Indoor and outdoor PM10 levels at schools located near mine dumps in Gauteng and North West Provinces, South Africa
BMC Public Health volume 17, Article number: 42 (2017)
Few studies in South Africa have investigated the exposure of asthmatic learners to indoor and outdoor air pollution at schools. This study compared outdoor PM10 and SO2 exposure levels in exposed (1–2 km from gold mine dumps) and unexposed schools (5 km or more from gold mine dumps). It also examined exposure of asthmatic children to indoor respirable dust at exposed and unexposed schools.
The study was conducted between 1 and 31 October 2012 in five schools from exposed and five from unexposed communities. Outdoor PM10 and SO2 levels were measured for 8-h at each school. Ten asthmatic learners were randomly selected from each school for 8-h personal respirable dust sampling during school hours.
The level of outdoor PM10 for exposed was 16.42 vs. 11.47 mg.m−3 for the unexposed communities (p < 0.001). The outdoor SO2 for exposed was 0.02 ppb vs. 0.01 ppb for unexposed communities (p < 0.001). Indoor respirable dust in the classroom differed significantly between exposed (0.17 mg.m−3) vs. unexposed (0.01 mg.m−3) children with asthma at each school (p < 0.001).
The significant differences between exposed and unexposed schools could reveal a serious potential health hazard for school children, although they were within the South African Air Quality Standards’ set by the Department of Environmental Affairs. The indoor respirable dust levels in exposed schools could have an impact on children with asthma, as they were significantly higher than the unexposed schools, although there are no published standards for environmental exposure for children with asthma.
Acute or chronic exposure to particulate matter <10 μm in diameter (PM10) is a worldwide concern. It is associated with the exacerbation of asthma attacks, the decline in lung function, preterm birth and an increase in hospital visits and deaths among children with pre-existing asthma conditions or respiratory diseases [1–9]. Children are the most susceptible population since they can receive a higher dose of PM10 in the lungs compared to adults. This may be due to greater fractional deposition with each breath and/or larger minute ventilation relative to lung size . Children spend approximately 7 or more hours per day at school, mostly in classrooms. This is the second highest time spent in the indoor environment after home, so makes the school an interesting area to assess air pollution exposure [11, 12]. Children’s personal exposure to indoor air pollutants, including PM10, is largely determined by pollutant concentration outdoors [13–15]. Research studies have shown that mine dumps are a major contributor to particulate matter air pollution to surrounding communities and that proximity is associated  with increased risk asthma symptoms. [17, 18] Taking into consideration that school children spend one-third of their total time inside school buildings, it is evident that air quality inside the classrooms should be of concern [5, 19, 20]. Whether it is indoor or outdoor, PM10 may have adverse biological effects when exposures are prolonged in children . Children who have asthma are a group that is particularly vulnerable to airborne pollutants such as PM10, SO2 and respirable dust. [22–27] In order to estimate the risk to children, particularly those with asthma; and develop a mitigation strategy, the actual levels of these air pollutants at schools near mine dumps need to be measured.
No studies appear to have investigated whether proximity to mine dumps influences outdoor air pollution and indoor respirable dust levels in South African schools. Thus, the aim of this study was to measure levels of PM10 and SO2 outside, as well as respirable dust indoors in schools exposed and unexposed to mine dust between 1 and 31 October 2012.
This study forms part of a bigger project initiated by Mine Health Safety Council of South Africa (MHSC) around communities located near mine dumps in Gauteng and North West, provinces in South Africa.
Study area, study period and demographics
Schools located 1–2 km (exposed) and 5 km or more (unexposed) [28, 29] from pre-selected five mine dumps in Gauteng and North West Provinces of South Africa were included in the study. The study was conducted between 1 and 31 October 2012. Table 1, lists the selected schools and Fig. 1 shows a map of the study area. The socio-economic and demographic profile of exposed and unexposed schools was similar.
The study participants were 13–14-year-old asthmatic learners. Ten of these learners were selected from each of the 10 schools (5 exposed and 5 unexposed) in Gauteng and North West provinces in South Africa. The socio-economic and demographic profile of the exposed and unexposed schools was similar. They form a subset of participants in the International Study of Asthma and Allergies in Children (ISAAC), 2012 survey. Three learners in each of two classrooms and four in one classroom were purposively selected for personal air sampling; Fig. 2 shows the seating position of learners within the classroom.
Commuting learners and learners that were not diagnosed as having asthma by the doctor/physician were not included in the study.
