Skip to main content

Table 3 The factors from all studies coded on the two-level classifications of ICF

From: Factors influencing work participation of adults with developmental dyslexia: a systematic review

2ndlevel ICF

Factors

Qualitative studies

Quantitative studies

Functions & structures

   

b1 Mental functions

   

b114

Orientation functions

 

36 -, 37 -

 

b126

Temperament and personality functions

Adaptability

34 +, 39 +

 

Optimistic

 

55

Perseverance/persistence

28 +, 29 +, 31 +, 35 + 36 +, 42+

46 +, 57+

Personal characteristics

 

47

Uncertain/insecure

28 -, 29 -

 

b140

Attention functions

 

30 -, 34 -, 36 -

 

b144

Memory functions

 

31 -, 34 +, 36 - 37 -, 43-

56-

Remembering instructions

42

 

Remembering names

42

 

b152

Emotional functions

Amount of passion

39

 

Anxiety

28 -, 37 -, 40 -

 

Aggressive feelings

28

 

Concern for patient safety

 

56

Confusion/anger

29 -, 30 -, 32 -, 37 -, 42-

 

Depression

37

 

Discouragement

32

 

Emotional problems

28

 

Fear of being stigmatized

40 -, 42-, 43-

 

Fear of exposure

37 -, 43-

 

Fear of failure

28 -

56-

Feelings of accomplishment

43-

49 +

Feeling of being different

28 -, 37 -, 43-

 

Feeling of inadequacy

34 -, 42-

 

Feeling of presenting a false impression (impostor phenomenon)

37

 

Frustration

28 -, 30 -, 32 - 37 -

 

Guilt/embarrassment

34 -, 37 -

55-, 56-

Inferiority feelings

28 -, 31 -, 37 -

56-

Sense of strength

29 +, 31 +, 35 +

 

Shame

34 -, 37 - , 43-

 

b156

Perception

 

29 +, 37 +

 

b160

Thought functions

 

29 +, 34 +, 35 -, 36 +

56+

b164

Higher-level cognitive functions

Executive functions

35

 

Holistic/visual thinking

31 +, 35 +

 

Increased creativity

29 +, 36 +, 37 +

 

Information processing

 

49 -, 57-

Organization and planning

29 -, 31 +, 36 +, 37 -, 39 -

49 +, 56-, 57-

Thinking outside the box

29

 

b167

Mental functions of language

Word retrieval

37

 

b180

Experience of self and time functions

Bothered by being different

36

 

Depersonalize LD

36

 

Disability self-awareness

30 +, 35 +, 36 +

 

Labeling LD as a kind of self-mockery

39

 

Negative self-perceptions

30 -, 34 -, 37 -

 

Not seeing themselves as having a disability

30 +, 40 +

 

Self-conscious

40

 

Activities (d1- d6) and participation (d7- d9)

d1 Learning and applying knowledge

d115

Listening

 

36

 

d155

Acquiring skills

Analytical skills

36 +

57-

Developing coping strategies

40

 

Developing different learning styles

42

 

Learning a new skill

42°, 44+

 

Learning operating instrument names

42

 

Practical skills

31 +, 35 +

 

d160

Focusing attention

 

31 +, 37 +

 

d166

Reading

 

28 -, 29 -, 30 -, 31 -, 35 -, 36 -, 37 -, 40 -, 42-, 43-

45°, 54°, 55-, 56-, 57-, 60-

d170

Writing (spelling)

 

28 -, 29 -, 30 -, 31 -, 34 -, 35 -, 36 -, 39 -, 40 -, 42-, 43-

49 -, 54-, 55-, 56-, 57-, 60-

Writing reports to work

33 -, 41-, 42-

 

d172

Calculating

 

36 +, 42-, 43-

56-, 60-

d175

Solving problems

 

31 +, 34 +, 36 +, 37 +

57+

d2 General tasks and demands

d210

Undertaking a single task

 

37

 

d220

Undertaking multiple tasks

Correcting mistakes

 

52

Gathering information

36°

56-

Giving lectures/presentations/training sessions

31 +, 35 -, 42-

 

Meetings

42-

56-

Representing a group

42

 

d230

Carrying out daily routine

 

28 ±, 36 ±, 37 ±, 40 ±, 42-, 43±

 

d240

Handling stress and other responsibilities

 

36

 

Handling responsibilities

28

 

d3 Communication

   

d310

Communicating with – receiving – spoken messages

 

30 -, 36 ±

 

d315

Communicating with – receiving nonverbal messages

Receiving body gestures

35

 

d325

Communicating with – receiving – written messages

 

