Skip to main content

Table 1 Relative frequencies (%) of choice of allocation scheme by randomization factors

From: Providing laypeople with results from dynamic infectious disease modelling studies affects their allocation preference for scarce medical resources—a factorial experiment

 

Overall

(pchi-squared test < 0.001)

Model-based information

on expected population-level effects

Time until death

 

Prevention

(n = 441)

Treatment

(n = 437)

Prevention

(pchi-squared test < 0.001)

Treatment

(pchi-squared test = 0.004)

Prevention

(pchi-squared test = 0.77)

Treatment

(pchi-squared test = 0.82)

   

No

Infoa

(n = 149)

Additional

Infob

(n = 292)

No

infoa

(n = 144)

Additional

infob

(n = 293)

Death within

5 years

(n = 227)

Death within

15 years

(n = 214)

Death within

5 years

(n = 231)

Death within

15 years

(n = 206)

Random allocation

(equal treatment)

12.2

6.6

12.8

12.0

8.3

5.8

12.8

11.7

6.1

7.3

First come, first served

(waiting-list)

NA

22

NA

NA

27.1

19.5

NA

NA

19.9

24.3

Young individuals first

(prioritarianism)

12.5

9.2

22.1

7.5

11.1

8.2

13.7

11.2

10.0

8.3

Promiscuous individuals

first (utilitarianism)

46

24.3

34.2

52.1

12.5

30.0

45.4

46.7

26.0

22.3

Long-lasting partnerships

first (individual behaviour)

12.7

9.6

16.8

10.6

9.7

9.6

11.0

14.5

10.0

9.2

Undecided

16.6

28.4

14.1

17.8

31.2

27.0

17.2

15.9

28.1

28.6

  1. apchi-squared test < 0.001 for prevention vs. treatment among participants who did not receive any information
  2. bpchi-squared test < 0.001 for prevention vs. treatment among participants who received any information