Bibliographic information | Intervention (I) | Target Population /Duration | Study Design Type of analysis | Cost results | Physical health related Effectiveness results | Perspective /Price year | Synthesis of costs and effects |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Comparator (C) | |||||||
Bonevski et al. 2011 [57] | I: Client centred, caseworker-delivered cessation support intervention for a socially disadvantaged population. | 200 community dwelling socially disadvantaged smokers including people with mental health problems attending a community social service centre | RCT | Resources and costs of interventions and impacts on health service use | Changes in smoking behaviour | Health system only | Not stated |
Australia | |||||||
C: Information on smoking cessation and telephone number for Quitline | 12 months | CCA | |||||
Carter et al. 2012 [52] | I: 12 week preferred intensity aerobic exercise, with motivational coaching and support | Community dwelling people aged 14-17 already in contact with health care services with depression | RCT plus focus group analysis | Boundaries not stated but will use Client Service Receipt Inventory to record health care service use. | Changes in depression using Children’s Depression Inventory | Not stated | Incremental cost per QALY gained |
England, UK | |||||||
QALYs using EQ-5D | |||||||
C: Usual care | 9 months | CUA, CEA | Physical Activity Intensity (Borg Scale) | ||||
Kruisdijk et al. 2012 [54] | I: 6 months exercise therapy or Nordic walking plus usual care | People aged 18-65 with diagnosis of depression or bipolar disorder who are being treated on an inpatient or outpatient basis | RCT | Resource use and costs determined using Trimbos/iMTA Questionnaire for Costs associated with Psychiatric Illness (TIC-P) | Risk factors for metabolic syndrome. Fitness and Physical Activity. QALYs using EQ-5D | Health care use and productivity losses | Incremental cost per QALY gained |
The Netherlands | |||||||
C: Usual care | 12 months | CUA | |||||
Stockings et al. 2011 [56] | I: Multi-modal smoking cessation intervention (brief motivational interviewing plus range of post discharge support for up to 16 weeks. | 200 smokers aged 18+ in an inpatient facility with acute mental health problems | RCT | Resource use and costs needed to deliver intervention | Changes in smoking behaviour. Use of alcohol and other substance abuse. Mental wellbeing | Health system only | Not stated |
Australia | |||||||
C: Hospital smoking care only includes a referral to Quitline on discharge. | 6 months post discharge | CCA | |||||
Verhaeghe et al. 2012 [53] | I: 10 week health promotion intervention (psycho-educational and behavioural group sessions, supervised exercise, individual counselling) targeting physical activity and diet plus usual care | People aged 18 – 75 with mental disorders living in sheltered housing. 201 in intervention; 83 in control group 9 months (RCT) | Cluster RCT and Markov Modelling to extrapolate risk of CVD and diabetes over 10 years | Intervention costs plus costs of health care utilisation | BMI, Waist Circumference, body weight, fat mass, QALYs using SF-36 | Health system | Incremental cost per QALY gained |
Belgium | |||||||
C:Usual care | 10 years (model) | CUA |