Traditional circumcision during manhood initiation rituals in the Eastern Cape, South Africa: a pre-post intervention evaluation
© Peltzer et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2008
Received: 04 November 2007
Accepted: 19 February 2008
Published: 19 February 2008
Circumcisions undertaken in non-clinical settings can have significant risks of serious adverse events, including death. The aim of this study was to test an intervention for safe traditional circumcision in the context of initiation into manhood among the Xhosa, Eastern Cape, South Africa.
Traditional surgeons and nurses registered with the health department were trained over five days on ten modules including safe circumcision, infection control, anatomy, post-operative care, detection and early management of complications and sexual health education. Initiates from initiation schools of the trained surgeons and nurses were examined and interviewed on 2nd, 4th, 7th and 14th day after circumcision.
From 192 initiates physically examined at the 14th day after circumcision by a trained clinical nurse high rates of complications were found: 40 (20.8%) had mild delayed wound healing, 31 (16.2%) had a mild wound infection, 22 (10.5%) mild pain and 20 (10.4%) had insufficient skin removed. Most traditional surgeons and nurses wore gloves during operation and care but did not use the recommended circumcision instrument. Only 12% of the initiates were circumcised before their sexual debut and they reported a great deal of sexual risk behaviour.
Findings show weak support for scaling up traditional male circumcision.
Accounts of serious complications or adverse events after adolescent and adult circumcision in traditional settings in Africa are legion. Every circumcision season there are articles in national and local newspapers depicting in words and pictures cases of advanced infection, severe loss of blood, mutilation, and even deaths due to events attributable to male circumcision. In the scientific literature, there are reports listing adverse events from traditional circumcision generated from hospital records [1–5] or circumcision/initiation school inspections , but without knowing the total number of males circumcised in that area (i.e., the denominator), it is not possible to estimate rates of adverse events. Circumcisions undertaken in non-clinical settings can have significant risks of serious adverse events, including death. Among 50 patients admitted to hospital with post-circumcision complications in Nigeria and Kenya between 1981 and 1998, 80% had been circumcised by medically untrained traditional surgeons. One of these patients died from septicaemia, two lost their penis from gangrene, and five others had permanent disability from complete or partial amputation of the glans or shaft . A further study of 48 boys presenting to hospital with post-circumcision complications in Nigeria found that the commonest complication was haemorrhage (52% patients) and infection (21%) . Among the Babukusu ethnic group in western Kenya, circumcision is part of the initiation rite for youth aged 8–20, and circumcision may be carried out traditionally or medically by a doctor, clinician or health professional. More detailed examination of 298 of the boys at 45–96 days post-operation showed that traditional circumcision was also associated with slower healing, more swelling, laceration and keloid scarring . Among the Xhosa in South Africa, an unsterilized unwashed blade may be used on a dozen or more initiates in a single session [2, 8]. Initiates are also significantly dehydrated during their 2 week period of seclusion in the belief that this reduces weeping of the wound, and after-care may be in the hands of a traditional attendant with no basic medical training . The combination of dehydration and septicaemia can result in acute renal failure, gangrene, tetanus or even death [2, 8]. The Eastern Cape provincial Department of Health recorded 2262 hospital admissions, 115 deaths and 208 genital amputations for circumcisions between 2001 and 2006 . To address this, traditional surgeons are now required by law to be officially recognized and registered with the provincial Department of Health . The Eastern Cape Legislature promulgated a law, known as Application of Health Standards in Traditional Circumcision Act No. 6 of 2001, which regulates traditional male circumcision .
Little information is available concerning rates of complications in traditional settings in Africa  and this seems the first study to test the feasibility of a safe traditional male circumcision intervention.
Pre-post training intervention assessment of traditional male circumcision of initiates attending 17 initiation schools in two Local Service Areas (LSAs), Nyandeni and Qaukeni of the O.R.Tambo district, Eastern Cape province.
Sample and procedure
The sample included 160 Xhosa initiates, mean age 18.7 years (SD = 1.9), range16 to 26 years; 27 (16.9%) were below 18 years; the number of years of formal education completed was mean 8.1 years (SD = 2.6), range 2 to 14 years.
Initiates were first informed about the study when undergoing medical examination for circumcision. Two junior HSRC researchers contacted traditional surgeons who had previously been trained and had also formally consented to the study about their circumcision schedule. At the second day after circumcision the designated medical officer, the clinical research nurse and an HSRC researcher visited the initiation school to introduce the study and individual formal consent was taken from the initiates about physical examination and an interview by the research nurse and the HSRC researchers. The clinical research nurse physically examined all initiates in each initiation school at the 2nd, 4th, 7th and 14th day after circumcision. In addition, they were interviewed with a semi-structured questionnaire on the 7th day after circumcision by the HSRC researcher. Complications identified at examination were either treated by the clinical nurse or referred to a health facility. Permission had been obtained from traditional surgeons and nurses to conduct examinations and an interview with their initiates. The clinical male nurses had been trained in circumcision physical examination by XK. Recruitment began on June 2007, and follow-ups were completed by mid July, 2007; all initiates agreed to participate in the study. The research protocol was reviewed and approved by the Human Sciences Research Council (HSRC) research ethics committee protocol REC 1/17/05/06. The provincial health department of the Eastern Cape, the district health office and traditional authorities in the study areas approved the study.