Personal air sampling
Personal air sampling was performed in the breathing zone of asthmatic learners during school hours from 8 am to 15 pm using a Gillian Personal Sampler. All the gravimetric sampling was done in accordance with the requirements of General Methods for Sampling and Gravimetric Analysis of Respirable, Thoracic and Inhalable Dust, Regulation 14/3 . Respirable particulate fraction is that fraction of inhaled airborne particles that can penetrate beyond the terminal bronchioles into the gas-exchange region of the lungs, usually measured in μg.m−3 .
Ambient air monitoring
An AEROQUAL mobile air monitoring station was used to measure the ambient PM10 and SO2 within the school premises, between 08 h00 and 15 h00, at a height of one meter, on an open space or ground. The mobile air monitoring station was placed downwind, in the South-easterly direction, where the wind is predominately blowing in the study areas.
All statistical analyses were performed using Stata™ version 14. Respirable dust was considered as the dependent variable and ambient air pollutants such as PM10, SO2 and date of sampling were independent variables. Eight-hour mean concentration of ambient air pollutants such as PM10, SO2 and respirable dust were determined. Pearson correlations coefficients were estimated to better understand their inter-relationship of PM10, SO2 and respirable dust. Descriptive statistics were used to explain data; standard deviations, percentiles and ranges were to illustrate data as appropriate. The t-test was using was used to compare the mean levels of respirable dust, PM10 and SO2 of exposed and unexposed schools. Ten filters for each school were weighed in the accredited laboratory. Data from the mobile air monitoring station and the laboratory were merged for analysis.
Crude and adjusted β-coefficients and 95% confidence intervals (CI) were calculated with univariate and multiple backwards hierarchical standard regression analysis to estimate the association between of respirable dust and independent variables such as PM10 outdoor concentration, SO2 outdoor concentration, school location, the date of sampling. Independent variables with a p-value <0.2 obtained in the univariate regression analysis were included in the multivariable regression analysis. A p-value < 0.05 in the multivariate regression analysis was considered statistically significant . The most parsimonious multivariate model is reported, i.e. the model with variables having a p-value < 0.05.
A total of 100 learners’ age between 13 and 14 years took part in the study. Fifty were from the communities exposed and other fifty from the unexposed communities. October encompassed part of the wet season in South Africa, Fig. 3 shows the percentage precipitation during the sampling period . The mean outdoor 8-h concentrations of PM10 and SO2 for both exposed and unexposed schools were within the South African Air Quality Standards’ set by the Department of Environmental Affairs . However, there was a significantly higher 8-h mean concentration of PM10 (p < 0.001), SO2 (p < 0.001) and respirable dust (p < 0.001) observed in schools located near mine dumps, as compared to unexposed schools (Table 2).
Table 3 shows the Spearman correlation coefficients of the indoor and outdoor pollutants. PM10 and respirable dust were significantly positively correlated with each other (p < 0.001). The strongest correlation coefficient observed was r = 0.41 (p-value = 0.02) between PM10 and respirable dust. No significant correlation was observed between SO2 and PM10, SO2 and respirable dust.
Results from the multivariate standard regression model (Table 4) indicated significant associations between respirable dust and PM10 (β = 0.27; 95% CI: 0.05–0.49); SO2 (β = −0.31; 95% CI:−0.57– − 0.05) and school location (β = −0.95; 95% CI:−1.18– − 0.71) respectively. The date of sampling was significantly associated with the indoor respirable dust in schools located near mine dumps in the univariate analysis (β = −11.59; 95% CI:−18.57– − 5.6), but not in the multivariate analysis.
The results of this study suggest that schools located near mine dumps in South African are exposed to higher levels of concentration of outdoor air pollutants such as outdoor PM10 and SO2 and indoor respirable dust compared to those located further away. Children with increased vulnerability to air pollution would be more likely to experience exacerbated asthma symptoms and attacks on both low and high air pollution days [35, 36]. The mean 8-h concentration levels of PM10 and SO2 were well below the South African Air Quality Standards’ set by the Department of Environmental Affairs . However, even such low levels might have a negative impact on the respiratory health of susceptible individuals, since there is no threshold limit for pollutants to trigger asthma symptoms and attack . Amenity deficiencies in schools such as poor maintenance and structural damage perhaps due to lack of funding observed during the survey may lead to pollutants infiltrating from the outdoor environment into the classrooms. Research studies have shown that asthmatic children miss more days at school than those without asthma [38–40]. This indicates that children attending schools in communities located near mine dumps, their respiratory health is not only compromised but also their academic performance might be negatively affected.
