From: HIV behavioural interventions targeted towards older adults: a systematic review
Article | Focus area | Participants | Study design | Intervention | Control group (Y/N) | Measure | Results | Summary |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Among HIV-Negative Older Adults | ||||||||
Small 2009 [60] | Knowledge | Individuals aged 50 years and older N = 50 | Both quantitative and qualitative data were gathered during each session and included a pre-survey and immediate post-37-item-survey, a focus group, and an HIV educational curriculum. | Four HIV education training sessions each lasting three hours covering the following topics: (a) Introduction and Overview, (b) Identifying Myths and Stereotypes, (c) HIV Facts, and (d) Provision of Resources. | No | Interest in HIV prevention and education (composite of two questions) | HIV knowledge was not significantly (p = .273) higher in the posttest (mean = 10.92) than in the pretest (mean = 10.32) | Substantive knowledge about HIV and AIDS remained low among respondents, and there was no significant change in knowledge after the administration of the modified curriculum |
Purposive sampling USA | Substantive HIV knowledge (composite of 15 questions) | |||||||
Orel et al. 2010 [58] | Knowledge | 11 participants of 89 aged 60 and older completed both questionnaires N = 11 USA | Before and after questionnaires | “No One is Immune Project” –six-hour education and prevention workshop held at senior centre. Post-test questionnaire administered immediately after workshop. | No | 45-item HIV/AIDS Knowledge Questionnaire | Increase in % answering correct | Workshop increased knowledge of HIV among older adults |
● HIV can be spread by mosquitoes (48 to 98) | ||||||||
● you cannot get HIV when getting a tattoo (25 to 78) | ||||||||
● women are always tested for HIV during their pap smears (12 to 100) | ||||||||
● No data provided on overall changes in scores | ||||||||
Altschuler et al. 2004 [59] | Knowledge | Adults aged 50 years and older USA N = 40 | Verbal feedback after educational program | 3 hour educational program. Curriculum includes overview, myths and stereotypes, facts and resources. | No | Group feedback on HIV awareness, HIV perceptions and ability to speak to health care providers | Participants identified learning that HIV was relevant to their lives; feeling empowered to speak up to their health care providers; positive impression being able to discuss a taboo topic. | Qualitative results suggest that education program can help individuals discuss HIV with partners. |
Rose 1996 [25] | Knowledge | Individuals aged >60 recruited at senior citizen meal sites USA | Pre and post-test cross-sectional survey | 20-30 minute age-specific AIDS education program delivered at meal site and educational pamphlet. Consisted of statistics and facts about HIV, prevention measures and case studies of elderly people with HIV. Post-test administered immediately following education program. | No | Questionnaire measured HIV knowledge and perceptions of susceptibility to HIV (Likert scales) | Significant increase in total knowledge about AIDS (p < 0.001), perceived susceptibility (p < 0.01) and perceived severity (p < 0.001) | Age specific education program significantly increased HIV-related knowledge at senior citizen meal sites |
Pre-intervention N = 458 | ||||||||
Post-intervention N = 318 | ||||||||
Among HIV-Positive Older Adults | ||||||||
Lovejoy et al. 2011 [53] | Risk behaviour | HIV-infected adults 45-plus years old who reported engaging in at least one occasion of unprotected sex in the 3 months prior to enrolment N = 100 USA | Randomised controlled trial | Telephone delivered motivational interviewing (MI) (client-focused and directive form of counselling) to reduce risky sexual behaviour | Yes (N = 23) | Episodes of unprotected sex in past 3 months | Participants in the 4-session MI arm engaged in the fewest occasions of unprotected sex at 3 and 6 month follow-up. Controls had on average 3.24 times as many occasions of unprotected sex (95% CI 1.79-5.85). Furthermore, 1-session MI participants had four times as many unprotected sex acts as 4-session MI participants at 3-month (OR = 3.98 [2.38–6.67]) and 6-month (OR = 4.39 [2.56–7.46]) follow-up. | Four sessions of telephone-delivered MI reduces sexual risk behaviour among HIV-positive older adults |
