Skip to main content

Table 3 Selected indicators and targets for NCD prevention and control in national health policies/plan and in NCD specific plans: Poor alignment and poor selection of indicators

From: A qualitative study of governance of evolving response to non-communicable diseases in low-and middle- income countries: current status, risks and options

Country

Sector-wide health plan/Policy

NCD-specific plan/policy

Baseline levels

Cambodia

Reduce between baseline (2005-08) and 2015,

Sample indicators to monitor progress mentioned, but no targets specified.

â–  Average baseline given for 2005-2008 ([13]; data from existing literature summarized in NCD-specific plan

â–  the adults smoking prevalence% (male/female) from 54/9 to 44/2

â–  Proposes monitoring through national STEP surveys

â–  Incidence of hypertension per 1000 population from 20 to 15

â–  Prevalence of adults with diabetes reported from public facilities from 2 to <2

â–  Incidence of cervical cancer per 10,000 population reported from public facilities from 25 to 12.5 [13]

Fiji [[14],[15]]

By 2015, reduce prevalence of

By 2014, reduce prevalence of

â–  Baseline from National NCD STEPS Survey 2002, no progress reported from prior National NCD Strategic Plan 2004-2008

â–  Diabetes (25-64 yr) from 16% to 14%

â–  Diabetes by 5%

â–  Proposes monitoring through National NCD STEPS Survey and National Nutrition Survey.

â–  Alcohol related injuries to less than 5%

â–  Common risk factors by 5%

â–  No periodicity/monitoring agency defined.

â–  moderate physical activity by 5%

â–  Intermediate risk factors by 5%

â–  fruing/vegetable intake (Adults) by 5%

â–  Major NCDs by 5%

â–  Current smoking (15-65yrs) from 37% to 33%

â–  Tobacco use: 10% from baseline

â–  reduce obesity by 6.2%

â–  Improve nutrition: No target

â–  Increase HPV vaccine coverage by 5%

â–  Alcohol related harm: No target

â–  Cardiovascular diseases by 5%

â–  Improve national NCD status by 5%

Malaysia [[16],[17]]

â–  Indicators are listed as prevalence of Ischemic heart disease, mental illness, CVD, Diabetes, cancer and chronic obstructive respiratory disease but with no specific targets.

By 2016, Reduce Prevalence of

â–  Baseline Data from National Health and Morbidity Survey 2006

â–  Diabetes from 11.6 to <13.6%

â–  Proposes monitoring through Behavioural Surveillance Survey, NCD Risk Factor Surveillance

â–  Obesity from 26.2% to <33.7%

â–  Periodicity/Monitoring agencies identified

■ Healthy Eating – no target given

â–  No past progress reported

■ Physical Activity – no target given

 

Mongolia[18, 19]

Between 2010 and 2015, Reduce prevalence of

Between 2009 and 2013, Reduce prevalence of

â–  Some baseline data given from 2004-2005

â–  Daily Smoking from 37% to 31%

â–  Smoking from 23.4% to 20.4%

â–  Mechanism to collect data and its periodicity not defined

â–  Daily salt intake (gm/day) from 13g to 12g

â–  Daily salt intake (gm/day) from 9.6 to 9.1

â–  No achievements or rate of progress described in the immediate past to inform the current target setting

â–  Increase the percentage of adult population that reduce alcohol intake to 2-3 std /wk from 30% to 40%

â–  Alcohol use among population (last month) from 29% to 27%

â–  Increase population doing fitness activities at least 3 times/wk from 20% to 25%

â–  Increase in population with active life-style on regular basis with minimum of 30 minutes from 18.4% to 23.4%

Philippines[20, 22]

Between 2006 & 2010, reduce prevalence% of

This is an operation manual. Indicators to be monitored are outlined but no quantified national targets for these indicators are given

Some baseline data 2000/2003

â–  Obesity from 4.3 to 3

Proposes Behavioural Risk Factor Surveillance System including Adult

â–  Smoking from 34.8 to <34.8

National Nutrition and Health Survey to monitor the progress.

â–  Alcohol from 46 to <46

No reporting of past progress

â–  Inactivity from 60.5% to 50.8%

By 2010, reduce mortality rates (per 100 000) to less than the baseline level in 2006 for

â–  CVD < 79.1

â–  COPD<63.2

â–  Diabetes <20.8

â–  Cancer <47.7 [22]

  1. Notes: The indicators are listed exactly in the same way as written in the respective plan/policy, however, for some countries, only selected indictors/targets and not all the indicators/targets given in a plan, are listed here for the sake of brevity.