In assessing the school environment both indoor and outdoor air pollution contribution should be considered, since children often play outside their classrooms during breaks . In this study, a statistically significant correlation between PM10 and indoor respirable dust was observed; this is in agreement with other research studies that the outdoor PM10 can infiltrate and influence the indoor concentration levels of respirable dust. [42–45] The exposure assessment study conducted during the dry season in one of the mine dumps included in this study showed that the average 24-h ambient air pollution levels were twenty times high than what is recommended by the South African Air Quality Standards’ set by the Department of Environmental Affairs [17, 34]. This suggest that mine dumps can have an influence on the indoor air pollution levels in the houses and schools of the nearby communities. A cross-sectional study conducted in the communities located close to mine dumps in South Africa showed that a significant number of residents still use coal or fossil fuel as the main residential heating or cooking fuel type; [18, 46] probably contributes to the ambient levels of SO2 in these communities. Research studies have indicated that asthmatics are very sensitive to inhaled SO2, and experience changes in pulmonary function and respiratory symptoms after periods of exposure to SO2 as short as 10 min is sufficient to induce broncho-constriction [47–50].
Limitations of the study were that only SO2 was determined. Other gaseous pollutants such ozone and nitrogen dioxide were not included due to the mobile air monitoring station which only had one SO2 sensor. Only 10 schools were included in the study, due to limited funds and Gillian personal pumps. The study had a small sample size resulting in a small statistical power and the findings of this study cannot be generalized to the whole population/schools in communities near mine dumps. The study was conducted only in spring wet season and measurements were done once per school in each community. Therefore, it is suggested that further studies should be conducted to contrast indoor and outdoor levels in dry and wet seasons for a longer duration.
The significant differences between exposed and unexposed schools could reveal a serious potential health hazard for school children. The indoor respirable dust levels in exposed schools could have an impact on children with asthma, as they were significantly higher than the unexposed schools, although there are no published standards for environmental exposure for children with asthma.
- μg/m3 :
Microgram per cubic meter
Anglo gold Ashanti
Crown gold recoveries
Durban Roodepoort deep
East rand proprietary mine
- NRF- DAAD:
National research fund – Deutscher Akademischer Austausch Dienst
- PM10 :
Particulate matter with size less than 10 μm in diameter
- SO2 :
Simple regression analysis
Pudpong N, Rumchev K, Kungskulniti N. Indoor Concentrations of PM 10 and Factors Influencing Its Concentrations in Day Care Centres in Bangkok, Thailand. Asia J Public Heal. 2011;2(1):3–12.
Lin M, Chen Y, Burnett RT, Villeneuve PJ, Krewski D. The influence of ambient coarse particulate matter on asthma hospitalization in children: Case-crossover and time-series analyses. Environ Health Perspect. 2002;110(6):575–81.
Nastos PT, Paliatsos AG, Anthracopoulos MB, Roma ES, Priftis KN. Outdoor particulate matter and childhood asthma admissions in Athens, Greece: a time-series study. Environ Health. 2010;9(45):3–12.
Zhao Z, Zhang Z, Wang Z, Ferm M, Liang Y, Norbäck D. Asthmatic symptoms among pupils in relation to winter indoor and outdoor air pollution in schools in Taiyuan, China. Environ Health Perspect. 2008;116(1):90–7.
Lin CC, Peng CK. Characterization of Indoor PM10, PM2.5, and Ultrafine Particles in Elementary School Classrooms: A Review. Environ Eng Sci. 2010;27(11):915–22.
Ritz B, Yu F, Chapa G, Fruin S. Effect of air pollution on preterm birth among children born in Southern California between 1989 and 1993. Epidemiol. 2000;11(5):502–11.
Kampa M, Castanas E. Human health effects of air pollution. Environ Pollut. 2008;151(2):362–7.
Bernstein JA, Alexis N, Barnes C, Bernstein IL, Nel A, Peden D, et al. Health effects of air pollution. Vol. 114. J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2004;114(5):1116–23.
Anderson HR. Air pollution and mortality: A history. Atmos Environ. 2009;43(1):142–52.
Zeman WD, Bennett KL. Deposition of fine particles in children spontaneously breathing at rest. Inhal Toxicol. 1998;10(9):831–42.
Chithra VS, Shiva Nagendra SM. Indoor air quality investigations in a naturally ventilated school building located close to an urban roadway in Chennai, India. Build Environ. 2012;54(1):159–67.
Daisey JM, Angell WJ, Apte MG. Indoor air quality, ventilation and health symptoms in schools: an analysis of existing information. Indoor Air. 2003;13(1):53–64.
Zhang J, Smith KR. Indoor air pollution: A global health concern. Br Med Bull. 2003;68(1):209–25.
