The actual and anticipated effects of restrictions on flavoured electronic nicotine delivery systems: a scoping review

Table 1 Characteristics of included studies

Study Type^a
*Restriction Type*	*Sales*	*Behaviour - Implemented*	*Behaviour - Hypothetical*	*Compliance*
Total ENDS Ban	4	1	2	3
Flavoured ENDS Restriction	3	1	6	0
ENDS Restriction Exempts Some Flavours	0	0	4	2
ENDS Restriction Exempts Some Retailers	0	3	0	3
All Flavoured Tobacco Product Ban	1	4	0	5
Location^a
*Restriction Type*	*US - Local*	*US - State*	*US - National*^b	*Non-US*
Total ENDS Ban	1	5	1	2
Flavoured ENDS Restriction	1	5	4	2
ENDS Restriction Exempts Some Flavours	2	0	4	0
ENDS Restriction Exempts Some Retailers	6	0	0	0
All Flavoured Tobacco Product Ban	9	0	0	0
Age Group^c
Youth	6
Young Adults	3
Adults	8
Industry Sponsored
Yes	1
No	29

^a Studies included multiple types of restrictions. Counts of restriction types sum to greater than the included number of studies
^b Studies were exclusive to hypothetical restrictions
^c Only studies with behaviour outcomes included

ISSN: 1471-2458