30 -, 36 -, 37 -

49 -, 57-

d330

Speaking

 

28 -, 31 +, 35 +, 36 ±

56-

Speaking in public

 

56

d335

Producing nonverbalmessages

Using drawings

31 +, 35 +

 

d345

Writing messages

Completing a literacy exercise

40

 

Filling in application forms

30 -, 40 -, 42-

60-

Keeping records

42+

56-

Note taking

30 -, 36 +, 42-

 

Taking telephone messages

42

 

d355

Discussion

Discussing (LD with employer/problems with colleagues)

30 -, 31 +, 34°, 35 +

 

d 360

Using communication devices and techniques

Dialing a phone

36

 

Multitasking (on a computer)

36

 

Using computer software/skills

28 +, 35 +, 36 +, 40 +

57-

d6 Domestic life

   

d660

Assisting others

Helping students

31 +, 32 +, 35 +

 
 

Motivate students

31 +, 32 +, 35 +

 
 

Validate students feelings

31 +, 32 +, 35 +

 

d7 Interpersonal interactions and relationships

d710

Basic interpersonal interactions

 

32

 

Using social skills

31 +, 35 +

46 +

d720

Complex interpersonal interactions

Forming relationships

28 -, 36 -

 

d740

Formal relationships

Relationships with clients

41

 

d8 Major life areas

d845

Acquiring, keeping and terminating a job

Ability to maintain the career

29 -, 40 -

56-

Demotion or dismissal

37 -, 40 -, 43-

56-

Meeting their goals

32 +, 42+

 

Occupation choice

42-

46°, 53-, 56-, 58-, 59-

Securing his current position

29 -, 34 +, 40 -

46 -, 49°, 57-

Seeking employment

40

 

Skills for performing the job

43

 

Survive within the workplace

40

 

Terminating a job

34 -, 43-

 

Working much harder

28 -, 31 -, 35 -, 36 -

 

d850

Remunerative employment

Achievement/accomplishment

28 -, 29 ±, 31 - 42±, 43-

 

Continuous changing of employment

40

 

Employment roles

40

 

Employment in unskilled/semiskilled occupations

28 -, 40 -

50 -, 60+

Employment in white-collar/blue-collar jobs

 

45°, 52 +, 53+, 55+

Enabled to excel

36

 

Having a job/being employed

28 +

47 +, 51 +, 55+

Having more jobs

 

47

Job history

28

 

Job at the level of their training or higher

28 +, 36 +

 

Job performance

33 +, 34 +, 43-

 

Limited employment opportunities

43-

47 -, 55-

Part-time employment

28 +, 29 +

55-

Permanently employed

 

55+, 60-

Quality of products and processes

41

 

Unemployed

28 -, 40 -

48 -, 52 -, 59-

Workforce abilities

 

47

Work-related environmental factors: terms of employment

 

Access to degree courses

42-

56+

Attendance

33

 

Change in job description/title

34

 

Current (annual) salary

 

46°, 49 + °, 51 -, 52 -, 59°

Extra study leave

42

 

Extra time

34 +

56+, 57+

Flexible schedule

33 +, 41+

 

Incentives and bonuses

34

 

Income derived from employment

 

59

On-the-job training agreement

31 +, 33 +

 

Promotion/Job advancement

30 +, 33 +, 34 +, 42+

51 -

Tenure used as productivity signal

30 +

47 +

Tenure with current employer

30 +

47 +

Wage -gap (with non-LD)

 

47 -, 51°, 52 +

Wage increase/decrease

33 +, 34 +

47 +

Working from home

41

 

Working at off hours late in the day or night

36 +, 41+, 42-

46 +, 49 +, 50 + 56+, 57+

Work-related environmental factors: social relationships at work

e3 Support and relationships

e315/e320

Extended family/friends

Support from family/friends

28 +, 29 +, 32 +, 33 +, 34 +, 35 +, 39 +

55+

e325

Acquaintances, peers, colleagues, neighbors and community members

Being loners/isolated in the job

37

 

Control/check by others

28 +, 31 +, 35 +, 36 +, 37 +, 42+

56+

Encouragement

 

56

Help from colleagues/co-worker assistance

28 +, 30 -, 31 + 34 +, 35 +, 37 +, 41+, 42+

46 +, 49 +, 56+

Joint goal planning

44

 

Joint working

35 +, 44+

 

Peer pressure

36

 

Performance feedback

37

 

Secretary dependent

36

 

Social relationships with co-workers (trust)

