Skip to main content

Table 1 Summary of studies assessing the proportion of unknown HIV status among patients with tuberculosis included in the analysis (n = 47)

From: Unknown HIV status and the TB/HIV collaborative control program in Ethiopia: systematic review and meta-analysis

Author, Year

Year Study

Study Region

Age Group

Health Facility

Study Design

Total TB

HIV R(%)

HIVNR (%)

HIV Unknown

Wondale et al 2017) [21]

2004–2014

SNNPR

All

Hospital

RC

2156

315 (14.60)

1289 (59.8)

552 (25.60)

Adane et al, 2018 [22]

2011–2015

Tigray

Adult

HC

RC

496

54 (11.00)

424 (85.00)

18 (3.63)

Ejeta et al., 2015 [23]

2009–2013

Oromia

All

HC

RC

1175

201 (17.10)

924 (78.60)

84 (7.15)

Getnet et al, 2017 [24]

2009–2014.

Somalia

All

Hospital

RC

1378

63 (4.60)

1311 (95.40)

4 (0.29)

Worku et al, 2018 [63]

2011–2016

Addis Ababa

All

Hospital

RC

340

58 (17.10)

263 (77.40)

19 (5.59)

Ramos et al, 2010 [25]

2002–2007

Oromia

All

Hospital

RC

2225

38 (1.70)

242 (10.90)

1943 (87.33)

Muluye et al, 2018 [66]

2012–2016

Oromia

All

Hospital

RC

995

68 (6.80)

889 (89.30)

38 (3.82)

Hailu et al,2014 [26]

2007–2011

Addis Ababa

Children

HC

RC

2708

346 (12.80)

945 (34.89)

1600 (59.08)

Arega et al., 2019 [27]

2015–2017

Addis Ababa

All

Hospital

RC

1876

117(6.70)

77 (4.10)

1682 (89.66)

Gebremariam et al.,2016 [28]

2008–2014

Oromia

All

HC

RC

1649

156 (10.00)

1406 (90.00)

87 (5.28)

Tafess et al, 2018 [29]

2004–2014

Oromia

All

Hospital

RC

1755

287 (16.40)

1174 (66.90)

294 (16.75)

Birlie et al, 2015 [30]

2008–2012

Amhara

all

HC

RC

810

141 (18.30)

631 (77.90)

38 (4.69)

Melese et al, 2018 [31]

2008–2013

Amhara

All

HC

RC

303

10 (3.30)

67 (22.10)

226 (74.59)

Berihun et al., 2018 [32]

2010–2015

Amhara

Adult

HC

RC

162

6 (3.70)

48 (29.60)

108 (66.67)

Endris et al., 2014 [33]

2007–2011

Amhara

All

HC

RC

417

24 (5.80)

182 (43.60)

211 (50.60)

Jaleta et al., 2017 [34]

2013–2015

Amhara

All

Hospital

RC

1820

315 (17.30)

621 (34.10)

884 (48.57)

Simieneh et al., 2017 [35]

2009–2014

SNNPR

All

Hospital

RC

1961

246 (13.9)

1519 (77.46)

196 (9.99)

Mekonnen et al., 2016 [36]

2011–2014

Amhara

All

HC

RC

990

227 (24.00)

704 (74.20)

18 (1.82)

Berhe et al., 2012 [37]

2009–2011

Tigray

All

HC

RC

470

35(8.60)

271 (66.60)

101 (21.49)

Tilahun et al., 2016 [38]

2009–2013

Addis Ababa

Children

HC

RC

491

82 (28.20)

209 (42.56)

200 (40.73)

Zenebe et al., 2016 [39]

2010–2015.

