Study | Credibility | Relevance | Score | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Data collection | Auditability | Reflexivity | Negative cases | Fair dealing | Transferability | Analytic generalization | ||
Adejumo 2020 [40] | x | x | Â | Â | Â | x | x | B |
Ajayi 2013 [38] | x | x | x | Â | x | x | x | A |
Bieh et al., 2017 [41] | x | x | x | Â | x | x | x | A |
Ogbuabor 2020 [42] | x | x | Â | Â | x | x | x | B |
Olukolade et al., 2017 [43] | x | x | Â | Â | x | x | Â | B |
Okeibunor et al., 2006 [44] | x | x | Â | Â | x | x | x | B |
Onyeneho 2010 [45] | x | x | Â | Â | x | x | x | B |
Oshi et al., 2016 [46] | x | x | Â | Â | x | x | x | B |
Ushie & Jegede 2012 [47] | x | x | Â | Â | x | x | x | B |
Ukwaja et al 2017 [48] | x | x | x | Â | x | x | x | A |
1-2 points = C, 3-5 points = B and 6-7 points = A | ||||||||
Quality assessment questions | ||||||||
Credibility | ||||||||
  Data collection | • Were explanations of sampling strategies and data collection methods provided? | |||||||
  Auditability | • Was the method of data analysis described and enough data displayed to allow the reader to determine whether the interpretations made by the researcher is supported by the data? | |||||||
  Reflexivity | • Did the authors acknowledge the influence of the research process and the presence of the researcher including the role of prior biases, assumptions and experience, on the collected data? | |||||||
  Negative cases | • Has appropriate attention been given to contradictory data? Are negative cases taken into account? | |||||||
  Fair dealing | • Did the authors explore alternative, plausible explanations for the data collected and incorporate a range of different perspectives? | |||||||
Relevance | ||||||||
  Transferability | • Did the authors provide information regarding participants, setting and context so that the reader might be able to determine the relevance of the findings to other settings (transferability)? | |||||||
  Analytic generalization | • Did the authors discuss findings within a broader context, propose generalization of findings and/or suggest a direction for future research? |