Skip to main content

Table 4 Hospitalization, medication, and diagnostic test costs

From: Tuberculosis and poverty: the contribution of patient costs in sub-Saharan Africa – a systematic review

Author(s) (year)

Country

Cost estimate (I$)

% Annual per-capita income (entire population)

% Annual per-capita income (income-poorest 20% of the population)

Notes

Hospitalization costs

Aspler, et al. [41]

Zambia

14

3

16

Median costs (IQR I$4- I$19)

Floyd, et al. [51]

South Africa

119

3

17a

Mean cost of 18-day hospital stay under DOTS (I$7 per day)

Floyd, et al. [51]

South Africa

407

11

59a

Mean cost of 60-day hospital stay under conventional system (I$7/day)

Floyd, et al. [50]

Malawi

498

262

1048

Mean cost of 58-day hospital stay under hospital-based strategy for smear-positive patients (I$9/day)

Floyd, et al. [50]

Malawi

138

73

289

Mean cost of 16-day hospital stay under community-based DOTS strategy for smear-positive patients (I$9/day)

Floyd, et al. [50]

Malawi

32

17

66

Mean cost of 8-day hospital stay under hospital-based and community-based DOTS strategies for smear-negative patients (I$9/day)

Gibson and Boillot [52]

Sierra Leone

1

0.53

2b

Mean hospital admission fees at a missionary hospital

Gibson and Boillot [52]

Sierra Leone

47

18

58b

Mean hospital admission fees at a government hospital

Mesfin, et al. [55]

Ethiopia

4

2

5

Mean cost of hospital admissions (median I$0)

Nganda, et al. [60]

Kenya

530

101

336c

Mean cost of 60-day hospital stay under hospital-based system for smear-positive patients (I$9/ day) (96% CI I$5- I$13)

Nganda, et al. [60]

Kenya

34

7

22c

Mean cost of 4-day hospital stay under community-based DOTS for smear-positive patients (I$9/ day) (96% CI I$5- I$13)

Okello, et al. [61]

Uganda

219

73

240d

Mean cost of 60-day hospital stay under conventional hospital-based care strategy for smear-positive patients (I$4/ day)

Okello, et al. [61]

Uganda

70

24

77d

Mean cost of 19-day hospital stay under community-based care strategy for smear-positive patients (I$4/ day)

Saunderson, P. [31]

Uganda

91

39

126

Mean cost for a 2-month hospital stay

Wilkinson, et al. [67]

South Africa

139

3.62

20e

Mean cost of 17.5-day hospital stay under community-based DOTS strategy (I$8/ day)

Wyss et al. [68]

Tanzania

15

5

12f

Hospitalization costs reported for one month

Medication costs

Aspler, et al. [41]

Zambia

15

3

18

Median costs for additional medications (IQR I$9- I$21)

Awofeso, N. [42]

Nigeria

548g

121

589h

Mid-range, one-time medication costs (range I$199- I$897)g

Chard, S. [46]

Uganda

20

7

22i

Mean costs for medications (range I$4- I$37)

Kemp, et al. [54]

Malawi

50

27

106j

Mean costs for smear-negative patients for user fees and drug costs outside of government health facilities (median I$19)

Kemp, et al. [54]

Malawi

18

9

37j

Mean costs for smear-positive patients for user fees and drug costs outside of government health facilities (median I$6)

Mesfin, et al. [55]

Ethiopia

22

12

25

Mean costs for additional medications (median I$7)

Diagnostic test costs

Aspler, et al. [41]

Zambia

7

2

8

Median cost for chest radiographic (IQR I$4-I$7)

Needham, et al. [58]

Zambia

9

2

13

Mean cost for diagnostic tests (unspecified) (median I$13)

Wyss, et al. [68]

Tanzania

10

3

7f

Unit cost for examination, laboratory, and X-rays

  1. a Income share based on 1995 estimates instead of 1994; b Income share assumed to be 6% by authors in absence of World Bank data; c Income share based on 1997 estimates instead of 1998; d Income share based on 1999 estimates instead of 1998; e Income share based on 1995 estimates instead of 1996; f Income share based on 2000 estimates instead of 1996; g Note: the study listed these costs as “prepayment fees,” but the costs were actually for medications. Moreover, these medication costs are reported with imprecision (i.e., a wide range), weakening the strength of the conclusion that TB medication costs were high in Nigeria; h Income share based on 1992 estimates instead of 1993; i Income share based on 1999 estimates instead of 1998; j Income share based on 1998 estimates instead of 2000.