The traditional surgeons and nurses from which the initiates were recruited had undergone a five day training by XK and GP including modules on: Introduction into initiation rites; Traditional Community Regulation as well as statutory regulation of Traditional Male Circumcision and Initiation into Manhood; Structure and function of the male sex organs; Procedure of safe circumcision, Infection control; STIs/STDs; HIV/AIDS; Infection control measures; Aftercare of the initiate including after care of the circumcision wound and initiate as a whole; Detection and early management of common complications of circumcision; Nutrition and fluid management; Code of conduct and ethics for traditional health practitioners; and Sexual health education . Traditional surgeons were also provided with a tool box including surgical (scalpel) blades, scalpel handles, latex hand gloves, sterilization instruments, and paper towel rolls, and traditional nurses received also the tool box including latex hand gloves, sterilization instruments, and paper towel rolls. Details on the training, the manual and its evaluation are reported elsewhere .
The assessment of initiates included a physical examination of the operation area following a standardized index of adverse reactions of male circumcision including pain, bleeding, haematoma, swelling, wound infection, delayed wound healing, excessive skin removed, insufficient skin removed, problems with urination and problems with appearance [12, 13].
The interview schedule for the initiates included socio-demographics, sexual and HIV risk behaviour and expectations about circumcision, based on a literature review [6, 14–16]. Response options included mostly "yes" and "no" responses.
In addition, four items of the Body Parts Satisfaction Scale by Berscheid, Walster, and Bohrnstedt  were used. Individual items indicated respondents' level of satisfaction with aspects of their body ranging from 1 = extremely dissatisfied to 6 = extremely satisfied.
The SPSS (version 14.0) statistical programme was used to analyze the data with descriptive statistics.
Adverse events following surgery
Circumcision complications of initiates assessed at four time points in percent
Description of Medical Complication
2nd day N = 152 (%)
4th day N = 159 (%)
7th day N = 193 (%)
14th day N = 192 N(%)
3 or 4 on pain scale
5 or 6 on pain scale
7 on pain scale
Dressing/bandage soaked through with blood at a routine follow-up visit
Bleeding that requires a special visit by the attendant for medical attention.
Bleeding that requires a visit to hospital or clinic and surgical re-exploration to control
Erythema (redness of skin) more than one cm beyond incision
Purulent discharge (pus) from wound
Cellulitis (infection spreading under the skin) or wound necrosis (gangrene or black, dead tissue) requiring hospitalization
Excessive skin removed
Client concerned, but there is no discernable abnormality
Skin is tight, but additional operative work not necessary
Requires re-operation or transfer to a medical facility to correct the problem
Insufficient kin removed
Foreskin partially covers the head only when extended
Foreskin still partially covers the head and re-operation is required to correct
Swelling or haema-toma (collection of blood)
More swelling than usual, but no significant discomfort
Significant tenderness and discomfort; no surgical procedure needed or only minor surgical re-exploration required
Surgical re-exploration or visit to hospital or clinic required to correct
Damage to the penis
Mild bruising or injury, not requiring treatment
Bruise or injury to the head or shaft of the penis requiring pressure dressing or additional surgery to control or repair
Portion or all of the head or shaft of the penis severed
Delayed wound healing
Healing takes longer than usual, but no extra treatment necessary
Additional non-operative treatment required
Requires re-operation to correct or visit to clinic or hospital required
Problems with passing urine
Temporary complaints that resolves without treatment
Requires special return to the clinic, but no additional treatment required
Requires referral to another facility for management
Severe thirst, but passed urine in past 24 hours and no dizziness
Severe thirst, and becoming light-headed, with no urine in past 24 hours
No urine in past 24 hours and lost consciousness or required visit to hospital or clinic to provide fluids or to treat related medical problems, such as kidney failure
Client concerned, but no discernable abnormality
Significant wound disruption or scarring, but does not require re-operation
Initiates were asked on the 7th day after circumcision about circumcision procedures. Most (85%) indicated that the traditional surgeon had been wearing gloves when performing circumcision and two-thirds (69%) of the traditional nurses wore gloves when caring. Further, 53% of the initiates reported that they had been circumcised with an assegai (spear) and 47% indicated that they had been circumcised with a surgical blade or knife.