Spengler JD. Indoor air pollution. N Engl Reg Allergy Proc. 1985;6(2):126–34.
Franklin PJ. Indoor air quality and respiratory health of children. Paediatric Respir Rev. 2007;8(4):281–6.
Mohner M, Kersten N, Gellissen J. The impact of respirable dust and respirable quartz on pulmonary function-results of a longitudinal study. Occup Environ Med. 2014;70(1):1–9.
Ojelede ME, Annegarn HJ, Kneen MA. Evaluation of aeolian emissions from gold mine tailings on the Witwatersrand. Aeolian Res. 2012;3(4):477–86.
Nkosi V, Wichmann J, Voyi K. Mine dumps, wheeze, asthma, and rhinoconjunctivitis among adolescents in South Africa: any association? Int J Environ Health Res. 2015;25(6):583–600.
Triantafyllou AG, Zoras S, Evagelopoulos V, Garas S. PM10, O3, CO Concentrations and Elemental Analysis of Airborne Particles in a School Building. Water Air Soil Pollut Focus. 2007;8(1):77–87.
Godwin C, Batterman S. Indoor air quality in Michigan schools. Indoor Air. 2007;17(2):109–21.
Kulkarni N, Grigg J. Effect of air pollution on children. Paediatr Child Health. 2008;18(5):238–43.
Prospero JM, Blades E, Naidu R, Mathison G, Thani H, Lavoie MC. Relationship between African dust carried in the Atlantic trade winds and surges in pediatric asthma attendances in the Caribbean. Int J Biometeorol. 2008;52(8):823–32.
Chen PC, Doyle PE, Wang JD. Respirable dust exposure and respiratory health in male Taiwanese steelworkers. Ind Health. 2006;44(1):190–9.
Timonen KL, Pekkanen J. Air pollution and respiratory health among children with asthmatic or cough symptoms. Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 1997;156(2 Pt 1):546–52.
Pekkanen J, Timonen KL, Ruuskanen J, Reponen A, Mirme A. Effects of ultrafine and fine particles in urban air on peak expiratory flow among children with asthmatic symptoms. Environ Res. 1997;74(1):24–33.
Steinman HA, Le Roux M, Potter PC. Sulphur dioxide sensitivity in South African asthmatic children. S Afri Med J. 1993;83(6):387–90.
Smargiassi A, Kosatsky T, Hicks J, Plante C, Armstrong B, Villeneuve PJ, et al. Risk of asthmatic episodes in children exposed to sulfur dioxide stack emissions from a refinery point source in Montreal, Canada. Environ Health Perspect. 2009;117(4):653–9.
Joburg’s iconic mine dumps are a health risk, say activists. 2016. Available from: http://mg.co.za/article/2012-12-14-00-citys-iconic-mine-dumps-are-a-health-risk-say-activists
Andraos C, Voyi K, Annegam H, Nkosi V, Spiers G, Gulumian M. Adverse health impacts associated with dust emmissions from gold mine tailings. South African: National Institute for Occupational Health; 2016. p. 1–42.
Health and Safety Executive. General methods for sampling and gravimetric analysis of respirable, thoracic and inhalable aerosols. Methods for the Determination of Hazardous Substances Health and Safety Laboratory 14/4; 2005. p. 1–13. Available from: www.hse.gov.uk/pubns/mdhs/.
Chapter 1 - Dust: Definitions and Concepts. 2016. Available from: http://www.who.int/occupational_health/publications/en/oehairbornedust3.pdf
Gortmaker SL, Hosmer DW, Lemeshow S. Applied Logistic Regression. Vol. 23, Contemporary Sociol. 2nd ed. New York: John Wiley and Sons; 1994. p. 159.
Average Weather in October for Johannesburg, South Africa. 2012. Available from: https://weatherspark.com/averages/29019/10/Johannesburg-Gauteng-South-Africa.
National Environmental Management. Air Quality Act 39 of 2004, Government Notice Gazette. 2005. Gazette No:28016.
Norris G, Young-Pong SN, Koenig JQ, Larson TV, Sheppard L, Stout JW. An association between fine particles and asthma emergency department visits for children in Seattle. Environ Health Perspect. 1999;107(6):489–93.
Moshammer H, Hutter HP, Hauck H, Neuberger M. Low levels of air pollution induce changes of lung function in a panel of schoolchildren. Eur Respir J. 2006;27(6):1138–43.
World Health Organization: Ambient (outdoor) air quality and health. 2014. Available from: http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs313/en/.
