habits. For example, consulted documents recommend that children clean their teeth two times a day, a message that is based on a high level of evidence. However, the documents do not state that the cleaning process should be carried out after each meal. Nevertheless, recommending that teeth are cleaned immediately after each meal may help children to consolidate habits and routines that entail health benefits.
This paper does not intend to recommend the exclusion, at a general level, of messages that are not clearly based on evidence. However, we do feel that it is advisable to place less emphasis on messages that are not backed up by sources of evidence with a greater degree of frequency. For example, this is the case of messages relating to protection against environmental agents.
This study presents a number of shortcomings that bear mention. Considering clinical practice guides and systematic views as the only source of evidence may limit the scope of the study. Nevertheless, the tenets of care practice consider observance of the recommendations of a clinical practice guide or high quality systematic review to represent the most efficient method of ascertaining the best clinical course to follow .
Nor can we consider the exclusive use of the Trip Database as an evidence search engine as a shortcoming. Other search engines and other search strategies may produce different results. However, we decided to use this pre-filtered source of evidence and thereby ensure that all documents consulted were based on evidence that has been rigorously verified.
As conclusion, almost a quarter of messages included in school textbooks have an unknown scientific evidence. These messages are included in textbooks along with messages that are solidly based on scientific evidence. Children receive all of these messages and are unable to identify the importance or lack of importance of a given message or the extent to which it is based on evidence. The results of our study suggest that there is a need to establish standards that will enable the publishers who draw up the texts and the teachers who employ such texts to select and impart messages with solid scientific evidence.
Finally, this study has some practical implications: The results of our study demonstrate that there is a need to establish a mechanism that is capable of selecting messages on the basis of the degree to which they are based on scientific evidence. The publication of books that respect the criterion of a firm basing in scientific evidence with regards to the messages that they contain will facilitate the acquisition of knowledge amongst children that has consistently proved capable of improving health and preventing illnesses.
Acknowledgements And Funding
Acknowledgements to Consejería de Economía, Innovación y Ciencia (Grupo CTS-177) y Fondos FEDER, to Consejería de Salud de la Junta de Andalucía (Project 03/2005), to Alejandro Otero East Andalusia Biomedical Research Foundation (FIBAO) and to Andalusia Public Health School, who provided financial support for the conduct of this research and supported the publication of this article.
- Official State Gazette: Organically Law 2/2006, of Education, May 3th. BOE num106 of 04-05-06
- Davó MC, Ruiz MT: Healthy Schools. Health Promotion and social change. Edited by: Colomer C, Álvarez-Dardet C. 2000, Barcelona: MassonGoogle Scholar
- Gavidia Catalán V: The health education in the Spanish handbooks. Rev Esp Salud Pública. 2003, 77: 275-85.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Park-Higgerson HK, Perumean-Chaney SE, Bartolucci AA, Grimley DM, Singh KP: The Evaluation of School-Based Violence Prevention Programs: A Meta-Analysis. J Sch Health. 2008, 78 (9): 465-79. 10.1111/j.1746-1561.2008.00332.x.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Shaya FT, Flores D, Gbarayor CM, Wang J: School-Based Obesity Interventions: A Literature Review. J Sch Health. 2008, 78 (4): 189-96. 10.1111/j.1746-1561.2008.00285.x.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Anonymous Program: Girls chat about fat celebrities and cartoons: A Health and Media Literacy Intervention Program. Health Educ Behav. 2003, 30 (6): 643-Google Scholar
- De Irala J, Urdiain IG, López Del Burgo C: Analysis of content about sexuality and human reproduction in school textbooks in Spain. Public Health. 2008, 122 (10): 1093-103. 10.1016/j.puhe.2008.01.005.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Marzo Castillejo M, Viana Zulaica C: Quality of the evidence and recomendation degree. Guías Clínicas. 2007, 7 (supl 1): 1-14.Google Scholar
- Barrio Cantalejo IM, Ayudarte Larios ML, Hernán García M, Martínez Tapias J, De Haro Castellano JM, Simón Lorda P, Sánchez García M: Presence of current child and adolescent health priorities in school textbooks. Gacet Sanit. 2008, 22 (3): 227-31. 10.1157/13123968.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Barratt A: Evidence Based Medicine and Shared Decision Making: The challenge of getting both evidence and preferences into health care. Patient Educ Couns. 2008, 73 (3): 407-12. 10.1016/j.pec.2008.07.054.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/11/54/prepub
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.