Skip to main content

Table 3 Impact of baseline externalizing behavioural problems, extracurricular activities, family, and school factors on externalizing behavioural problems

From: Extracurricular activity participation moderates impact of family and school factors on adolescents’ disruptive behavioural problems

 

Substance use

Authority

Delinquent

Absenteeism

 

Measures

β

SE

OR

95 % CI

β

SE

OR

95 % CI

β

SE

OR

95 % CI

β

SE

OR

95 % CI

Model 1

Extracurricular Activity

                
 

 Sport (yes)

-.13*

.05

.87

.78–.97

-.34**

.12

.71

.56–.91

    

.21**

.07

1.2

1.1–.1.4

 

 Expressive (yes)

    

-.41***

.11

.66

.54–.82

-.23***

.06

.80

.70–.90

-.23***

.06

.79

.70–.88

 

 Religious club (yes)

-.21***

.06

.81

.72–.92

-.25*

.12

.78

.61–.99

-.18*

.08

.83

.71–.98

-.15*

.07

.86

.75–.99

 

 Youth club (yes)

    

-.02

.10

.98

.80–1.2

.09

.07

1.1

.96–1.2

    
 

Family factors

               
 

 Parent Status (single)

.37***

.06

1.4

1.3–1.6

.40***

.11

1.5

1.2–1.8

.16*

.08

1.2

1.0–1.4

.21**

.07

1.2

1.1–1.4

 Siblings – none

                

  1/2 siblings

    

-.01

.13

.99

.77–1.3

.02

.09

1.0

.86–1.2

-.03

.08

.97

.84–1.1

  3+ siblings

    

.25

.16

1.3

.94–1.7

.17

.11

1.2

.95–1.5

.23*

.10

1.3

1.0–1.5

 Parent-adolescent relationship (bad)

.54***

.07

1.7

1.5–2.0

1.0***

.13

2.7

2.1–3.5

.56***

.10

1.7

1.4–2.1

.52***

.09

1.7

1.4–2.0

 

 Level involvement

.12*

.04

1.1

1.1–1.2

.48***

.07

1.6

1.4–1.8

.15***

.05

1.2

1.1–1.3

.09*

.04

1.1

1.0–1.2

 

School factors

               
 

 Bully Victim – no

                

  1 type

.48***

.05

1.6

1.5–1.8

.26*

.10

1.3

1.1–1.6

.41***

.07

1.5

1.3–1.7

.23***

.06

1.3

1.1–1.4

  2 types

.63***

.06

1.9

1.7–2.1

.45***

.13

1.6

1.2–2.0

.79***

.08

2.2

1.9–2.6

.59***

.08

1.8

1.5–2.1

  3 or 4 types

.86***

.07

2.4

2.0–2.7

.85***

.13

2.3

1.8–3.0

.85***

.10

2.4

2.0–2.9

.58***

.09

1.8

1.5–2.1

 

Moderating effect

                

Model 2

Sport

                

Parent-adolescent relationship

                

 Good

-.11

.06

.89

.79–1.0

-.43***

.13

.65

.51–.83

    

-.21**

.08

.81

.70–.94

 Bad

-.26

.14

.77

.59–1.0

.38

.37

1.5

.71–3.0

    

-.21

.26

.81

.49–1.4

Parent status

                

 Single

-.06

.09

.95

.79–1.1

-.40

.21

.67

.44–1.0

    

-.18

.14

.84

.63–1.1

 Couple

-.17**

.07

.84

.74–.96

-.31*

.15

.74

.55–.99

    

-.22**

.08

.80

.68–.95

Siblings

                

 0

    

-.96***

.28

.38

.22–.66

    

-.31

.16

.73

.53–1.0

 1–2

    

-.12

.16

.89

.65–1.2

    

-.11

.09

.90

.75–1.1

 3+

    

-.47

.26

.62

.37–1.0

    

-.56**

.19

.57

.40–.82

Bullying

                

 No

-.08

.07

.92

.80–1.1

-.39*

.15

.68

.50–.92

    

-.11

.09

.90

.75–1.1

 1 type

-.34**

.12

.71

.56–.90

-.47

.27

.62

.37–1.0

    

-.28

.17

.76

.54–1.1

 2 types

-.08

.15

.92

.69–1.2

.04

.33

1.0

.54–2.0

    

