Skip to main content

Table 1 Warning statements by primary characteristics

From: Developing cancer warning statements for alcoholic beverages

Statement

Message frame

Numerical evidence

Fear appeal*

Specificity of cancer

Warning: alcohol harms your health

Negative

   

Warning: alcohol increases your risk of cancer

Negative

 

Yes

General

Alcohol causes cancer: reduce your intake to reduce your risk

Positive

  

General

Reduce your drinking to reduce your risk of cancer

Positive

  

General

Alcohol increases your risk of bowel cancer

Negative

 

Yes

Specific

Alcohol increases your risk of breast cancer

Negative

 

Yes

Specific

Alcohol increases your risk of breast, bowel, throat, and mouth cancer

Negative

 

Yes

Specific

Alcohol increases your risk of cancer

Negative

 

Yes

General

Alcohol can cause breast cancer

Negative

 

Yes

Specific

Alcohol can cause bowel cancer

Negative

 

Yes

Specific

Alcohol causes around 5000 new cases of cancer each year

Negative

Yes

 

General

Alcohol causes 1 in 20 cancer deaths

Negative

Yes

 

General

  1. *Cancer warning statements that did not feature a positive frame or numerical evidence were classified as fear appeal messages.