Identifying Community Physical Activity and Health Resources by Utilizing Members of a Physical Activity Network

Background: Back pain is one of the leading causes of health care expenditure in the US and is linked to an increased body mass index. Many evidence-based modalities for the prevention and treatment of back pain closely mirror recommendations for weight loss and include physical activity and health maintenance activities (PAHM). Collaboration was sought with the West Virginia Physical Activity Network (WVPAN) leadership to ascertain community assets, and perceptions of the use of PAHM in the treatment of back pain by WVPAN members. Methods: Participants for the study were recruited from the West Virginia Physical Activity Network. This grassroots organization is lled with volunteers from various sectors who have either signed up via email or liked the WVPAN Facebook page. This network was purposely selected as the study population because of the statewide reach and their familiarity with resources in their local communities. A brief survey instrument was designed to gather their scaled perceptions about various treatment modalities related to back pain, and to gather their local knowledge related to specic providers in their communities. In addition, participants were given a free text box to list any local assets or resources for the nine treatments listed, and county of residence, and the nature of their connection to the physical activity network. Descriptive analyses were used to describe overall patterns of survey data. The qualitative data were compiled manually by the research team to show themes of specic treatments mentioned across different parts of the state. Results: Participants overwhelmingly supported physical therapy, exibility training, yoga, and core strengthening as treatments for back pain. The majority of respondents were “undecided” about other treatments such as cognitive behavioral therapies and acupuncture. Conclusions: The implementation of PAHM interventions in communities could help treat patients with back pain, and may reduce reliance on the pharmacological treatment for back pain. The current study’s data support the potential of such approaches in many West Virginia counties. Also, local resources, and context can be gleaned from community leader surveys utilizing previously developed infrastructure for PAHM promotion.

inconvenience, and lack of support. 4,5,6 Systematic studies regarding the viability and implementation of such interventions in high risk communities are warranted.
West Virginia leads the nation in rates of adult with obesity as well as obesity-related chronic diseases such as diabetes and hypertension. 14 Another, non-silent complication of obesity is back pain, which has a social and economic signi cance in its own right. The implementation of PAHM interventions in communities could help treat patients with back pain, and may reduce reliance on the pharmacological treatment for back pain.
There is a growing body of evidence that community based efforts can be effective in promoting physical activity. 7, 8 ,9 Programs that include personal contact and are tailored to the speci c characteristics of the community have proven to be most effective. 10 These interventions take on additional importance in rural environments where social and cultural factors may affect sustainability. Fortunately, many individuals and groups are passionate about improving physical activity and healthy lifestyles in their local communities. In West Virginia, one such organization is the West Virginia Physical Activity Network (WVPAN). The WVPAN aims to increase physical activity by assisting communities to create a culture of a physical activity. 11 Members of the network serve as "community leaders" to promote and assist in local efforts to improve health through physical activity. The interventions within WVPAN consist of many options including walking groups and biking clubs along with competitive running (e.g., trail races, community 5k). This organization also maintains a directory of physical activity groups around the state, support individual initiate physical activity helps organize events to promote physical activity and share stories of what's happening in the state around physical activity. The WVPAN also lists other partners for physical activity and health on its website. 11 This pilot study is the rst step in planned implementation of evidence-based interventions to promote physical activity as recommended by Rabin and colleagues. 12 Rabin's suggestions include a conducting a prestudy to ensure recommendations build upon individual and organizational capacity. This information is meant to inform trial interventions at primary care facilities in several counties where viable and available PAHM resources were identi ed through an additional partnership, with the Practice Based Research Network (PBRN). This would provide education and support to primary health care providers to consider non-pharmacological treatment interventions for patients with back pain. Thus, the primary purpose of the study was descriptive in nature, speci cally to inform future intervention work in communities. The aim of the current study was to collaborate with WVPAN leadership, speci cally, SZ (Sam Zizzi, coauthor of this paper) to ascertain the assets (resources available in their community), and context (circumstances that impact the acceptability and accessibility of physical activity resources) of the use of PAHM in the treatment of back pain by WVPAN members as community leaders.

