Skip to main content

Table 4 Interventions and healthcare costs

From: A decision analytic model to investigate the cost-effectiveness of poisoning prevention practices in households with young children

Parameter

Description

Data sources

Derivation of required cost information

Point estimate (standard error (SE))

Distribution

Intervention costsa

cFixed

Fixed cost of setting up an intervention scheme for 100 000 households

Saramago et al. 2014 [14]

Saramarago Cooper et al. [14]

£79,529

Fixed

cAccept

Cost of accepting intervention

 

Assumption

£0.40

Fixed

cTravel

Travel time and costs

 

Travel time and costs Nottingham home safety equipment schemeb hourly rate including on costs and vehicle costs is £25 (estimate obtained through personal communication) to install 5 items of safety equipment. We allocated 1/5 th of hourly rate to poisoning prevention activities.

£5.00

Fixed

Intervention schemes

cInter1

Usual care

 

No cost associated with usual care as no intervention is provided.

£0.00

Fixed

cInter2

Education

 

Estimate based on 5 min of health visitors time costing £44 (interquartile rage £33–£54) [19]. This assumes education is provided during contact for other reasons (e.g. child health surveillance contact). No travel costs are included as it is assumed contact either occurs in clinic or during home visit for other reasons.

£3.67

 

cInter3

Free or low cost safety equipment.

 

2x kitchen cabinet locks (based on providing one pop-It Lock™ costing £2.65 and one magnetic lock costing £4.80 each plus vat). This assumes locks are provided during contact for other reasons (e.g. child health surveillance contact). No travel costs are included as it is assumed contact either occurs in clinic or during home visit for other reasons.

£7.45

Fixed

cInter4

Education + equipment

 

Cost of education and two cabinet locks = £3.76 + £7.45. This assumes education and locks are provided during contact for other reasons (e.g. child health surveillance contact). No travel costs are included as it is assumed contact either occurs in clinic or during home visit for other reasons.

£11.12

Fixed

cInter5

Education + equipment + home safety inspection

 

Cost of education, two cabinet locks, home safety inspection and travel = £3.67 + £7.45 + £3.67 + £4.99. This assumes education, home safety inspection and locks are provided by a health visitor during contact covering prevention of a range of injuries, of which poison prevention is a part. It assumes poison prevention education and home safety inspection each takes 5 min of health visitor time.

£19.78

Fixed

cInter6

Education + equipment + fitting

 

Education + equipment + fitting Cost of education, two cabinet locks and fitting of two locks (assumed takes 5 min of safety equipment fitters time at £25 per hour) and travel = £3.67 + £7.45 + £2.08 + £4.99. This assumes education is provided by a health visitor during a contact for other reasons (e.g. child health surveillance) and locks and fitting of locks are provided by a safety equipment scheme during contact covering prevention of a range of injuries, of which poison prevention is a part. It assumes poison prevention education takes 5 min of health visitor time and fitting of locks takes 5 min of safety equipment fitters’ time at £25 per hour.

£18.19

Fixed

cInter7

Education + equipment + home inspection + fitting

 

Education + equipment + home inspection + fitting Cost of education, two cabinet locks, home inspection, fitting of locks and travel = £3.67 + £7.45 + £3.67 + £2.08 + £4.99. This assumes education is provided by a health visitor during a contact for other reasons (e.g. child health surveillance) and home safety inspection, locks and fitting of locks are provided by a safety equipment scheme during contact covering prevention of a range of injuries, of which poison prevention is a part. It assumes poiso

n prevention education takes 5 min of health visitor time and the home safety inspection and fitting of locks each take 5 min of safety equipment fitters’ time at £25 per hour.

£21.86

Fixed

Healthcare costs (Hospital and primary care costs)

cAmb

Cost of emergency transfers

PSSRU [19]

 

£263 (SE = £21.48)

Gamma

cED1

Cost of emergency department treatment of cases not leading to hospital inpatient stay (minor injury)

PSSRU [19]

 

£112 (SE = £27.41)

Gamma

cED2

Cost of emergency department treatment for cases leading to hospital inpatient stay (major injury)

PSSRU [19]

 

£146 (SE = £42.22)

Gamma

cAdmit1

Cost of a non-elective short (<2 days) inpatient admission

PSSRU [19]

 

£586 (SE = £223.70)

Gamma

cAdmit2

Cost of a non-elective long (≥2 days) inpatient admission

PSSRU [19]

 

£2461 (SE = £810.37)

Gamma

cChro

Annual cost of chronic ill-health

HALO study (Nicholl et al.: The Long Term Health and Healthcare Outcomes of Accidental Injury (The HALO Study) Final Report, (Unpublished))

 

£386.42 (SE = £96.72)

Gamma

cFatal

Cost of fatal injury

Saramago et al., 2014 [14]

 

£205.50

Fixed

cGP

Cost of 11.7 min GP consultation

PSSRU [19]

 

£43

Fixed

  1. a In the base case analysis, assumed that a specified amount of a home visitors time is spent on the poisoning prevention part of the visit. Hence we assumed 5 min of home visitors time is allocated for poisoning education, 5 min of safety fitter’s time for home safety inspection relevant to poisoning prevention and 5 min of safety fitter’s time for fitting two cupboard locks
  2. b The Nottingham safety equipment scheme provides a maximum number of items to be installed 2 gates, 2 cupboard catches, window catches, blind chord clips and a bath mat. Therefore assume 1/5th of travel time and costs are for poisoning prevention