Skip to main content

Table 2 Fluid reported intake from average of 3-day 24-h recall and 7-day diary registrya

From: Comparing a 7-day diary vs. 24 h-recall for estimating fluid consumption in overweight and obese Mexican women

Fluid consumption

24-h recall

7-day diary

Absolute difference 24 -h recall vs. 7-day diary (p-value)b

Total fluid consumption:

(n = 190)

(n = 190)

 

 kcal/d

266 [152, 375]

311 [187, 430]

−56 (0.072)

 mL/d

2094 [1700, 2649]

2259.0 [1710, 2693]

−165 (0.237)

Type of beverages

Sugar sweetened beveragesc

(n = 173)

(n = 177)

 

 kcal/d

126 [76.7, 248.1]

167 [101.8, 268.9]

−41 (0.017)

 mL/d

403 [234, 723]

416 [246, 652]

−13 (0.845)

Fruit juicesd

(n = 34)

(n = 55)

 

 kcal/d

63 [39.2, 78.4]

34 [16.8, 48.4]

30 (<0.010)

 mL/d

162 [87, 175]

75 [37, 110]

87 (<0.010)

Milk and milk products without added sugare

(n = 98)

(n = 131)

 

 kcal/d

60 [39.7, 100.5]

58 [25.5, 106.5]

−2 (0.195)

 mL/d

126 [83, 227]

108 [44, 211]

18 (0.025)

Milk and milk products with added sugarf

(n = 96)

(n = 113)

 

 kcal/d

92 [59.9, 152.5]

73 [33.5, 129.5]

19 (0.011)

 mL/d

150 [87, 264]

87 [48, 177]

63 (<0.010)

Alcohol beveragesg

(n = 30)

(n = 49)

 

 kcal/d

95 [45.6, 159.4]

45 [27.5, 110.2]

50 (<0.010)

 mL/d

133 [106, 300]

90 46, 157]

43 (<0.010)

Unsweetened beveragesh

(n = 74)

(n = 85)

 

 kcal/d

3 [1.6, 13.5]

2 [0.8, 9.1]

1 (0.082)

 mL/d

190 [86, 370]

143 [71, 339]

47 (0.023)

Water

(n = 187)

(n = 190)

 

 mL/d

1340 [883, 1917]

1554 [821, 1986]

−214 (0.261)

  1. aMedian and 25th–75th percentile, or as specified
  2. bMann–Whitney rank-sum test
  3. cSugar-sweetened beverages: canned or commercial juices, soft drinks, atole (beverage with sugar, without milk), artificial fruit beverages with sugar, sugar-sweetened traditional beverages, such as lemonade, hibiscus water, and rice water [aguas frescas], coffee or tea with sugar
  4. dFruit juices: natural fruit and vegetables juices without sugar added
  5. eMilk and milk products without added sugar: milk and drinkable yogurt (plain or light), atole with milk, without sugar added, fermented beverage without sugar, coffee or tea with milk or cream substitute
  6. fMilk and milk products with added sugar: sweetened milk, yogurt or fermented beverages, atole with milk and sugar, milk with chocolate, milkshake, coffee or tea with milk and sugar added
  7. gAlcohol beverages: beer, alcoholic eggnog, rum, wine, vodka, whisky, with or without other ingredients
  8. hUnsweetened beverages: sugar-free carbonated beverages, atole without sugar or milk, mineral water, coffee and tea without sugar, beverages with noncaloric sweeteners