|Author(s) & Year of publication (Country)||Title||Methodology/purpose||Theme/focusing point||Findings/outcomes||Limitations||Quality grading|
De Silva et al. 2013 |
|Health status and quality of life of female garment workers in Sri Lanka||
Sample size: 1058 (female only).
Used structured questionnaire.
Respondents were selected randomly.
4 FGD (each consists 6 respondents).
Used Stata to carry out tabulations.
|To understand the quality of life and the health problems of the female garment workers.||
Reported health vulnerabilities issues:|
(a) Presence of musculoskeletal problem: 15.5%
Common symptoms of musculoskeletal problem:
Back pain (57.3%), Pain in knees (31.7%), Shoulder (9.1%), Neck (6.7%).
(b) Headaches: 7.6%
(c) Work related injury/accidents: 5.6%
(d) Respiratory problems: 3.4%
(e) Dermatological problem: 2.2%
(f) Emotional abuse: 0.5%
Exclusion of male respondents was not explained.|
The causes of health vulnerabilities were not exposed in this study.
|Lombardo et al., 2012  (Sri Lanka)||
Musculoskeletal symptoms among female|
garment factory workers in Sri Lanka
Cross sectional study.|
Sample size: 1058 (quantitative), & 24 for FGD (qualitative) (female only).
1st phase: FGD of 4 groups (each group consists of 6 female workers).
2nd phase: primary data was collected from 1058 female garment workers who were randomly selected for interviewing using a self-administered questionnaire.
Descriptive statistics were calculated, bivariate & multiple logistic regression analysis was done.
|To assess the presence of musculoskeletal symptoms among the respondents & to find the correlations between these symptoms and socio-demographic factors of the respondents.||
Prevalence of musculoskeletal symptoms among the respondents: 16%.|
Common symptoms (affected body area):
Hand & wrist (7.3%)
Forearm & elbow (3%)
Causes of musculoskeletal symptoms: Increased age, job tenure, & work nature (i.e. long standing position while working).
|Male workers were excluded.||Strong|
Saha et al., 2010 |
Health status of workers engaged in the small - scale|
garment industry: how healthy are they?
Sample size: 112.
Used semi-structured questionnaire.
2 FGDs (each consisted of 9 respondents) were also conducted.
|To explore the relationship between morbidity profile, socio-demographic & occupational factors with musculoskeletal disorders.||
Prevalence of musculoskeletal symptoms (chief complaints) among the respondents: 69.64%.|
Affected body area: Neck (64.10%), Low back (41.03%).
Common symptoms: Pain (69.23%), Weakness (38.46%).
Causes: Bad working environment, remaining in a bent position for long time, ill ventilation, poorly illuminated room.
Other health problems: Malnutrition (37.50%), Acidity & heart burn (26.79%), Skin diseases (25%), Insomnia (21.43%), Hypertension (16.07), General weakness (14.29%), Problems with vision (12.05%).
• Stress, especially among the female workers, is another rising & alarming problem.
|Although the title of the article gives the impression to focus on the overall health status of the workers, this piece of work predominantly pointed out only musculoskeletal problems of the workers||Strong|