Expectations about traditional male circumcision
When participants were asked about their perceptions about traditional circumcision most respondents 126 (70%) felt that they expected some complication following male circumcision.
Most (57.8%) expected to stay in the bush for a month, 40% less than a month and 11.1% for more than a month.
Body parts satisfaction post-circumcision (7th day)
Size of sex organs
Appearance of sex organs
Overall body appearance
Sexual behaviour and HIV risk
Sexual behaviour and HIV risk of initiates
First sex with 17 years and below
Had sex in past 12 months
Number of sex partners
3 and more
Condom use at last sex
During the past 12 months has a doctor or other health professional told you that you had a sexually transmitted disease (STD)
Past month alcohol use
Past week alcohol use
Sex under the influence of alcohol
How susceptible/at risk to get HIV
Not susceptible at all
Self-rated HIV knowledge
Did you previously receive AIDS education
Using a pre-post intervention evaluation design, this study evaluated 192 initiates who had undergone a traditional male circumcision intervention with trained traditional surgeons and traditional nurses in the Eastern Cape, South Africa. The study found that from 192 initiates physically examined at the 14th day after circumcision by a trained clinical nurse the following major adverse events following surgery were found: 40 (20.8%) had mild delayed wound healing, 31 (16.2%) had a mild wound infection, 22 (10.5%) mild pain and 20 (10.4%) had insufficient skin removed. Bailey and Egesah  conducted an examination of 298 boys at 45–96 (M = 62) days post-operation following traditional circumcision in Kenya and found in 21.4% not fully healed, foreskin remaining 11.6%, swelling 13.9%, lacerations 16.9% and keloid scarring 17.4%. When insufficient foreskin is excised, the results are uncosmetic and cicatrisation of the distal foreskin and wound contracture may occur. Sepis due to infection occurs in up to 10% of patients and varies in severity from mild and local to heavy suppuration and ulceration or to septicaemia in which case it may lead to death if not treated early with antibiotics . The 1989 review of the American Academy of Pediatrics' Task Force on Circumcision reported that the rate of postoperative complications of male circumcision was approximately 0.2% to 0.6% in the United States. The majority of complications were minor, the most common being local infection and bleeding . Krieger et al.  found among 479 medically circumcised male adults in Kenya that 3.5% were associated with adverse events judged definitely, probably or possibly related to the procedure. The most common adverse events were wound infections (1.3%), bleeding (0.8%), and delayed wound healing or suture line disruption (0.8%). After 30 days, 99% reported being very satisfied with the procedure.
This study found that only 12% were to be circumcised before their sexual debut and reported a great deal of sexual risk behavior: 9% had been diagnosed with a sexually transmitted infection in the past 12 months, 15% reported to have had three or more sex partners in their lives and 38% had not used a condom at last sex. Similar HIV risk behaviour was also found in a study by Jewkes et al.  among sexually active Xhosa youth. Shisana and Simbayi  also found in the 2002 national HIV prevalence survey in South Africa that most men only get circumcised after they have become sexually active. In this study among 21% initiates delayed wound healing was found 14 days post-operation. Most young men (88%) were found to be sexually active prior to circumcision and such a long period for healing could expose them to elevated risk for HIV infection through an open wound. Bailey and Egesah  found that in their post-operative traditional male circumcision sample in Kenya that the wounds of 24% of those circumcised had not fully healed when they were observed at 60 days post-operation.
Relatively high rates of circumcision complications were found among this sample of initiates who underwent traditional circumcision with specifically trained traditional surgeons and nurses. Although traditional surgeons had been trained and were provided with surgical blades prior to conducting the studied circumcisions, more than half (53%) had used the culturally more acceptable but less safer assegai (spear) for the circumcision, which may have contributed to some of the circumcision complications. Regarding wound care 31% of the traditional nurses did not wear gloves that had been provided during the training which may have contributed to wound infections.
It appears that a five day training for traditional surgeons and nurses is not sufficient and that more training is needed in the surgical procedure, the control of sepsis, post-operative wound care, recognition of complications, and referral to hospital would also be beneficial. Further supportive trainings may be the most effective way for promoting cognitive, attitudinal, and behavioural change. The use of the appropriate surgical instruments and wound care needs to be emphasized by traditional leaders. In order to improve timely and appropriate monitoring of initiates by designated medical officers initiation schools should only be established in more central and easily accessible locations. Post operation counselling with initiates should be conducted including HIV risk reduction, reproductive, HIV pre-test and manhood counselling.
Traditional surgeons and nurses need to be appropriately registered and fulfilling all criteria stipulated in the male circumcision act. Consideration should be given to a certification process for practitioners who undergo approved training programmes . A training manual for traditional male circumcision (explicating traditional methods of circumcision and wound care) should be further tested and finalized. Additional studies are needed of complication rates and male circumcision practices with specifically trained traditional surgeons and nurses in order to design the appropriate intervention for the safest traditional male circumcision possible.
