Skip to main content

Table 4 Recommendations compared to the Russell standard

From: Exploring consensus on how to measure smoking cessation. A Delphi study

 

Russell standard

Findings

Recommendations (Russell 2.0)

Self-report

Prolonged abstinence

Over the whole follow-up period

Prolonged abstinence

6 or/and 12 months

Prolonged abstinence

6 or/and 12 months

   

Point prevalence abstinence

7 daysa

Point prevalence abstinence

7 daysa

   

Continuous abstinence

6 monthsa

  
   

Number of cigarettes smoked

7 daysa

Number of cigarettes smoked

7 daysa

Grace period

 

Undefined

 

Undefined

 

Two weeks

Biochemical validation

Carbon monoxide

(9 p.p.m. in) expired air

Carbon monoxide

expired air

  
   

Cotinineb

salivaa

Cotinineb

(15 ng/ml in) salivaa

Follow-up

 

6 or/and 12 months

 

6 or/and 12 months

 

6 or/and 12 months

  1. aDifferent from the Russell standard
  2. bUse biochemical validation in new product and harm-reduction studies