Skip to main content

Table 4 Management by private practitioners of children with presumptive tuberculosis, by age groups, in 12 selected districts in Pakistan, 2016

From: How do private practitioners in Pakistan manage children suspected having tuberculosis? A cross sectional study

Practice of private health care providers

Total

0–4 years

5-11 years

12-14 years

p-value

n(%)

n(%)

n(%)

n(%)

Presumptive child TB

 

6519

1691

3214

1614

 

Diagnosed TB

All

5193 (79.7)

1564 (92.4)

2545 (79.2)

1084 (67.2)

< 0.0001

Bacteriologically positive

498 (7.6)

68 (4.0)

204 (6.3)

226 (14.0)

Clinically diagnosed

4695 (72.0)

1496 (88.5)

2341 (72.8)

858 (53.1)

Notified

Notified to NTP

187 (2.9)

35 (2.1)

90 (2.8)

62 (3.8)

< 0.0001

Investigation practices

Tuberculin Skin/PPD testing

219 (3.4)

45 (2.7)

112 (3.5)

62 (3.8)

0.1464

Sputum Smear

1875 (28.8)

242 (14.3)

910 (28.3)

723 (44.8)

< 0.0001

X-ray

3005 (46.1)

683 (40.4)

1499 (46.6)

823 (51.0)

< 0.0001

X-pert test

324 (5.0)

34 (2.0)

146 (4.5)

144 (8.9)

< 0.0001

Granuloma/Histopathology

837 (12.8)

175 (10.4)

406 (12.6)

256 (15.9)

< 0.0001

Culture

152 (2.3)

13 (0.8)

73 (2.3)

66 (4.1)

< 0.0001

Number of tests done*

Only clinical assessment

2559 (39.3)

842 (49.8)

1219 (37.9)

498 (30.9)

< 0.0001

1 test

2217 (34.01)

574 (33.9)

1165 (36.3)

478 (29.6)

2 tests

1270 (19.5)

223 (13.2)

617 (19.2)

430 (26.6)

3 tests or more

473 (7.3)

52 (3.1)

213 (6.6)

208 (12.9)

Management practices

Referred for TB diagnosis

3121 (47.9)

842 (49.8)

1578 (49.1)

701 (43.4)

< 0.0001

Diagnosed and referred

2443 (37.5)

494 (29.2)

1293 (40.2)

656 (40.6)

Treated

955 (14.6)

355 (21.0)

343 (10.7)

257 (15.9)

Place of referral (n = 5564)

District TB Centre (NTP)

3812 (68.5)

832 (62.3)

2006 (69.9)

974 (71.8)

< 0.0001

Private laboratory

1190 (21.4)

388 (29.0)

561 (19.5)

241 (17.8)

Private specialist hospital/GP

562 (10.1)

116 (8.7)

304 (10.6)

142 (10.5)

  1. *indicates how many tests were performed to reach final diagnosis