Still one should emphasize the danger of the procedure, even with an intervention of additional training. Improving the quality of male circumcision services could reduce healing times and thus reduce risk of HIV infection in those who resume sexual activity soon after circumcision. Counselling males not to engage in sex until they are fully healed must be included in post-op instructions. Circumcision cannot be a stand alone procedure; it must be integrated with behavioural and reproductive health counselling in order to minimize both complications and risk of HIV infections .
We thank USAID for funding the study. In addition, the support by the provincial and district health department including the circumcision designated medical officers in conducting the study is acknowledged.
- Meintjies G: Manhood at a price: socio-medical perspectives on Xhosa traditional circumcision. 1998, Institute of Social and Economic Research. Rhodes University, 1:Google Scholar
- Mayatula V, Mavundla TR: A review on male circumcision procedures among South African blacks. Curationis. 1997, 20 (3): 16-20.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Ahmed A, Mbibi NH, Dawam D, Kalayi GD: Complications of traditional male circumcision. Ann Trop Paediatr. 1999, 19 (1): 113-7. 10.1080/02724939992743.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Crowley IP, Kesner KM: Ritual circumcision (Umkhwetha) amongst the Xhosa of the Ciskei. BJU. 1990, 66 (3): 318-21.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Magoha GA: Circumcision in various Nigerian and Kenyan hospitals. East Afr Med J. 1999, 76 (10): 583-6.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Kanta XGM: Traditional male circumcision and initiation into manhood: legal, health and environmental perspectives. 2004, Gonubie, Eastern Cape: Impilo ya Bantu Health and Development ProjectsGoogle Scholar
- Bailey RC, Egesah O: Assessment of clinical and traditional male circumcision services in Bungoma District, Kenya: Complication rates and operational needs. [http://www.aidsmark.org/resources/pdfs/mc.pdf]
- Naude JH: Reconstructive urology in the tropical and developing world: a personal perspective. BJU Int. 2002, 89 (Suppl 1): 31-6. 10.1046/j.1465-5101.2001.naude.136.x.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Meissner O, Buso DL: Traditional male circumcision in the Eastern Cape--scourge or blessing?. S Afr Med J. 2007, 97 (5): 371-373.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Province of the Eastern Cape: Application of health standards in traditional circumcision Act, 2001 (Eastern Cape); Provincial Gazette No. 818(extraordinary). 2001, Bisho/King William's Town: Province of the Eastern CapeGoogle Scholar
- Peltzer K, Nqeketo A, Petros G, Kanta X: Evaluation of a safer male circumcision training programme for traditional surgeons and nurses in the Eastern Cape, South Africa. AJTCAM.
- WHO: Manual for male circumcision under local anaesthesia. 2006, Geneva: WHOGoogle Scholar
- UNAIDS: Male circumcision: Global trends and determinants of prevalence, safety and acceptability. 2007, Geneva: UNAIDSGoogle Scholar
- Chabikuli NM, Ogunbanjo GA: The feasibility of performing male circumcision at two public clinics in South Africa. S Afr Fam Prac. 2001, 23 (5): 16-19.Google Scholar
- Engelbrecht A, Smith S: Why do male patients request circumcisions?. S Afr Fam Prac. 2004, 46 (2): 25-28.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Meel BL: Community perception of traditional circumcision in a sub-region of the Transkei, Eastern Cape, South Africa. S Afr Fam Prac. 2005, 47 (6): 58-59.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Berscheid E, Walster E, Bohrnstedt G: The happy American body: a survey report. Psychol Today. 1973, 7: 119-131.Google Scholar
- American Academy of Pediatrics: Report of the task force on circumcision. Pedia. 1989, 84: 388-391.Google Scholar
- Krieger JN, Bailey RC, Opeya J, Ayieko B, Opiyo F, Agot K, Parker C, Ndinya-Achola JO, Magoha GA, Moses S: Adult male circumcision: results of a standardized procedure in Kisumu District, Kenya. Sex Trans Dis. 2001, 28 (10): 608-12. 10.1097/00007435-200110000-00007.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Jewkes R, Dunkle K, Nduna M, Levin J, Jama N, Khuzwayo N, Koss M, Puren A, Duvvury N: Factors associated with HIV sero-positivity in young, rural South African men. Intern J Epi. 2006, 35: 1455-1460. 10.1093/ije/dyl217.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Shisana O, Simbayi L: Nelson Mandela/HSRC study. South Africa national HIV prevalence, behavioral risk and mass media, households survey. 2002, Cape Town: Human Sciences Research CouncilGoogle Scholar
- The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/8/64/prepub