Skip to main content

Table 1 Mechanical, physical, chemical exposure among immigrants compared with natives

From: A systematic review of working conditions and occupational health among immigrants in Europe and Canada

Author (ref number)

Sample, method, country, study period

Observed mean differences or risk estimates, immigrants compared with natives:

Diaz-Serrano et al. [33]

General working pop., survey, Catalonia, 2006

Noise: mean = 1.8 vs.1.7a, dust: mean = 1.9 vs. 1.6a, heavy loads: mean = 1.8 vs. 1.6a

Dunlavy et al. [35]

General working pop, survey, Sweden, 2010–11.

Physical demanding work: ERR# = 1.3 (Latin-American) a, ERR# = 1.4 (other Non-Western)a, awkward working posturesNS

Premji & Lewchuk [60]

General working pop., survey, Canada, 2005–6

Heavy physical workload: ERR# = 1.7 a, toxic substances: ERR# = 0.6 (m) a

Ronda et al. [64]

General working pop., survey, 31 European countries EU, 2004–5

Vibrations: ERR# = 1.4(m) a /1.4(w) a, noise: ERR# = 1.3(m) a, high temperature: ERR# = 1.3(m) a, heavy loads: ERR# = 1.2(m) a/1.8 (w), painful positions: ERR# = 1.21(m)a, standing: ERR# = 1.2a, fume/dust: ERR# = 0.55 (w) a

Ronda et al. [63]

General working pop., survey, Spain, 2004–5

Lifting weightsNS, forced positionsNS, standing: ERR# = 1.2 (m) a/ 1.3 (w) a, chemical exposureNS, temperature: ERR# = 1.8(m) a/ 2.1(w) a, noiseNS

Smith et al. [70]

Cohort of immigrants, survey, Canada, 2000–01,

Higher physical demands compared to before arrival in Canada: Poor English: OR = 1.7 a, Refugee applicants: OR = 2.9 a.Data on natives = n/a

  1. OR odds ratio, RR relative risk, # ERR estimated relative risk based on reported prevalence numbers
  2. astatistically significant. NS not statistically significant, m men, w women, n/a not available