-.66**

.22

.52

.34–.79

 3 or 4 types

-.08

.16

.92

.67–1.3

-.26

.33

.77

.41–1.5

    

-.17

.25

.84

.51–1.4

Expressive

                

Parent Status

                

 Couple

    

-.33**

.12

.72

.56–.92

-.25***

.07

.78

.68–.90

-.28***

.06

.75

.67–.86

 Single

    

-.63**

.20

.53

.36–.79

-.15

.13

.86

.67–1.1

-.06

.12

.95

.74–1.2

Siblings

                

 0

    

-.21

.24

.81

.51–1.3

    

-.29*

.14

.75

.57–.98

 1–2

    

-.39**

.12

.68

.53–.86

    

-.23***

.07

.79

.69–.90

 3+

    

-.90**

.34

.41

.21–.78

    

-.18

.17

.84

.60–1.2

Parent-adolescent relationship

                

 Good

    

-.46***

.11

.63

.51–.79

-.23***

.07

.79

.70–.90

-.21***

.06

.81

.72–.91

 Bad

    

-.07

.31

.93

.51–1.7

-.19

.23

.83

.53–.1.3

-.63**

.21

.53

.35–.80

Bully Victim

                

 No

    

-.76***

.16

.47

.34–.64

-.42***

.09

.66

.55–.73

-.18*

.07

.84

.73–.96

 1 type

    

-.16

.20

.86

.58–1.3

-.25*

.12

.78

.61–.97

-.41***

.12

.66

.53–.83

 2 types

    

-.15

.24

.86

.53–1.4

.23

.15

1.3

.93–1.6

-.18

.16

.84

.63–1.1

 3 or 4 types

    

-.01

.26

.99

.60–1.6

.10

.19

1.1

.77–1.6

-.29

.19

.75

.51–1.1

Religious

                

Parent Status

                

 Couple

-.18**

.07

.83

.72–.96

-.28

.15

.76

.57–1.0

-.19*

.09

.83

.69–.99

-.18*

.08

.83

.71–.97

 Single

-.27*

.12

.76

.61–.96

-.19

.22

.82

.53–1.3

-.17

.16

.85

.61–1.2

-.02

.17

.98

.70–1.4

Siblings

                

 0

    

-.05

.28

.95

.55–1.6

    

-.26

.19

.77

.52–1.1

 1–2

    

-.36*

.16

.70

.52–.95

    

-.12

.09

.89

.75–1.1

 3+

    

-.10

.28

.91

.52–1.6

    

-.21

.17

.81

.59–1.1

Parent-adolescent relationship

                

 good

-.22*

.07

.80

.69–.91

-.25

.13

.79

.61–1.0

-.16

.08

.86

.73–1.0

-.13

.07

.88

.76–1.0

 bad

-.08

.16

.93

.70–1.3

-.38

.37

.69

.33–1.4

-.60

.34

.55

.29–1.1

-.58*

.27

.56

.33–..95

Bully victim

                

 No

-.08

.08

.92

.79–1.1

-.19

.16

.83

.60–1.1

-.33**

.11

.72

.58–.89

-.20*

.09

.82

.68–.98

 1 type

-.52***

.13

.60

.46–.77

-.42

.29

.65

.37–1.2

-.04

.16

.96

.70–1.3

-.33*

.16

.72

.53–.98

 2 types

-.41*

.17

.66

.48–.92

-.61

.36

.54

.27–1.1

-.22

.19

.80

.55–1.2

.09

.20

1.1

.73–1.6

 3 or 4 types

-.03

.16

.97

.71–1.3

.01

.31

1.0

.55–1.8

.18

.23

1.2

.77–1.9

.27

.23

1.3

.84–2.0

 

Baseline Behaviour

                

Model 3

Substance Use

3.3***

.12

27.2

21.7–34.2

            

Interaction Authority

    

1.9***

.16

6.8

4.9–9.4

        

Delinquency

        

2.0***

.10

7.6

6.3–9.2

    

Absenteeism

            

1.6***

.08

5.1

4.4–6.0

  1. Models are controlling for sex, ethnicity, religion, parental education, household income, housing, and social class; significance is shown in the table * p < .05 ** p < .01 *** p < .001