Skip to main content

Table 4 Summary of the themes that emerged during the focus groups discussion on materials pertaining to physical activity promotion and aging

From: The need to modify physical activity messages to better speak to older African American women: a pilot study

Theme

Brief theme description

Sample quotes

1. We may have trouble in reading it

This theme represents the perceptions of older African American women towards the PA materials presented to them during the focus group discussion. Perceptions varied among the three materials.

Physical Activity Guidelines for Older Adults:

ā€œā€¦ the words, need to be brought down to another level, I think that some of it could be a little elevated for some peopleā€¦ if the seniors, they may be having problems with the readingā€¦ so they canā€™t relate or read all those wordsā€¦some African American descendent would have trouble with thisā€¦ itā€™s way too much information, itā€™s information overloadedā€¦ā€ (72Ā years - Inactive)

Briefly, the Physical Activity Guidelines for Older Adults was not appealing to the women in both focus groups because of the difficult language, technical terminology and information overload.

The ā€œBe Active Your Wayā€ was considered a mid-point in regarding preference between the three because it brings a compact message and it is more visual; despite some participants still recognize the terminology used as challenging.

Be Active Your Way:

ā€œā€¦ Itā€™s a little bit more condensed than the CDC paper and it doesnā€™t give you what the, all the wordings that the CDC paper doesā€¦ itā€™s a little bit easier to readā€¦ā€ (66Ā years - Inactive)

At the other end the ā€œExercise and Physical Activityā€ brochure, language was only mentioned in a positive context.

ā€œā€¦ Itā€™s more colorful, it has perked my interest. Iā€™m a visual learnerā€¦ I like just the bar on the bottom that says, ā€œBe active, healthy, and happyā€. I think those are active wordsā€¦ I want to be active, healthy, and happyā€¦ (66Ā years - active)

Exercise and Physical Activity: Your Everyday Guide:

ā€œā€¦ I think that the instructions for the exercises are easy to readā€¦ they basically word it easyā€¦ and them of course having the illustration, kind of step by step, helps because you can actually see a picture and associated with the instructions you haveā€¦ I like it because they have actually broken it downā€¦ they go in-depth, thinking about beyond a certain class of peopleā€¦ and make them want to readā€¦ā€ (65Ā years - Active)

2. It does not reflect us

This theme represents the concern of the women from both focus groups regarding the examples of activities used in the materials. Women from both groups expressed their concern that examples of activities provided in the materials do not reflect the reality of the African American population.

ā€œā€¦for black womenā€¦ there were restrictions on the physical activity for black Americansā€¦ You couldnā€™t even go swimming in the pool. You were restricted. You certainly couldnā€™t hang out at the track in the high school and walk around the track at a high school, and be suspect. You couldnā€™t go to a public beach and swimā€¦ā€ (65Ā years - Active)

ā€œā€¦ it has a lot to do with economicsā€¦ looking at these lists [examples of activities provided in the materials for moderate and vigorous intensity] to me I still keep going back to the black versus white, whereas these are not the things we have thought of all of our entire lives.ā€ (66Ā years - Inactive)

  1. Materials included in the focus groups discussions, Exercise and Physical Activity: Your Everyday Guide; The Physical Activity Guidelines for Older Adults; and Be Active Your Way: A Guide for Adults