Sampling and Recruitment
Participants for the study were recruited from the West Virginia Physical Activity Network (WVPAN). This grassroots organization is lled with volunteers from various sectors (e.g., education, business, healthcare, and tness) who have either signed up via email or liked the WVPAN Facebook page.
Members of the organization come from all areas of the state, and there is a mix of both professionals and community lay leaders. Communications that go out to the WVPAN are managed by the Center for ActiveWV within the College of Physical Activity and Sport Sciences at West Virginia University. The network was purposely selected as the study population because of the statewide reach and their familiarity with resources in their local communities.

Survey Instrument
The brief survey instrument was designed to gather their scaled perceptions about various treatment modalities related to back pain, and to gather their local knowledge related to speci c providers in their communities. Thus, the primary dependent variables were the respondents' perceptions of the use of nine treatments for back pain. For these scaled items, the members were asked to indicate their agreement or disagreement using a ve-point Likert type scale with nine PAHM treatments for back pain. The scale varied from "Strongly Disagree" (1) to "Strongly Agree" (5). These modalities included physical therapy, chiropractic care, aerobic exercise, exibility training, massage, acupuncture, yoga/Pilates/tai-chi, medication use (i.e., NSAIDs), and cognitive behavioral therapies. A free text box was included after the scaled items asking participants to list any local assets or resources for the nine treatments listed. County of residence and the nature of their connection to the physical activity network (e.g., healthcare provider, tness provider, government organization, educator, etc.) were also collected. No additional demographic variables about participants were collected.

Procedures
After Institutional Review Board approval, an online survey was emailed to all 1,248 members of the WVPAN using the online survey system, REDCap. REDCap is a secure web-based application utilized by West Virginia University. 13 A week later, a reminder email was sent to members who had not responded to the survey. Additionally, a live link to the questionnaire was also posted on the WVPAN member Facebook page. Participants indicated their consent to participant by checking a box that would then open the survey. All returned questionnaires were received anonymously through the REDCap application.

Statistical Analyses
Since the primary purpose of the study was exploratory, descriptive analyses were used to describe overall patterns of results for the scaled data. Speci cally, means and standard deviations were generated for the scaled items and percentages were calculated for the categorical items. These quantitative analyses were conducted directly within the REDCap program. For the open text responses, qualitative content analysis was applied to the data using an inductive approach. The most common responses were compiled manually by the research team to show themes of speci c treatments mentioned across different parts of the state.

Results
After two email reminders, 145 responses to the email survey were received covering 41 of the 55 (73%) counties in WV, resulting in an 11.6% response rate. The most members were from two of the higher populated areas of West Virginia, Kanawha (16%) and Monongalia counties (17%). Five members who completed a survey did not indicate their county of residence. The number of members by county are illustrated in Figure 1.
The WVPAN membership includes formal and informal connections to physical activity. Some are employees or owners of tness related businesses. Others are teachers or health care providers. We asked the respondents to self-identify with one of six categories. Fitness enthusiast was included as a category to capture those with no formal or professional role in physical tness but have joined the WVPAN to stay connected with the networks' activity. Approximately 75% of respondents were associated with the WVPAN in a formal role through their work as an educator, government employee, tness instructor, or healthcare provider. The greatest number of respondents indicated their a liation with the WVPAN was as an educator (43%). Seven respondents did not indicate their a liation. The details of the member's connection to the WVPAN are presented in Table 1.
Members of the WVPAN overwhelmingly agreed that physical therapy is important for back pain with 93% indicating they agreed or strongly agreed with this statement. Other physical activities such as exibility training and core strengthening were also highly supported at 95%. The majority of respondents were "undecided" about other treatments such as cognitive behavioral therapies and acupuncture. Details of survey responses are represented in Table 2.
The WVPAN members were asked to identify local resources or assets for PAHM treatments for back pain that they felt might be of interest to patients or health care providers. Free-text answers included dance, swimming, stress reduction, and general wellness. The volume of write-in resources by county are represented in Figure 2.
The most referenced resource was yoga, which was well represented across the state in 15 counties. Counties where yoga was referenced as a resource for treating low back pain are indicated in Figure 3.