3 arms – 4-sessions (N = 39), 1 session (N = 38) or nothing/control (N = 23). | ||||||||
Ruiz and Kamerman 2010 [57] | Referral for care | HIV-positive patients aged >60 years N = 57 USA | Descriptive | Functional screening for detection of comorbidities and referral for further care if failed in 3 or more domains | No | Referrals for comorbid conditions | 17 patients were referred due to problems in multiple domains including cognitive dysfunction (10), problems in daily living (8), nutritional issues (6), depression (5), and mobility (5) | Screening for comorbidities among HIV-positive older adults can facilitate referral for further care likely to improve quality of care and outcomes |
Illa et al. 2010 [54] | Risk behaviour | HIV-positive, 45 or older, sexually active in last 12 months | Randomised controlled trial | Project ROADMAP (re-educating older adult in maintaining AIDS prevention). | Yes | Sexual risk (number of partners, partner HIV status, sexual acts, condom use) | Inconsistent condom use with partners of negative or unknown serostatus reduced from 9% at baseline to 1.3% at 6 month follow-up among intervention group (p = .003); reduced from 4% to 3% with control group (p = .999) | Group psycho-educational sessions reduced unprotected sexual acts with partners of unknown or negative serostatus |
Intervention group: educational brochure and four psycho-educational group sessions designed for HIV-positive older adults. Sessions focused on information, motivation, behavioural skills and risk reduction behaviours. Control: educational brochure only. | ||||||||
N = 241 (149 intervention group and 92 in control group) USA | ||||||||
HIV knowledge (33 item measure) Sexual self-efficacy | ||||||||
Heckman et al. 2001 [37] | Coping | HIV-positive individuals aged 50 years and older attending AIDS service organizations | Pilot pre- and post-test cohort study | Coping improvement group intervention | No | Severity of HIV-related Life Problem Scale | Increased social wellbeing (2.20 to 2.41, p < 0.05) | Group sessions focusing on coping strategies had limited impact on coping and stress but increased social wellbeing among HIV-positive older adults |
Ways of coping Questionnaire Functional assessment of HIV Infection Scale | ||||||||
Marginal non-significant change in coping (p < 0.10) | ||||||||
Marginal non-significant decrease in stress associated with AIDS-related loss and health concerns (p <0.10) | ||||||||
Provision of Social relations | ||||||||
Marginal non-significant increase in support from friends (p < 0.10) | ||||||||
Heckman et al. 2006 [55] | Coping | HIV-positive individuals aged 50 years and older recruited from AIDS service organizations with diagnosis of depression or dysthymia N = 90 USA | Randomised controlled trial with delayed treatment control Embedded cohort study Assessed pre, post (within 1 week of completion) and at3 months | 12, 90 minute sessions, telephone delivered weekly coping improvement group intervention to reduce psychological distress 1) Immediate treatment (n = 44) 2) Delayed treatment (control) (n = 46) | Yes, delayed treatment, control group | Geriatric depression scale (GDS) Symptom checklist 90-revised (SCL-90-R) | Intervention group reported fewer psychological symptoms (p = 0.05), less life stressor burden (p = 0.058), less use of avoidant coping strategies (p = 0.05) and marginally higher levels of coping self-efficacy (p = 0.10) compared to controls with no effect on depressive symptoms, loneliness or use of engagement coping Within cohorts IG: significant decrease in depressive symptoms (p < 0.003) psychological symptoms (p < 0.001), life-stressor burden (p < 0.03) and avoidance coping (p < 0.04) at 3 months Delayed group: significant decrease in psychological symptoms (p < 0.03), life stressor burdens (p < 0.001), loneliness (p < 0.03) and greater coping self-efficacy (p < 0.04) following intervention | Telephone delivered coping group sessions among HIV-positive people with depression were effective in reducing psychological symptoms and stress |