31 +, 35 +, 37 -

56+, 57±

Support in the workplace

29 +, 30 -, 34 +, 35 + , 42+

56+

Workforce morale

42

 

e330

People in position of authority

Employer assistance-support

30 -, 34 +, 38 +, 42-

47 +, 49 +, 56+, 57+

Role of employer-supervisor

30 +, 31 +, 37 +

51 -, 57°

Support of rehabilitation staff

33

 

e4 Attitudes

   

e425

Individual attitudes of acquaintances, peers, colleagues, neighbors and community members

Appreciation of/consideration to mental disabilities

41

 

Attitudinal barriers

41-, 42-

 

Awareness/detection of the disability

34 -, 36°, 40 -, 41+, 42-

 

Discrimination

40 -, 41-, 43-

47 -

Interest in, acceptance / understanding of dyslexia

28 -, 34 -, 41-, 42-, 43-

56-, 57-

Labeling people with LD as lazy, slow, dumb or stupid

22 -, 39 -, 41-, 42-

 

LD makes me important

34

 

LD as a tool to address misconceptions about LD

32 +

57+

Reactions of co-workers

28°, 31 - 32 +, 34 ±, 35 -, 36 -, 39°, 40 -, 41-, 42-, 43-

56±

Stigmatization by colleagues

40 - , 42-, 43-

 

e430

Individual attitudes of people in position of authority

Acceptance of dyslexia by employer

34 +, 36 +, 43+

56-

Detection/awareness of the disability

34 -, 36 -, 40 -, 41-, 42-

47°

Employer attitudes and knowledge

30 +, 38 -, 42-

 

High expectations of people with LD

32 +, 43-

 

Judgment of work on disability

28

 

Negative responses from employer

31 -, 34 -, 40 -

 

Stigmatization by employer

40

 

Work-related environmental factors: task content

 

Benefits of current position

33

 

Challenging students to achieve their potential

31 +, 35 +

 

Control over their work

31 +, 36 +,

 

Demands involving reading or writing

 

53-, 55-, 58-

Demands of the job

33 -, 37 -

46 +

Finding a niche

29 +, 36 +

 

Increase of independence

36

 

Job level

28

 

More responsibility

31 +, 30 +, 33 +, 34 +

 

Much information in a constant stream

 

56

Multitasking is required

 

56

Prioritizing tasks

 

46 +, 49 +, 57+

Productivity demands

33

 

Self-regulation

 

46 +, 49 +

Taking work home

41+, 42-

 

Working under pressure

42

 

Workload, pressure, more stress

29 -, 34 -, 41-, 42-, 43+

56-

To work by myself

30 +, 37 +

 

Work-related environmental factors: working conditions

e125

Products and technology for communication

Assistive technology (like a dictaphone, internet, navigation software, watch, microcassette)

32 +, 34 +, 35 +, 36 +, 40 +, 42+, 43+

46 +, 57+

Clear signs

42

 

Computer spelling and grammar programs

28 +, 35 +, 36 +, 42+

56+

Simple words and pictures

42

 

Technology interferes with work/Experiment with technology

36

 

Visual aids

31

 

Voice-mail

36

 

e135

Products and technology for employment

Accommodations on the job

29 -, 30 -, 32 +, 34 +, 36 +, 38 -, 40 - , 42+, 43-, 44

46 +, 49 -, 57+°

e1650

Financial assets

Budget for an assistant

28 +, 34 +

 

Money

40 -, 41-

 

Other working conditions

Accessibility of the office environment

41

 

Changing/improving the work environment

42

 

Finding a quiet/personal work environment

35 +

46 +

Hearing the words spoken aloud

36

 

A mentor

33 +, 34 +

 

Time

31 -, 34 +, 35 -, 37 -, 41-, 42-

 

Using proofreaders

35 +, 36 +, 43+

46 +, 57+

Other work-related environmental factors

 

Centrality of LD in his career

39

 

Critical knowledge and experiences on LD of employers

38

 

Disabling barriers

40

 

Information about (the impact of) dyslexia for employers

30 -, 38 -

 

Job shadows

33

 

Job visits

33

 

School-to-work program

33

 

Training sessions regarding disability

41

 

Vocational rehabilitation

33

 

Work-related injury risk

 

50

Other environmental factors

e550

Legal services, systems and policies

Certifying disability

41

 

Disability Discrimination Act

41

 

Diversity agenda

41

 

Equality issues

41

 

Knowledge of the ADA

30

 

Legislation on adults with LD

34 +, 41+

 

e570

Social security services, systems and policies

Income from government benefits/resources

 

59

Personal factors

   

---

General personal data:

Age

 

