Table 3 Cross-tabulation of study design by outcome category
From: The impact of participatory budgeting on health and wellbeing: a scoping review of evaluations
Outcomes | Case studies single | Case studies multiple | Quantitative Observational Study (Population level data) | RCT |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Population Social Impacts (poverty, health, education, housing, sanitation) | Kendall 2015 [18] | aBiderman 2007 [24] aBoulding 2010 [9] aGoncalves 2014 [25] aTouchton 2014 [26] aWorldBank 2008 [8] | ||
Economic and budgetary (funding of public services) | Stewart 2014 [20] | Cabannes 2005 [49] Cabannes 2015 [39] Del Prado 2015 [40] Dzinic 2016 [17] | Biderman 2007 [24] Boulding 2010 [9] Da Silva 2014 [33] Goncalves 2014 [25] Jaramillo 2013 [23] Jaramillo 2015 [27] Touchton 2014 [26] aWorldBank 2008 [8] Grillos 2017 [28] | Beuermann 2014 [21] |
Political (participation, democratic processes, political systems) | Abers 1998 [34] Baiocchi 2001 [47] Baiocchi 2003 [35] Célérier 2015 [36] Hernandez 2010 [41] aKendall 2015 [18] aStewart 2014 [20] Hajdarowicz 2018 [63] | Bassoli 2012 [48] aCabannes 2015 [39] Luchmann 2012 [42] McNulty 2015 [43] Montambeault 2016 [50] Nylen 2003 [37] Renno 2010 [51] SQW Consulting 2011 [19] Talpin 2012 [38] Wu 2011 [46] Gregorčič 2016 [52] | Borba 2012 [32] Garcia 2011 [29] Schneider 2002 [22] aWorldBank 2008 [8] |