Lindgren S, Lokshin B, Stromquist A, Weinberger M, Nassif E, McCubbin M, et al. Does asthma or treatment with theophylline limit children’s academic performance? N Engl J Med. 1992;327(13):926–30.
Currie J, Hanushek EA, Kahn EM, Neidell M, Rivkin SG. Does Pollution Increase School Absences? Rev Econ Stat. 2009;91(4):682–94.
Bener A, Kamal M, Shanks NJ. Impact of asthma and air pollution on school attendance of primary school children: are they at increased risk of school absenteeism? J Asthma. 2007;44(4):249–52.
Molnár P, Bellander T, Sällsten G, Boman J. Indoor and outdoor concentrations of PM2.5 trace elements at homes, preschools and schools in Stockholm, Sweden. J Environ Monit. 2007;9(2):348–57.
Koponen IK, Asmi A, Keronen P, Puhto K, Kulmala M. Indoor air measurement campaign in Helsinki, Finland 1999 - The effect of outdoor air pollution on indoor air. Atmos Environ. 2001;35(8):1465–77.
Schembari A, Triguero-Mas M, De Nazelle A, Dadvand P, Vrijheid M, Cirach M, et al. Personal, indoor and outdoor air pollution levels among pregnant women. Atmos Environ. 2013;64(1):287–95.
Guo H, Morawska L, He C, Zhang YL, Ayoko G, Cao M. Characterization of particle number concentrations and PM2.5 in a school: Influence of outdoor air pollution on indoor air. Environ Sci Pollut Res. 2010;17(6):1268–78.
Blondeau P, Iordache V, Poupard O, Genin D, Allard F. Relationship between outdoor and indoor air quality in eight French schools. Indoor Air. 2005;15(1):2–12.
Nkosi V, Wichmann J, Voyi K. Chronic respiratory disease among the elderly in South Africa: any association with proximity to mine dumps? Environ Heal. 2015;14(33):1–8.
Koenig JQ. Air pollution and asthma. J Allergy Clin Immunol. 1999;104(4 Pt 1):717–22.
Guillen Perez JJ, Guillen Grima F, Medrano Tortosa J, Garcia-Marcos Alvarez L, Aguinaga Ontoso I, Niguez Carbonell JC. Unusual attendance at Hospital Emergency Services for asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and SO2 air pollution in Cartagena (Spain). Rev Esp Salud Publica. 1995;69(3–4):305–14.
Tseng RY, Li CK. Low level atmospheric sulfur dioxide pollution and childhood asthma. Ann Allergy. 1990;65(5):379–83.
Lin S, Hwang SA, Pantea C, Kielb C, Fitzgerald E. Childhood asthma hospitalizations and ambient air sulfur dioxide concentrations in Bronx County, New York. Arch Environ Health. 2004;59(5):266–75.
Authors would like to thank the principals, teachers, and all learners who took part in the study. We are also grateful to Mine Health and Safety Council of South Africa (MHSC) for funding the study. A special thanks to Martin Oosthuizen of KDOHC Occupational Hygiene Company for assisting in conducting personal air sampling amongst the learners.
The funding for the field survey came from the Mine Health Safety Council of South Africa (MHSC) and National Research Fund – Deutscher Akademischer Austausch Dienst (NRF – DAAD).
Availability of data and materials
We did not receive research ethics approval to share the raw field data publicly. The data belong to the University of Pretoria and the Mine Health Safety Council of South Africa.
VN and KV participated in the design of the study, data collection, statistical analysis and interpretation of the results, drafted and critically revised the manuscript. JW participated in the statistical analysis and interpretation of the results, drafted and critically revised the manuscript. All authors have read and approved the final manuscript. The majority of the work for this study was conducted at the University of Pretoria (UP). VN was registered as a PhD student at UP. VN was employed at UP until 31 August 2016. The editing, addressing comments from the reviewer’s and final submission of this manuscript were done at the South African Medical Research Council, where VN has been employed since 1 September 2016.
Authors and the Mine Health and Safety Council of South Africa (MHSC) declare no competing interests.
Consent for publication
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Ethical approval (number 235/2011) for the study was obtained from the Research Ethics Committee of the Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Pretoria, Gauteng (reference number: D2012/79) and North West Department of Education (reference number: 24-04-12). School principals and governing bodies were approached and gave their consent for the study. Parents or guardians of the participants granted consent. Signed assent forms were obtained from the participants. All information was handled with strict confidentiality.
About this article
Cite this article
Nkosi, V., Wichmann, J. & Voyi, K. Indoor and outdoor PM10 levels at schools located near mine dumps in Gauteng and North West Provinces, South Africa. BMC Public Health 17, 42 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-016-3950-8