Skip to main content

Table 2 Binary logistic regression testing factors associated with experience of the claims process

From: Injured worker experiences of insurance claim processes and return to work: a national, cross-sectional study

Factor

Sample Characteristics

Positive Experience

Negative or Neutral Experience

Binary Logistic Regression

N

col %

N

row %

N

row %

AOR

95% CIs

p value

Total

10946

100.0

8431

77.0

2515

23.0

n/a

  

Age categor

 15 to 35 years

2849

26.0

2248

78.9

601

21.1

1.00

  

 36 to 55 years

5495

50.2

4110

74.8

1385

25.2

1.01

(0.90,1.14)

0.856

 56 + years

2602

23.8

2073

79.7

529

20.3

1.33

(1.16,1.53)

< 0.001

Sex

 Female

3950

36.1

2897

73.3

1053

26.7

1.00

  

 Male

6996

63.9

5534

79.1

1462

20.9

1.22

(1.10,1.34)

< 0.001

General health

 Very Good/Excellent

4253

38.9

3705

87.1

548

12.9

1.00

  

 Poor/Fair/Good

6627

60.5

4678

70.6

1949

29.4

0.37

(0.33,0.41)

< 0.001

 Missing

66

0.6

       

Condition

 Musculoskeletal Conditions

6490

59.3

4927

75.9

1563

24.1

1.00

  

 Fractures

1346

12.3

1138

84.5

208

15.5

1.50

(1.28,1.77)

< 0.001

 Neurological Injury & Disease

210

1.9

164

78.1

46

21.9

1.18

(0.84,1.67)

0.334

 Mental Health Conditions

643

5.9

343

53.3

300

46.7

0.47

(0.39,0.55)

< 0.001

 Other traumatic

1881

17.2

1559

82.9

322

17.1

1.30

(1.13,1.49)

< 0.001

 Other diseases

365

3.4

293

80.3

72

19.7

1.13

(0.86,1.48)

0.389

 Missing

11

0.1

       

Jurisdiction

 Queensland

2183

19.9

1775

81.3

408

18.7

1.00

  

 Tasmania

1076

9.8

826

76.8

250

23.2

0.86

(0.71,1.04)

0.117

 Western Australia

1491

13.6

1227

82.3

264

17.7

1.08

(0.90,1.30)

0.382

 Seacare

258

2.4

193

74.8

65

25.2

0.65

(0.47,0.90)

0.010

 New South Wales

1534

14.0

1180

76.9

354

23.1

0.77

(0.64,0.91)

0.002

 South Australia

1329

12.1

1021

76.8

308

23.2

1.02

(0.85,1.22)

0.857

 Comcare

785

7.2

558

71.1

227

28.9

0.85

(0.68,1.05)

0.126

 Northern Territory

280

2.6

189

67.5

91

32.5

0.51

(0.38,0.68)

< 0.001

 Victoria

2010

18.4

1462

72.7

548

27.3

0.74

(0.63,0.87)

< 0.001

Days to lodge claim

 Less than 7 days

3639

33.2

2962

81.4

677

18.6

1.00

  

 7 to 13 days

2382

21.8

1867

78.4

515

21.6

0.91

(0.79,1.04)

0.161

 14 to 27 days

2151

19.7

1654

76.9

497

23.1

0.86

(0.75,1.00)

0.044

 28 to 55 days

1379

12.6

1008

73.1

371

26.9

0.77

(0.66,0.91)

0.002

 56 to 83 days

494

4.5

346

70.0

148

30.0

0.70

(0.56,0.87)

0.002

 84 to 180 days

549

5.0

370

67.4

179

32.6

0.63

(0.50,0.78)

< 0.001

 Over 180 days

351

3.2

223

63.5

128

36.5

0.60

(0.46,0.77)

< 0.001

 Missing

1

0.0

       

Employer type

 Premium-paying

9895

90.4

7689

77.7

2206

22.3

1.00

  

 Self-insured

1051

9.6

742

70.6

309

29.4

0.75

(0.63,0.88)

< 0.001

Time post claim

 6 to 11 months

8182

74.7

6365

77.8

1817

22.2

1.00

  

 12 to 17 months

1268

11.6

974

76.8

294

23.2

0.97

(0.83,1.13)

0.653

 More than 18 months

1496

13.7

1092

73.0

404

27.0

0.78

(0.67,0.89)

< 0.001

Year of interview

 2013

2486

22.7

1885

75.8

601

24.2

1.00

  

 2014

4304

39.3

3304

76.8

1000

23.2

1.11

(0.97,1.26)

0.119

 2016

4156

38.0

3242

78.0

914

22.0

1.17

(1.03,1.34)

0.018

  1. Note: AOR Adjusted Odds Ratio, CI 5 and 95% confidence intervals, p value = level of statistical significance; N number, col.% = column percentage; row % = row percentage; Higher AOR correspond with a positive claims experience