Skip to main content

Table 2 Summary of pooled relative risks of different health outcomes due to air pollution

From: Meta-analysis of adverse health effects due to air pollution in Chinese populations

 

PM10

 

NO2

 

SO2

 

O3

 

Health outcome [Ref. #]

RR

SE

RR

SE

RR

SE

RR

SE

Mortality

        

All causes[25–40]

1.0031 R*

5

1.0140 R*

17

1.0071 R*

9

1.0042 F*

6

Cardiovascular diseases[25–37, 39, 41]

1.0049 R*

7

1.0162 R*

22

1.0072 R*

17

1.0051 R*

13

Respiratory diseases[25–27, 30–33, 35, 37, 39, 40, 42, 43]

1.0057 R*

9

1.0220 R*

33

1.0129 R*

36

1.0048 F*

14

Cardiopulmonary diseases[34, 39, 43]

1.0034 F*

6

1.0155 R*

54

1.0123 F*

15

1.0023 F

15

Cardiac diseases[30, 31, 34, 39]

1.0062 R*

15

1.0177 F*

23

1.0182 R*

41

1.0026 R

31

Cerebrovascular diseases[30, 31, 34, 36, 39]

1.0057 R*

18

1.0147 R*

39

1.0079 F*

26

1.0057 R*

29

Ischemia heart diseases[36, 44]

0.9963

52

1.0130 R

118

1.0280*

82

  

Chronic obstructive pulmonary diseases[28–31, 45]

1.0065 R

41

1.0184 R*

58

1.0095 R*

43

1.0071 R

39

Influenza and pneumonia[31, 34]

1.0105 F*

33

1.0175 F *

49

1.0235 F *

70

1.0054F

45

Non-cardiopulmonary[31, 34, 39]

1.0028 F*

6

1.0094 R*

19

1.0076 F*

16

1.0025 F*

10

Cancer[28, 29, 43]

1.0031*

15

  

1.0020 R

14

  

Diabetes[46]

1.0060

31

1.0130

66

1.0110

320

  

Accidental[31, 34]

1.0015 F

22

1.0000 F

46

0.9988 F

56

1.0005 R

59

Hospital admissions

        

All causes[47]

0.9972

17

1.0014

49

1.0003

34

  

Cardiovascular diseases[31, 47]

1.0021 R*

10

1.0095 F*

21

1.0079 R*

43

1.0024

11

Respiratory diseases[31, 47]

1.0039 R

22

1.0060 R*

24

1.0014 F

15

1.0081*

12

Cardiac diseases[31]

1.0058*

11

1.0100*

13

1.0098*

21

1.0012

13

Cerebrovascular diseases[31, 48]

0.9981 R

40

1.0032 F

21

0.9986 F

31

0.9994 F

19

Ischemia heart diseases[31, 48]

1.0065 F*

20

1.0142 R

74

1.0102 F*

36

1.0024 F

21

Asthma[31]

1.0077 F*

24

1.0094 F*

31

0.9992 F

47

1.0162 F*

30

Chronic obstructive pulmonary diseases[31]

1.0132*

17

1.0194*

20

1.0070*

31

1.0154*

19

Influenza and pneumonia[31]

1.0066*

20

1.0076*

24

1.0009

38

1.0109*

23

Pneumonia[48]

1.0006

47

1.0071

84

1.0062

146

1.0081

81

Acute respiratory diseases[31]

1.0088*

20

1.0122*

25

1.0055

38

1.0155*

22

Emergency admissions

        

Cardiovascular diseases[49]

1.0060*

26

1.0130*

36

1.0160*

51

  

Respiratory diseases[49]

    

1.0130*

41

  

Ischemia heart diseases[49, 50]

1.0070

41

1.0100

51

1.0100

77

  

Cerebrovascular diseases[49]

1.0030

36

1.0080

51

  

0.9920

46

Cardiac diseases[50]

1.0050*

20

1.0120*

26

1.0160*

31

1.0045*

21

Heart failure[49]

    

1.0360*

117

  

Asthma[51]

1.0060*

20

1.0090*

26

1.0040

36

1.0150*

20

Chronic obstructive pulmonary diseases[51]

1.0050*

10

1.0090*

20

1.0070

36

1.0110*

15

Emergency room visit

        

All causes[52]

1.0002

5

1.0070*

14

1.0023

10

  

Cardiovascular diseases[53, 54]

1.0030

15

1.0140

71

1.0140*

51

  

Respiratory diseases[55, 56]

1.0011

23

1.0050

38

1.0010

20

  

Ischemia heart diseases[53]

1.0010

46

      

Cerebrovascular diseases[50]

1.0010

31

      

Heart failure[50]

1.0120

97

      

Cardiac arrhythmias[50]

1.0020

51

      

Hypertension[57, 58]

1.0188

69

1.0689

286

1.0370*

173

  

Acute upper respiratory infections[55]

1.0130*

20

1.0320*

77

1.0180*

46

  

Acute pharyngitis[55]

1.0120*

46

1.0300

168

1.0170

102

  

Adverse birth outcomes

        

Stillbirth[59]

1.0200

153

1.0053

163

1.0076

39

1.0051

130

Preterm birth[60]

1.0442*

144

1.0543*

186

1.1189*

265

1.0463*

218

Low birth weight – 3rd trimester[61]

    

1.0110*

26

  

Low birth weight – entire pregnancy[62]

    

1.0087

46

  
  1. Note. RR, with Bold represents pooled relative risk per 10 μg/m3 increase in pollutant concentration, RR not Bold was the RR of single study. SE, Standard error in 10-4. R represented random effects. F represented fixed effects. * indicated statistically significant at alpha = 0.05. 95% Cl = 1.96*SE ± RR.