Amhara

All

Hospital

RC

1761

459 (26.06)

1235 (70.13)

67 (3.80)

Assefa et al., 2017 [40]

2013–2013

Addis Ababa

All

Hospital

RC

710

148 (20.84)

533 (30.26)

29 (4.08)

Sintayehu et al., 2014 [41]

2010–2013

Oromia

All

Hospital

RC

2043

328 (16.05)

1650 (80.76)

27 (1.32)

Tefera et al., 2016 [42]

2009–2013

Amhara

All

Hospital

RC

1280

262 (20.46)

645 (50.39)

373 (29.14)

Asebe et al., 2015 [43]

2011–2013

Gambella

All

Hospital

RC

1156

280 (24.22)

792 (60.05)

84 (7.27)

Kebede et al., 2017 [44]

2014–2015

Amhara

All

Hospital

RC

227

56 (24.60)

135 (59.50)

36 (15.86)

Sisaya et al., 2018 [45]

2009–2015

Oromia

All

Hospital

RC

272,526

13,680 (11.8)

101,588 (37.2)

157,258 (57.70)

Biruk et al., 2016 [46]

2008–2012

Amhara

All

Hospital

RC

1584

212 (13.40)

420 (26.50)

952 (60.10)

Yakob et al., 2018 [47]

2012–2015

SNNP

All

HC

RC

725

72 (9.90)

645 (91.10)

80 (11.03)

Addis et al., 2013 [48]

2008–2011

Amhara

All

HC

RC

482

123 (38.10)

200 (61.90)

159 (32.99)

Yadeta et al., 2013 [49]

2009–2011

Oromia

Adult

Hospital

RC

682

215 (32.20)

467 (68.47)

14 (2.05)

Akessa et al., 2015 [50]

2012–2013

Oromia

All

Hospital

RC

510

114 (22.40)

354 (69.40)

42 (8.24)

Yilma et al.,2019 [51]

2008–2014

Amhara

All

Hospital

RC

1952

600 (30.73)

1072 (54.92)

208 (10.66)

Ayele et al., 2015 [52]

2009–2014

SNNP

All

HC

RC

3722

499 (13.41)

3002 (80.66)

221 (5.94)

Woldeamanuel etal,2018 [53]

2013–2015

Amhara

All

Hospital

RC

262

114 (45.80)

135 (54.20)

13 (4.96)

Demile et al., 2018 [54]

2014–2015

Addis Ababa

All

Hospital

RC

389

34 (8.90)

321 (84.30)

26 (6.68)

Ejetab et al., 2018 [64]

2015–2017

Gambella

All

Hospital

RC

995

96 (9.64)

141 (14.18)

758 (76.18)

Zenebe et al.,2016 [55]

2010–2013

Afar

All

Hospital

RC

3634

510 (14.03)

1991 (54.79)

133 (3.66)

Asres et al., 2016 [56]

2008–2014

SNNPR

Children

HC

RC

790

77 (9.74)

535 (67.73)

178 (22.53)

Gebreegziabher et al.,2016 [57]

2007–2013

Amhara

All

HC

RC

15,140

716 (4.68)

6086 (40.19)

8338 (55.07)

Asebe et al.,2014 [58]

2003–2014

Gambella

All

Hospital

RC

4300

423 (9.83)

1021 (23.74)

2856 (66.42)

Abebe et al., 2015 [59]

2008–2012

Oromia

All

Hospital

RC

2107

178 (8.45)

1775 (84.24)

156 (7.40)

Alemu et al., 2017 [60]

2009–2014

Gambella

All

Hospital

RC

2519

605 (24.02)

1579 (62.68)

335 (13.30)

Tachbele et al., 2017 [61]

2007–2012

Oromia

All

Hospital

RC

916

158 (17.25)

553 (60.37)

2 05 (22.38)

Tarekegne et al., 2016 [62]

2009–2012

Amhara

All

Hospital

RC

2096

404 (19.27)

1601 (76.38)

91 (4.34)

Amante et al., 2015 [67]

2007–2012

Harar

All

HC

RC

976

179 (18.34)

460 (43.17)

261 (26.74)

Shibabaw et al., 2018 [65]

2011–2016

Amhara

All

Hospital

RC

235

61 (25.96)

162 (68.93)

12 (5.11)

  1. SNNPR South national nationality and people of representative, HIV Human immune Virus, TB Tuberclosis, R Reactive, NR Non-Reactivity: tuberculosis, RC a retrospective cross-sectional study, HC health center, children age < 15 years