45°, 46°, 49°, 52°, 60°

Socio-demographic factors

Gender

 

45 +, 46°, 47 - 48 -, 49°, 50 +, 52°. 54°, 60°

Language

 

54

Socio-economic status

39 +, 40 -

48 +

Standard/level of education

41°

45°, 48 +, 59+, 60+

---

General ‘mental’ personal factors

Aggravation

30

 

Common sense

 

56

Confidence

42+

56+

Creative

31 +, 37 +

56+

Demoralized

40

 

Desire to help others

31 +, 37 +

 

Detail oriented

36

 

Diligent

 

56

Empathic

31 +

56+, 57+

Humorous

35 +

56+

Innovative

31 +, 37 +

 

Learning/Coping strategies:

28 +, 29 +, 31 +, 37 +, 40 +, 41+, 42+

46 +, 47 +, 49 +, 56+

 

Adjusted to the disability

43

 

Ask caller to speak slowly

42

 

Authoritative language

39

 

Avoid my weaknesses

36

 

Avoidance

28 -, 35 -, 36 +

 

Aware of limitations

35

 

Be aware of problem words

42

 

Bluffing

39

 

Camouflage

28 -, 40 -

 

Compensatory skills

36 +, 39 +, 43+

47 +

Develop own shorthand

42

 

Disclosing weaknesses

31

 

Distancing himself from others

29 -, 39 -

 

Establish themselves as intelligent

40

 

Excessive amount of energy in work

28

 

Exposing own difficulties

31

 

Get writings/forms checked

35 +, 42+

 

Give colour coded feedback

35

 

Hiding the LD

35 -, 37 -, 40 -

 

Leave and come back later, when losing concentration

42

 

Make careful mental and concrete preparations

35

 

Make lists or leave notes for myself

 

56

Make people write things down what they have said

35 +, 36 +

 

Mnemonics

35

 

Other practical solutions

28

 

Overcompensation

28

 

Paper and pencil in pocket

42

 

Pattern of overachieving

29

 

Physical activities to recall ideas

35

 

Read back messages to caller

42

 

Read novels to experience different types of writing

42

 

Repeat names many times

42

 

Repression

28

 

Tricks

28

 

Using prompts to recall topics

35

 

Use set phrases

42

 

Visualization techniques

35

 

Write things out in rough

42

 

Literacy level

40 -

54+, 59+, 60+

Openness

28 ±, 30 -, 31 +, 42-, 43-

 

Patience

36

 

Personal problems

28

 

Pride

29

 

Satisfaction with life

28

 

Secretive

43

 

Sensitive to emotional experiences of others

29 +, 31 +, 36 +, 37 +

 

Self-advocacy

30 ±, 38 +, 44+

 

Self-control

28

 

Self-disclosure

30 -, 32 +, 34 +,35 +, 37°, 38 -, 39°, 40 -, 43

46 -, 49 0-, 56+, 57

Self-efficacy

35 +

46 +, 49 +

Self-empowerment

39

 

Self-esteem

29 +, 31 +, 32 +, 35 +, 36 +, 39 +, 42+

48 +

Self-promotion

30

 

Self-reliant

36

 

Self-sufficient

36

 

Social person

36

 

Stress avoidance

28

 

Stress-experience/being stressed

28 -, 29 -, 34 -, 35 -, 36 -, 37 -, 42-

 

Stubborn

 

57

Tolerant

 

56

Visual

31 +, 35 +

 

---

Health related personal factors

Accepting the LD/dyslexia

28

 

Experiences with LD/dyslexia

29 -, 37 -

 

Impact of the LD/dyslexia

28 -, 36 -, 37°, 40°, 41-, 42-, 43-

46 -, 49 0-, 55-, 56-. 57-

Locus of control

 

48

Management of the LD/dyslexia

40

 

---

Work related personal factors

Collaborative/co-operative

31

 

Commitment

33

 

Compliance

38

 

Determination

31 +, 35 +, 36 +, 42+

56+

Focus

33

 

Force of will

39

 

Goal driven

33

 

Independence

29 +, 32 +, 36 +

49 +

Job/career satisfaction

28 0+, 36 +, 43+

46 +, 49 +, 51 -

Prestige aspirations

31 +

48 +

Proactive

31 +

 

Productivity/worker characteristics

 

47

Successful

29 +, 31 +, 32 +, 36 +, 41+

 

Tenacity

34

 

Underchallenged

29

 

Work ethic

29

 
  1. The studies which are in bold are the studies that meet the minimum level of the quality criteria. (In each category the findings are in alphabetical order).