Skip to main content

Table 1 AUDIT study hypotheses

From: Do federal and state audits increase compliance with a grant program to improve municipal infrastructure (AUDIT study): study protocol for a randomized controlled trial

 

        Primary objective: Impact evaluation

H1

Municipal administrators in treated municipalities are aware of

 

their treatment status

H2

Municipal administrators in treated municipalities audited in year 1

 

believe the probability of being audited in year 2 is lower than in

 

year 3

H3

Municipal administrators in treated municipalities have higher

 

long-run beliefs about the probability of being audited

H4

Municipal administrators in treated municipalities have higher

 

knowledge of FISM grant rules and regulations

H5

Municipal administrators in treated municipalities manifest

 

preferences for municipal investments more in accordance with

 

FISM priorities

H6

Municipal administrators in treated municipalities are more

 

aware of lack of capacity and more likely to manifest plans for

 

improving capacity

H7

Municipal administrators in treated municipalities are more likely

 

to comply with FISM reporting and data accessibility rules

H8

Audited municipalities report allocating more FISM investment

 

funds to localities outside the council seat and to public goods

  Secondary objective: Differences between state and federal audits

 

H9

The federal auditor (ASF) yields more observations and more

 

refunds to the federal treasury than state auditors (EFSL)

H10

The ASF yields more severe observations and opinions than EFSL

  Tertiary objective: Interactions with local accountability system

 

H11

Municipal administrators in treated municipalities have different

 

expectations about future political appointments

H12

Municipal administrators in treated municipalities have different

 

expectations about career prospects

H13

Municipal administrators in treated municipalities perceive the

 

ASF as a more important principal

H14

State governors compensate audited municipalities for refunds to

 

the federal government

  1. This table lists the pre-specified hypotheses that will be tested to help meet the study objectives.