Discussion
In this study, we sought to assess community resources, assets, and context for the utilization of PAHM for treatment of back pain through a previously developed community network. Within the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research Constructs, the nature and quality of formal and informal networks, basic assumptions, attitudes, and shared perception of importance amongst stakeholders, as well as available resources must be assessed and accounted for. 15 In addition, "overcoming indifference or resistance" amongst "champions," or community leaders, is a key component of an implementation intervention Previous work by our group has demonstrated an openness amongst patients with back pain in a subspecialist clinical setting to discuss PAHM and other weight loss strategies as a way to aid in the treatment of back pain, but that implementation of PAHM is challenging without speci c regional knowledge of local PAHM resources. 16 This survey of WVPAN community leaders gives an overview of possible PAHM resources throughout the state while also assessing attitudes towards PAHM for the treatment in back pain amongst this group of stakeholders. Importantly, PAHM resources appear to be available throughout the state, although possibly not in every county. More physical activity resources were identi ed in the more populous counties of the state while yoga was more widespread throughout the state. The survey also assesses the potential buy-in of future implementation interventions by community leaders, whom seem to strongly support PAHM methods as a treatment for back pain. In particular, physical therapy, yoga and exibility training, and aerobic exercise were felt to be of bene t.
These modalities may be areas of particular interest for further study.
This study contributes to the growing body of community engaged research. This process involves "working collaborative with groups of people a liated by geographic proximity, special interest, or similar situations with respect to issue affecting their well-being". 17 In this study, we partnered with the WVPAN, a group of people who share a special interest in physical activity in West Virginia. Community engagement is a proven strategy to identify priorities for physical activity and healthy lifestyles in unique communities. For example, Fialkowski et al., engaged with the Children's Healthy Living Program to identify environmental priorities to address childhood obesity in remote and underserved populations in the USA and a liated Paci c Islands. Researchers found the community leaders and those invested in childhood health were grateful for the opportunity to discuss childhood obesity and provide input. 18 One of the priorities discussed was promoting physical activity.
Community involvement is essential when seeking local knowledge and context. 19 Integrating community-based knowledge in research, in turn bene ts the community. Moreover, members who provide local knowledge informed by their experiences contribute to greater program success and sustainability. 19 By engaging with the WVPAN to identify PAHM to treat back pain, we found many locally identi ed resources to inform future interventions aimed at providing acceptable options for treatment. These results are similar to John et al., who engaged community members to create an attribute map though photos exploring local resources for diet and physical activity. 20 The current study demonstrates the feasibility of partnering with grassroots organizations such as the WVPAN for a novel approach of engaging members of a state wide community, as partners in research.
Limitations of this study include bias as a result of its survey methodology, as well as response rate.
Because community leaders with an established interest in PAHM were surveyed, it is not known if buy-in would be similar amongst others in a rural West Virginia community. Survey respondents with strong feelings regarding PAHM may have been more likely to follow through with the survey, which may have biased results towards more favorable perception of PAHM. This bias is likely magni ed by the low response rate of 11.6%, which nevertheless may be somewhat mitigated by the sample size. However, in future work in these communities, this bias towards the implementation of PAHM may bene t researchers and clinicians as participant buy-in could already by established, allowing a vehicle for intervention.

Conclusion
Local resources and context can be gleaned from community leader surveys utilizing previously developed infrastructure for PAHM promotion. However, with a low response rate to the survey, further work is needed as these results just represent the attitudes of this group. Nevertheless, this data can provide valuable input for the construction of clinical trials regarding utilization of PAHM in rural West Virginia community settings.

Declarations
Ethics approval and consent to participate: This study was approved by the West Virginia IRB protocol # 1711849628 Consent for publication: Not Applicable Availability of data and materials: All data generated or analyzed during this study are included in this published article Competing interests: The authors declare that they have no competing interests Funding: Research reported in this publication was supported by the National Institute of General Medical Sciences of the National Institutes of Health under Award Number 5U54GM104942-03. The content is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the o cial views of the National Institutes of Health. Support was provided for the survey collection and analysis through providing and maintenance of the REDCap application. 13 Authors' contributions: All authors, CS, TH, SZ, and PD read and approved the nal manuscript and contributed equally to the data collection and analysis.
Maps created with the permission of mapchart.net. Belongs to a government agency 17%

Tables
Healthcare provider 7% Own a health related business 5% Fitness instructor 4% *Fitness enthusiast defined as those with no formal role within the WVPAN or in their community   Write in resources for back pain treatment by county