Skip to main content

Table 4 Employment conditions among immigrants compared with natives

From: A systematic review of working conditions and occupational health among immigrants in Europe and Canada

Author (ref number)

Sample, method, country, study period

Observed mean differences or risk estimates, immigrants compared with natives:

Akhavan et al. [15]

Women working in a municipality, survey, Sweden, 2003

Temporary contract: PR 20% vs 8% (m) (no statistical test provided)

Borrell et al. [21]

A sample of immigrant workers, survey, Ireland, 2006–08

Temporary contracts: PR 40% vs 27%a (m) and PR 19% vs 21%NS (w)

Chen et al. [26]

General working pop. of immigrants, survey, Canada, 2001–4.

Over-educated: PR 52% (PR range: 32% western Europe thru 63% Southeast Asia). No data on natives.

Diaz-Serrano [33]

General working pop., survey, Spain, 2004/5.

Permanent contract: Prevalence difference = −33% (Latin American) a and − 38% (African) a and − 7% a (EU15)

Dunlavy et al. [34]

General working pop., Sweden 2010

Over-educated (objectively): PR 21% (non-western) and PR 15% (Western Europe) vs. PR 14% among native-born workers. No statistical test.

Premji and Lewchuk [60]

General working pop. Survey, Canada, 2005–6

Temporary contract: PR 37% vs 42% NS

Ronda et al. [64]

General working pop., survey, 31 European countries EU, 2004–5

No work contract: PR 10% vs 7% a (m) and PR 17% vs 8% (w)a

Smith PM and Mustard [72]

General working pop., survey, Canada, 2001

Temporary contract: OR 1.84, 95%CI 1.04–3.26

Solé et al. [73]

General working pop., survey, Spain, 2006

Temporary contracts: 48% vs. 37% a

Sousa et al. [75]

General working pop., survey, Spain, 2008–9.

Work contract: PR 41% temporary, 9% no contract, 24% undocumented vs. PR 41% and 12%, n/a, respectively.

Vives et al. [90]

General working pop., survey, Spain, 2004/5

Employment precariousness: PR 18.3% vs 5.6% a

  1. OR Odds ratio, PR prevalence (%)
  2. astatistically significant. NS not statistically significant, m men, w women, n/a not available