HIV-related life-stressor burden scale UCLA Loneliness Scale (10-item) | ||||||||
The Ways of Coping Checklist (WOCC) | ||||||||
Coping self-efficacy Scale | ||||||||
Heckman et al. 2011 [35] | Coping | HIV-positive individuals aged 50 years or older with Beck Depression Inventory-II score 10 or more and Modified mini-mental state examination score of 75 or greater. N = 295 USA | Randomised controlled trial 3 arms | 1) 12 90 minute sessions face-to-face coping improvement (FFCI) group intervention (n = 104) | Yes | Geriatric Depression Screening Scale | Both FFCI and IPSG participants reported fewer depressive symptoms than controls post-intervention, 4- and 8-month follow-up. This effect was not always statistically significant (p’s < 0.01-0.1). IPSG reported fewer depressive symptoms compared to control. | An age-appropriate coping improvement group intervention was effective in reducing depressive symptoms in HIV + older adults. The effect was more pronounced amongst subjects suffering greater levels of depressive symptoms. |
Completed using audio-computer assisted self interviews (A-CASI) | ||||||||
2) 12 session interpersonal support group (IPSG) intervention (n = 105) | ||||||||
3) Individual therapy upon request (ITUR) control (n = 86). Subjects had access to standard psychosocial services available in the community. | ||||||||
Effect size greater for subset of participants with mild, mod and severe depression at baseline | ||||||||
Souza et al. 2008 [56] | Physical support | Subjects HIV+, older than 60 (Mean 65.6+/- 2.9), sedentary at baseline. 3 subsequently excluded due to >3/12 absence from training program N = 11. | Prospective Case series study | 1 year resistance training program 4 exercises targeting major muscle groups 3 sets 8-12 reps at light, mod and heavy resistance respectively 2 sessions/week, one year | No | Anthropometric indices: Body mass, circumferences and skin folds Body composition (DEXA) Strength and functional tests: Sub-maximum weight lifted Two functional tests performed every 4 months assessing walking speed, and sit-to-stand performance. | No significant change in weight Strength improvements of between | Following one year of progressive resistance training HIV positive older adults showed significant improvements in strength and functional capacity, no changes in body composition and improved immunological indices. |
74-97% (p’s = 0.003-0.021) | ||||||||
Functional tests: decreased times for sit-stand (2.00 to 1.57 s, p = 0.003) and walking 2.4 m (9.25 to 6.58 s, p = 0.003) | ||||||||
All subjects medical able to complete training and not using cortico- or anabolic steroids Brazil | ||||||||
Souza et al. 2011 [36] | Physical support | Subjects HIV+, age > = 60 (M = 64.4 +/- 3.0) Ave. 9 year history of HIV, recruited at Hospital in Sao Paulo, Brazil N = 11 with 21 controls All subjects medically able to complete training and not using cortico- or anabolic steroids | Controlled trial | Progressive resistance exercise 2 sessions per week for 1 year. | Yes, age, activity and gender matched HIV–controls (N = 21) | Strength and functional tests: Sub-maximum load monitored bi-monthly Functional test of walk and sit-stand speeds. Anthropometric and metabolic indices: Weight; BMI Lipid and glycaemic profiles (values registered in clinical record immediately before and after training program) | Although weaker at baseline, HIV + subjects increased weight lifted from 1.52 to 2.33 times baseline, a significantly greater improvement than controls (1.21-1.48, p < 0.01) HIV + lighter, significantly lower BMI (p = 0.007 pre and p = 0.004 post) Faster at walking tests (significant, p = 0.036 pre-, not significant post-training). HIV + significantly faster at sit-to-stand after training than controls (p = 0.005) Fasting BSL significantly improved in both groups (p’s = 0.027-0.037). | Progressive resistance exercise training produced increased strength and functional gains in older adults living with HIV, with gains superior to those seen in age-matched HIV- controls. An effect was also seen on metabolic indices. |
Five exercises utilised major muscle groups | ||||||||
3 sets 12/10/8 repetitions at sub-maximum load |